Tag Archives: #intervention

Top of Mind

Posted on by

Will they or won’t they?
The intervention question
Is now top of mind

 

As we approach Japanese Fiscal Year end, and while we all await Friday’s PCE data, the FX markets have taken on more importance, at least for now.  The big question is, will there be intervention by the Japanese?  Late last night, USDJPY traded to a new thirty-four year high of 151.96, one pip higher than the level touched in September 2022 which catalyzed the last intervention by the BOJ/MOF.  Recall, last week the BOJ “tightened” monetary policy by exiting their 8-year experiment with negative interest rates and ‘promised’ that they were just getting started.  Granted, they didn’t indicate things would move quickly in this direction and they also explained they would remain accommodative, but they did seem confident that this would change a lot of opinions.  Remember, too, that the market response to that policy shift was to weaken the currency further while JGB yields actually drifted lower.

So, here we are a bit more than a week later and the yen has fallen to new lows.  What’s a country to do?  In the timeless fashion of governments everywhere with respect to currency moves, they immediately started jawboning.  Last night we heard from BOJ Board member Naoki Tamura as follows, “The handling of monetary policy is extremely important from here on for slow but steady progress in normalization to fold back the extraordinarily large-scale monetary easing.  The continuation of an easy financial environment doesn’t mean there won’t be any more rate hikes at all.”  Traders did not exactly quake in fear that the BOJ was suddenly going to tighten aggressively, let’s put it that way, and so nothing has really changed.  One other thing to note is that Tamura-san is seen as the most hawkish member of the current BOJ, at least per Bloomberg Intelligence’s analysts.  Take a look at their views below.

But wait, there’s more!  We also heard from Japanese FinMin, Shunichi Suzuki, that the government would take “decisive steps” if they deemed it necessary to respond to recent currency movement.  And the, the coup de grace, an emergency meeting between the MOF, the BOJ and the Financial Services Agency (FSA) is ongoing as I type (6:30) to help come up with a plan.  

Does this mean intervention is coming soon to a screen near you?  While it is certainly possible, the ultimate issue remains that the relative monetary policy settings between the US (higher for longer) and Japan (still at ZIRP with a hike expected in…October) remain such that the yen is very likely to remain under pressure.  Remember, too, that Japan is in the midst of a technical recession, so tightening monetary policy is not likely to be appreciated by Mr and Mrs Watanabe.  At the end of the day, the politics of inflation are very different in the US and Japan, and I would contend that in Japan, it is still not the type of existential problem for the government that it appears to be in the US.

FWIW, which is probably not much, I expect the MOF to follow their playbook, talk tougher, check rates and ultimately intervene over the next several days.  They will take advantage of the upcoming Easter holiday weekend and the reduced liquidity in markets to seek an outsized impact for the least amount of money possible.  But I do not see them changing their monetary policy before the autumn and so I look for continued yen weakness over time.  Be careful in the short run, but the direction of travel is still the same, USDJPY will rise.

For China, the fact the yen’s weak
Has Xi and his staff set to freak
They’re all quite dismayed
‘Cause Japanese trade
Has lately been on a hot streak
 

The other story in markets has been the ongoing ructions in the Chinese renminbi market.  It is key to understand that this is directly related to the yen story above as China and Japan are fierce competitors in many of their export activities.  But of even more concern to Xi and his gang is that Japanese exports to China are growing so rapidly and Japan ran a trade surplus with China in December (the last month with data released).  When you are a mercantilist nation like China, having a key competitor, like Japan, allow its currency to weaken dramatically against your own is a major problem.  Last week I highlighted the dramatic decline of the yen vs. the renminbi, and that has not changed.  Below is a chart from tradingeconomics.com showing Japanese exports to China ($billions) showing just how much this trend has changed and continues to do so.

Ultimately, both of these countries rely on exports as a critical part of their economic growth and activity, and in both cases, exports to the US and Europe are crucial markets.  If the Japanese continue to allow the yen to weaken, China has a problem.  Remember, Japan does not have capital controls, so while they don’t want the yen to collapse, they are perfectly comfortable with capital outflows in general.  China, on the other hand, is terrified of massive outflows if they were to even consider relaxing capital controls.  The fact is both companies and individuals work very hard to get their money out of the country.  This is one reason that gold is favored there by the population, and the reason that the government banned bitcoin as it was an open channel for funds to leave the country. 

This battle has just begun and seems likely to last for quite a while going forward.  The Chinese are caught between wanting to devalue the renminbi to compete more effectively and maintaining a stable exchange rate to demonstrate there are no fiscal or economic problems in the country.  Alas for Xi and the PBOC, never the twain shall meet.  I would look for a continuation of the recent market volatility here as they will use that uncertainty to discourage large position taking by speculators.  But, as I have maintained for a long time, I expect that USDCNY will trade to 7.50 and beyond as time progresses.

And that’s really it for today.  Ultimately, very little happened in markets overnight, certainly there were no changes in the recent data trajectory nor in any commentary from speakers (other than that mentioned above).  It is a holiday week and a key piece of data, PCE, is set to be released on a broad market holiday this Friday.  Do not look for large moves before then.

There is no US data due today but we do hear from Fed Governor Christopher Waller this afternoon so there is an opportunity for some market movement then.  But for now, consolidation seems the most likely outcome.

Good luck

Adf

Towel Throwing

Posted on by 
Did they sell?  Or not?
The new Mr Yen, Kanda
Explained, “No comment”

As is clear from the chart below (source tradingeconomics.com), there was a bit of movement in the USDJPY market yesterday morning.  The price action certainly had the feel of intervention, with a nearly 2% decline that occurred in seconds, but there has been neither confirmation nor denial of any BOJ trading activity.  Kanda-san, who is vice minister of international affairs which is the MOF role that deals with the currency, is the current Mr Yen.  His comments were certainly cryptic and as such, not very informative.  “We will continue with the existing stance on our response to excessive currency moves,” said Kanda. “While we are basically like a Gulliver in the market, we’re also coming and going as a market player, so usually we won’t say whether or not we’ve intervened each time,” Kanda said.  

The story that makes the most sense is that the BOJ reached out to the major Japanese banks in NY and London and checked rates.  The fact that the move happened minutes after the spot rate finally breeched the 150 level certainly was suspicious and indicated that contrary to yesterday’s comments by Watanabe-san, a former Mr Yen, the level really does matter, not just the speed of the move.  Others have tried to explain that breeching 150 triggered selling levels, but if there were exotic option barriers at 150, and I’m sure there were, the more typical move would be an acceleration higher as stop-loss orders by dealers were triggered.  The spike down, at least in my experience, is a sign of exogenous activity, not market internals.

Looking ahead, are we likely to see more of this type of activity?  You can never rule out currency support from any nation whose currency is weakening sharply, but there are G7 and G20 constructs that are supposed to limit these, and are designed to focus on volatility of movement, not levels.  This appeared contrary to those concepts, so we have much yet to learn.  At the end of the month, the BOJ will publish any intervention activity as part of their transparency initiative, but that might as well be next year for all the information it will provide.  Be wary of further movements like this, but the fundamentals continue to point to a higher USDJPY, especially given the accelerating rise in US Treasury yields.

The bond market rout keeps on going
As we see more folks towel throwing
The question at hand
Is can Powell stand
The pressure that’s certainly growing

Thus far, there’s no sign that the Fed
Is worried when looking ahead
More speakers were heard
To follow the word
That higher for longer’s not dead

Of course, away from the FX market, where the dollar has continued to show remarkable strength overall, the big story is the Treasury market.  After yesterday’s sharp move, the 10-year yield is higher by 23bps so far in October and it is only the morning of the third session of the month!  The yield curve inversion is down to -32bps and 30-year Treasury yields are pressing 5% now, a level not seen since summer 2007.  This sharp move has been the true driver of almost all markets and as long as it continues, there is going to be more pain for risk assets.  There has been no change in the fundamentals and yesterday’s move was ascribed to a much higher than expected JOLTS Job Openings number, which printed at 9.61M, far above the forecast 8.8M and a huge jump from last month’s outcome.  This seemed to encourage the Fed speakers to maintain their higher for longer attitude with a number still looking for one more rate hike this year.  Once again, I will point to Friday’s NFP number and its importance as a key driver of Fed policy.  If that number remains strong, and Unemployment remains low, the Fed can maintain this policy stance with limited fallout politically.

The rise in Treasury yields is being copied elsewhere around the world with yields following the US higher.  While today is seeing a bit of consolidation, with European sovereign and Treasury yields currently softer by 1bp-2bps, this is a trading effect, not a change of heart.  Interestingly, even JGB yields are getting dragged along higher as they closed last night at 0.80%, their highest level since 2012, the beginning of Abenomics.  But in the end, this is all about US yields with the rest of the world continuing to follow their lead.  I heard some analysts claiming this was a blow-off top in yields and we have seen the end.  Alas, I don’t believe that as history shows the yield curve will move back to a normal stance and with the Fed firmly in the higher for longer camp, 10-year yields have further to rise.  Yes, something is likely to break at some point, but so far, the few hiccups have been contained.

Not surprisingly, risk assets had a tough time in yesterday’s session with US indices all falling sharply, by -1.3% or more.  Yesterday’s European bourses were also under significant pressure and the Asian markets open overnight got hit hard as well with the Nikkei (-2.3%) and Hang Seng (-0.8%) the biggest movers.  However, this morning, Europe has a touch of green on the screen, with small gains on the order of 0.3% and US futures are also edging higher, +0.15% at this hour (7:45).  I wouldn’t read too much into this modest bounce and fear that there is further, and potentially much further, to go.  One of the remarkable things about the equity market is that earnings estimates for 2024 are for a rise of 12% on 2023 earnings.  Given the ongoing rise in energy costs and the increasing probability of a recession, those seem quite optimistic.  As they are revised lower, that, too, will weigh on equities, and by extension all risk assets.

Lastly, in the energy space, oil (-1.7%) is under further pressure this morning, although the fundamentals wouldn’t indicate that is the right move.  Not only did we see a further draw in inventories in the US, notably at the key Cushing, OK storage depot, but we heard from Russia that they are going to continue to restrict production by 300K bbl/day through the end of the year.  Meanwhile, the law in the US is set that the government cannot sell oil from the SPR when the inventory level falls below 330 million barrels.  Currently, it sits at 327 million, so that supply has ended.  Nothing has changed my view that oil has much higher to go, albeit not in a straight line.

Metals prices remain generally under pressure although gold (+0.2%) seems to be bouncing with other risk assets this morning on a technical trading basis.  However, both copper and aluminum are still sliding, typically a harbinger of weaker economic activity to come.

As to the dollar broadly, it, too, is a touch softer this morning, pulling back from highs seen yesterday in sync with all the markets.  But the same fundamentals driving the bond and stock markets are in play here, higher yields leading to more demand and a higher dollar.  Yes, this will end at some point, but we need to see a change in policy for that to happen.  The next real chance we have for something like that is on Friday with the payroll report.  A weak report, which seems unlikely at this time given the other employment indicators, would almost certainly change the market’s tone.  However, until then, look for positioning to continue to favor a stronger dollar, and for more and more dollar short sellers to get stopped out.

On the data front, this morning brings ADP Employment (exp 153K) as well as Factory Orders (-2.1%) and ISM Services (54.5).  the PMI Services data from Europe indicated that the worst may be over, but that there is, as yet, no real rebound.  We hear from a few more Fed speakers, but thus far they remain consistent, higher for longer is appropriate.

Today could see more consolidation of the recent moves across the board, but I do not believe that we have come to the end.  Calling a top or bottom is always impossible but remembering that the trend is your friend is likely to keep your activities in good shape.

Good luck

Adf

Beggar Thy Neighbor

Posted on by

A story that’s making the rounds
Although, it, so far, lacks real grounds
Is that the US
Might try to depress
The dollar ‘gainst euros and pounds

If so, that’s incredible news
And dollar bulls need change their views
But beggar thy neighbor
Does naught but belabor
The trade war, instead, it, defuse

The most interesting story that has started to gain traction is the idea that the Trump administration is considering direct intervention in the FX markets. While most pundits and investors focus on the Fed and how its monetary policy impacts the value of the dollar (which is completely appropriate), the legal framework in the US is that the Treasury is the department that has oversight of the currency. This means that dollar policy, such as it is beyond benign neglect, is formulated by the Secretary of the Treasury, not the FOMC. This is why the Treasury produces the report about other countries and currency manipulation every six months. Also, this is not a new situation, it has been the case since the abandonment of the Bretton Woods Agreement in 1971.

Since the Clinton Administration, the US policy has been a ‘strong dollar is in the US best interest’. This was made clear by then Treasury Secretary Robert Rubin and has been an accepted part of the monetary framework ever since. The issue with a strong dollar, of course, is that it can be an impediment for US exporters as their goods and services may become uncompetitively priced. Now, during the time when the US’s large trade deficits were not seen as problematic, the strong dollar was not seen as an issue. Clearly, earnings results from multinational corporations were impacted, but the government was not running policy with that as a priority. However, the current administration is far more mercantilist than the previous three or four, and as we have seen from the President’s Twitter feed, dollar strength has moved up the list of priorities.

It is this set of circumstances that has analysts and economists pondering the idea that the Treasury may direct the Fed to intervene directly in the FX market, selling dollars. History has shown that when a country intervenes by itself in the FX market, whether to prevent strength or weakness, it has generally been a failure. The only times when intervention has worked has been when there has been a general agreement amongst a large group of nations that a currency is either too strong or too weak and that intervention is appropriate. The best known examples are the Plaza Accord and the Louvre Accord from the mid-1980’s, where the G7 first agreed that the dollar was overvalued, then that it had reached an appropriate level. The initial announcement alone was able to drive the dollar lower by upwards of 10%, and the active intervention was worth another 5%. The result was a longer term weakening of nearly 40% before it was halted by the Louvre Accord. But other than those situations, for the large freely floating currencies, intervention has been effective at slowing a trend, but not reversing one. And the current dollar trend remains higher.

If the US does decide to intervene directly, this will have an enormous short-term impact on the FX market (and probably all markets) as it represents a significant policy reversal. However, in the end, macroeconomic fundamentals and relative monetary policy stances are still going to drive the value of every currency. With that in mind, it could be a long time before those influences become dominant again. Of course, the other thing is that the history of beggar-thy-neighbor FX policy is one of abject failure, with all nations seeking the same advantage, and none receiving any. Certainly, this is something to keep on your radar.

Away from that story, the dollar is actually stronger this morning, with the euro having breached 1.12, the pound tumbling toward 1.24 and most currencies, both G10 and EMG on the back foot. In fact, this is the problem for the Trump administration on this front, the growth situation elsewhere in the world continues to deteriorate more rapidly than in the US. Not only did Friday’s employment data help support the dollar, but this morning we saw very weak UK and Italian Retail Sales data to add to the economic malaise in those areas. In fact, economists are now forecasting negative GDP growth in the UK for Q2, and markets are pricing in a 25bp rate cut by the BOE before the end of the year. Meanwhile, in the Eurozone, all the talk is about how quickly the ECB is going to restart QE, with new estimates it could happen as soon as September with amounts up to €40 billion per month. While that seems to be a remarkably quick reversal (remember, they just ended QE six months ago), with the prospect of an ECB President Lagarde, who has lauded QE as an excellent policy tool, it cannot be ruled out.

Pivoting to the trade story, the latest news is that senior officials will be speaking by phone this week and the chances of a meeting, probably in Beijing in the next few weeks are rising. The problem is that there are still fundamental differences in world views and unless one side caves, which seems unlikely right now, I don’t see a short-term resolution. What is more remarkable is the fact that the lack of any discernible progress on trade is no longer seen as an issue by any markets. Or at least not a major one. While equity markets have softened over the past two sessions, the declines have been muted and, at least in the US, indices remain near record highs. Bond yields have risen a bit, implying the worst of the fear has passed, although in fairness, they remain incredibly low. But most importantly, the dialog has moved on, with trade no longer seen as the key fundamental factor it appeared to be just two months ago.

Turning to this morning’s news, there is only one data point, JOLT’s Job Openings (exp 7.47M) but of much more importance we hear from Chairman Powell at 8:45 this morning, followed by Bullard, Bostic and Quarles later in the day. Powell begins his testimony to Congress tomorrow morning, but everyone will be listening carefully to see if he is going to try to walk back expectations for the July rate cut that is fully priced into the market. My money is on confirming the cut on the basis of continued low inflation readings. However, given that is the market expectation, there is no reason to believe the dollar will suffer on the news, unless he is hyper dovish. So, the current strong stance of the buck seems likely to continue for the rest of the day.

Good luck
Adf