A Rate Hike Boycott

Said Yellen, the job market’s cooling
Not faltering, but it’s stopped fueling
Inflation, and so
You all need to know
More rainbows are coming, no fooling!

Meanwhile, from the EU, Herr Knot
Was strangely less hawkish than thought
Inflation’s plateaued
Which opens the road
To starting a rate hike boycott

As we await today’s US Retail Sales data, and far more importantly, next week’s FOMC and ECB meetings, it seems that there is a concerted effort to talk inflation down by both the US and European governments.  For instance, yesterday, Treasury Secretary Yellen was explaining how, “the intensity of hiring demands on the part of firms has subsided.  The labor market’s cooling without there being any real distress associated with it.”  Now, I have no doubt that Secretary Yellen would dearly love that to be the case, although her proof on the subject remains scant.  Perhaps she is correct and that is the situation but given her track record regarding forecasting economic activity (abysmal while at the Fed and in her current role), I remain skeptical.  Certainly, while last month’s NFP data was slightly softer than forecast, it did not speak to a significant change in the labor market situation.

She proceeded to add how inflation was clearly coming down, although was careful to warn against reading too much into one month’s numbers, kind of like she was doing.  One thing she was not discussing was how the ongoing surge in deficit spending by the government, which she was personally overseeing, was having any impact on inflation.  Alas, history shows that there is a strong link between large deficits and rising inflation.  Maybe this time is different, but I doubt it.

But as I said, there seems to be a concerted effort to start to talk down inflation, especially as the efforts to actually address it are increasingly politically painful.  The next example comes from the Eurozone, where Klaas Knot, Dutch central bank chief and number one hawk on the ECB Governing Council suddenly changed his tune regarding a rate hike in September.  It was just a month ago, in the wake of the ECB’s last rate hike, when Madame Lagarde essentially promised a July hike, that he was on the tape explaining that a September hike was also critical and certain.  But now, his tone has changed dramatically, with comments like “[it] looks like core inflation has plateaued,” and he’s “optimistic to see inflation hitting 2% in 2024.”  

Again, maybe that outlook is correct and inflation in the Eurozone is going to come crashing down (remember, it is currently 5.4% on a core basis, far above the 2% target), but this also seems unlikely.  For instance, this morning’s headline, FRANCE TO RASE REGULATED ELECTRCITY PRICES BY 10%, would seem to be working against the idea that inflation is going to fall sharply.  In fact, one of the key reasons inflation ‘only’ rose as high as it did in the Eurozone, peaking at 10.6% last year, was that virtually every government subsidized skyrocketing energy prices for their citizens much to their national fiscal detriment.  Now that energy prices have come off the boil, they are ending those subsidies and hence, prices are rising to reflect the current reality.  So, the inflation they prevented last year will simply bleed into the statistics this year.

Politically, what makes inflation so difficult for governments is the fact that regardless of how they try to spin the situation, the population sees rising prices in their everyday lives and are unlikely to believe the spin.  However, that will not stop governments from doing their best to change attitudes via words rather than deeds.  Of course, given the prevailing Keynesian view that there is a direct tradeoff between employment and inflation, that puts politicians in a very difficult spot.  No politician is going to encourage rising unemployment just to get inflation down hence the ongoing attempts to jawbone inflation lower.  Ultimately, nothing has changed my view that inflation, as measured by CPI or PCE, is going to find a base in the 3.5%-4% area and be extremely difficult to push past those levels absent a catastrophic event.  And I certainly don’t wish for that!

But let’s take a look at how markets are responding to the renewed attempts to talk inflation lower, rather than actually push it lower.  Certainly, yesterday’s US equity performance showed no concerns over mundane issues like inflation as all 3 major indices continued to rally to new highs for the year.  Alas, there is less joy elsewhere in the world as Chinese stocks suffered along with most of Asia, although the Nikkei did eke out a small gain.  In Europe this morning, while the screen is virtually all red, the movements have been infinitesimal, on the order of -0.1% across the board.  And US futures at this hour (7:45) are showing similarly sized tiny declines.

The real news is in the bond market, which has taken this new government push to heart, and we now see yields falling across the board, in some cases quite sharply.  Treasury yields are down -4.5bps, but that pales in comparison to European sovereigns, all of which are lower by at least 7bps with Italian yields tumbling 12.5bps.  This newfound ECB dovishness is clearly a welcome relief for European governments, French electricity prices be damned.

In the commodity space, the base metals continue to signal a recession is on its way as both copper and aluminum continue to slide, but oil seems to have found a base for now, and is still higher on the month.  As to gold, it should be no surprise that it is rallying this morning, pushing back above $1960/oz as the combination of lower yields and a lower dollar are both tail winds for the barbarous relic.

Turning to the dollar, excluding the Turkish lira, which has tumbled 2.5% in anticipation of another underwhelming monetary policy response this week when the central bank meets, the rest of the EMG bloc is firmer, led by THB (+1.2%) on the combination of a broadly weaker dollar and hopes that the political stalemate in the wake of the recent election there is soon to be solved with a new candidate coming forward.  But the strength is broad-based across all 3 regions.  In the G10, NZD (-0.7%) is the only real laggard as market participants position themselves for tonight’s CPI release there with growing concerns that the central bank is not doing enough to support the currency and economy.  Otherwise, the bloc is generally firmer, albeit not dramatically so.

On the data front, Retail Sales (exp 0.5%, 0.3% ex autos) leads the way followed by IP (0.0%) and Capacity Utilization (79.5%) at 9:15.  There are still no Fed speakers, so while a big miss in Retail Sales could have an impact, I continue to expect that the equity earnings schedule is going to be the driving force in markets until the Fed meets next week.  So far, the first sets of numbers have been positive, but there is a long way to go.  

For now, the dollar remains on its heels, and I suspect that is where it will stay until next Wednesday at least.

Good luck
Adf

Still Remote

A Eurozone nation of note
Has recently had to demote
Its latest predictions
In most jurisdictions
Since factory growth’s still remote

The FX market has lately taken to focusing on economic data as the big stories we had seen in the past months; Brexit, US-China trade, and central bank activities, have all slipped into the background lately. While they are still critical issues, they just have not garnered the headlines that we got used to in Q1. As such, traders need to look at something and today’s data was German manufacturing PMI, which once again disappointed by printing at just 44.5. While this was indeed higher than last month’s 44.1, it was below the 45.0 expectations and simply reaffirmed the idea that the German economy’s main engine of growth, manufacturing exports, remains under significant pressure. The upshot of this data was a quick decline of 0.35% in the euro which is now back toward the lower end of its 1.1200-1.1350 trading range. So even though Chinese data seems to be a bit better, the impact has yet to be felt in Germany’s export sector.

This follows yesterday’s US Trade data which showed that the deficit fell to -$49.4B, well below the expected -$53.5B. Under the hood this was the result of a larger than expected increase in exports, a sign that the US economy continues to perform well. In fact, Q1 GDP forecasts have been raised slightly, to 2.4%, on the back of the news implying that perhaps things in Q1 were not as bad as many feared.

Following in the data lead we saw UK Retail Sales data this morning and it surprised on the high side, rising 1.1%, well above the expected -0.3% decline. The UK data continues to confound the Chicken Little crowd of economists who expected the UK to sink into the North Sea in the wake of the Brexit vote. And while there remains significant uncertainty as to what will happen there, for now, it seems, the population is simply going about their ordinary business. The benefit of the delay on the Brexit decision is that we don’t have to hear about it every single day, but the detriment remains for UK companies that have been trying to plan for something potentially quite disruptive but with no clarity as to the outcome. Interestingly, the pound slid after the data as well, down 0.25%, but then today’s broader theme is that of a risk-off session.

In fact, looking at the usual risk indicators, we saw weakness in equity markets in Asia (Nikkei -0.85%, Shanghai -0.40%) and early weakness in European markets (FTSE -0.1%) but the German DAX, after an initial decline, has actually rebounded by 0.5%. US futures are pointing lower at this time as well, although the 0.15% decline is hardly indicative of a collapse. At the same time, Treasury yields are slipping with the 10-year down 4bps to 2.56% and both the dollar and the yen are broadly higher. So, risk is definitely on the back foot today. However, taking a step back, the reality is that movement in most markets remains quite subdued.

With that in mind, there is really not much else to discuss. On the data front this morning we see Retail Sales (exp 0.9%, 0.7% -ex autos) and then at 10:00 we get Leading Indicators (0.4%) which will be supported by the ongoing equity market rally. There is one more Fed speaker, Atlanta’s Rafael Bostic, but the message we have heard this week has been consistent; the Fed remains upbeat on the economy, expecting GDP growth on the order of 2.0% as well as limited inflation pressure which leads to the current wait and see stance. There is certainly no indication that this is going to change anytime soon barring some really shocking events.

Elsewhere, the Trump Administration has indicated that the trade deal is getting closer and there is now talk of a signing ceremony sometime in late May, potentially when the President visits Japan to pay his respects to the new emperor there. (Do not forget the idea that the market has fully priced in a successful trade outcome and when it is finally announced, equities will suffer from a ‘sell the news mentality.) With the Easter holidays nearly upon us, trading desks are starting to thin out, however, while liquidity may suffer slightly, the current lack of market catalysts means there is likely little interest in doing much anyway. Overall, today’s dollar strength is likely to have difficulty extending, and if we see equity markets reverse along the lines of the DAX, it would not be surprising to see the dollar give back its early gains. But in the end, another quiet day is looming.

Good luck and good weekend
Adf

Given the Easter holidays and diminished activity, the next poetry will arrive on Tuesday, April 23.

Disruption and Mayhem

Tomorrow when Parliament votes,
According to some anecdotes,
Another rejection
Will force introspection
As well as a search for scapegoats

For traders the story that’s clear
Is Brexit may soon engineer
Disruption and mayhem
And soon a new PM
Who’s not named May just might appear!

As we begin a new week, all eyes remain focused on the same key stories that have been driving markets for the past several months; the Fed, Brexit and the US-China trade talks. Ancillary issues like weakening Eurozone and Japanese growth continue to be reported but are just not as compelling as the first three.

Starting with Brexit this morning, after a weekend of failed negotiations, PM May looks on course to lose the second vote on her negotiated deal. Interestingly, the EU has been unwilling to make any concessions of note which implies they strongly believe one of two things: either the lack of a deal will force a delay and second referendum which will result in Remain winning, or they will be effectively unscathed by Brexit. I have to believe they are counting on the first outcome, as it is a purely political calculation, and in the spirit of European referenda since the EU’s creation, each time a vote went against the EU’s interest (Maastricht, Treaty of Lisbon, etc.) the government of the rejecting country ignored the result and forced another vote to get the ‘right’ result. However, in this case, it appears the EU is playing a very risky game. None of the other referenda had the same type of economic consequences as Brexit, and a miscalculation will be very tough to overcome.

While several weeks ago, it appeared that PM May had been building some support, the latest estimates are for a repeat of the 230-vote loss from late January. The question is what happens after that. And to that, there is no clear answer. The probability of a hard Brexit continues to rise, although many still anticipate a last-minute deal. But the pound has declined for nine consecutive sessions by a total of 3.0% (-0.2% overnight) and unless some good news shows up, has the opportunity to fall much further. The next several weeks will certainly be interesting, but for hedgers, quite difficult.

As to the Fed, last night Chairman Powell was interviewed on 60 Minutes along with former Fed Chairs Bernanke and Yellen. Powell explained that the economy was strong with a favorable outlook and that rates were at an appropriate level for the current situation. When questioned on the impact of President Trump’s complaints, he maintained that the Fed remained apolitical and independent in their judgements. And when asked about the stock market, he essentially admitted that they have expanded their mandate to include financial markets. Given the broad financialization of the economy, I guess this makes sense. At any rate, there is no way a Fed chair will ever describe the economy poorly or forecast lower growth as it would cause a panic in markets.

Finally, turning to the trade talks, the weekend news indicated that there has been agreement over the currency question with the Chinese accepting an effective floor to the renminbi. Although the Chinese denied that there was a one-way deal, they repeated their mantra of maintaining a stable currency. As yet, no signing ceremony has been scheduled, so the deal is not done. However, Chinese equity markets rebounded sharply overnight (after Friday’s debacle) as expectations grow that a deal will be ready soon. It continues to strike me that altering the Chinese economic model is likely to take longer than a few months of negotiations and anything that comes out of these talks will be superficial at best. However, any deal will certainly be the catalyst for a sharp equity rally, of that you can be sure. One other thing to note about China is that we continue to see softening data there. Over the weekend, Loan growth was reported at a much lower than expected CNY 703B ($79.4B), not the type of data that portends a rebound. And early this morning, Vehicle Sales were reported falling 13.8%! Again, more evidence of a slowing economy there.

In the meantime, Friday’s payroll data was a lot less positive than had been expected. The headline NFP number of just 20K (exp 180K) was a massive disappointment, and though previous months were revised higher, it was just by 12K. However, the Unemployment Rate fell to 3.8% and Average Hourly Earnings rose 3.4% Y/Y, the strongest since 2007. Housing data was also positive, so the news, overall, was mixed. Friday saw markets turn mildly negative on the US, with both equities and the dollar under pressure.

Add it all up and you have a picture of slowing global growth with the idea that monetary policy is going to tighten quickly fading from view. The critical concern is that central bankers have run out of tools to help positively impact their economies when things slow down. And that is a much larger long-term worry than a modest slowing of growth right now.

Looking at the data this week, two key data points will be released, Retail Sales and CPI. Here is the full list:

Today Retail Sales -0.1%
  -ex autos 0.2%
  Business Inventories 0.6%
Tuesday NFIB Small Biz Optimism 102.0
  CPI 0.2% (1.6% Y/Y)
  -ex food & energy 0.2% (2.2% Y/Y)
Wednesday Durable Goods -0.7%
  -ex transport 0.2%
  PPI 0.2% (1.9% Y/Y)
  -ex food & energy 0.2% (2.6% Y/Y)
  Construction Spending 0.4%
Thursday Initial Claims 225K
  New Home Sales 620K
Friday Empire Manufacturing 10.0
  IP 0.4%
  Capacity Utilization 78.5%
  Michigan Sentiment 95.5
  JOLT’s Jobs Report 7.22M

So, lots of stuff, plus another Powell speech this evening, but I think Retail Sales will be the big one. Recall, last month, Retail Sales fell 1.2% and nobody believed it. But I have to say the forecast is hardly looking for a major rebound. In the end, though, the US economy continues to be the top performing one around, and while the Fed may no longer be tightening, we are seeing easing pressures elsewhere (RBA, ECB). Today’s price action has shown little overall movement in the dollar, but the future still portends more strength.

Good luck
Adf