As markets await the release

Of Payrolls, all things are at peace

But once it’s revealed

We need watch the yield

In 10-years lest it should decrease



While Goldilocks is still the meme

And certainly, Jay Powell’s dream

The data’s beginning

To show growth is thinning

More quickly both down and upstream

So, here’s the scoop.  Today is payrolls day and that is the only thing that anybody cares about right now, ahead of the release, and it will be the topic du jour by all the talking heads for the rest of the day.  As of 7:00am, here are the latest consensus forecasts according to tradingeconomics.com:

Nonfarm Payrolls	180K
Private Payrolls	153K
Manufacturing Payrolls	30K
Unemployment Rate	3.9%
Average Hourly Earnings	0.3% (4.0% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours	34.3
Participation Rate	62.7%

Now, looking at a chart of the past year’s releases, the numbers seem to show a very gradual decline, albeit hardly in a regular manner.

But let’s take a look at some underlying data that may help us understand the bigger picture a bit better.  First off, one of the things that draws a great deal of criticism is the birth/death model that the BLS uses to estimate the number of new companies that start up, hiring people, compared to the number of companies that close with the resulting job losses.  A key reason that every month this year has seen the data revised lower is because that portion of their data continues to be revised lower.  Historically, the birth/death model is at its worst during an inflection point, when the economy is either entering or exiting a recession.  Those downward revisions are a strong clue that things are not going that well.

But there is something else worth noting and that is the BLS breaks the payroll data down on a state-by-state basis as well.  This is not something that gets a lot of press but is nonetheless important.  While this data only goes back to 1976, that is still a fairly robust series.  I highlight this because every time in the past, when all 50 states + Washington DC have seen a decline in the number of employed workers, we have been in a recession already.  And shortly thereafter, the first negative NFP prints started showing up, usually withing 2-3 months.  Well, guess what?  Last month saw every state in the union report a decrease in the number of employed persons.  This is quite a negative signal for the economy, and one that is not getting much press, certainly not from the soft-landing set.  

I’m not saying that we are going to get a negative NFP print this morning, just that it seems one is coming to a screen near you soon.  If history is any guide, then sometime in Q1 seems realistic.  And ask yourself how Chairman Powell and his friends on the FOMC will respond to that type of data.  They had better hope that the recent trend in inflation, which has clearly been on a downward trajectory, continues, because otherwise, the Chairman will have nowhere to hide.  Cut rates to address economic weakness while stoking still firm inflation?  Leave rates on hold to fight inflation and let growth crater further?  Talk about a rock and a hard place.

It seems to me that the evidence continues to pile up on the side of a recession coming early next year.  Absent another wave of MMT or helicopter money or some type of direct fiscal stimulus by the federal government, this business cycle seems destined to end soon.  The bond market has been telling us that since the beginning of last month.  The oil market has been telling us that since the beginning of last month too.  The stock market has still not gotten the message.  It will, trust me, and it won’t be pretty.  However, I don’t think today is the day it will happen.  Just be prepared.

So, how have markets performed leading up to the NFP data?  Well, following yesterday’s rally in US stocks, Asia had a mixed picture.  Japanese equities continue to be pressured by a combination of concern over tighter monetary policy and a strengthening yen.  There was, however, a bump on the road to that tighter policy thesis as Q3 GDP was revised lower to -2.9% Y/Y, with the M/M falling -0.7%.  Will they really tighten policy into a shrinking economy?  Meanwhile, despite the word from the Chinese Politburo that they would be adding more fiscal stimulus in 2024, shares in Hong Kong and on the mainland barely eked out gains of 0.1%.  The rest of APAC, though, had a decent performance, with gains ranging from 0.3%-0.9%.

European bourses are in good shape today, with green across the board, albeit some just barely (DAX +0.1%) and some more robustly (CAC +0.7%).  Finally, US futures are edging lower, -0.2% or so, as I type (7:30am).

In the bond market, yields, which as we know have been trending sharply lower since early November, are rebounding slightly this morning with Treasuries up 3bps and European sovereigns all showing increases of between 5bps and 9bps. That seems a bit odd to me as there has been no data indicating inflation is rising or growth is impressive of late.  In fact, the Eurozone inflation data continues to point to deflation as Germany’s final reading came in at -0.4% in November.  In fact, as much as markets are expecting the Fed to cut rates soon, with a 60% probability now priced in for the March meeting, I suspect that the ECB is going to be cutting before the Fed as Eurozone growth and inflation are falling rapidly.  As to JGB’s, yields there edged higher by 1bp overnight and currently sit at 0.75%, certainly not pressing on the 1.00% cap.  

Turning to the commodity markets, oil (+2.2%) has finally found its footing with WTI back above $70/bbl.  While there continue to be rumors that OPEC+ is going to cut production further, this feels much more like a trading bounce than a structural move.  Interestingly, industrial metals are having a very good day with both copper and aluminum higher by 1% or more although gold is unchanged on the day.  Ordinarily, I might attribute that to a weaker dollar except that the dollar’s not weaker this morning.

Speaking of the dollar, if you remove the yen from the equation, it has, in truth, been reasonably strong.  Perhaps a better description is that other currencies have been weak as things like European economic doldrums weigh on those currencies while declining oil prices weigh on the petro-currencies.  Now, for all the JPY bulls out there, be careful as the weakening GDP growth and the fact that the most recent CPI data, while still above target, started to decline means that there is less pressure on Ueda-san to change policy.  Yes, they have started to discuss the idea of lifting rates out of negative territory, but they have also been quite clear that they need to see wage gains and the wage story really won’t be clear there until the March wage negotiations are completed.  All I’m saying here is that we have come quite a long way in less than a month.  Do not be surprised by a sharp rebound that wipes out a lot of profit and positions.

And that’s really it for the day.  At 10:00 we also see the first cut of the Michigan Sentiment Index (exp 62.0) as well as the concurrent inflation expectations indices (1yr 4.5%, 5yr 3.3%).  But by then, I expect that the excitement will have passed, and the market will be following whatever trend develops from the payrolls.  If pressed, I expect a softer number, something like 100K and a tick higher to 4.0% on Unemployment.  If that is correct, I expect that the market will continue with its ‘bad news is good’ concept and buy stocks in anticipation of Fed rate cuts.  But remember, virtually every time the Fed is cutting rates aggressively because economic activity is declining, risk assets are being sold, not bought.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf