Tag Archives: #Citisurprise

Fight!

Posted on by

When fired upon, his response
Was jumping back up at the nonce
His cry was to “Fight!”
And some on the right
Now claim he’s a man, renaissance!

 

As John Lennon told us in 1977:

Nobody told me there’d be days like these
Strange days indeed

While this poet tries to keep politics largely out of the discussion, during these strange days, it is THE story of note.  Of course, by now you all not only have heard of the assassination attempt on former President Trump’s life on Saturday at a political rally in Butler, PA, but you all almost certainly have your own opinions about all the different theories, conspiracy and otherwise, so I will not go down that road.  I will simply note that it speaks poorly of the current political zeitgeist.  And while cooler heads are calling for a step away from the abyss, I have not yet seen the public take that step backwards.  Maybe soon.

In the meantime, my efforts are designed to help make sense of how both the political and economic storylines may impact the markets, and correspondingly, try to help those of you who need to hedge financial exposures, with a little understanding.  But history shows, when politics leads the news, the degree of difficulty goes up significantly.

The first thing to note is that sometimes, when momentous things occur in the real world, any financial implications take some time to manifest themselves.  With that in mind, I thought I would take a 30,000 foot view of the macroeconomic situation as we head into the new week.

The data of late calls into question
If we are now in a recession
With joblessness rising
And prices downsizing
Perhaps growth is seeing regression
 
And it’s not just here in the States
Where growth appears in dire straits
In China, as well,
Things have gone to h*ll
As data of late demonstrates

The question that is being asked more frequently is, are we currently in a recession?  While the data that has been released of late has been slowing, in the US it has not generally reached levels consistent with inflation, although there are some outliers that do point in that direction.  For instance, Friday’s Michigan Sentiment reading was pretty lousy at 66.0, well below expectations, and as can be seen in the below chart from the FRED data base, seemingly heading toward, if not already at, levels consistent with recessions (gray shaded areas).

Source: FRED Data base

As well, a look at the Citibank Economic Surprise Index, an index that tracks the difference between the actual data releases and the consensus forecasts ahead of time, shows that data is consistently failing to meet expectations.

Source: Yardeni.com

Here, too, the data does not appear to have quite reached levels seen in the previous two recessions, but recall that those two recessions were not garden-variety, with the GFC the deepest recession since the global depression in 1929, and the Covid recession remarkably short and sharp in the wake of the unprecedented government shutdowns that occurred in early 2020.  But going back in time, it is generally true that if data released consistently underperform expectations, it is a signal of overall economic weakness.

There are many other data points that are showing similar tendencies like the Unemployment Rate, which I have discussed lately, and is gaining momentum in its move higher.  As well, a look at almost all production factors or Retail Sales, which are reported in nominal terms, shows that when they are deflated by the inflation data of the past several years, real activity has been minimal or even declining.  A look at the below chart shows Retail Sales in both nominal and real terms with the latter actually declining since 2021 despite the rising nominal figures.  In other words, people are simply paying more for the same amount or less of stuff.

Source: brownstone.org

And this is not just a US situation.  As is typically the case, if the US is slowing, the rest of the world is going to suffer given its place as both the largest economy overall, and the largest mass consumer of everybody else’s stuff.  So, last night when China released its latest data, it showed the Q2 GDP disappointed, printing 4.7% while Retail Sales rose only 2.0%, far below Industrial Production, which grew 5.3%.  

Source: Bloomberg.com

In fact, this chart is the graphic representation of why nations around the world are calling for more tariffs on Chinese goods.  The combination of a still-collapsing property market there with the absence of significant government stimulus and a massive debt overhang has led President Xi to seek to increase industrial output and exports (remember the trade data from last week where exports soared, and imports actually declined) thus flooding other markets with goods and harming local manufacturing in other nations.  This is merely one more issue that policymakers must navigate amid a growing global concern over both political and economic unrest.

Summing it all up, I believe the case for there being a recession is growing strongly, and while nominal GDP is likely to remain positive, especially in the US given the government’s nonstop spending spree, real economic activity is suffering.  This has major implications for markets, especially as they appeared to still be priced for that perfect 10-point landing.  As I have written consistently, if (when) things turn more sharply, the Fed will respond quickly and cut rates and the impact on markets will be significant, especially for the dollar which will almost certainly decline sharply.  Just be nimble here.

I am sorry for the extended opening, but obviously, there is much ongoing.  So, let’s take a look at how things are behaving this morning.  At the opening of trading on Sunday evening, arguably the market that was showing the most impact was FX, where the dollar, which had fallen sharply at the end of last week in the wake of that CPI data, had rebounded a bit.  The narrative seems to be that the assassination attempt will secure President Trump’s reelection and the dollar will benefit from the economic policies that are believed to come with that.  As well, at this hour, (6:30) we are seeing US equity futures rallying, up 0.4% across the board.  That’s quite the contrast with the overnight session where the Nikkei (-2.5%) came under severe pressure as investors grow concerned over potential JPY strength.  Too, the Hang Seng (-1.5%) fell sharply although mainland shares have behaved better, little changed overnight, as investors look toward the Third Plenum with hopes that President Xi will unveil something to help the Chinese economy.

In Europe, though, this morning sees red across the screens, albeit not dramatically so.  The CAC (-0.4%) in Paris and the IBEX (-0.5%) in Madrid are the laggards, unwinding some of last week’s rebound, but every major market is under pressure this morning.  The lone piece of data released was Eurozone IP (-0.6%) which fell back into negative territory for the 6th time in the past twelve months.  Certainly, this is not pointing to a robust economy in Europe.

In the bond market, Treasury yields have backed up 4bps, also on the “Trump” trade, as investors believe that a Trump victory will result in more aggressive growth policies and higher US yields.  However, in the Eurozone, and in Asia, government bond yields are essentially unchanged from Friday’s levels as I don’t think foreign investors know what to think now about the US and how it may impact other nations going forward.  After all, if the US does grow more quickly in response to a Trump victory, will that mean more or fewer opportunities for tariffs and other mechanisms to affect foreign nations?

In the commodity markets, things are quiet with oil essentially unchanged this morning, as it consolidates at its recent highs.  Market technicians are looking for a break above $85.00/bbl, but I think that will require some substantially better economic data, which as explained above, does not seem to be in our immediate future.  In the metals markets, precious metals are little changed with gold consolidating above the $2400/oz level near its recent all-time highs, although copper (-0.9%) and aluminum (-0.8%) are both under pressure on the weaker economic picture.

Finally, the dollar is little changed overall this morning from Friday’s levels.  The early dollar strength seen last night has ebbed a bit although we still are seeing some strength against peripheral currencies like ZAR (-1.2%), NOK (-0.5%) and SEK (-0.5%).  The rand story seems to be more about local politics and the inability to get the new government up and running, while deeper investigation into the Skandies shows that this is a phantom move based on an unusual close on Friday.  My sense is there has really been no net movement here, as we have seen in the euro and the pound, both of which are mere pips from Friday’s closing levels.

On the data front this week, there is some important news as well as a series of Fed speeches starting with Chairman Powell this afternoon at 12:30.

TodayEmpire State Manufacturing-6.0
TuesdayRetail Sales0.0%
 -ex autos0.1%
 Business Inventories0.3%
WednesdayHousing Starts1.31M
 Building Permits1.39M
 IP0.3%
 Capacity Utilization78.6%
ThursdayECB Rate Decision4.25% (unchanged)
 Initial Claims235K
 Continuing Claims1855K
 Philly Fed2.9
 Leading Indicators-0.3%
Source: tradingeconomics.com

While there is not as much information due as we saw last week, I think the Retail Sales data will be instructive as another indicator of whether the economy is starting to roll over.  As well, watch for revisions from previous data releases as history shows that revisions to weaker numbers are another signal of a recession.  It will be quite interesting to see if Powell hints at a cut at the end of the month.  Certainly, the Fed funds futures market is not looking for that with <5% probability currently priced in although the September meeting is now a near-lock at 94%.  Remember, too, that after Friday’s speeches conclude this week’s group of 10 Fed comments, they will enter their quiet period and we won’t hear anything else until the FOMC meeting on July 31st.

While there is much to digest, my take is that we have rolled over in the economy.  The real question is about inflation and its ability to continue to decline.  Friday’s PPI data was the opposite of the CPI data on Thursday, showing hot prints for both headline and core, and indicative of resurging price issues.  Alas, I don’t rule out more stagflationary outcomes.  Funnily, I think that will ultimately help the dollar after an initial dip.

Good luck

Adf

Not Well Understood

Posted on by

The ISM data was weak
And traders, more bonds, did soon seek
The oil price fell
The dollar, as well
But stocks ended close to their peak
 
So, is now bad news really good?
‘Cause Jay will cut rates, or he should
Or is it the case
That growth’s slowing pace
Means risk is not well understood

 

The narrative had a little hiccup yesterday as the ISM data was released far weaker than expected.  The headline number, 48.7, fell vs. last month and was a full point below market expectations.  The real problem was that while the Employment sub-index was solid, New Orders tanked, and Prices remained high.  If you add this to the Chicago PMI data from Friday, which at 35.4, was the lowest print since the pandemic in May 2020 and back at levels seen in the recessions of 2001 and 2008, it is fair to question just how strong the US economy is right now.

Adding to this gloom is the news that the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow estimate slipped to 1.8% for Q2, down from 2.7% last Friday, and the trend, as per the below chart, is not very pretty.

Given the data, it can be no surprise that the Treasury market rallied sharply, with yields declining 8 basis points on the session, although they are little changed this morning.  After all, if the economy is slowing, the theory is that inflationary pressures will decline, and the Fed will be able to cut rates sooner rather than later.   And maybe that is true.  But when we last heard from the FOMC membership, most were pretty convinced they needed to see more proof that inflation was actually lower, rather than simply that slowing growth should help their cause.  And I might argue that a weak ISM print, especially with the prices portion remaining high, is hardly the proof they require.

But yesterday’s markets were a bit confusing overall.  While the initial response to the weak data led to immediate selling across all equity markets, by the end of the day, those losses were reversed such that the NASDAQ had a fine day, rising 0.5%.  Ask yourself the question, why would stocks rebound despite further evidence that the economy is slowing down.  The obvious answer is that a slower economy will lead to slowing inflation and allow the Fed to reduce interest rates before long.  Of course, the flip side of that story is that a slower economy implies companies will lose pricing power as demand slides, thus reducing available profit margins and overall profits.  It seems hard to believe that stock prices will rally amid declining earnings, although these days, anything is possible.

While the Fed’s quiet period has many advantages (in truth I wish the entire time between meetings was the quiet period) one of its key attributes is that the narrative can run wild in whatever direction it likes.  As we will be receiving quite a bit of data this week, I suspect the narrative will have a few more twists and turns yet to come, although there is no question that the bulls remain in control of the conversation.  

One other thing to keep in mind about that ISM data is that while the US data was weak, the PMI data elsewhere in the world indicated that the worst had been seen elsewhere.  While it is not full speed ahead yet in Europe or the UK or China, the trend is far better than in the US.  Remember, a key part of the narrative is that the US is the ‘cleanest shirt in the dirty laundry’ and so funds continue to flow into US equities and the dollar by extension supporting both.  But what if other nations are starting to see an uptick in their growth stories while the US is starting to slide a bit?  Perhaps the non-stop bullishness for the NASDAQ will find a limit after all.  Perhaps another way to consider this is to look at the Citi Economic Surprise Index, which is designed to compare actual data releases with the forecasts before the release.  As such, a high number shows better than expected data and vice versa.  As you can see from the below chart, the trend here is lower.

Source: macrovar.com

One interesting aspect of this chart is that you can see during Q1, when the equity markets rallied and bullishness was rife, this index was rallying as well.  But remember what we learned last week regarding Q1’s GDP, it was revised lower to just 1.3% annualized.  So, if better than expected data still led to weak growth, what will declining data do?  

In the end, at least in my view, the economy is struggling overall, although not collapsing.  If I am correct, then it leads to several potential, if not likely, outcomes.  While the Fed has continuously claimed they remain focused on inflation, if growth starts to decline more sharply, and unemployment starts to rise more rapidly, they will cut rates regardless of CPI or PCE, and they may well end QT if not start QE again.  The clear loser here will be the dollar.  Equity markets are likely to initially react to the rate cuts and rise, but if earnings suffer, I think that will reverse.  Bond markets, too, will rally initially, but if inflation rebounds, which seems highly likely if the Fed eases policy, I don’t think the long end of the yield curve will be very happy, and we could easily see 5.0% or higher in 10-year yields.  Finally, commodities will see a lot of love and rally across the board.

Ok, let’s look at what happened overnight, as other markets responded to the surprisingly weak US data.  Asia wound up mixed, similar to the US indices, as Japan (-0.25%) slipped while China (+0.75%) rallied along with Hong Kong (+0.25%).  But the big mover overnight was India (-5.75
%) which fell sharply as the election results there indicated that PM Narendra Modi, while winning a third term, saw a decline in his support that left him somewhat weakened.  The rupee (-0.5%) also slipped, although nothing like what we saw yesterday in Mexico.  As to the rest of the region, we saw winners (Indonesia, Malaysia) and laggards (Taiwan, Korea, Australia) so no real trend.  In Europe, this morning, there is a trend, and it is all red, with losses ranging from -0.4% in the UK to -1.1% in Spain.  The only data here was employment in both Spain and Germany, and while both numbers were a touch soft, neither seemed dramatic.  And, as I type (8:00), US futures are all lower by -0.3%.

In the bond markets, yesterday’s Treasury rally was mimicked by European sovereigns, with yields there falling as well, albeit not quite as much as in the US.  This morning, the European market is extremely quiet, with yields +/-1bp from yesterday’s closes.  However, overnight, we did see Asian government bond yields fall, with JGB’s -3bps and greater declines elsewhere in the space.

Oil prices (-1.85%) are under severe pressure this morning, following on yesterday’s $3/bbl decline, falling another $1.50/bbl.  It seems the combination of the weak ISM data and the OPEC+ discussion of an eventual return of more production to market next year was enough to convince a lot of long positioning to throw in the towel.  As is its wont, the oil market can move very sharply and overshoot in either direction.  It feels to me this could be one of those cases.  But commodity prices are getting killed everywhere this morning as although metals held up well yesterday, this morning we are seeing blood in the water.  Both precious (Au -0.9%, AG -3.4% and back below $30/oz) and industrial (Cu -2.3%, Al -0.5%) are falling as slowing growth and the belief that it will reduce inflationary pressures is today’s story.

Finally, the dollar, which sold off sharply yesterday in the wake of the ISM data, is bouncing a bit this morning, at least against most of its counterparts.  While most of the G10 is softer, led by NOK (-1.2%), the outlier is JPY (+0.85%) which is suddenly behaving like a safe haven amid troubled times.  I think that the increased uncertainty amid Japanese investors as to the state of the global economy may have them bringing home their funds, especially now that 10yr JGB yields are above 1.0% with no hedging costs.  As to the EMG bloc, MXN (-1.7%) remains under severe pressure but today they are not alone with all EEMEA currencies and other LATAM currencies declining as well.

The two data points this morning are the JOLTS Jobs Openings (exp 8.34M) and Factory Orders (0.6%), both released at 10:00.  Obviously, there is no Fedspeak, so I expect that equities will be the driver, and if fear starts to grow, we could get an old-fashioned risk off day with stocks falling, bonds rallying and the dollar gaining as well.

Good luck

Adf