“Something appears to be giving”
Said Waller, the true cost of living
So, bonds rallied hard
The dollar was scarred
But stocks were quite unreactive-ing

The narrative clearly has changed
With hawks on the Fed now estranged
Is everything better?
As world’s largest debtor
We need low rates to be arranged

Fed Governor Chris Waller, one of the erstwhile hawks on the FOMC was covered in white feathers yesterday as he explained his latest perception that the Fed was on a path to achieving their 2% inflation goal as Q3’s expansive GDP was clearly an outlier and the data he cited showed economic growth slowing toward trend just below 2%.  The other Fed speakers on the day did not back him up specifically, and in fact, Governor Bowman explained her base case was the Fed needed to hike still further to be certain inflation was under control.  However, the market only had eyes for Waller and has heard the following message from the Fed, ‘we have finished hiking, and the next move will be a cut.’  Although this had been a building narrative, until yesterday there had been consistent pushback from virtually every Fed speaker with the higher for longer mantra.  However, the current belief set is that higher for longer has just been buried and that lower rates are in our future.  Let the celebrations begin because the Fed has achieved the much discussed, though rarely achieved, soft-landing.

However…it is still a bit premature, to my mind, to celebrate accordingly.  In fact, just yesterday the Case Shiller Home Price Index showed an annual rise of 3.9%, which although 0.1% less than forecast, also shows that the widely claimed decline in house prices due to higher yields, has not materialized.  And consider, if yields are set to go lower, the idea that house prices are going to fall and feed into lower inflation seems absurd unlikely.

But logic has never been an important part of any market narrative, and this time is no different.  The fact that declining bond yields (Treasuries fell 6bps yesterday and a further 5bps in the aftermarket) and the fact that the dollar, as measured by the DX, fell 0.5% led by USDJPY falling nearly 1.5% to its lowest level since September, has eased financial conditions thus supporting economic activity and inflation, is of no importance to the narrative.  Once again, we have heard from some big-name traders, Bill Ackman in this case, claiming that the Fed is now going to cut well before the market is pricing, predicting the first cut in March 2024. The market response to this has been for Fed funds futures to price a 40% chance of a March cut and a 75% chance of one at the May meeting.

And maybe all this is correct.  However, as I wrote yesterday, I believe that we are going to see a significant additional amount of federal government largesse to help prop up the economy, and that is not going to push inflationary pressures lower, the opposite in fact.  As is always the case, nothing matters until it matters, and right now, the only thing that matters is that the narrative is all-in on rate cuts coming soon to a screen near you.  While we could easily see further short-term weakness in equity markets as portfolios rebalance after a huge equity rally this month, it certainly seems like a push higher in risk assets is on the cards into Christmas.

As we consider the price action from yesterday and overnight, the thing that really stands out is that the US equity markets did so little on this very clear change in tone from a key Fed speaker.  Had you told me this was going to be Waller’s attitude prior to the session, I would have expected US equity markets to rally by 1+% each, with the NASDAQ really embracing the idea of lower rates.  But while the three major indices all closed in the green, it was only at the margin, +0.1% – +0.3% with a very late day rally.  Yes, futures are pointing higher this morning, up about 0.3% across the board, but again, this is somewhat unimpressive.  Perhaps the market has already priced in this idea, hence the 10% rally in November.

There is another wrinkle in this narrative as well, and that is that APAC shares are underperforming in both China and Japan.  Regarding the former, the Hang Seng (-2.0%) fell again as continuing concerns over Chinese corporate growth and profitability weigh on the index with Meituan reporting poor results.  On the mainland, despite hopes that the government was going to do more to support the property market, thus far it has been all talk, and no action and investors are getting tired of waiting.  Europe, however, is having a better go of it this morning, excluding the UK, where continental indices are all nicely higher, at least 0.5% with some as much as 0.9%.  

Not surprisingly, European debt markets are rallying as European sovereigns are following the US lead, ignoring the pleas from ECB speakers that higher for longer remains the path forward.  As such, we are seeing further declines on the order of 4bps – 6bps across the continent, matching US yield declines for the past two days.  Yields in Asia, though, are quite interesting with some very different narratives playing out there.  Starting with Japan, which saw yields fall 9bps last night, back to their lowest level since September, we heard from BOJ member Seiji Adachi that it was premature to consider exiting ultra-loose monetary policy amid global economic uncertainties and the end of the aggressive rate hikes in the US.  That seems counter to what had been the building narrative regarding Ueda-san’s next move.  Australia saw yields decline 14bps but in New Zealand, the decline was much more muted, just 2bps, after the RBNZ left rates on hold, as expected, but was far more hawkish in their statement than expected and hinted at potential further rate hikes.  

Turning to the commodity markets, oil continues to rebound, rallying another 1.8% this morning and recouping all its recent losses as confusion still reigns over the OPEC+ meeting tomorrow, or perhaps to be delayed again.  As well, it seems that a massive early winter storm closed ports in the Baltic and so oil shipments have been interrupted there for the time being.  Gold, though, has been the big story in commodity markets as it exploded higher yesterday after the Waller comments, jumping $30/0z (1.5%) to levels last seen in May and once again approaching its all-time highs of $2085/oz.  The market technicians are getting quite excited as they see a break there as having potential for a much larger run higher.  A case can be made that this is not a vote of confidence in the Fed’s anticipated future handling of inflation, but for now, we can simply attribute it to lower interest rates around the world.

Finally, the dollar has taken a straight-right to the chin and is reeling against virtually all its counterparts, both G10 and EMG. While we have seen a bit of a rebound this morning, since Monday’s close, EUR (+0.3%), GBP (+0.5%) and JPY (0.65%) have all rallied nicely, and that is after giving up some of those gains overnight.  We saw similar movement in the EMG bloc with CNY (+0.3%), PLN (+0.3%) and BRL (+0.8%) all responding positively to the Waller comments.  As I have been saying recently, if the Fed is truly done, then the dollar is likely to suffer, at least until such time as the other central banks fall in line.

On the data front, in addition to the Case Shiller Home Prices yesterday, we saw Richmond Fed Manufacturing which disappointed at -5.0 (exp 1.0), yet another sign that growth is waning.  It is data like this that has Waller in the mindset that slowing growth will lead to lower inflation.  Of course, rising home prices would certainly be a crimp in that theory.  Today we see the second look at Q3 GDP (exp 5.0%) with Real Consumer Spending expected at +4.0%.  We also get the Fed’s Beige Bok at 2:00pm and Cleveland Fed president Mester speaks at that time.  It will be interesting to hear if Mester, a very clear hawk, confirms the Waller thoughts or tries to push back alongside Governor Bowman.

For now, while the dollar has bounced slightly this morning, as long as the narrative remains the Fed is done and that cuts are coming soon, you have to believe the dollar is going to fall further from here.  If pressed, I would suggest USDJPY has the furthest to decline, but the fact that we have already had pushback from the BOJ implies that they are not that unhappy it remains weak.  After all, it supports their corporate sector and helps keep inflation higher, which remains one of their goals.

Good luck

Adf