While everyone’s waiting to see
How high or low payrolls might be
The news from elsewhere
Is starting to wear
Quite thin, look at China’s Zhongzhi
 
This bankruptcy sounds the alarm
That others there might come to harm
The soft-landing tale
Which still is quite frail
Has started to lose its quaint charm

Before we start on the payroll report, I think it is important to mention a significant issue that was revealed last night in China, where Zhongzhi, one of the largest non-bank financial and investment companies on the mainland, filed for bankruptcy and liquidation.  It has been missing both interest and principal payments for the past several months and it simply became too great a problem to ignore any longer.  The data released indicates that the company had ~$31 billion more in liabilities than assets and has become one of the largest bankruptcies in China’s history.  

The company was a major player in the property market there, although its main business was high yielding investment products, essentially structured notes, where much of the property backed collateral has fallen dramatically in value and where cash flows that had underpinned the notes have now ceased amid the property collapse.  This is hardly an advertisement for the Chinese economy and another sign that things there remain in a downtrend.  While the renminbi is marginally firmer this morning, up 0.2%, that is a consequence of the PBOC establishing the CFETS fixing at a much stronger than expected level in their effort to prevent substantial weakness in the currency.  

The upshot is that the Chinese economy remains in difficult straits, and the government’s reluctance to increase fiscal support is being felt everywhere.  (On the other hand, the PBOC has added $600 billion in liquidity to the economy in the past week.)  Ongoing weakness in Europe is another problem for Chinese exporters and the ongoing disagreements and tariff wars with the US simply add additional pressure to President Xi.  Next Saturday the first big election of 2024 will be held, in Taiwan, and if the incumbent party retains control, currently the betting favorite, Xi may find himself with quite a few problems to address this year.  A weak economy, rising geopolitical tensions globally and a rejection of his entreaties to the people of Taiwan is a bad look for a megalomaniacal dictator like Xi.  Just sayin’.

OK, let’s turn to this morning’s big story, the NFP report.  Here are the analyst consensus estimates according to tradingeconomics.com:

Nonfarm Payrolls	170K
Private Payrolls	130K
Manufacturing Payrolls	5K
Unemployment Rate	3.8%
Average Hourly Earnings	0.3% (3.9% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours	34.4
Participation Rate	62.7%
ISM Services	52.6
Factory Orders	2.1%

Now, yesterday we saw two other pieces of employment data, the ADP (164K and much higher than expected) and Initial Claims (202K and much lower than expected).  These numbers have many in the market looking for a strong print although the correlation between ADP and NFP has been underwhelming for quite a while.  While we can discuss the merits of the estimates and the overall strength of the economy, I think we are better served, this morning, to focus on the potential impacts of a given number and how that has been evolving so far this week/year.

This morning, the 10-year yield is up to 4.04%, some 25bps above the lows touched post-Christmas, and starting to indicate that some people are having second thoughts on the idea of the Fed aggressively cutting rates this year.  As an example, while I never believed there to be a chance of a rate cut at the end of January, the market was pricing a 17.5% chance of that just a week ago.  This morning the probability is down to 4.7%.  As well, just last week the market was pricing in 6 rate cuts in 2024.  That is now down to 5 cuts and fading. One of the big stories around this morning is that someone has put on a very large option position expiring later today that the 10-year yield will be above 4.15%.  To profit, this trade will require one of the largest yield moves seen in months.

The point is that the nirvana belief set that had been driving markets since the beginning of November is clearly under a significant amount of pressure here.  After all, the NASDAQ has had 5 consecutive negative closes, bond yields, as mentioned, have rallied sharply and are breaking through short-term technical resistance, the dollar is rallying, and the bulls are feeling quite unloved.

Is this the end of the bull story?  Frankly I don’t believe that is the case.  However, risk assets got a bit overexuberant during November and December and have come a long way in a short time.  It is not surprising to see a retracement of prices to help unwind some of the froth.  Ultimately, I believe the question that matters in the medium and long term is the state of the economy and whether the recent growth trajectory will continue, or if we have peaked for now.

One of the things that has me concerned in the medium term is the fact that the government continues to run a massive fiscal deficit despite what appears to be a reasonably strong economy.  Recall, Keynes instructed governments to spend during recession, but tighten their belts during good times.  However, the new mantra is far more in line with Modern Monetary Theory, which is spend as much as you can at all times.  

A quick thought experiment regarding the underlying economy might look like this: GDP = $27 trillion, Federal spending = $10 trillion, Federal deficit = $1.7 trillion.  What if the government didn’t run a deficit, but was neutral?  Removing that much stimulus from the economy would have a significant negative impact on the US economy’s growth trajectory, which is the reason no politician wants to do that.  But the question at hand is how healthy is the economy on its own?  And are growth prospects there really that substantial?  One of the keys to the recent employment picture is that government jobs continue to grow rapidly (look at the gap between NFP and private payrolls).  As long as the US government can continue to borrow money cheaply to fund its profligate ways, it is completely realistic to expect the economy to continue to grow.  However, the reason the bond market story is so important is that the bond market is the place where it will become clear if this is possible.  If Treasury yields continue their recent climb, the pressure on the economy will increase, and the pressure from the government on the Fed to support the bond market will increase.  Forget ending QT.  If the Fed were to find itself in a place where they needed to restart QE to support the bond market, that would be an incredibly important signal that inflation was going to accelerate again, and likely commodity prices would follow.  That would also be a very negative sign for the dollar.  So, lower bonds, lower dollar, higher commodities and likely a nominal rise in equities, at least initially.  My point is there is much about which we need be concerned and wary.

In the quickest of recaps possible, equities around the world have mostly been under pressure with only Japan managing to rally but weakness in China and across all of Europe.  The same is true with US futures, all in the red this morning by about -0.3%.

Bond yields are also rising around the world (except in Japan) with gains on the order of 6bps-8bps across the continent, similar to what we saw in Australia overnight. 

Oil prices are rebounding this morning, up 1.3%, despite much larger than expected inventory builds shown in yesterday’s IEA data, but the metals markets are continuing under pressure for now with the base metals weak and gold edging lower.

And finally, the dollar is continuing its rebound led by USDJPY, where the yen is down a further 0.4% and back above 145 for the first time since early December.  In the G10 space, I would say the movement has been about -0.3% overall, but in the EMG space, things are a bit more active with average declines here of about -0.7% across the three main geographic blocs.

That’s really it.  Now we just wait for the payroll report and later this morning the ISM Services number, and then we get to hear from Tom Barkin again, but it would be shocking if his view changed from just two days ago.  For some reason, I have a feeling the payroll data will fall short this morning, but that’s just a feeling.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf