Quite Frail

More systems have shown they can fail
With Chase and United quite frail
Is this World War III?
If so, it could be
A sign all positions are stale

So far, both these companies claim
Twas internal, tech was to blame
But risk appetite
Has now taken flight
With short sellers fanning that flame

Over the course of the past four days, we have seen major tech problems at Microsoft, the FAA, United Airlines and JPMorgan Chase although all of them have ostensibly been fixed.  In each case, internal technical issues were declared to be the problem with no evidence of a major hacking.  I know yesterday I called on Sir William of Ockham in discussing the FAA outage as likely to be just that, a tech glitch.  But I must admit it is getting harder to ignore the idea that there may be a larger issue ongoing in the background.

After all, if there was a major cyber-attack by Iran or North Korea or China, or anybody, a group of anarchists for example, would the government really admit that up front?  It would not speak well of our tech capabilities and defenses for these things which have been discussed frequently over the past several years.  It is certainly possible that these large organizations, each having their own fiefdoms and each having a great deal of technology investment that dates back generations in tech terms, are having their own Y2K moments, with their internal systems unable to keep up with ever increasing demands.  But four major organizations within a four-day span and it certainly raises eyebrows if not questions.

As of now, markets have taken the explanations at face value and are trading on other issues, largely puking tech shares everywhere around the world as fears the AI trade is ending continue to grow, but remember, markets are fickle and they could collectively decide there is a bigger problem and flee to Treasury bonds all at once if we see another tech problem at another well-known company in the coming days.  Something to keep in mind.

Meanwhile, President Trump is in the Philippines today before heading onto the APEC meeting in Shenzhen, China later in the week.  The mooted meeting between Presidents Trump, Xi and Putin remains a key focus for the world, but not so much for markets.

So, let us turn to the markets and calculate the damage we have seen of late.  Remember when oil prices were the key driver of everything?  Ever since March and the initial foray into Iran, oil was the number one indicator of what was happening in markets.  But not anymore.  There were many who expected the oil price to rise to $200/bbl or beyond with the disruption caused by the closure of the Strait of Hormuz.  Yet if we look at the chart over the past year, the initial spike high of $119.48/bbl is the peak, and that came a week after the initial attacks.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Quite frankly, eyeballing the current level, as depicted by the blue line on the chart, it is fair to say we are right in the middle of the range having declined from the late October peak pretty steadily.  By all accounts, there is plenty of supply of crude around, and as evidenced by the fact that both gasoline and heating oil (a diesel proxy) futures prices are falling even faster than crude, there is plenty of that as well.  In fact, if you look at the below chart of those two products, you can see just how much they have fallen, each nearly 20% from those late October levels, and both are down sharply today as per the chart inset.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

As well, the coming glut narrative is picking up steam, with several articles this morning discussing just that situation, how there is plenty of the stuff around, and while current shipping costs are high, the strong belief that the entire conflict will end sooner rather than later has resulted in fears that we could see a very sharp decline in oil prices soon.  At least fears by the oil companies making a killing these days.

But you know who hasn’t developed those fears?  That’s right, the FOMC!  Yesterday Cleveland Fed president Hammack was explaining why numerous small rate hikes were her preferred method of keeping the Fed up to speed while expressing concern that people’s behavior was beginning to change.  But is that really the case?  Once again, the biggest risk in my view is that the Fed tightens aggressively into the oil price shock just as oil prices start falling sharply.  Consider this possible outcome:

  1. Fed hikes 50bps in December (to catch up)
  2. Equity markets extend their recent decline
  3. Energy demand wanes amid high interest rates
  4. Strait of Hormuz reopens
  5. Oil prices go back to $50/bbl with gasoline at $2.00/gal
  6. Economy slows sharply

I wonder how frequently Fed speakers will be on the tape if the economy slows to recession levels after they hike rates.  I’m guessing they will disappear.  This is not to say this is what is going to happen, just that it is a viable scenario.  I fear the probability of a major central bank error is growing.

In the equity markets, tech hatred fear is strong and that has been the driver.  Yesterday’s sharp declines in the US were followed by sharp declines throughout Asia (Tokyo -1.3%, HK -1.0%, Korea -2.6%, Taiwan -2.3%, Australia -1.8%) with China the outlier here as the plunge protection team was at it again capping the loss at -0.1%.  The problem the Chinese have is that their latest program, a cheap loan program for companies to buy their own shares, has far less take-up than anticipated, i.e. companies don’t want to repurchase their own stock.  If they don’t with cheap financing, why would anybody else?

In Europe, despite the fact that they have virtually no tech, stocks are lower there as well (France -0.8%, Germany -0.6%, Spain -0.6%, UK -0.8%) and US futures at this hour (7:25) are mixed with NASDAQ bouncing slightly while DJIA futures fall.

One of the markets doing a bit better, though, is the bond market with treasury yields (-2bps) slipping again today and European sovereign yields all lower by between -2bps (Germany, UK) and -7bps (France) with everything in between.  This is not a sudden belief that debt problems are going to disappear but rather a flight to something that seems less likely to drop 50% on a whim.

Which takes us to the FX markets.  Looking at the broad dollar, it continues to garner support as whatever my data center concerns might be, in the current period of growing fears about equity markets, the dollar’s haven status is making itself felt.  So, the euro (-0.2%) is below 1.10 for the first time since April 2025 and I continue to believe is heading toward parity, or certainly 1.0500.  The combination of the growing hawkishness from the Fed and ongoing Eurozone economic weakness is adding to the haven trade.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Now, in fairness, German ZEW data this morning was the best since the Iran war began but if you look at the below chart, it doesn’t inspire that much confidence that things are great in Germany.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Recall the Germans are still deindustrializing based on their energy policy and have a barely functional government given the deep divide in the nation politically.  German companies are openly explaining they will not be investing in new production facilities there, so the future needs to be called into question absent some major policy shifts.

But if we widen our scope to the EMG bloc, the one that jumps out is BRL, which slipped -2.1% yesterday, extending its decline in the past month (since Lula’s re-election) to -15%!

Source: tradingeconomics.com

The proximate cause was the Brazilian Senate approving Lula’s spending plans, which given the Socialist leanings of that government, are unfunded and driving investors away.  While that is an extreme example, my take is that going forward, we are going to see similar spending plans from governments all around the world (France anyone?) and investors are going to seek out relative safety.  This bodes well for the dollar, the Swiss franc, gold and potentially the yen.

As to the data this morning, Retail Sales (exp 0.2%, 0.4% ex-autos) along with IP (0.1%) and Capacity Utilization (76.8%) are on the docket.  We have lots more Fed speak with Hammack, Waller and Williams all almost certainly going to explain why they need to hike further.  Interestingly, the declining stock market seems to have given pause to those thinking 50bps is coming next month, although the 25bp hike is still a ‘lock’.

Uncertainty reigns right now and in that scenario, the dollar does feel safer than most currencies and Treasuries are likely to maintain their bid.

Good luck

Adf

Still Scarred

Conspiracy theories abound
As Friday saw air travel downed
But Occam would say
That all the delay
T’was simply the tech was unsound

Its impact on markets was nil
Instead, PPI was the thrill
With readings so hot
Each Fed speaker thought
That more rate hikes they must instill

Meanwhile, as we look round today
The shadow of Jensen holds sway
Tech stocks were sold hard
And bonds are still scarred
The buck? It, right now’s, the best play

Fortunately, I was not flying anywhere on Friday, nor did I have plans on Saturday or anytime soon, as that turned into a huge clusterf##k.  One of the remarkable things about information flow these days is the speed with which conspiracy theories are propagated.  Whether it was the crash of Microsoft office tools (the Babylon Bee captured it well) last week or the crash of the FAA’s communication network which forced the ground stoppage on Friday, people immediately assume that there is a cyber-attack of some sort and are hunting for culprits.  But as William of Ockham postulated so many years ago, “plurality should not be posited without necessity” which is an old English way of saying that usually, the correct explanation of something is the simplest.  And ask yourself whether it would be harder for a major cyberattack by parties unknown, or that the 1960’s era technology that underpins the FAA’s communications are simply likely to fail given their age?

But all that happened as the markets were approaching their closes anyway, and the day’s activity was really driven by the PPI data released Friday morning, that while actually slightly softer than forecasts, was deemed smoking hot and led to further selling of Treasuries although the equity market remains in thrall to the Huang Chronicles.  As well, we had more Fed speakers explaining that they were quite concerned about inflation with the implication that the Fed would be hiking more aggressively going forward.

If we look at the below chart from rateprobability.com, you can see that over the course of the past week, the markets have added an additional 25bps of rate hikes to their pricing (I hesitate to use the word forecast).

So, after a stronger than expected NFP number and CPI and PPI both continuing to show price pressures, albeit not accelerating ones, the market, as led by the numerous Fed speakers who have suddenly become Volckeresque, is all in on at least 75bps and possibly 100bps of hikes over the next year.

If we consider what has been the underlying cause of the recent price pressures, it is fair to look at energy prices, notably oil and its derivatives, although electricity has also risen dramatically, as at least one of the primary drivers.  And yet, over the past month or so, gasoline prices, the product with the highest correlation to CPI as well as public angst, have fallen nearly 20%, far outstripping oil’s -11% performance as per the below chart from tradingeconomics.com

Regardless of the day-to-day in the Strait of Hormuz, from what I read the flow through the Strait has been in the 80% – 100% of its pre-war flows, with more products making their way through lately.  History has repeatedly shown that central banks hiking interest rates into an energy price shock have committed significant monetary policy errors.  I fear we are going to see the Fed join this roster of ignominy yet again.  (If they wanted to reduce price pressures, they could stop expanding the balance sheet and start to restrict M2 growth, but that is not the Keynesian way.). In the end, I fear that Fed rate hikes in conjunction with questions over the future investment in technology, especially on the data center front (more on this in a minute) may well portend a much slower growth environment in 2027.

Regarding data centers and the seeming wholesale rejection, or at least the numerous restrictions, seen from the recent elections, I have a feeling this could be the trigger for a reversal in the dollar.  Let me explain.

I have repeatedly made the case that when looking around the world, the broad macroeconomic picture is one where the US has absolutely been the driving force for growth.  We have seen massive inward investment flows as President Trump’s policies, whether you love them or hate them, have been a clear catalyst to bring significant manufacturing back into the US.  This has been a key support for the dollar, especially when comparing to, for instance, the Eurozone, where their energy policies have been destroying whatever industry they had.  Certainly, there is no inward investment there and that has been a key driver of my view the euro would head to parity and below.  As you can see in the below chart, the euro peaked in January of this year, alongside gold and silver, and has been falling ever since, and at an increasing rate lately.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Parity is within sight and a place we traded just three years ago.  However, if the new national direction is going to prevent the ongoing investment in data centers and AI, the deleterious effects, both short and long term are going to grow, and the US growth advantage may well disappear.  If that is how things play out, the case for a strong dollar takes a severe hit.  After all, slower growth will result in the Fed reversing course and looking to cut rates, it will undermine equity market performance reducing inward investment there, and it will alter perceptions of where companies should build their facilities.  Right now, those things all point to the US as the prime location.  If we change that, the consequences will be real.

On to the rest of the market situation.  In the equity markets, Friday’s US activity that saw the DJIA edge higher while the NASDAQ continues to suffer from AI exhaustion, led to broad weakness across Asia (Tokyo -2.4%, China -0.9%, Korea -3.6%, Taiwan -6.0%) although there were a few bright spots (HK +0.5%, India +0.6%, NZ +0.9%).  Both China and Japan released key data last night and it was not pretty in either place as per the below from Bloomberg.com.

Actual               Forecast       Previous

Slowing growth in both nations with the Chinese housing market still under pressure and investment collapsing while Japanese GDP slips is the current situation.  Going back to my point about the US leading the global growth impulse, if the political winds have shifted, it is not impossible to foresee a global growth slowdown which benefits nobody, except maybe bond investors!

Quickly, European equity investors needn’t worry about these gyrations since they have no tech companies to be impacted and the result is +/-0.2% in equity markets across the UK and the continent this morning.  As to US futures, at this hour (7:35) the NASDAQ (-1.5%) is weighing on everything and dragging them lower.

In the bond market, last Wednesday and Thursday were the big movers with Friday’s price action seeing very modest bond weakness, yields edging higher slightly.  And this morning, Treasury yields (-2bps) have slipped a bit while European sovereign yields are basically unchanged to higher by 1bp.  Sliding oil and product prices as well as potentially slowing growth is convincing more and more investors that bonds are not a bad place to be.

We’ve already discussed oil and gas, and despite their price declines, we are seeing weakness in both gold (-0.3%) and silver (-2.3%) as it appears that short selling is the new driver here.  Certainly, the dollar’s strength and prospects for higher Fed funds are weighing on the precious metals sector, but if you step back, things seem riskier than not these days.

Finally, the dollar continues to rally vs. most of its counterparts although this morning’s movement has been modest, on the order of 0.1% to 0.25%.  Right now, the safe haven story seems to have the strongest legs and that can certainly last for a while.  But I cannot look at that EUR chart above without concluding that we are merely seeing ordinary market movement as the dollar heads higher from an oversold position and will soon find itself in an overbought position instead.  Technicians are all excited about the dollar’s breakout higher, but I will warn again that if the politics are truly changing in the US, the future prospects for the dollar are probably dimming.

On the data front this week, there is some interesting stuff as follows:

TodayEmpire State Manufacturing18.0
TuesdayRetail Sales0.2%
 -ex autos0.4%
 IP0.1%
 Capacity Utilization76.8%
WednesdayHousing Starts1.27M
 Building Permits.38M
ThursdayInitial Claims196K
 Continuing Claims1725K
 Philly Fed19.2
 Leading Indicators0.1%
FridayMichigan Confidence52.0

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But more frighteningly interestingly we hear from eleven FOMC members, including Chairman Warsh today at noon, across 17 different venues.  It seems that Chairman Warsh’s view of allowing the markets to do the work and have the FOMC keep quiet has not been embraced yet.  As I continue to explain, they love the sound of their own voices too much to simply shut up!

The question at hand is whether the ongoing rout in AI focused stocks, especially with the Anthropic IPO due to come this Thursday, will upset the applecart elsewhere.  If so, 10-year yields at 5.12% are probably pretty attractive overall as a slowing economy will likely see demand pressures abate.  And if the oil shortage is indeed followed by a glut (which has historically been the case of every commodity shortage) and gasoline and oil prices fall back to pre-Iran levels, is the Fed really going to hike that much?  Maybe the trade is getting long Fed funds futures in December 2027.

Good luck

Adf’

Inflation’s Hemlock

The story of note was a stock
That everyone thought was a lock
To go up forever
‘Cause Jensen was clever
And built AI chips round the clock

But suddenly, there was a shock
With Jensen’s head put on the block
So, his stock got crushed
With longs getting flushed
While all of the haters did squawk

And elsewhere, the Fed’s fiercest hawk
Explained that inflation’s hemlock
To not just the people
But also the sheeple
Who cut rates while talking the talk

First things first, Marvel was Select Dog yesterday and we look forward to the show tomorrow, the National Dog Show, which is televised on NBC right after the Thanksgiving Day parade.  We are hopeful that he will be Best of Breed and compete on TV.

Second, I can offer very little insight into the Nvidia situation.  I recall writing last year about the news of Singapore being the second largest market for their chips and discussing how those might have been heading to China.  I guess that was, in fact, the case.  My observation about Jensen Huang is that when men, and specifically men, get that rich and powerful, they become of the belief that nobody can touch them.  We have seen it in business and politics throughout history, and this is no different.

My take, FWIW, is that Nvidia is still going to be making chips and AI is going to continue to be a part of our future.  I saw someone on X this morning compare Nvidia to Enron, claiming the entire company is a fraud.  That feels extreme to me, but then I neither own the stock nor followed it closely.  If it is a fraud, it would certainly be the largest in history!  It would also have a deleterious impact on the rest of the global equity markets, so keep that in the back of your mind.

In the meantime, perhaps our time is better spent on the FOMC speakers who have turned incredibly hawkish over the past several weeks.  It’s almost as though the committee, looking through a post-election, political lens, has decided to concentrate on their PRIMARY mandate, stable prices.  It’s been six years since the core PCE, their preferred metric, has been at their 2.0% target or lower, a track record of failure unmatched in history as you can see in the FRED chart below.

As I’ve discussed here many times, there has been zero evidence that inflation would be retreating to their target for years, but they managed to cut the Fed funds rate from 5.33% to 3.63% anyway.  At the time I called it out as political, and nothing has changed my mind it was anything but.  Perhaps President Trump should have a national address and call them out by name as the ones who have overseen rising inflation and remind everyone that he wanted to fire a bunch of them, but the Supreme Court said he couldn’t.  If people are upset, they should take it up with the FOMC directly.  He could even, helpfully, offer up their addresses.

Removing my tongue from my cheek, my point is, and has been, the FOMC has been failing at its role for many years.  I’m trying to understand why they have suddenly decided inflation is too high.  Alas, politics continues to be the most likely answer to that question.

All week, we have been inundated by Fedspeak, and there are four more speeches on the calendar today.  While it is no surprise that the most hawkish, Hammack, Schmid, Logan and Waller, have been calling for more rate hikes, even the previously more moderate voices have been coming out strongly in favor of more hikes.  The below list of speakers offers an idea of just how much they want to get their point across.

Monday, November 9

  • Michelle Bowman (Vice Chair for Supervision) — ~8:40 AM
  • Austan Goolsbee (Chicago Fed) — ~10:00 AM
  • Tom Barkin (Richmond Fed) — ~12:15 PM

Tuesday, November 10

  • Christopher Waller (Governor) — ~4:00 AM (London event)
  • Lorie Logan (Dallas Fed) — ~10:50 AM
  • Jeffrey Schmid (Kansas City Fed) — ~1:30 PM
  • Michelle Bowman — ~3:30 PM
  • Anna Paulson (Philadelphia Fed) — ~6:30 PM

Wednesday, November 11

  • No major speakers listed (Veterans Day; Fed holiday for some releases)

Thursday, November 12

  • Beth Hammack (Cleveland Fed) — ~9:00 AM
  • Michael Barr (Governor) — ~10:00 AM
  • Austan Goolsbee — ~11:15–11:30 AM
  • Mary Daly (San Francisco Fed) — ~1:10 PM
  • Jeffrey Schmid — ~1:30 PM
  • John Williams (New York Fed) — ~6:30 PM

Friday, November 13

  • Susan Collins (Boston Fed) — ~9:10 AM
  • Michelle Bowman — ~10:50 AM
  • Mary Daly — ~11:10 AM–12:00 PM
  • Philip Jefferson (Vice Chair) — ~7:00 PM

More importantly, though, is the question of whether it is this hawkishness that is driving the bond market, or if it the bond market’s recent sharp back up in yields that is driving this hawkishness.  I would contend Chairman Warsh wants to believe the latter and there is an old bond market saying that goes, ‘when the Fed is worried about inflation, the bond market stops worrying but until then, the bond market is the one doing the work’.  If that still holds, I expect that given the near unanimity of hawkishness being expressed across the entire FOMC, that bond yields may well be peaking here.  That certainly feels out of consensus this morning.

The one thing that does seem clear, though, is that the dollar has been the main beneficiary of the recent hawkish tone in both the bond market and by the Fed.  Using the euro as our proxy, as you can see in the chart below, it has back to its lowest level since Liberation Day in April of last year.

Source: tradingecnomics.com.

However, once again I remind everyone that all the teeth-gnashing about the dollar’s strength is extremely myopic.  As you can see just over the past five years, the euro has been both much weaker and stronger.  If anything, it remains virtually impossible for me to look at Europe, with the fiscal problems and rioting in France, as well as the energy policies that are impoverishing the entire continent and think keeping capital there is the safe bet.  Add to that the fact that yields across Europe are substantially lower than in the US, and economic activity, which was released this morning at 1.3% for the Eurozone over the past year, is much slower.  So, low rates and slow growth, quite the combination, but maybe not where you want to invest.

As well, there has been recent discussion about the yen, which traded through 160 again yesterday, and is right there as I type, for the first time since the last intervention back in early September.  This has tongues wagging that the BOJ may need to come back to the market

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But consider the fact that the dollar is strong against everything as you can see in the below chart of the DXY and USDJPY over the past month.  The movement is virtually identical, hardly indicative of a weak yen, but rather a strong dollar.  No matter what the BOJ does, it will have virtually no impact of note, so I am extremely skeptical there will be any activity there.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

In fact, there is no better way to demonstrate this fact than to look at the EURJPY cross, which shows that the euro is, in fact, declining more rapidly than the yen as you can see below.  The idea of yen intervention is off the table in my mind.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Ok, well, this is, theoretically, an FX commentary, so some days, that’s what you get.  Maybe the most interesting thing as we look through the rest of the markets is how little the Nvidia issue impacted equity markets overall.  The three main US indices fell by -0.35% yesterday, hardly a rout, and this morning futures are higher by 0.2% across the board as I type (7:20).

Last night, Asia was mixed with some gainers (Japan +0.5%, Taiwan +1.4%) and some laggards (China -0.7%, HK -1.6%, Korea -1.0%) with the rest of the region showing similar ups and downs.  Certainly, there was no overriding theme.  In Europe this morning, bourses are tantamount to unchanged as the data showed weak growth and rising inflation but was released as expected.  And of course, given there is no tech space of which to speak in Europe, selling tech shares doesn’t impact those indices!

The bond market, though stable this morning (Treasury yields +1bp, European sovereigns +2bps to 3bps) has seen yields rise rapidly during the past week.  In the US, as you can see in the below chart, we are higher by 32bps in the past week.  As per my discussion above, perhaps we are toppish if the Fed is going to get on the case.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Finally, commodities have moved to the back burner.  Again, it’s almost as though affordability was a political issue, not a real one, as since the election, I cannot remember hearing about one person explaining prices are rising too quickly that was not a Fed speaker.  Oil is bored and little changed this morning, still below $90/bbl.  EIA inventory data showed builds in both crude and gasoline and the price of gasoline is lower by -18.4% in the past month with heating oil (a diesel proxy) -12.1%.  It continues to be difficult to know what to think about the Iran situation as we continue to get mixed messages regarding the US stance.  Are there negotiations?  Have they ended?  President Trump indicated there would be no escalation and that seems to be the driver in oil markets for now.

As to the metals markets, rising interest rates have been killing them as the alternative to non-yielding gold and silver has become far more attractive.  While they are stable this morning, since late August, as you can see below, gold (-16.3%) and silver (-27.5%) have both been under significant and steady pressure.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

There is no evidence that governments are going to stop printing money as their promises remains far larger than their fiscal means.  But as long as we continue to hear the hawkish commentary, I suspect the metals will struggle.

On the data front, this morning brings PPI (exp 0.4%,6.6% Y/Y headline; 0.3%, 5.0% Y/Y core) but with CPI already out, will it matter?  And as per the above, we have four more Fed speakers to regale us with why they need to raise rates further.  At this point, as you can see from the cmegroup.com table below, pricing for a full 100bps further of hikes is starting to come around.  Personally, I don’t see it, but I’m not on the Fed.

There is a great deal of uncertainty right now in markets, with many things that had been assumed being called into question.  However, the data continues to show that despite the angst, economic activity in the US continues to move along well.  With the rate situation as it is, you have to like the dollar to continue its recent rise.

Sorry for the extended length this morning, but I missed so much yesterday 

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Chthonic

The bond vigilantes have spoken
The CPI data was smokin’
For Waller a half
Would not be a gaffe
But rather a TDS token

The dollar responded by soaring
While bonds, everyone were abhorring
Though stocks settled chthonic
It’s not clear it’s chronic
And oil, remarkably’s, boring

On this Veteran’s Day, let me start by thanking all of you who served in the name of this nation, I truly appreciate your efforts and service.  As well, given it is a partial holiday, with banks, and therefore the bond market, closed, I will endeavor to keep this short this morning.

You may recall that yesterday morning we heard from Fed Governor Chris Waller who explained that not only did 25bps make sense, but if yesterday’s CPI data was hot, 50bps should be on the table.  And he got his wish (?), with the headline printing at 0.4% and the core at 0.3% (remember official Y/Y data was absent because of last year’s government shutdown.). Certainly, the bond market got the message with 10-year yields jumping 10bps and 2-year yield exploding 13bps during the session as per the below chart.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Here’s the thing about the inflation data, at least in my opinion, the current rate has largely been the rate for quite a while.  Broad-based inflation has been running in the 3.5% ish area for a while now, and it certainly doesn’t appear that it will be declining anytime soon.  As the Inflation Guy, Mike Ashton, explains, yesterday’s data showed that there were few outliers, everything is just rising at that pace.

The bigger problem remains that the Fed has this myopic belief that adjusting the short-term interest rate is going to solve the inflation problem while they continue to grow M2.  While my Excel skills seemed to be sleeping this morning, the below two charts are from FRED data showing the last 10 years of M2 growth annualized and Headline CPI.  There is a very clear relationship between the growth in M2 and the subsequent lagged growth in CPI.  The problem is, M2 is growing at a solid 6.0% clip which bodes ill for reducing the rate of inflation anytime soon.

As Mike explains, while higher interest rates may destroy demand, they also raise the costs of supply and do not have a consistent impact on inflation.  Milton Friedman explained many years ago, “inflation is always and everywhere a monetary phenomenon”, but the current neo-Keynesian framework doesn’t like that viewpoint so focuses on interest rates.  Alas!

But this is where we are in central banking circles, so it is unlikely to change in the near term.  It will be very interesting to see if Chairman Warsh can institute meaningful change at the Fed, because if it happens there, it will follow around the world.  We would all be better off if that was the case.

Beyond the bond market, how did things behave?  Surprisingly, at least to me, while stocks were lower, it was hardly a rout, with the NASDAQ (-0.75%) the worst performer in the US and the other major indices lower by -0.35% or so.  And Asia seemed just fine, with gains in Tokyo (+1.3%), China (+0.4%), Korea (+2.6%) and Taiwan (+3.6%) with only HK (-1.0%) lagging on many alleged issues with profit-taking seeming the key driver.  After all, in the past week, it had rallied 8%, so taking some money off the table was reasonable.

Meanwhile, European bourses are generally having a good day (Germany (+0.75%), France (+0.4%), UK (+0.4%) although both Spain (0.0%) and Italy (0.0%) are not taking part.  A dearth of data has left investors to contemplate their own navels this morning.  But whatever fears there were yesterday about rising interest rates, the better than expected Coreweave earnings last night has the US futures on a roll with the NASDAQ (+1.9%) leading the way higher.

Oil prices (+1.1%) are modestly higher this morning but still below $90/bbl and there is still lots of back and forth as to whether talks are ongoing or not.  The one thing I have become far more certain about is that there is plenty of crude around.  Diesel remains a problem, but that is more a Ukraine/Russia thing than an Iran thing I believe.  As to metals, gold (+0.3%) and silver (+2.5%) are both stronger this morning after both sold off hard yesterday on the rate story.  Ultimately, as long as M2 continues to grow quickly, and it is growing faster elsewhere in the world, notably China, precious metals vs. fiat currencies leans in favor of metals.

Finally, the dollar exploded higher yesterday, jumping 0.7% as per the DXY and as you can see in the chart below.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Interestingly, for the first time in more than a month I read something about the yen, which had been idling on either side of 158 in the wake of the September intervention, but this morning, the yen (-0.3%) has slipped further and is now back to levels not seen since early September with the dollar above 159.00.  However, if one considers that this is not a yen phenomenon, but rather a dollar one, it strikes me there is little reason for the BOJ/MOF to be concerned.  There is nothing they can do about a broad dollar move higher.

Of course, that is the question, are we setting up for a broad dollar move higher?  If you believe in 50bps by the Fed next month and ongoing hawkishness, I can see the case and the futures market is pricing a probability of that now, with 25bps in both December and January the high probability events as per the below from cmegroup.com

Remember, there are still four weeks before the next FOMC meeting with PCE and NFP data coming before that meeting, and all the Congressional machinations that are possible in this lame duck session.  Fundamentally, I see no reason for that much more tightness, but I have been wrong before.

And that’s all today.  There is no data because of the holiday.  Tomorrow, there will be no poetry as we are taking Marvel to another show in the morning.  So, I will be back on Friday and who knows what will have happened by then!

Good luck

Adf

As the Politics Fray

Now, some have suggested the gov
Is showing the stock market love
Supporting the bulls
With deep pocketfuls
Of cash, lest the bears, too hard, shove

But who in the market will chance
Their own cash, if asked to advance?
The Fed’s not permitted
So who benefitted
From rallies? At least at first glance

Which brings us to ‘flation today
And whether more views it can sway
A hot print may thrust
Funds up, when discussed
Next month as the politics fray

Starting with the stock market’s movement over the past several sessions, wow is all I can say.  There have clearly been some changes in opinions, at the very least, as evidenced by the massive rally, then decline, then rally again.  The horizontal red line on the chart is the closing level of the S&P 500 on November 2, the day before the election, at 7555.  With all the gyrations of the post=-election hysteria, the market is in exactly the same place after last night’s close.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Certainly, the immediate post-election rally made no sense to me, but the word is that the sharp sell-off the next day was led by deleveraging of ETF positions and some forced closures of smaller hedge funds.  I have no insight into that, but it is certainly possible.  But it has been hinted by some that both the Wednesday rally, as well as Friday’s and yesterday’s are part of a concerted government campaign to support the stock market.  The thing about this story is I cannot comprehend the mechanism.  Who is buying?  Arguably, the Democratic victors would want to show the market approves of them, but they have no government tools to do so, and we know the Fed is not legally allowed to touch equities.  I’m confident Secretary Bessent wouldn’t be part of that either.  Did they get Soros and Gates to pony up on their own?  Those two won’t spend 2 nickels of their own money for anything.  China has an organized process, their national team, where insurance companies and banks are told to buy, and they do.  That seems hard to believe here.  I need proof to change my mind on this one.

So, what was the driver?  Well, the one thing we know is that sometimes markets can be quite volatile, especially when they really don’t know what is coming up.  The reading of Articles of Impeachment against Secretary of War Hegseth cannot help as it indicates things could get messy very quickly, well before the Democratic majorities are sworn in, and damage can be done with the current lame-duck session already destroyed.  But that would be a distinct negative for stocks, so the rebound makes no sense.  There are pieces to this puzzle that are very well hidden, I believe, so be careful.

But ask yourself who really benefits from this rally.  What was a big issue in a number of races?  Personal profits made by members of Congress.  It is not hard to believe that they would impose as much pressure as possible on any players capable of buying to push things higher for their personal benefit.  I don’t know how they can do it, but that doesn’t mean they can’t although I still need proof.  Keep in mind though, sometimes stocks go up and other times they go down and it’s as simple as that.

The other story today is, of course, the CPI release.  It is important, though, to frame the discussion based on new information we have from Fed Governor Waller who explained this morning in London, “However, if inflation comes in substantially higher than I expect, more robust action by the FOMC may be called for.”  Now, he didn’t say what he expected, so there is some wiggle room, but he also indicated that 50bps might be appropriate.  That’s a far cry from voting for no change last month.

Forecasts for this morning are as follows: 0.3% headline and 0.2% core M/M with the Y/Y expectations missing because last year, you may remember, we were in the middle of the government shutdown and no data was printed.  Of course, 0.3% still annualizes to ~3.7%, well above target.  But this is all a story of the past.  Arguably, the FOMC is supposed to address the future.  So, what is one of the biggest drivers of CPI?  Gasoline prices.  If we look at the RBOB contract, the two red vertical lines represent the end of September and the end of October.  In the interim, gasoline fell by 3.2% and as of this morning, has fallen substantially further on the latest word that President Trump indicated talks were going well and there is no need to escalate fighting in Iran.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Oil prices (-1.0% today, -10.5% in the past week) are continuing to decline and that will surely have a positive impact on inflation, i.e. reducing price pressures.  And I think this is exactly the point with respect to why the Fed, and basically every central bank, does things poorly.  They respond to history that cannot be changed while ignoring what is happening at the current time (anybody remember transitory inflation?).

The fatal flaw in most current monetary policy is central banks seem to ignore money, ironically, with the virtually universal view amongst that set being Keynesian, or neo-Keynesian, which means they look entirely at the demand side.  The other day I highlighted that M2 is growing quickly again and that is going to keep upward pressure on inflation regardless of the price of gasoline.

So, wrapping up, it appears that Governor Waller has highlighted today’s CPI print as THE critical piece of information in his next FOMC vote, the Fed funds futures market has moved back to a 99% probability of a hike in December after his comments and 2-year Treasury yields have jumped 6pbs on the Waller comments.  See if you can determine what time he spoke this morning from the below chart.  FYI, that was a 5-minute move.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

There is no shortage of moving pieces in the market right now and generating a coherent story as to the narrative has become difficult even for the narrative writers themselves.  In the meantime, let’s tour the markets.

While 2-year yields jumped sharply on the Waller comments, 10-year yields are only higher by 1bp, and European sovereign yields are lower by between -1bp and -3bps across the board as per the below Bloomberg screenshot.  These yields are more directly following the oil price, I believe.

Turning to equities, yesterday was a spectacular day with rallies almost everywhere in the world.  Again, a (Bloomberg) picture is worth 1000 words here.

The regional Asian bourses didn’t disappoint either with Korea (+4.4%) and Taiwan (+2.5%) both up strongly on the rebound in tech and AI shares.  However, as I type at 7:00, US futures are mixed with NASDAQ (-0.3%) slipping a bit although DJIA (+0.4%) are gaining a bit.  All eyes are on the CPI number.

We’ve discussed oil already, but Governor Waller’s biggest impact may have been on gold (-1.6%) and silver (-2.0%) as both responded immediately to the call for higher US rates.  Despite the Waller comments, though, we are still a long way from the next meeting, 29 days to be exact, and a lot can happen between now and then.  Interestingly, the next CPI will be released the day after the FOMC meeting, but word is they get that info ahead of time, so perhaps they will know.

Finally, despite all the gyrations elsewhere, the dollar is still asleep this morning.  Other than NOK (-0.5%) which is sliding on the oil price decline, the rest of the FX market is +/-0.25% or less relative to yesterday’s closing prices.  Again, my view is that FX is decoupling, at least for now, from the broader market narrative.  As an aside, the below chart of NOK vs Brent Crude offers proof of the petrocurrency status of the krone.  It is so strong it is remarkable.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

And that’s really it for the day.  We hear from a bunch more Fed speakers, Logan, Bowman, Schmid and Bowman again, and my take is there will be more hawkishness than dovishness, especially if this morning’s CPI is hot.  The question becomes, if CPI is hot, will that push stocks lower?  After all, the prospect of higher rates is seen as a negative for equity markets, but the ability of companies to raise prices is a clear positive for earnings.  Which one matters more?

We have seen significant volatility already recently and there is nothing indicating that is going to slow down.  I still don’t think a rate hike is in order, but I am not on the FOMC so they don’t care.  And in their framework, they are suddenly terrified.  (As I asked before, though, if they start hiking rates more aggressively and the economy slows, will the newly empowered Democrats be happy?)

Good luck

Adf

Something is Wrong

The data on Friday was strong
With bulls happy they were all long
And so far, today
Things still seem that way
And yet, it feels something is wrong

No matter the truth on the ground
The narrative seeks to confound
All news that is good
With blatant falsehood
Lest media ratings fall down

Humans are an odd species.  Positive outcomes are positively loathed by so many, or at least so many whose role is to disseminate information.  I have to believe that is a natural outcome as while that group may be a minority, they have realized if they get to write the narrative, even if it is completely false, they can instill their misery on the large majority of people who are pretty happy to go about their lives and see the good that exists.  This is not to say that bad things don’t happen, they clearly do.  It is also not to say that there are no bad people, or that only bad people go into media, but it certainly appears that there is a larger than statistical aggregation of doomsayers in the media business.

I highlight this because if one looks at Friday’s data objectively, assuming one can do so, it was unambiguously positive as a description of the economy.  The payroll data was much stronger than expected with NFP printing at 165K, 100K more than forecast, while the Unemployment Rate fell to 4.1%.   As well, Michigan Sentiment rose to 51.0, still lousy, but higher than last month and the forecast, although as you can see from the below chart, the trend remains lower ever since Covid.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Not only that, equity markets had a generally positive day on Friday, stabilizing from Thursday’s dramatic decline, and actually rising slightly, as per the below chart.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

And this morning, US futures are higher across the board, with the DJIA +1.0% as I type at 7:07am with the other two major indices showing lesser gains.  Europe is universally higher and Asia had a pretty good session led by Taiwan (+5.0%) after their plunge protection team entered the market.  You can see all this in the screenshot from tradingeconomics.com.

I highlight this because I did not see one positive story this morning in the press about anything of note.  There is still a significant amount of discussion regarding Thursday’s declines and what that means and if it portends the beginning of the end of the major rally.  And this morning’s new fixation is on Jensen Huang’s girlfriend and whether or not she is/was a Chinese spy, with the Nvidia board opening an investigation and the shares lower by -6.4% this morning.  This is all in accord with the media theme, ‘if it bleeds, it leads’.  So, the amateur psychologist in me is wondering why so many people want to see bad things happen to others and lap up stories about those things, whether they are real or fake and whether they are history or forecast.  This is the doom porn I mention all the time.  I guess winning and having good outcomes is just not as satisfying for some and I fear their number is growing.

And ultimately, this is my greatest fear, that the negativity that permeates social media, and my experience is that is the majority of stuff, will lead to worse actual outcomes.  One need only look at the recent elections and wonder how even though affordability was the single biggest concern according to polls, the party elected to power has NEVER in history been able to address that in an adequate manner.  We are already hearing about price freezes being implemented along with moratoria on economic activity like data center construction, and I assure you, all that will do is result in shortages of stuff with two coincident outcomes, black markets and long wait times, both of which are simply inflation in another guise.  As Friedrich Hayek noted, “if socialists understood economics, they wouldn’t be socialists.” (as an aside, if you have never seen this video, it is so well done!)

And that is enough philosophizing for this morning, let’s look at the other markets around.  Bonds are pretty sleepy this morning with treasury yields unchanged although European sovereign  yields are slipping a few basis points as the session progresses as you can see in the below Bloomberg.com screenshot.  While yields remain higher over the past year, they have generally retreated recently.

Here’s the thing about bonds, though, while their recent performance has been far better than many expected just a month ago, we cannot lose sight of the longer-term trend which turned at the end of Covid and has been trending with higher yields for the past 5 years at least.  Just look at the chart below from yahoo finance.  A 40-year trend of lower interest rates ended and seems to have reversed pretty clearly.  We will need to see yields slide quite a bit further to break this new trend.  My point is bond strength (lower yields) may not be a long-term position here, just a good trade.

In the commodity space, oil (-2.8%) is falling once again this morning and taking products (gasoline -2.0%) along with it.  It remains difficult for anybody not directly involved with the ostensible Iran negotiations to know if there are negotiations and what is happening.  One thing I read this weekend was that the recent ‘defensive’ attacks on Qeshm Island and others in the area are part of a systematic US campaign to degrade what’s left of Iranian missile command along the Strait to help maintain traffic volumes there.  But frankly, it is almost as though the Iran war is becoming extraneous to the oil market.  Clearly there remains plenty of oil around and now, nine months into this campaign, the only shortages, diesel, are largely a result of Ukraine’s attacks on Russian refineries.

It is worth noting that today’s RBOB futures price is right where we spent virtually the entire post Covid Bidenflation years, as per the below chart, with lower prices only achieved at the beginning of President Trump’s second term with his drill, baby, drill policies.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Given the relationship between gold and oil, it should be no surprise that the precious metals complex is stronger this morning (Au +1.1%, Ag +1.5%).  The best case for owning these metals remains the fact that M2 continues to climb rapidly in the US, and regardless of where interest rates go, inflation will be hard to control with that outcome.

Finally, the dollar is on its back foot this morning, down roughly 0.5% +/- a bit across the board.  The biggest gainer was NZD (+1.25%) after their national election left the ruling center-right National Party in power, easing concerns over worse economic policies (they have enough bad ones already), and we also saw KRW (+1.3%) rebound after a rough week as corporate repatriation of dollars helped support the won.  But really, since the beginning of October, the dollar has been a nonevent in markets, and I continue to believe it is separating itself from the narrative, at least for a while.

On the data front, this is inflation week and here’s what we have coming.

TuesdayNFIB Small Biz Optimism97.7
 CPI0.3% (3.9% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (2.8% Y/Y)
ThursdayInitial Claims195K
 Continuing Claims1720K
 Existing Home Sales3.98M
FridayPPI0.4% (6.6% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.3% (5.0% Y/Y)

Source: tradingeconomics.com

As well, we have the 3-year, 10-year and 30-year auctions this week, and we hear from 11 Fed speakers over 18 different venues!  That’s just too much.  It will be interesting to see how this plays out now.  After all, consider that my thesis is the hawkishness has been driven by, or at least abetted by, the idea that most FOMC members dislike President Trump and want to hurt him, but now that the Democrats will be in charge of both houses of Congress, do they want to raise rates?  Seems like the Fed has found itself in a difficult position where hawkishness will hurt their favored partners.  Perhaps the most enjoyable thing this morning was the WSJ article by the former Fed (Powell) whisperer, Nick Timiraos, basically admitting that politics is going to drive the Fed going forward despite all the claims that the Fed is apolitical.

So, that’s the week.  Wednesday is Veteran’s Day and markets will be closed.  For now, regardless of the politics, markets are showing optimism with oil falling and equities rising.  I have a feeling things will remain choppy for a while and there is still a chance of some negative outcomes especially if Congress tries to implement some of the craziest themes.  I assure you that Medicare for all will be a massive economic, and market, disaster, although I don’t believe that is on the near horizon.

Good luck

Adf

Naught But a Guess

The blood on exchanges is real
As traders and markets now feel
The future may not
Be all that they thought
When Trump wrote “The Art of the Deal”

It’s clear there was leverage, excess,
And that’s what has driven this stress
So, when might it end
This big new down trend?
An answer’d be naught but a guess

It was certainly ugly if you owned stocks yesterday, that’s for sure.  Ironically, while I had bought portfolio protection for an event of this nature post-election, Wednesday’s rally convinced me that the Democratic sweep had been priced into the markets already, and following my trading rules, I sold out the puts at a small loss.  Oops!  The lesson is that sometimes, trading discipline can result in decisions that don’t work out the way you expect, but that doesn’t mean trading discipline is a mistake.

As of 6:15 this morning, this is how futures markets around the world were behaving, and you can already see that there is a bounce in the NASDAQ as some dip buyers are jumping back into the market.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

The real outlier is India, where equities rose 2.2% overnight on the back of somewhat lower oil prices and, I think more realistically, a place where international fund managers believe the AI fallout is not going to be as significant.  But it is also worth noticing the YTD performances, where despite the angst generated by yesterday’s price action, long-term holders of equities remain in the green everywhere except China (and Russia, but that doesn’t count as a real market).  And you wonder why the Chinese National Team, as they call it, or the plunge protection team, as it is more colloquially known, is on the case.  In fact, Bloomberg had an interesting article on the subject this morning.

So, is the world ending?  That feels like an aggressive statement at this point.  Were some market excesses washed out yesterday?  That seems very clear.  Is the US economy going to fall into a recession?  That is a much harder question to answer, and the answer depends on your timeline.  Eventually, I suspect that will be the case, but it certainly doesn’t appear to be a near-term probability.  After all, look at the data we saw yesterday, where Initial Claims fell to 189K, a 57-year low while Continuing Claims have also been trending steadily lower since the middle of last year.  Something else to consider on the Initial Claims result is 57 years ago, the US population was 203 million or so, compared to today’s 340 million.

Perhaps just as importantly, the productivity data yesterday rose to 3.6% Q/Q in Q3, and as you can see below, continues to point to positive economic outcomes going forward.  After all, productivity growth is the key to economic growth, especially given the slowdown in population growth.  Maybe AI’s benefits are starting to show up after all.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

All this is a way of saying that yesterday was not, in my opinion, the beginning of the end of the equity market’s long-term rally.  I remain of the opinion that the upcoming gridlock between Congress and the Administration is going to prevent very much from happening at all, and generally, that is a net benefit to the economy and markets.

Attention now turns to the tape
And whether employment’s shipshape
The trend has been lower
Which could mean growth’s slower
But many misread that landscape

To finish off a week full of significant news, we get the payroll report this morning with the following expectations:

Nonfarm Payrolls65K
Private Payrolls64K
Manufacturing Payrolls5K
Unemployment Rate4.2%
Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (2.9% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours34.4
Participation Rate61.9%
Michigan Sentiment48.0

Source: tradingeconomics.com

For those of us who have been following markets for a long time, an NFP number of 65K would be considered near recessionary, which makes the Unemployment Rate at 4.2% that much harder to understand.  But as has been identified over the past two years, the Trump administration’s crackdown on illegal immigration has dramatically changed the nature of this data, as confirmed by several Fed working papers on the subject.  The result is that previous estimates of the need for between 150K and 200K new jobs every month to prevent the Unemployment Rate from rising have been whittled down to between 0 and 50K.  With that in mind, the recent NFP trend may not seem as concerning.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

In fact, it is this dichotomy, the fact that the labor market seems to be in very good shape according to the data, and the overall economic angst that clearly exists across the nation, which remains difficult for many to understand.  But that is where we are.

With all the other things ongoing, we have not heard anything about the Fed lately, and I must imagine Chairman Warsh is thrilled with that.  Are they still going to hike rates next month?  The UK just hiked, as did Australia, the ECB and the BOJ while the Fed paused last week although markets are pricing a 70% probability of a December hike.  But with oil starting to retreat, and more importantly gasoline prices retreating as per the below chart, are inflationary pressures really extant?

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Thinking through the Fed’s Keynesian framework, I would expect they could well see a change on the horizon.  Of course, the fact that this framework has been wrong for decades will not dissuade them from believing it.  Alas, as long as they continue to increase the size of their balance sheet, which they have been doing despite talking up rate hikes, I fear they will not arrive at their desired 2.0% PCE outcome anytime soon.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

A resumption of the previous downtrend would be a far more effective methodology for them to rein in inflation.  Maybe Chairman Warsh will get his way one day.

As to other markets, bond yields saw another sharp decline yesterday but this morning, they are bouncing a bit, (US +3bps, Germany +2bps, UK +5bps, France +4bps) ahead of the NFP data.  However, over the past month, Treasury yields are now lower by 50bps in pretty much a straight line as per the below chart.  For now, at least, Treasuries remain a place to hang your hat if you are an investor.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Perhaps more interestingly, despite the decline in yields, the dollar is firmer across the board this morning, with the euro (-0.4%) under pressure, albeit not as much as the Antipodeans (AUD -0.7%, NZD -0.8%).  As yields everywhere are following the US lead, this must be something else.  It is entirely possible that this short-term move is the embodiment of the haven trade as investors bought dollars to buy Treasuries, but if they were liquidating their US equities, they already had those dollars.  One cannot rule out the idea that the relative macroeconomic stories between the US and the rest of the world remain heavily in favor of the US.  Certainly, this is not indicative of an immediate slowdown of the inward investment to the US in the wake of the election, but it is early days.

Lastly, if we look at commodity markets, oil (0.0%) has been chopping back and forth during the session as everybody is trying to figure out whether Mr Trump is going to resume attacks on Iran or if a deal is coming soon.  Crack spreads, (the value able to be retrieved from a barrel of oil), have fallen substantially from where they were just a month ago as per the below chart from data4thepeople.com, although they remain elevated in the long-term scheme of things.

In the metals markets, gold (-0.4%) has regained the $4000/oz level after significant month end selling last week and seems to be stabilizing here.  Silver (+0.6%) is in the same boat, having weathered the sub-$50/oz storm.  Until we see changes in fiscal policies and the ensuing monetary profligacy that always follows, I believe that these metals will retain their value.  But commodities have always been extremely volatile, after all, they are the very epitome of the boom-bust cycle.  Yet over time, inflation has eroded fiat currencies universally.

And that’s all I’ve got.  I’m happy it is the end of the week, as it has been more than enough to think about.  My sense is that with the election now behind us, focus will return to more market internals and the Fed, but for now, I expect that most folks just want to get to the weekend!

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

No Real Distaste

The rally in stocks was amazing
And bonds, they as well, came out blazing
The dollar was smoked
As oil bulls choked
While metals are now upward gazing

Does this mean the markets embraced
The outcome with no real distaste?
Or were traders short
And forced to abort
Those views in a manner posthaste?

My sense is t’was more of the latter
Though there is a fair bit of chatter
That gridlock implies
New lawmaking dies
As Congress, the Prez, wants to shatter

We do live in interesting times as the discrepancy between what the data implies and how the population responds is the widest I can ever remember.  In the past, this level of popular angst was only really visible during serious recessions, going back to the 1970’s, and certainly the twin recessions of 1981 and 82.  But more recently, the GFC was a major blow to both the economy and the markets and everybody was miserable and scared together.  However, since then, things have changed.  I guess I should have seen Tuesday’s outcome because ahead of the 2016 election, my thesis was that the recovery from the GFC was only felt by the political insiders with the rest of the country feeling left behind, and that was evidence of the change that was coming.  And all the discussion of the K-shaped economy should have been the clue that this was also going to be a change election, and it certainly was.  I guess the question is, where do we go from here?

Perhaps no chart better describes the change in tone than the below of the DJIA (blue line) and the NASDAQ (green line).

Source: tradingeconomics.com

This is the very embodiment of the rotation trade as blue chip companies have benefitted from the perception of what the Democratic majority is going to do compared to the previous leaders, the AI and semiconductor sectors.  This effect has also been seen internationally as in Asia, Tokyo (-1.8%), Korea (-5.3%) and Taiwan (-3.2%) all suffered greatly last night while the rest of the region saw solid gains (India +2.6%, Australia +2.6%, New Zealand +2.2%). You will have noticed I left out China (+0.3%) and HK (+3.7%) as their performance was more a result of official Chinese support than a sentiment indicator, with the plunge protection team actively buying a series of ETFs in the session.

In Europe, the Bloomberg screenshot below tells the story eloquently.  As there are vanishingly few tech firms on the continent, when tech is under pressure and other companies are performing well, you can bet Europe will shine.

As to the US this morning, the thesis continues to play out with NASDAQ futures -0.6% while DJIA futures are +0.6% at this hour (6:45).

Bond markets are a bit more confusing to me as they are supposed to be the ‘smart’ money and yet they appear to be simply responding to lower oil prices with no thoughts of the future.  Certainly, oil prices have declined a bunch, although they rebounded 1.0% this morning, but are still under $90/bbl.  However, it seems that the strong belief is that oil prices are going to remain lower, and drag product prices with them, as suddenly, peace in Iran (and Ukraine?) are becoming an assumption.  However, if we think through the Democratic platform, with their ongoing efforts to kill the oil and gas industry and support wind and solar as the future of energy, it is virtually designed to raise prices, and by extension, feed into inflation.  But for now, the strong belief that lower energy prices are coming is the narrative.  So, yields continue to slide.  As you can see in the below Bloomberg screenshot, over the past month there is just one market that has seen higher yields, Brazil, which is election related.  But otherwise, although yields remain higher than one year ago, they are lower everywhere else in the world over the past month.

In fact, it was just one month ago when the peak concern over Treasury yields was reached with forecasts for 6% and 7% 10-year yields becoming common.  I wonder where those guys are now.

We discussed oil already, but the precious metals markets have been amongst the biggest beneficiaries of this new thesis with gold (+1.7%) having rallied $238/oz since its month-end spike low, a more than 6% rise.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Silver, too, has seen a massive bounce off those month end lows, as per the below, more than $4.00/oz or more than 8%.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Now, the story here is all about lower oil prices leading to lower yields along with a lower dollar and thus a benefit for metals prices.  And that is certainly true.  But I wonder, is there something else driving this movement?  There had been a significant amount of short-selling in these markets as traders who were all-in on the higher yields play were sure metals had lost their luster.  Clearly, some part of this recent jump is short covering.  And what of the long-term thesis that the debasement of all fiat currencies will result in higher metals, and all commodities, prices?  I haven’t heard about the debasement trade lately at all, but do not be surprised if that starts to come back into vogue going forward.  After all, as I wrote yesterday, there is zero indication that a Democratic congress is going to consider austerity.

And lastly, the dollar, which fell sharply yesterday, is little changed this morning, or maybe slightly higher on net.  The BOE hiked rates by 25bps as universally expected and the pound has not responded although there was a Bloomberg article this morning describing how on a trade weighted basis, the pound is back to its highest level in a decade on the back of resilient growth and expectations for more rate hikes going forward.

Here’s the thing about the FX markets, they are relative plays pitting one currency vs. another.  Now, if you look at the yield table above, with a couple of exceptions, Brazil, France and Switzerland, yields have slipped between 30bps and 40bps across the board.  Is a 10bp differential really enough to get traders excited?  I don’t think so.  Rather, the dollar remains a flow driven product and the biggest risk to the dollar, in my view, is if the inward investment that we have been seeing for the past two years, declines, let alone reverses.

Regardless of the government, the US remains the most dynamic economy in the world, and investment is going to come this way, but any slowdown will certainly weigh on the greenback.  It remains to be seen how this plays out going forward once the new Congress is in place in January.  Interestingly, I think the best thing about this is my suspicion that the new majorities are going to spend all their time trying to ‘get’ Trump and his administration and ignore legislation of consequence.  A perfect example of gridlock being a benefit.

Remember, tomorrow we see the payroll report, but ahead of that we have a bunch of stuff this morning including: Initial Claims (exp 196K), Continuing Claims (1710K), Nonfarm Productivity (2.8%) and Unit Labor Costs (0.6%).  We also hear from three Fed speakers, Hammack the hawk, Logan the hawk and Barkin, a moderate.  Yesterday’s ADP Employment number was stronger than expected at 86K while the Trade Deficit was slightly smaller at -$105.0B.  ISM Services was a touch light at a, still strong, 54.5 and there was a small net draw in EIA inventories.  Net, if you look at the data, there is no evidence the economy is doing poorly.  But that is certainly the zeitgeist.

Investors are comfortable with the new rotation narrative and the idea that oil prices are going to fall and bring inflation lower.  Along with that idea is the dollar will retreat.  Maybe, but I am not that confident that is the way things play out for very long.

Good luck

Adf

A Plus or a Mess?

This poet was totally wrong
Expecting a ‘publican throng
At polls yesterday
But one can’t downplay
The message delivered was strong

The question we now must address
Is, is this a plus or a mess?
The early returns
Show few new concerns
And nothing approaching distress

The election results are very clear and now we move on to the more difficult stage, governing.  Certainly, this was a rejection of President Trump’s agenda, or at least some of his actions, with the Iran war resulting in much higher energy costs a significant issue for the electorate.  However, in many ways, this is the best possible outcome for markets as political gridlock has historically been a net positive for the economy.  If Congress cannot pass new laws, that is generally a good thing.  And this was made clear last night as you can see in the chart below of the S&P 500, which saw losses early in the evening and then a complete reversal to where futures are now higher by 1.1% as of 6:10 this morning.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

The other statistic I keep reading is that in the year following a midterm election, equities have been higher for the past 18 midterms.  Of course, the breakdown of which industries and market sectors improve is unclear, and the past is not prolog, but it has certainly been a highlight amongst the early commentators.

At any rate, as this is not a political discussion, let’s turn our focus to things economic and financial.  On the economy, the US data continues to be solid as per yesterday’s JOLTs data which showed more job openings, but perhaps just as importantly, more Quits, which implies that there is a greater willingness for people to leave their job as they believe their prospects of finding a new, better one are improving.  That has historically been a sign of a strong labor market.  If we look at the below chart from FRED of the Quits data this century, it is not hard to make the case that we have bottomed after the Covid induced market disruptions and beginning to trend back higher.  Given the slowing population growth and the ongoing illegal immigration crackdown, it is easy to believe that job prospects are improving for those in the workforce.

This morning we get the ADP Employment number (exp 69K) and, of course, Friday brings the latest NFP data.  Again, the US data continues to demonstrate an economy that is growing in many areas.  When I compare this with the economic data elsewhere in the world, I continue to have difficulty seeing the appeal elsewhere.  With that in mind, though, it will be interesting to see just how much of the inward investment promised over the past two years will pan out given the changes in Washington.

So, let’s see how the rest of the world responded to the US elections, assuming that was the driver.  In equity markets, Europe is virtually giddy over the outcome with all the major bourses much higher led by Spain (+2.8%) but with large gains across the board (France +1.5%, Germany +1.5%, UK +1.25%).  And US futures, as mentioned above are stronger with both the NASDAQ (+0.9%) and DJIA (+1.5%) also doing well.  Asia, though, saw things a little less positively.  Japan (-1.4%) slipped along with Taiwan (-0.8%) and Australia (-0.6%) although there were positives as well.  For instance, the Chinese plunge protection team was active last night increasing both loans and direct support as the CSI 300 rose 2.3% dragging the Hang Seng (+1.7%) along for the ride.  Too, Korea (+0.6%) benefitted from yesterday’s relief in the tech space.  But overall, equity markets are nonplussed this morning, if not genuinely happy.

In the bond market, yields are lower this morning and I must admit, I don’t understand the logic.  Now, if you look at the chart below of the past 24 hours, you can see that this has not been a straight-line process, but here we are with 10-year yields lower by -3bps as I write.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

I read one blurb explaining the market was anticipating lower deficits going forward but I fail to understand how that will work.  There is zero evidence that a Democrat led congress will pass an austerity budget, and I expect that President Trump would veto any bills that raise taxes, so I am at a loss as to the source of that deficit reduction, at least on the surface.  Perhaps the ongoing crackdown on fraud will be sufficient to reduce the deficit, but that seems a stretch.  And if everything becomes a continuing resolution, that is not going to reduce expenditures.  However, yields around the world are largely lower with Europe benefitting from the Treasury market’s lead as the weaker European credits (France, Italy, Spain, UK, Greece) all enjoy bond rallies with yields slipping -4bps or so across the board.  As it happens, German bund yields are unchanged this morning.

In the commodity space, oil (-1.0%) continues to slide although I have seen nothing indicating that a deal to end the war in Iran was imminent.  In fact, the WSJ this morning had an article about how Iran was desperately trying to stop the flow of oil and using guerilla tactics but having limited success doing so.  Iran’s bigger problem is now that the election is past, President Trump has a pretty free hand in doing what he wants there, and the evidence continues to show that the blockade is really hurting the Iranians.  As I said yesterday, my sense is this is going to end before long.

With oil continuing its recent decline, and yields lower, it should be no surprise that metals markets have benefitted, but the magnitude is surprising.  Gold (+2.8%) and silver (+4.4%) have recouped all of their declines of the past week, as per the below chart.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Will this rally hold going forward?  Much depends on the dollar’s performance, which today is much lower, and how the interest rate structure evolves.  If lower yields are on the horizon, perhaps this is just the beginning.

And yet, if we look at the CME Fed funds futures market, the probability of a hike in December rose in the wake of the election, which seems at odds with that narrative.

So, let’s look at the dollar this morning.  It is lower across the board, and by a decent amount virtually everywhere.  if you look at the table below from tradingeconomics.com, you can see that the only exceptions are RUB, which isn’t really a tradable currency, CNY, which didn’t move and BRL, which despite the dollar weakness can find no strength as investors continue to exit the economy there.  Otherwise, it’s pretty unanimous, nobody wants dollars today.

Will this continue?  Positioning in the dollar heading into the election was net long, so I expect much of this movement is simply the beginnings of unwinding those positions.  But as I frequently highlight, the dollar is merely in the middle of its long-term range, neither especially rich nor cheap here, so its future will depend on the fundamentals.  Perhaps today’s Eurozone inflation data, which printed at 4.0%, has traders looking for a more hawkish ECB but there is no evidence of that based on implied probabilities from futures and swaps markets as you can see below in the chart from rateprobability.com.

While the BOE is set to hike rates tomorrow, other than the RBA, which looks like it is done, the trajectory of future rate hikes appears pretty similar across the board.

I see no reason for the dollar to collapse, although it is possible that inward investment will diminish, which will slow any significant rise in the greenback.

On the data front, along with ADP Employment mentioned above, we see the Trade Balance (exp -$108B) and ISM Services (54.8) as well as the EIA oil inventories with a small build expected.  I expect that we are setting up for more range trading in the dollar with the chance of a strong trend in either direction vanishingly small right now.

Good luck

Adf

A Sneak Peek

As awful as things seemed last week
On Monday we got a sneak peek
Of how things might play
When we see the day
The mullahs and Trump finally speak

At this point, it’s not very clear
If talks have brought settlement near
But I have a sense
That there’s no pretense
And things will be settled this year

When I wrote yesterday morning, oil had only moved half of its ultimate decline as stories about more successful peace talks regarding Iran made the rounds as per the below chart.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

You can see the large red candle shortly after 8:30 yesterday morning when positive news about the Ayatollah expanding negotiating room for the civilian government came out.  One of the noteworthy market moves was the fact that prompt prices for physical delivery, which had been trading as much as $30/bbl above the futures prices we see, collapsed back to a di minimis premium.  That indicates a belief that oil is going to flow again through the Strait, and soon.  Word is Iran has offered to reopen the Strait if the US ends the blockade.  This tells me the blockade has been extremely effective and that Iran is really running out of cash.  After all, why would they consider a deal ahead of the election?  Of course, they may believe their heartfelt endorsement for Democrats has done its job and they will win today.  The only thing I know about today is I cannot wait for the political ads to end on TV!

But it was not just oil that moved, we saw bond yields slip another -2bps yesterday, now down to their lowest level since mid-September.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

The Treasury’s borrowing estimates were within effective pennies of expectations, and I don’t think will have a major impact.  Of more importance is the refunding estimates to see how much Secretary Bessent will be borrowing in longer dates going forward.  There is talk of eliminating the 20-year bond, which never seemed to find a home, and a reduction in 30-year bond issuance, both of which would serve to reduce supply and support prices/reduce yields.  We shall see on Wednesday.

Precious metals soared on the decline in yields, the slipping of the probability of a Fed hike in December, now down to 73%, and the slipping dollar.  But stocks, which started the morning in a great mood, did give back a bunch on the tech side.  And that was yesterday.

The booths open early this morning
And both sides, the other, are scorning
Meanwhile, China tweaks
And wartime still wreaks
More havoc, it should be a warning

Which brings us to this morning and the beginning of Election Day.  You already know my views and that I am well outside the mainstream of opinion.  We shall learn more this evening and I suspect that the question of control of both Houses will be determined before we go to bed, certainly that will be the case in the Senate.

Elsewhere, the PBOC adjusted the RRR for foreign exchange at local banks, increasing the ratio from 4% to 6% to slow the too rapid strengthening of the renminbi.  We have discussed here before that CNY remains significantly weaker than its fundamentals and that is a policy stance China maintains to support its export-led mercantilist economy.  But under significant pressure from around the world, the renminbi had been appreciating steadily.  However, it seems that the PBOC decided the pace was too quick, which is odd given they were the ones in charge, but nonetheless, the change yesterday resulted in a sharp reversal in CNY (-0.4%) which while not extreme, counts as sharp in that currency.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

I am confident that CNY will resume its appreciation over time, but perhaps at a much slower pace.

The other noteworthy news item this morning was the report that there was limited military activity on Qeshm Island in the mouth of the Strait of Hormuz.  The report is the Iranians fired a surface-to-air missile at a US fighter jet and the US responded by attacking the missile installation.  Ostensibly this has not derailed the alleged ongoing negotiations although oil (+2.1%) has rebounded off the lows seen yesterday.  A not surprising consequence of the move in oil is that metals prices have sold off aggressively again (Au -1.0%, Ag -3.2%, Cu -3.0%) as that relationship remains fully intact.  Reading about the metals markets, the best explanation I have seen regarding their recent price declines has been a discussion of the reduction in overall liquidity that is available amid ongoing expansion of debt issuance by both public and private sectors.  Consider, the more debt that is sold to investors, the less they have to buy other things, with commodities being the first thing tossed aside.

In this vein, the most likely event to change this ongoing situation will be the resumption of QE as central banks will eventually be forced to, once again, buy sovereign debt to support their own debt markets.  I know this is diametrically opposed to what Chairman Warsh has indicated he would like to do, but I struggle to find an alternative solution to a lack of funds available for investors.  We are already seeing specific sectors of the economy feel that strain, notably the worst credits as CCC credit spreads have exploded relative to the rest of the risk curve.  Rotation in the equity markets does not solve this problem, so metals, which have had a tremendous run over the past several years, remain the current asset to unload.

As to the rest of the markets, Treasury yields have backed up 2bps this morning while European sovereign yields are higher by between 4bps (Germany, Netherlands) and 7bps (Italy) amid growing concern over both the rebound in oil prices and the ongoing fiscal profligacy that is evident throughout Europe.  While US yields have fallen back sharply from their October highs, European yields remain much closer to those levels as debt/GDP ratios remain a major concern for investors there.

In the stock market, Asian markets were mixed as the Nikkei (-2.2%), China (-1.4%) and HK (-0.7%) all suffered on the ongoing angst over tech stocks and the rotation out of that sector although Korea (+4.6%) which is the poster child for tech stock dominance, had a remarkably strong session.  Taiwan (-2.5%) was in the gutter as was Indonesia (-2.0%), which continues to suffer from concerns over transparency and its potential removal from the MSCI frontier markets category.  Other regional bourses moved far less, with a mix of gainers and laggards.

European markets, though, are all under pressure this morning, with all but Paris (-0.25%) down by -0.6% or more.  There has been no data released this morning here except Swiss Inflation which rose to 1.5%!  Maybe that’s why there is rioting in Zurich.  As to US futures, they are mixed this morning with the DJIA (-0.9%) suffering while the other two major markets are either side of unchanged at this hour (7:15).

Finally, the dollar is broadly firmer this morning with one glaring exception, NOK (+0.8%) which is obviously responding to the bounce in oil prices.  BRL (-1.1%) is a currency we haven’t discussed much lately but as you can see from the below chart, there has been no recovery, whatsoever, from the electoral surprise last weekend.  Too, you can see the BOVESPA stock market also remains under pressure.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But the major currencies aren’t doing much today, perhaps biding their time for election results.  In fact, I suspect that will be much of the story during today’s session although I would be careful of early announcements from exit polls declaring victories on either side.

On the data front, yesterday’s ISM data was strong, 55.5, with Prices Paid softer than expected at 75.2.  This morning we see the JOLTs Job Openings data (exp 7.10M) and Factory Orders (1.2%) but neither will matter to markets today.  Last night, the RBA hiked their base rate by 25bps, as expected, although the decision was split and AUD (-0.3%) lost a little luster as expectations of future hikes were reduced.

Unless the Iran situation comes completely unstuck today, it is all about the elections and for that, we need to wait until this evening at the earliest.  Hedged and close to the vest remains the way, I believe.

Good luck

Adf