Twas just seven days in the past
When fears of recession forecast
Were rapidly rising
And folks analyzing
The data had flags at half-mast
 
But in a remarkable twist
Turns out that recession was missed
Instead, all is great
With not long to wait
Til worries no longer exist!

 

Until this week, I had always understood the Covid-linked recession to be the shortest on record, lasting just a few months.  But apparently, that is no longer the case.  You may recall that after last Friday’s weaker than expected NFP data and the increase in the Unemployment Rate to 4.3%, the commentariat was certain that the Fed had maintained their monetary policy too tight for too long.  The result was that the US had entered a recession, or at least was on the cusp of one.  Certainly, this appeared to be the market narrative as equity markets sold off aggressively on Friday and then again on Monday.  While there was much discussion of the impact of the BOJ’s policy adjustments and that as an additional catalyst, the key is panic was rampant.

However, it appears it was nothing more than a bad dream.  As of this morning, the S&P 500 is essentially unchanged from where it was at last Friday’s close as can be seen in the chart below.  

Source: tradingeconomics.com

All of the angst that had been felt because of that NFP print (which was still positive at 114K) and all of the clutching of pearls and gnashing of teeth that analysts suffered was unnecessary as the Fed sensibly made no policy changes and the equity market absorbed some volatility and is back to flat on the week.  

Does this imply everything is fine with the world?  Absolutely not.  There are still numerous concerns for both the economy and the financial markets, notably the bond market, but the world has not ended, and equity markets are reflecting that fact.  

All joking aside, the economy continues to show a mixed picture and arguably the biggest medium-term concern should be the willingness of investors to continue to finance the US deficit.  This is a fundamental that cannot be ignored forever and one that revealed itself again this week as both the 10-year and 30-year auctions had tails* of more than 3 basis points.  The implication of those outcomes is that demand for US Treasury debt at current levels could be waning, and that is a genuine problem.  

Consider that, already, interest payments by the Treasury on its debt exceed $1 trillion annually.  If buyers in the market demand higher interest rates and there are no expenditure reductions (which seems likely regardless of the election outcome), either yields will rise, or other buyers will need to be found.  Who might those other buyers be?  Well, obviously, the Fed is the number one suspect, although if they were to restart QE with inflation running above target, I suspect it would be very difficult to hide and the impact on inflation would likely be to push it higher, clearly not their goal.  Therefore, as I have written before, be ready for regulatory changes that require banks and insurance companies to hold larger portfolios of Treasury securities as part of their capital buffers.  This process would be far more opaque politically but would create the price insensitive bid that the Treasury needs.

To recap, the recession has not yet arrived, investors are climbing out of their foxholes and there are potential concerns regarding the bond market and natural demand for the ongoing increases in issuance.  While next week’s CPI data will be closely scrutinized, my sense is the equity narrative is going to be far more focused on production and consumption than on prices. 

In the meantime, let’s review last night’s session and see how things are behaving as we head into the weekend.  After yesterday’s impressive rally in the US, where all Monday’s fears were erased because the Initial Claims number seemed to indicate the job market wasn’t collapsing, Asian markets had a pretty good session as well.  The Nikkei (+0.6%) and Hang Seng (+1.2%) both followed the US higher as did virtually every other market in Asia except mainland Chinese shares (CSI 300 -0.35%) after Chinese inflation figures printed a touch higher than forecast.  It does seem to feel like the Chinese market is decoupling from the rest of the world.  Meanwhile, European bourses are all firmer this morning led by Spain’s IBEX (+0.9%) and the CAC (+0.5%) in Paris.  Clearly, fears over Monday’s meltdown have abated everywhere.  Lastly, at this hour (7:30), US futures are pointing slightly higher as well.  As I said above, Monday was just a bad dream.

In the bond markets, yields are declining almost everywhere with 10-year Treasuries falling 4bps and all European sovereigns seeing yields decline by between -3bps and -5bps.  Whatever fears existed during the auctions seem to have abated somewhat, at least for now.  But the bigger picture concerns over Treasury supply remain in place, if in the background today.

In the commodity markets, oil (+0.4%) continues to creep higher and has now retraced all its losses from the week.  However, the big picture here remains that oil is rangebound between $70/bbl and $90/bbl.  While the Middle East situation continues to cause some concerns, the absence of a widely anticipated strike by Iran on Israel has left traders on edge, but not actively hedging the prospects.  As to the metals markets, both gold and silver, which had very strong rebounds yesterday, are little changed on the morning, consolidating those gains.  Interestingly, copper (+1.6%) is showing a bit of life, perhaps on the view that the recession has not yet arrived, or more likely because traders who had shorted the red metal are closing positions ahead of the weekend.

Finally, the dollar is mixed this morning with a variety of gainers and laggards across both the G10 and EMG blocs.  In the former, AUD (-0.3%) is lagging as it adjusts after yesterday’s strong gains based on a more hawkish RBA view.  At the same time, JPY (+0.5%) is higher this morning although it has been trading either side of 147.00 for the past three sessions with no obvious directional bias.  Given the importance of monetary policy decisions to this currency pair, the fact that the BOJ walked back their hawkishness and the Fed speakers we have heard this week have continued the mantra of the time is not yet right for a cut, although September may be good, it shouldn’t be that surprising that it has found a new short-term equilibrium.

In the emerging markets, the chart below showing the relative moves of ZAR, MXN and BRL, the three key risk proxies, shows that all have strengthened from their worst levels on Monday, an indication that traders are returning to the carry trade.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

It is also worth noting that CNY (+0.2%) continues to track the yen at a slower pace.  The idea that the PBOC is willing to let the renminbi trade in a more volatile manner as long as it does not strengthen aggressively vs. the yen remains intact.

There is no data on the docket today and once again there are no Fed speakers scheduled either.  To my eyes, the market is exhausted after the wild moves at the beginning of the week.  I expect that there is limited appetite for aggressive price action in any market today and absent either an Iranian attack on Israel or a true black swan event, my best guess is it will be a quiet session heading into the weekend. 

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

*A tail in a bond auction simply describes how much higher the actual results were than the market’s anticipation of those results prior to the auction’s completion as priced in the when-issued market.  Typically, for 10-year bonds, that tail is close to zero, and even 30-year bonds average about 1bp.  A 3bp tail is considered quite wide and concerning as it indicates a lack of buying interest by investors of all stripes.