To traders, the ceiling for debt
Is starting to grow as a threat
As Yellen explained
She’ll soon be constrained
From paying our bills, just not yet
Some folks claim an alternate way
Exists which could help save the day
To quickly influx
A cool trillion bucks
Just mint a new coin to help pay
In addition to all the Congressional drama over the Biden spending agenda, the US is also being buffeted by the debt ceiling drama. We’ve all seen this movie before, where US law requires Congress to approve the amount of debt that can be issued by the Treasury in order to pay for the spending that Congress mandates. (A little-known fact is that the debt ceiling was not enacted to impose discipline on Congress, in fact it was the opposite. Prior to the debt ceiling’s implementation, Congress was required to vote on the funding for each spending bill they enacted on an individual basis. The debt ceiling was created to allow Treasury to fund the Congressional spending mandates in a smoother and more efficient manner. My how things have changed!) But back to our story… the current situation is that the debt ceiling has been reached and the Treasury is not empowered to issue any new debt (it can roll over maturing debt) in the current situation. While the Treasury does have some cash on hand, and can move funds around in its various accounts, by most measures, it appears that there are about 2 weeks of funding left before the government will have to default on paying some bills on a timely basis.
Now default was never contemplated by the Founding Fathers, with them going so far as to explain in Section 4 of the 14th Amendment of the Constitution:
The validity of the public debt of the United States, authorized by law, including debts incurred for payment of pensions and bounties for services in suppressing insurrection or rebellion, shall not be questioned. But neither the United States nor any State shall assume or pay any debt or obligation incurred in aid of insurrection or rebellion against the United States, or any claim for the loss or emancipation of any slave; but all such debts, obligations and claims shall be held illegal and void. [author’s emphasis]
It is this confluence of events which has led to a somewhat creative thought regarding how the government can overcome their problem, minting a trillion-dollar platinum coin. One thing that is clear is that the Treasury has the legal right to mint coinage, which is why despite the talk of the Fed printing money, the actual money printer is the Treasury department. Those $20 bills in your wallet are printed at the US Mint, a part of the Treasury. And the right to print money is fiercely protected by every nation as it is a good source of revenue (known as seignorage). Consider, they print money and can use it to buy real stuff, whether tanks, or medicines or anything else. All of those things cost far more than the paper that money is printed on. As well, paper money is considered part of the Treasury’s coinage capability.
Now, in economic terms, $20 bills are actually zero-coupon perpetual bonds. A claim on a fixed notional of assets with no interest rate paid and no maturity date. The same is true with quarters and dimes and nickels, no maturity date, no interest rate, some ascribed value. This has led to the idea that the Treasury can mint a coin with a notional value of $1 trillion (made of platinum to denote its high value), deliver it to the Fed and get $1 trillion of spending power in their general account. This idea was first mooted in 2011 as a similar split in Congress brought the US government very close to an actual default. Ten years later, as the concept of MMT has become more widely accepted as a viable path forward (it’s NOT), the idea is once again gaining traction. It certainly solves some problems, notably it prevents a default, but more importantly to the Democrats in Congress, it prevents a distasteful political vote that can be used as a cudgel by Republican opponents in the next election.
Of course, my question is, why would they stop at $1 trillion? After all, if current spending plans are for $5 trillion, why not mint five coins, or ten so they have some spare change? You can see the danger of this slippery slope, especially in the current economic environment where inflation is already running rampant. The addition of $1 trillion or $5 trillion more into the economy without the creation of new products or services would really turbocharge inflation.
While thus far, it seems this idea remains at the margin, given the dysfunctionality of Congress these days, and the shrinking timeline for action, it cannot be ruled out. My sense is that while it could have a short-term positive impact on the dollar and markets, it would relatively quickly be understood to be a massively inflationary action with both bonds and the dollar suffering accordingly.
OK, with that food for thought, let us take a look at market activity today. The first thing to note is that China is in the midst of its Golden Week holidays, which means there are no markets there until next week. Hong Kong (-2.2%) and Tokyo (-1.1%), however, were both open, although neither had a very positive session. Hong Kong suffered as they halted trading in Evergrande shares and other real estate companies fell sharply. Europe, on the other hand has edged slightly higher this morning, (DAX +0.0%, CAC +0.2%, FTSE 100 +0.2%) although it is hard to get too excited over the movement. US futures, on the other hand, are all pointing a bit lower, on the order of -0.4% at this hour.
Bond markets are seeing some selling this morning with 10-year Treasury yields higher by 3.5bps, although since the very sharp move last week, they have been consolidating either side of 1.50% yields. European sovereigns are also under some pressure with yields there moving up (Bunds +1.8bps, OATs +1.6bps, Gilts +2.0bps), although there has been precious little news on which to trade.
In the commodity market, oil prices continue to trade higher (WTI +0.3%) as does Nat Gas (+2.3%). While precious metals are under some pressure (Au -0.6%), industrial metals are firm this morning (Cu +1.35%, Al +0.6%) and agricultural prices are mixed in slow trading.
As to the FX market, the dollar is definitely under some pressure this morning with CHF (+0.45%) leading the way higher in the G10 with NOK (+0.4%) and GBP (+0.4%) next in line. The only laggard today is JPY (-0.15%) which is confusing given the Swiss franc’s performance as otherwise, one could consider this a somewhat risk-on day. But US equity futures are not helping that story either. In the EMG space, things are a little clearer as the CE4 (HUF +0.75%, PLN +0.6%, CZK +0.3%) are the top performers as all of them continue to get supported by central bank comments regarding tighter monetary policy. On the downside, MXN (-0.45%) is suffering the opposite as Banxico comments indicated that there would be no 50 basis point rate hikes anytime soon, something the market was beginning to price in. Net, the dollar is probably slightly softer, but the recent uptrend remains intact.
Data this week is fairly slow up until Friday’s payroll report:
|Average Hourly Earnings||0.4% (4.6% Y/Y)|
|Average Weekly Hours||34.7|
A couple of things worth mentioning are that last week, the NFP forecast was 535K, so starting to slip. Also, we continue to hear that there is no wage inflation, yet 4.6% Y/Y will be the highest non-Covid related level since before the GFC. On the Fed speaker circuit, this week is far less noisy with only 4 speakers, none of whom are going to change the narrative.
As to the dollar overall, I believe we are in an uptrend for now, having broken through previous strong resistance, and I expect that we are likely to see this trend continue. Use pullbacks to hedge, but they will not be large in my view.
Good luck and stay safe