In China, the news wasn’t great

As Moody’s no longer could wait

Because of a glut

Of debt, they did cut

The outlook for China’s whole state



Investors were already wary

And as such, since last January,

Afraid of more shocks

Have been selling stocks

In quantities not arbitrary

The biggest news overnight was Moody’s downgrading their outlook for Chinese debt to negative from its previous stable view.  Moody’s currently rates the nation at A1, 4 notches below the best available of Aaa, but still a solid investment grade rating.  However, citing the property downturn in the country and the concomitant fiscal pressures that are building on local governments’ balance sheets, it appears there is a growing concern that national debt will be issued to cover the local failures.  

It must be very difficult to be a local government financial official in China as the competing pressures of ever faster growth and maintaining sound finances have become impossible to attain simultaneously.  The real question is, will President Xi determine that fiscal stability is more important than economic growth?  While that appeared to be his view last year, this year he seems to have changed his focus to growth.  Perhaps the fact that the US economy seems to be maintaining very solid growth while China is stumbling has become too much of a bad look for him to tolerate further.  (And that’s not to say things are fantastic here.) 

At any rate, his efforts to encourage more widespread economic activity while simultaneously deflating the immense property bubble there is starting to run into trouble.  As the pace of growth slows in the country, exacerbated by the demographic decline of the population (it is getting old and the population is shrinking), Xi appears to have thrown fiscal caution to the wind.  Once again, my concern is that if the domestic economy continues to deteriorate, Xi will determine that it is time for some international adventures to shore up his support at home.  I would contend that is not on anyone’s bingo card right now, but it is something to watch.

The market response to the news was to further sell Chinese equities with both onshore and Hong Kong markets suffering, each declining nearly 2%.  This weighed on Japanese markets (Nikkei -1.4%) as well as Taiwan, South Korea, and Australia, with only India ignoring the story.  It makes some sense that the China and India stories are uncorrelated given India is one of the few nations not reliant on China for much with respect to trade.  

Away from that story, however, things have been remarkably quiet on the economic front.  We saw Services PMI data from around the world with China, interestingly, one of the few nations printing above 50 (Caixin Services PMI 51.5), while all the continent remains firmly below the 50 boom-bust line save the UK which printed a much better than expected 50.9 reading.  While the market is waiting for US ISM Services data (exp 52.0) as well as JOLTS Job Openings data (9.3M), there is scant little else to discuss this morning.  Recall, though, as the week progresses, we will be receiving much more important data, notably the payroll report, which may help clarify the state of things now.

But, lacking anything else to discuss, let’s run down markets.  Away from Asia, equity markets are mixed with continental bourses all modestly firmer, on the order of 0.3%, although the FTSE 100 is lower by -0.5% despite the better than expected PMI data.  US futures are also pointing lower this morning, about -0.5% after a desultory day yesterday on Wall Street.

In the bond markets, Treasury yields have edged a bit lower this morning, -3bps, resuming what has been a powerful downtrend in yields.  In Europe, though, yields have really taken a dive, with sovereign bonds there all seeing declines of between 7bps and 9bps.  The weak PMI data has investors now bringing forward EB rate cuts to June.  Adding to this story were comments from the ECB’s Schnabel, historically one of the more hawkish members, describing the possibility of rate cuts next year as appropriate.  This seems quite similar to the Waller comments last week given Schnabel’s presumed importance on the ECB.  Finally, JGB yields are 2bps softer after slightly softer than expected Tokyo CPI data was seen as a harbinger for slowing inflation across Japan.  Once again, the idea that interest rate policy in Japan is due to normalize soon is being challenged by the facts on the ground.

Turning to commodities, oil (-0.3%) is slipping again as the weak PMI data encourages worries of an impending recession and the OPEC+ meeting was not taken seriously by the market as an effective manner to reduce supply.  Inventories have been building lately, so further pressure seems viable.  Meanwhile, metals markets are under further pressure with both copper and aluminum falling by more than -1.0% and gold, which had a remarkable session yesterday with a greater than $100 trading range, edging down a few bucks, but still well above the $2000/oz level.

Finally, the dollar refuses to obey the narrative and die.  Instead, it is higher again this morning vs. almost all its counterparts, both G10 and EMG.  The laggard today is AUD (-0.9%) which fell after the RBA left rates on hold, as expected, but apparently was not seen as hawkish as traders anticipated and the market has removed the pricing for any further rate hikes there.  The only exception to this movement has been the yen, which is now 0.1% firmer although in the wake of the Tokyo CPI data, it fell sharply.  USDJPY remains beholden to the twin narratives of declining US interest rates and normalizing monetary policy in Japan.  Right now, those stories are not working in concert, so until they do so, in either direction, I expect the yen will be choppy but not really make much headway in either direction.

Aside from the ISM and JOLTS data, we only see the API Crude Oil inventory data with a draw of 2.2 million barrels expected.  As there are no Fed speakers, it is shaping up to be a quiet day overall.  With that in mind, look for limited activity until 10:00 when the data is released and then I suspect that we remain in a ‘bad news is good’ regime.  So, weak ISM is likely to encourage risk taking on the belief the Fed will cut more aggressively and vice versa.  The same is true with the JOLTS data.  As to the dollar, I suspect it will follow the rate story, so strong data will help the buck and weak will see a bit of selling.

Good luck

Adf