Tag Archives: #minutes

The NASDAQ in Tatters

Posted on by

The only thing that really matters
Is whether NVIDIA shatters
It’s forecasted earnings
And market bulls’ yearnings
Else watch for the NASDAQ in tatters
 
Of lesser importance we see
The thoughts from the FOMC
Since last they all met
Stock bulls have beset
The rate hawks with obvious glee

 

While I know this is a macro focused discussion, and that is what this poet understands best, unquestionably, the biggest market news for the day, for all markets, is the NVIDIA earnings release after the close this afternoon.  There has been more press about this particular number, and more commentary on Fintwit (FinX?) than any other single stock earnings number I can remember.  And let me be clear, I have no idea what is forecast, let alone what the whisper number is, nor do I really care.  But I am definitely in the minority.  My take is that there are many analysts who will consider adjusting their big picture view of the economy and markets based on one company’s earnings.  This might be a sign that things are somewhat unhinged in markets.  

Before then, absent any hard statistical data, we will see the FOMC Minutes from the January 31st meeting.  You may remember that as the one where Chairman Powell flopped back to hawkish after he flipped to a dovish pivot in December.  Since then, there has been a pretty steady drumbeat from all the FOMC members that they are still not confident they have beaten inflation and so want to wait further before they cut rates.  And it’s a good thing they have had that view as last week we all saw that inflation was not cooling quite like the doves had expected.  In fact, they look pretty smart right now because of their reluctance to join the rate cutting mania.

A review of the Fed funds futures this morning shows that the probability for a March cut has fallen to just 6.5% while May is down to a 37.3% probability.  As a demonstration of just how much things have changed in the past month, in the middle of January, March was priced for a 46% probability and May for an 85% probability of the first cut in the cycle.  As well, we have seen the number of cuts priced for the full year fall from 6 down to just under 4, not far from the dot plot guidance we received back in December.  So far, the Fed has been successful in getting its message across despite a great deal of wailing and gnashing of teeth that if they didn’t cut soon, the world would end.

This begs the question, why is everybody so keen to see the Fed cut rates at all?  Consider the issue from the perspective of the saver and retiree.  Things are much better when one’s money market account yields 5% than 0% so I expect that most retirees are pretty happy at the current state of affairs.  From the equity market’s perspective, the very fact that we have set 11 new S&P 500 all-time highs so far in 2024 indicates that the current level of interest rates is not that big a problem broadly speaking.  Yes, there are segments of the market that have underperformed but that is always the case.  

On the flipside, of course, Janet Yellen would like to see rates decline as it would cut her interest rate bill, and certainly all those commercial property holders with mortgages coming due this year, a number that has grown to ~$960 billion I understand, are desperate for lower rates, but that is a pretty small subset of the country.  All I’m saying is that if the current rate structure is benefitting savers and also putting downward pressure on the rate of inflation, it’s just not clear why so many are desperate for a change.  And what if, just for argument’s sake, PCE is hot as is the February CPI print which comes ahead of the next FOMC meeting?  Rate hikes are going to start to get discussed a lot more frequently.

One other thing to keep in mind is that the US economy is currently the only major one that is showing any real life.  Europe, the UK and Japan are all in recession and China’s growth is effectively stagnating.  Other nations are desperate to cut interest rates to help support their economies but are unwilling to do so for fear that their currencies will fall further and invite even more inflation (China excluded) onto their shores.  So, they really want the Fed to cut so they can follow along without the concomitant problem of a falling currency.  But is the Fed responsible for the problems in Europe or Japan?  I think not.

At any rate, we will not solve this dilemma today, and all we can do is observe how things play out over the coming weeks and months.  FWIW, which is probably not a huge amount, I have seen precious little evidence that inflation is going to collapse, and rather expect it to stay here or edge higher.  In that case, I think the Fed may maintain their current rates for far longer than even June.  Absent a banking crisis, perhaps started by more trouble in the commercial real estate sector, my view remains, at most, one token cut this year.  Of course, if we do see that banking crisis, then 300bps will be the minimum.

Ok, overnight, most markets remain in thrall to the NVIDIA earnings story with one exception, China, where the regulators there tightened things even further instituting a new rule that there can be no net selling by institutional accounts in the first 30 minutes of trading or the last 30 minutes of trading.  This was in response to an algorithmic hedge fund selling a huge chunk of shares Tuesday ($350mm) in just a one-minute window and pressuring the whole market lower.  Apparently, they have been fined and prevented from trading for the rest of the week.  The idea behind the rule seems to be that if there can be no net selling in the last 30 minutes, the Chinese plunge protection team can work its magic unimpeded and push things higher on command.  I continue to wonder why the Chinese Communist Party is so keen to support the very essence of capitalism, but there you have it.  

With this in mind, you will not be surprised to know that the CSI 300 rallied 1.4% and the Hang Seng 1.6% overnight.  But the rest of Asia was less positive with most markets following the US lead lower.  Europe, though, except for the UK’s -0.85% performance, is higher on the day despite an absence of any major data or news.  The scuttlebutt is that there is a positive vibe for NVIDIA earnings.  Seriously!  As to the US futures, at this hour (7:45), they are continuing yesterday’s decline with the NASDAQ leading the way lower by -0.65%.

In the bond market, Treasury yields are softer by 1bp this morning while most European yields are higher by 1bp, so in other words, not much movement overall.  Asia saw a similar lack of movement as traders are awaiting the Minutes, NVIDIA and the uptick in Fedspeak tomorrow.

Oil prices (-0.4%) are a bit lower this morning but are just giving up yesterday’s small gains.  In fact, they are essentially unchanged so far in February as concerns over weakening global growth have been offset by concerns over an uptick in the middle east anxiety.  Speaking of energy, what I haven’t mentioned is NatGas, which while higher today by 10%, given it has fallen to $1.75/MMBtu, the move is not that impressive.  Warmer than expected weather has really undermined the price action lately.  In the metals markets, gold (+0.3%) continues to creep higher and today copper (+0.3%) is following suit.  As to aluminum, it is much higher, +2.4%, as concerns over fresh US sanctions on Russian aluminum have raised the risk of overall market disruption.

Finally, the dollar is little changed against most of its counterparts, G10 and EMG.  The biggest mover I see is ZAR (+0.4%) after core CPI ticked higher than expected and raised thoughts of tighter monetary policy there.  In the G10, NZD (+0.25%) is also responding to a higher-than-expected PPI print bringing a rate hike more sharply into focus there.  Otherwise, nada.

Aside from the Minutes, there is nothing else of note on the data calendar.  We do hear from Atlanta’s Raphael Bostic and Governor Michelle Bowman today, but I don’t expect either to waver from the current lack of confidence story.  It feels like it is going to be a quiet session overall, with the real fireworks reserved for 4:15 or so when NVIDIA reports.

Good luck

Adf

Somewhat Miffed

Posted on by

The Minutes did naught to explain
Why Jay might need raise rates again
But if we all harken
The Fed’s Thomas Barkin
The future seems cloudy with rain
 
So, now it seems Jay’s somewhat miffed
As he and his team try to shift
The views he expressed
That rate cuts were blessed
And markets did act sure and swift

 

Remember the certainty with which market participants determined that the Fed had not only finished raising interest rates, but that they would be cutting them quite soon?  That is so last year!  It seems that after a powerful Santa Claus rally that was inaugurated by Secretary Yellen’s move to issue more T-bills and less coupons, and then seemingly confirmed at the December FOMC meeting, where the dot plot showed no more rate hikes and a median expectation of three cuts this year, and where Chairman Powell, when given a chance to push back on this new narrative in the press conference, went out of his way to embrace the ‘rate cuts coming soon’ narrative, the Fed is no longer happy about the situation.  Instead, now they seem to want the market to ratchet back these expectations for a quick decline in interest rates.  At least, that’s what we heard from Richmond Fed president Tom Barkin yesterday, “The FOMC’s December meeting got a lot of attention. We acknowledged the progress on inflation and explicitly reaffirmed our willingness to hike if necessary.”  [emphasis added].

Meanwhile, the Minutes seemed to lean more hawkish than not, “It was possible that the economy could evolve in a manner that would make further increases in the target rate appropriate.  Several also observed that circumstances might warrant keeping the target range at its current value for longer than they currently anticipated.”  Arguably the best line, though, was “Participants generally perceived a high degree of uncertainty surrounding the economic outlook,” which is likely the most honest statement they have ever made.  In the end, the Minutes didn’t sound very dovish to me, but as I mentioned above, the press conference came across far more dovishly.  One other thing to note is that they mentioned QT for the first time in quite a while.  It seems that they recognize the incongruity of shrinking the balance sheet while cutting interest rates, so they have begun to consider how to message any changes there.

With this new information being absorbed, the market is now in the process of re-evaluating the idea that rate cuts are going to happen as quickly and as substantially as thought just a week ago.  At this time, there is just a 10% probability of a cut at the end of this month (it was nearer 20% last week) and the March probability is down to 70% (it was 79% last week) though the market is still pricing in 6 cuts in 2024.  FWIW, that seems outside the bounds of how things will ultimately play out, and I maintain that while a cut could easily be made by the May meeting, I do not foresee inflation cooperating which will force a lot of rethinking.

To summarize the Fed story, the market has sensed a disturbance in the easing force that had been widely assumed and a key driver of the late 2023 risk rally.  This morning, markets have stabilized after two consecutive negative days to open the year.  As such, let us keep our eyes peeled for more, new and, potentially non-narrative, information going forward. 

Looking at the latest data releases overnight and this morning, they consisted of the Services PMI data as well as German state inflation.  Regarding the former, both Australian and Japanese data were soft although Chinese data was better than expected with the Caixin Services PMI printing at 52.9, continuing its rebound from summer lows.  Across Europe, Italian (49.8), French (45.7), German (49.3) and the Eurozone composite (48.8) all showed contractionary numbers although the UK (53.4) vastly outperformed.  As to the German state-by-state inflation readings, every one of them bounced sharply from last month’s recent lows and the market is looking for a sharp rebound in the national CPI to 3.7% later this morning.  As I have written before, that combination of rising inflation and weak growth is a tough situation for Madame Lagarde.  My money is still on her to address the growth rather than the inflation, although she will likely wait until the Fed moves before doing so in Frankfurt.

With all this in mind, let’s take a look at the overnight market activity.  In Asia, the picture was mixed although there was more red than green on the screen.  While the Nikkei (-0.5%) fell, other Japanese indices held their own, and we saw some strength in Indian shares as well.  However, China remains under pressure, despite the stronger than anticipated PMI reading and that has been weighing on South Korea, Hong Kong and Australia overall.  However, in Europe, we are seeing modest gains this morning, only on the order of 0.1% or 0.2%, but green is more pleasant than the red of the past two days.  As to US futures, they are little changed at this hour, although again, better than their recent performance.

In the bond market, from the time I wrote yesterday morning, yields fell through the rest of the session by nearly 7bps in the 10yr Treasury market, and this morning, they have bounced back from the closing levels by 4bps.  We have seen similar price action throughout Europe where yesterday’s declines to closing lows have been reversed and we are now between 6bps and 9bps higher than the end of Wednesday’s session.  JGB yields, though, remain anchored at 0.60%, unchanged.

Oil (+1.0%) is continuing to rebound as the situation in the Middle East seems to be getting more complex.  The Houthis continue to attack Red Sea shipping, Israel killed a Hezbollah leader in Lebanon, potentially widening the conflict and there was a terrorist bombing in Iran (with the best guess it was internally executed by an unhappy faction) which can only serve to increase the overall tension levels.  While the broader weakness we have seen in this space is likely a response to weaker overall economic activity, especially in China, at some point, that activity will pick up and I expect oil prices to do so as well.  In the metals complex, base metals are under further pressure this morning, with both copper and aluminum down -0.6% or so, although gold (+0.2%) is bucking that trend, perhaps on the back of the dollar’s marginal weakness this morning.

Speaking of the dollar, as measured by the DXY it is -0.2% softer this morning with pretty uniform losses vs the major G10 and EMG currencies.  The one exception is the yen (-0.6%) which continues to suffer based on the idea that the BOJ will not be able to consider interest rate normalization in the wake of the recent earthquake on the country’s west coast.  In truth, the dollar seems to be quite the afterthought in markets right now, with much greater focus on the bond market and central bank actions as the drivers.  While I would carefully watch if the dollar starts to break these correlations, I don’t see it as a key driver right now.

On the data front, we see a few things this morning, starting with ADP Employment (exp 115K) and then Initial (216K) and Continuing (1883K) Claims.  As well the Services PMI data is released later this morning (51.3) and finally we get the EIA oil inventories with another large draw of 3.7 million barrels expected which ought to continue to support the black, sticky stuff.

There are no Fed speakers on the calendar although we must all be watchful for the pop-up CNBC interview if they feel their message, whatever it may currently be, is not getting proper attention.  While the first two sessions of the year were certainly uncomfortable for risk assets, I do not believe that my idea of a solid first half followed by more evident problems in the second half of the year has been dismantled.  Clearly, tomorrow’s NFP data will be critical, and we will discuss it ahead of the release.  Until then…

Good luck

Adf

A Raw Deal

Posted on by 
The Minutes according to Jay
Explained more rate hikes are in play
At least that’s the spin
From media kin
But could that lead us all astray?

Yesterday’s key news was the release of the FOMC Minutes.  The market read, at least the headline read, was that they were hawkish which played a key role in the equity market decline in the afternoon, as well as the bond market decline leading to the highest 10yr yields since 2008.  Below is what I believe is the key paragraph from the Minutes with my emphasis.

“With inflation still well above the Committee’s longer-run goal and the labor market remaining tight, most participants continued to see significant upside risks to inflation, which could require further tightening of monetary policy. Some participants commented that even though economic activity had been resilient and the labor market had remained strong, there continued to be downside risks to economic activity and upside risks to the unemployment rate; these included the possibility that the macroeconomic effects of the tightening in financial conditions since the beginning of last year could prove more substantial than anticipated. A number of participants judged that, with the stance of monetary policy in restrictive territory, risks to the achievement of the Committee’s goals had become more two sided, and it was important that the Committee’s decisions balance the risk of an inadvertent overtightening of policy against the cost of an insufficient tightening.” 

It strikes me that based on the fact we have already heard from two FOMC voting members, Harker and Williams, that rate cuts are on their mind for 2024, and the lines I have highlighted above, the once unanimous view of a hawkish Fed is beginning to fall apart.  Now, if the data continues to outperform expectations like it has recently (consider the Retail Sales data from Tuesday) I expect the FOMC to maintain their hawkishness.  The Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow forecast has just risen to 5.75%, far above trend growth and certainly no implication for the end of tightening.  But remember, that is a volatile series, and we are a long way from the end of Q3.  Ultimately, I suspect that a growing number of FOMC members are starting to get queasy over the higher for longer mantra given the equity market’s recent shudders.  We shall see.

The Chinese are starting to feel
That Xi’s given them a raw deal
The yuan keeps on falling
While growth there is stalling
And values of homes are unreal

The PBOC was pretty vocal last night as they explained all the things they are going to do to manage a clearly deteriorating situation in China.  Here are some of the comments they released:

PBOC: TO MAKE CREDIT GROWTH MORE STABLE, SUSTAINABLE

PBOC: TO USE VARIOUS TOOLS TO KEEP REASONABLY AMPLE LIQUIDITY

PBOC: TO RESOLUTELY PREVENT OVER-ADJUSTMENT IN EXCHANGE RATE

PBOC: TO OPTIMIZE PROPERTY POLICIES AT APPROPRIATE TIME

PBOC: CHINA IS NOT IN DEFLATION RIGHT NOW

PBOC: LOCAL FISCAL BALANCE PRESSURE INCREASING

PBOC: HAS EXPERIENCES, TOOLS TO SAFGUARD STABLE FOREX MARKET

Which was followed by the following headline, CHINA TOLD STATE BANKS TO ESCALATE YUAN INTERVENTION THIS WEEK.

Add it all up and the Chinese are getting increasingly worried.  There is a great chart in Bloomberg today that shows the change in house prices across China, which puts paid to the official narrative that prices have fallen just 2.4% from the August 2021 highs.  They have clearly fallen a lot more as evidenced by this chart and the comments above.

In the end, the Chinese have a lot of work to do to keep their economy going.  While they remain concerned over the weakening CNY, it is clearly one of the best relief valves they have, and it will slowly weaken further.  Money is leaving the country.

An attitude change
Is becoming apparent
No JGBs please!

And finally last night the BOJ auctioned off some 20yr JGBs and the auction results were awful.  The tail was the widest, at nearly 8bps, since 1987, while the spread between 10yr and 20yr bonds widened by nearly 5bps.  It seems that demand was not nearly as robust as had been expected.  Given that nominal yields in the 20yr are 1.35% and CPI is 3.2% core, it is not that surprising.  Bonds everywhere are losing their luster, at least longer duration bonds, and I see no reason for that trend to end until economic activity is clearly declining.  China’s woes have not yet bled to either the US or Japan, while inflation remains sticky.  Today, globally yields are higher by between 4bps and 6bps.  This process still has more to go in my estimation.

Which brings us to the rest of the overnight session, where after another weak equity performance in the US, we saw Japan and non-China Asia soften, although Chinese markets held in on the back of the PBOC comments and promises of more support for the economy there.  European bourses are somewhat softer this morning but nothing dramatic and at this hour (7:30) US futures are higher by about 0.25% across the board.

Oil prices (+0.9%) have rebounded and after a brief foray below $80/bbl have recaptured that key level.  Metals prices are also firmer this morning across the board as both base and precious varieties see demand.  This seems largely in line with the fact the dollar is under modest pressure this morning.

And the dollar is under modest pressure this morning, at least vs. the G10, where every currency is firmer, but the moves are very small.  NOK (+0.4%) is the leader on the back of the oil move, but everything else is higher by between 0.1% and 0.25%.  In the emerging markets, the picture is a bit more mixed, with some gainers (ZAR +0.45%, HUF +0.35%) and some laggards (MYR -0.55%, PHP -0.5%) with both those currencies feeling pressure from concerns their respective central banks will not maintain the inflation fight.

On the data front, we see Initial (exp 240K) and Continuing (1700K) Claims as well as Philly Fed (-10.4) and Leading Indicators (-0.4%).  The data continues to have both highs and lows with yesterday’s IP jumping 1.0%, much better than expected, but the Empire Mfg data on Tuesday a very weak -19.  There are no Fed speakers today so I expect much will depend on whether or not dip buyers emerge in the equity markets.  It feels like we are teetering on the edge of a bigger risk-off move with another 10% down in equities entirely possible.  In that event, I do like the dollar to show resolve.

Good luck

Adf

Angina

Posted on by 
This week all the problems in China
Have given the markets angina
Last night, we are told
Stocks oughtn’t be sold
While Xi tries to hold a hard line-a

For the third day in a row, China is the story du jour.  Two stories from last night illustrate the problems in the Chinese economy are either spreading more widely or simply becoming more widely known outside China.  The litany of issues are as follows: Chinese authorities requested that investment funds not be net sellers of equities this week; the PBOC added the most cash to the economy via reverse repos in six months; investors who have not been repaid by Zhongrong International Trust were seen outside the company’s Beijing HQ protesting openly; and the yuan continues to slide despite PBOC efforts to moderate the currency’s decline.

A brief recap of the process in the onshore CNY market shows that each morning the PBOC sets a central rate for the day (the CFETS rate), ostensibly based on a basket of currencies they follow, and when the market starts trading, it must remain within a +/- 2% band around that central rate.  Historically, when the PBOC wanted to signal that the currency was getting too strong or too weak, that CFETS rate would be set further in their desired direction than the model implied to help guide the market.  Well, lately, the PBOC has been setting the CFETS rate for a much stronger than expected CNY, but the market has largely been ignoring that. Bloomberg has an excellent chart showing the rising discrepancy that I have reprinted below.

The bars on the chart represent the difference, in pips on the RHS axis, between the actual CFETS fix and the estimates from analysts’ models.  Notice that from November 2022 through the beginning of July, that difference was virtually nil.  The point is the models have proven themselves over time to be accurate, so these big discrepancies are policy choices.

As the PBOC watches the currency of its closest ally, Russia, collapse in slow-motion, it is clearly concerned about its own situation.  The added pressure of slowing growth and the problems in the investment sector are making things more difficult.  The fact that China is on a monetary easing path while the rest of the world is still tightening is naturally going to undermine the value of the renminbi, but the great fear in China is a rapid devaluation.  

The biggest problem the PBOC has is that unlike the situation with youth unemployment, where they simply decided to stop publishing the data, they don’t really have that choice in this situation.  They cannot hide what they are doing and expect that the FX market will be able to function realistically.  And China needs an FX market because of the huge portion of their economy that is reliant on international trade.  

There is no easy answer for the Chinese here.  If they seek to support the domestic economy with easier monetary policy, the renminbi is very likely to continue to fall as locals seek to get their money out of the country and invest in higher yielding assets.  The fact that the Chinese equity markets have been slumping simply adds more pressure to the situation.  There is a well-known idea in international finance called the impossible trilemma which states that no country can have the following three things simultaneously:

  1. A fixed foreign exchange rate 
  2. Free capital movement
  3. Independent monetary policy

China’s situation is that while the FX rate is not actually fixed, it is carefully and closely managed; while there are significant capital controls, there is still a steady flow of funds leaving the country, often via international real estate investments, so there is some freedom of flows; although of course, there is no attempt at independence by the central bank.  However, what we can readily observe is that even maintaining control of the currency while there is any ability to move capital offshore is virtually impossible these days.  Nothing has changed my view that we are headed to 7.50 and beyond over time.  And, to think, I didn’t even have to discuss weak earnings from Tencent or further concerns about Country Garden going bankrupt.

With that as our backdrop, it cannot be surprising that risk is under some pressure.  After all, the Chinese economy remains the second largest in the world.  The big change for markets is that after two decades of China being the fastest growing major economy in the world, now it is much slower than both Japan and the US (Europe is still in the dumps) and portfolio adjustments are still being made.

Looking at the overnight session, after a weak US market, with all three major indices lower by more than -1.0%, Asia followed suit completely, with markets there also under significant pressure, falling by -1.0% or more pretty much throughout the time zone.  European bourses, though, have edged higher after a weak performance yesterday, but the gains are di minimis, and in the UK, after inflation data showed the BOE’s job is not nearly done, the FTSE is a bit softer.  US futures are little changed this morning as the market awaits the FOMC Minutes this afternoon.

Treasury yields have backed off a bit, down about 2bps, and we are seeing similar movements in Europe. However, 10yr Treasury yields remain well above 4.0% and certainly seem like they are trending higher.  In the wake of the much stronger than expected Retail Sales data yesterday morning, 10yr yields spiked to 4.26%, their highest level since last October, and tantalizingly close to the highest levels seen in more than 15 years.

Oil prices (+0.3%) which have been sliding for the past week, consolidating their strong move over the past two months, seem to be stabilizing above $80/bbl for now.  We are also seeing modest strength in the metals complex today, although the movement has been very tiny.  Gold has managed to hold the $1900/oz level, but its future performance will depend on the dollar writ large I think.

And finally, the dollar, which has been quite strong overall lately, is softening a touch this morning, with only two weaker currencies in the EMG bloc, KRW (-0.5%) and CNY (-0.1%) as both respond to the problems mentioned above.  But elsewhere, this seems to be a bit of a relief rally with the dollar sagging broadly.  The G10 space is seeing similar price action with only CHF (-0.2%) and JPY (-0.1%) lagging slightly, while the rest of the bloc edges higher.  But movement of this tiny magnitude tends to mean very little.

On the data front, Housing Starts (exp 1450K) and Building Permits (1463K) come first thing with IP (0.3%) and Capacity Utilization (79.1%) at 9:15.  Finally, at 2:00 the Minutes from the July FOMC meeting will be released and given the change in tone we have heard from several members lately, with cuts now on the table for next year, it will be interesting to see how that plays out.

Today feels like a consolidation day, without any significant catalysts, so I expect a quiet session overall.  Unless the Minutes change everyone’s views regarding the next steps by the Fed, I maintain my view of dollar strength over time.  At least until the Fed actually turns things around.

Good luck

Adf

Inflation’s Fate’s Sealed

Posted on by 
The Minutes revealed that the Fed
When pondering their views ahead
Are no longer all
Completely in thrall
With hiking til more ink is red

However, they also revealed
That some felt a still higher yield
Was proper for June
And want more hikes soon
To make sure inflation’s fate’s sealed

Yesterday’s FOMC Minutes were interesting for the fact that after more than a year of the committee remaining completely in sync, it appears we have finally reached the point where there is a more robust discussion of the next steps.  The hawkish pause skip was very clearly an uneasy compromise between those members who thought it was appropriate, after 10 consecutive rate hikes, to step back and see if things were actually playing out in the manner their models predicted and those that remained adamant it was inappropriate to delay their process as there has been far too little progress on the reduction in services inflation.  Remember, the Fed’s models are entirely Keynesian in that they assume higher interest rates reduce demand by forcing financing costs higher.  It is why Chairman Powell has repeatedly explained that in order to achieve their goals, a little pain is going to be required.

 

But consider the nature of the current bout of inflation.  Was this driven by excess money being created in the banking sector and spent on business investment, or even share buybacks?  Or was this inflation driven by excess money being created, and then handed directly to the public in order to help everyone during the government-imposed lockdowns, thus spent immediately on goods, and eventually on services once the lockdowns were lifted?

 

I would argue that the latter is a more accurate representation of the current situation, one more akin to the post WWII economy than the 1970’s oil embargo led economy.  If this is the situation, then perhaps continuing to raise interest rates may not be the best solution to the problem.  In fact, as Lynn Alden indicates in her most recent piece, it could well be counterproductive.  If this inflation is fiscally (meaning government led) driven rather than monetarily (meaning bank lending led) driven, higher interest rates simply add to the amount of money available to spend by the public.  In fact, this process becomes circular as higher interest rates increase the amount of interest paid to bondholders adding to their disposable incomes, while simultaneously increasing the size of the fiscal deficit, thus increasing debt issuance, and driving interest rates higher still.  This is an unenviable place for the Fed to find itself, especially since its models don’t really accept this premise.  Rather, they continue to fight the 1970’s inflation via the Volcker playbook, which may only exacerbate the situation.

 

My growing concern is that the Fed is fighting the wrong enemy, and in fact, has no tools to fight the excessive fiscal spending which is currently the key driver of demand.  As such, it is very realistic to expect inflation, whether measured as PCE or CPI, is going to remain elevated on a core basis for quite a while yet.  When combining this thesis with both deglobalization and incremental labor shortages, the case for higher inflation for longer becomes even more compelling.  We have already seen that the housing market has not behaved at all in the manner expected by the Fed’s (or anybody’s) models, with prices holding up far better than anticipated given the dramatic rise in interest rates over the past 18 months.  It is not hard to believe that other variables in the Fed’s models are equally wrong.  In the end, this is further confirmation, to me, that the Fed will be fighting its inflation battle for a very long time.

 

How have markets reacted to this new information?  Not terribly well with financial assets falling in value around the world.  This is true in equities, where yesterday’s modest US declines were followed by much sharper falls in Asia and Europe with the Hang Seng (-3.0%) the laggard but all of Europe down by more than -1.0% today.  US futures are also under pressure, down about -0.4% as I type (7:30).

 

But despite the fall in equity markets, bond prices are tumbling as well with yields rising around the world.  Treasury yields are actually the best performers, rising only 4bps this morning, although that has taken them tantalizingly close to the 4.00% level which has proven to be a more significant hurdle for equities in the recent past.  But in Europe and the UK, bond yields are screaming higher with Gilts (+10bps) leading the way, but all Continental sovereigns seeing yields rise by at least 6bps.  This is interesting given the fact that the only data released today was Construction PMI data which was incredibly weak across all of Europe and the UK.  Clearly, the prospect of higher Fed funds is one of the driving forces here as higher for longer gets more deeply embedded in the market belief set.

 

Speaking of higher Fed funds, the market is currently pricing an 85% probability of a hike later this month and then only a slight chance of a second one, despite the Fed’s comments.  In Europe, the situation is similar, with a 90% probability priced for July but only one more hike in total by the end of the year.  And remember, the ECB is 125bps behind the Fed in terms of the level of rates, and inflation remains higher in the Eurozone than in the US.  It feels like there will be more changes to come in these markets.

 

Oil prices, meanwhile, continue to be supported with the rationale being the Saudi’s continued production cuts.  While there is a story that Iran has been pumping more oil into the market, the price action has certainly been a bit more bullish lately.  Structurally, there is still going to be a shortage of oil over time, but for now, that doesn’t seem to matter.  Meanwhile, base metals are edging lower this morning, after the weak construction data, and gold remains stuck in its consolidation.

 

As to the dollar, it is generally, though not universally, lower this morning with the yen (+0.6%) the leading gainer on fading risk sentiment, although there is also a building story that Ueda-san is going to be making some adjustments in the near future in order to mitigate the recent weakness.  While it has been relatively slow and steady, as it approaches 145, it clearly seems to be generating some discomfort.  But in the G10, the weakness is broad.  However, in the EMG bloc, the dollar has had a much better showing rising against a majority of the group with ZAR (-0.9%) the laggard on the weaker metals’ prices, but weakness throughout APAC and LATAM currencies as well.  If we continue to see US rates climb higher, I expect that the dollar will be dragged along for the ride.

 

On the data front today, there is a lot of stuff, starting with ADP Employment (exp 225K) and followed by the Trade Balance (-$69.0B), Initial Claims (245K), Continuing Claims (1734K), JOLTS Job Openings (9885K) and finally ISM Services (51.2) at 10:00.  I saw a story that there has been a seasonal adjustment issue with the Claims data because of the Juneteenth holiday, which is quite new, and so not necessarily properly accounted for in the release.  Over time, these things will smooth out, but do not be surprised if today’s Claims print is higher than expected.  And of course, this all leads up to tomorrow’s NFP report, something I will discuss then.  Dallas’s Lori Logan speaks today, but she is not currently a voter.  Next week, however, we hear from a lot of Fed speakers, so perhaps some fireworks are on the horizon.

 

Overall, I think there is a case to be made that the Fed is looking in the wrong direction and that they will continue to raise the Fed funds rate and drive all yields higher without having the desired disinflationary impact.  In that scenario, I think the dollar still looks the best of the bunch.

 

Good luck

Much Pain

Posted on by

There once was a nation quite strong

Whose policies worked for so long

But war in Ukraine

Inflicted much pain

And now it seems they were all wrong

Relying on, energy, cheap

They rose to the top of the heap

But when prices rose

They’d naught to propose

‘Bout how to, advantages, keep

It turns out that Germany has fallen into a recession after all.  The German Statistics office revised down their Q4 2022 GDP reading from stagnation at 0.0%, to a -0.5% reading after adjusting for a substantial decline in government spending.  Meanwhile, Q1 GDP growth fell -0.3%, so Germany is solidly in a recession, at least based on the traditional definition of two consecutive quarters of negative GDP growth.  It certainly is remarkable that an economy that predicated itself on levering cheap, imported energy into the manufacture of steel, chemicals and machinery would encounter any problems simply because it became totally reliant on raw materials from a communist regime…NOT!  But in fairness, the Germans have hamstrung themselves by spending hundreds of billions of euros in their Energiewende program to reduce greenhouse gas emissions.  Unfortunately, this included shuttering their entire nuclear power fleet, which had produced upwards of 25% of their electricity with zero emissions and replacing it with heavily subsidized solar and wind power generation.  (By the way, whoever thought that solar power was a good idea in Northern Europe?  Arizona I get, Germany not so much.)

Granted, prior to Vladimir Putin invading Ukraine, things were going along swimmingly.  China was soaking up so much of what Germany was producing, and of course the rest of Europe were huge customers as well.  But it turns out risk management is a real thing, and not just when it comes to your foreign exchange or interest rate risks.  If we learned nothing else from the Covid pandemic it is that surety of supply of critical products or inputs is worth a lot, perhaps just as much as the price of that supply.  

Once Russia invaded, though, the world changed dramatically, and a critical flaw in the German economy was exposed.  Prior to the invasion, because of Energiewende, German electricity prices were the highest in Europe and approaching the highest in the world.  And that included cheap Russian gas as a source.  Now those prices are higher still and major manufacturers are picking up stakes and moving their facilities to places where they can get reliable, and relatively inexpensive, energy.  BASF moving key production to both China and Saudi Arabia is merely indicative of the problems Germany will have going forward.  It strikes me that Germany has a long road to hoe in order to get their economy back working as effectively as it had in the past.  This does not bode well for the euro (-0.2%) which is continuing its slow grind lower this morning, as the dollar continues to buck the majority analyst view of USD weakness.

The future belongs to AI

At least that’s what bulls glorify

So, last night we learned

Nvidia earned

A ton helping futures to fly

Obviously, this is not an equity piece and so I rarely cover specific names, but the buzz on Nvidia’s earnings is having a significant impact on markets overall.  The most instructive thing is to look at the performance of the NASDAQ vs. that of the Dow, at least in the pre-market futures trading.  At this hour (7:30), NASDAQ futures are higher by 2.0% while Dow futures are lower by -0.4%.  This dichotomy continues to grow on a daily basis, with the tech megacaps generating virtually all of the equity market performance seen this year, hence the relative outperformance of the NASDAQ vs. both the S&P 500 and the Dow.  The narrowing breadth of the market’s performance, with 7 names accounting for more than the entire S&P 500 gains this year means the other 493 names are actually lower.  From a more macro point of view, historically, price action of this nature has preceded significant bear markets every time it has occurred.  It is very easy to look at the totality of information including still high US inflation, softening growth metrics and a stock market that is reliant on just 7 names for its performance, and conclude a reckoning is coming.  Oh yeah, did I mention that the Fed remains committed to keeping its policy at current, relatively tight levels?  It is no wonder that the recession that is forecast to come soon is so widely forecast.

Quickly, the FOMC Minutes yesterday indicated that while there was a lot of discussion as to whether or not rates needed to go higher, there was zero discussion that rates would need to decline anytime soon.  The commentary we have heard since the last meeting has certainly had a less conclusive tone regarding further hikes, with several members indicating they thought a pause for observation was worthwhile.  But unless the economy craters, and Unemployment spikes much higher, there is no reason  to believe the Fed is going to change course.  And that, my friends, will continue to support the greenback for quite a while.

As to the overnight session, after a weak US equity performance yesterday, Asia was mixed and most European bourses are edging lower on the order of -0.2%.  It is certainly no surprise that the DAX is falling, and we have also seen lackluster data from France weighing on the CAC.  The problem for Europe is they don’t have any megacap tech stocks to support the indices.

Bond yields continue to mostly edge higher with gains on the order of 1bp this morning although there was a standout here, Gilt yields have risen by 9bps, still feeling the hangover from yesterday’s inflation data.

Meanwhile, in commodities, recession is the watchword as oil prices (-1.2%) are giving back some of their recent gains, although copper has seen a trading bounce.  

And finally, in the FX markets, the dollar continues to perform well, rising against all its G10 and most EMG counterparts.  Remarkably, the debt ceiling concerns seem to be the driver as the dollar is still considered the safest of havens despite the issues here.  There have been no outstanding stories to note other than the risk-off nature of things.

On the data front, we see Initial (exp 245K) and Continuing (1800K) Claims as well as the second look at Q! GDP (1.1%).  Also, Chicago Fed  National Activity (-0.2) is released, which has been pointing to slowing economic growth for a while now.   Two Fed speakers, Barkin and Collins are on the slate today, but I feel that mixed message continues unabated and won’t be changed here.

Ultimately, until the Fed backs off, the dollar is going to continue to perform well, keep that in mind.

Good luck

Adf

Somewhat Bizarre

Posted on by

Apparently, no one expected
The Fed, when they last met, detected
Their actions thus far
Were somewhat bizarre
And so, a new stance was erected

Not only would they halt QE
But also, a shrinkage they see
In balance sheet sizing
So, it’s not surprising
The bond market filled bears with glee

“…it may become warranted to increase the federal funds rate sooner or at a faster pace than participants had earlier anticipated.”
“… participants judged that the appropriate timing of balance sheet runoff would likely be closer to that of policy rate liftoff than in the Committee’s previous experience.”
“Many participants judged that the appropriate pace of balance sheet runoff would likely be faster than it was during the previous normalization episode.”

These were the words from the FOMC Minutes of the December meeting that roiled markets yesterday afternoon.  Arguably there were more as well, but these give the gist of the issue.  Suddenly, the Fed sounds so much more serious about their willingness to not only taper QE quickly, and not only begin to raise the Fed Funds rate, but also to actually shrink their balance sheet.  If the Fed does follow through on this, and finishes QE by March, starts raising the Fed Funds rate and also begins to reduce the size of the balance sheet, then you can expect that the global risk appetite is going to be pretty significantly reduced.  In fact, I would contend it is the last of these steps that is going to undermine risk assets, as balance sheet reduction will likely result in higher long-term bond yields and less liquidity available to flow into risky assets.  As I have highlighted in the past, in 2018, the last time the Fed was both raising interest rates and shrinking the balance sheet, the resulting 20% equity market decline proved too much to withstand.  Are they made of sterner stuff this time?

One other thing to note was that while omicron was mentioned in the Minutes, it was clearly not seen as a major impediment to economic growth in the economy.   The fact that, at least in the US, there doesn’t appear to be any appetite/willingness for complete lockdowns implies that the nation is beginning to move beyond the pandemic fear to a more relaxed attitude on the issue.  Granted there are still several city and state governments that are unwilling to live and let live, but for the nation writ large, that does not seem to be the case.  From an economic perspective, this means less demand interruptions but also, likely, less supply interruptions.  The inflationary impact on this change in attitude remains uncertain, but the underlying inflationary trends remain quite strong, especially housing.  Do not be surprised to see CPI and PCE peak in Q1, but also do not be looking for a return to 2.0% levels anytime soon, that is just not in the cards.

And really, that was the driving force in yesterday’s market activity and is likely to be the key feature going forward for a while.  We will certainly need to pay close attention to Fed comments to try to gauge just how quickly these changes will be coming, and we will need to pay attention to the data to insure that nothing has changed in the collective view of a strong employment situation, but in the US, at least, this is the story.

The question now is how did other markets respond to the Minutes and what might we expect there?  Looking at equities, the picture was not pretty.  Following the release, US equity markets sold off sharply with the NASDAQ falling 3.3% on the day and both the Dow (-1.1%) and S&P500 (-1.9%) also suffering.  Activity in Asia was also broadly weaker with the Nikkei (-2.9%) and Australia’s ASX (-2.75%) both sharply lower although Chinese stocks were less impacted (Hang Seng +0.7%, Shanghai -0.25%).  The story there continues to revolve around the property sector and tech crackdowns, but recall, both of those markets had been massively underperforming prior to this Fed news.  As to Europe this morning, red is the color of the day (DAX -1.0%, CAC -1.2%, FTSE 100 -0.5%) as the data mix showed continued high inflation in Germany with every Lander having reported thus far printing above 5.1%.  As to US futures, they are not buying the bounce just yet in the NASDAQ (-0.5%), but the other two indices are faring a bit better, essentially unchanged on the day.

It can be no surprise that the bond market is under further pressure this morning as the Fed has clearly indicated they are biased to not only stop new purchases but allow old ones to mature and not be replaced.  (There is no indication they are considering actually selling bonds from the portfolio.  That would be truly groundbreaking!)  At any rate, after the Minutes, yields jumped an additional 3bps and have risen another 2.8bps this morning.  This takes the move in 10-year yields to 23 basis points since the beginning of the week/year.  Technically, we are pushing very significant resistance levels in yields as these were the highs from last March.  If we do break higher, there is some room to run.  As well, the rise in Treasury yields is driving markets worldwide with European sovereigns all selling off (Bunds +3.5bps, OATs +4.2bps, Gilts +5.5bps) and similar price action in Asia, where even JGB’s (+2.0bps) saw yields rise. Real yields have risen here, although as we have not seen an inflation print in the US since last month, that is subject to change soon.

On the commodity front, the picture is mixed today with oil (+1.2%) higher while NatGas (-1.2%) continues to slide on milder weather.  Uranium (+3.9%) has responded to the fact that Kazakhastan is the largest producer and given the growing unrest in the country, concerns have grown about its ability to deliver on contracts.  With yields higher, gold (-0.6%) and silver (-2.2%) are both softer as are copper (-1.4%) and aluminum (-0.5%).  Clearly there are growing concerns that higher interest rates are going to undermine economic growth.

Finally, in the FX markets, the broader risk-off tone is manifesting itself as a generally stronger dollar (AUD -0.7%, NZD -0.6%, NOK -0.35%) with only the yen (+0.25%) showing strength in the G10.  In the EMG bloc, the picture is a bit more mixed with laggards (THB -0.9%, CLP -0.7%, MYR -0.5%) and some gainers (ZAR +0.8%, RUB +0.7%, HUF +0.5%).  Rand is the confusing one here as the ruble is clearly benefitting from oil’s rise and the forint from bets on even more aggressive monetary policy.  However, I can find no clear rationale for the rand’s strength though I will keep looking.  On the downside, THB is suffering from an increase in the lockdown levels while MYR appears to be entirely dollar driven (higher US rates driving dollar demand) while the peso seems to be suffering from concerns over fiscal changes regarding the pension system.

On the data front, this morning brings Initial Claims (exp 195K), Continuing Claims (1680K) and the Trade Balance (-$81.0B) at 8:30 then ISM Services (67.0) and Factory Orders (1.5%, 1.1% ex transport) at 10:00.  But tomorrow’s payroll report is likely to have far more impact.  And the Fed calendar starts to fill out again with Daly and Bullard both on the slate for today and seven more speakers over the next week plus the Brainerd vice-chair hearings.

I’m a bit surprised the dollar isn’t stronger in the wake of the new Fed attitude, but perhaps that is a testimony to the fact there are many who still don’t believe they will follow through.  However, for now, I expect the dollar will continue to benefit from this thesis, albeit more gradually than previously believed, but if we do see risk appetite diminish sharply, look for a little less tightening enthusiasm from Mr Powell and friends, and that will change sentiment again.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

On the Brink

Posted on by

Most pundits worldwide seem to think
The Fed is now right on the brink
Of both raising rates
And having debates
On how soon the BS should shrink

And so, today’s Minutes are key
To see if the FOMC
Has made up its mind
That they’re now behind
The curve, and need hurry QT

I am old enough to remember the last time the Fed decided that they wanted to shrink their balance sheet and normalize policy, way back in 2018.  As I recall, when first mooted, then Fed Chair Janet Yellen (she of Treasury Secretary fame) described the process of the gradual reduction as ‘like watching paint dry.’  Who knew drying paint was so exciting!  Of course, she couldn’t bring herself to even start the process.  Ultimately, the combination of slowly raising the Fed Funds rate and simultaneously reducing the size of the balance sheet (which all occurred on Powell’s watch) led to a declining stock market throughout Q4 2018 with the largest Christmas Eve sell-off ever seen in stocks as the culmination of the events.  Two days later, Chairman Powell explained he was just kidding, and tighter monetary policy was a thing of the past.

But that was then.  It’s different this time!

Actually, it’s not.  In fact, what we have learned from observing markets for many years is that it is never different.  While the catalysts may change, market responses remain pretty much the same time and again.  So, here we are three years later with the Fed’s balance sheet having more than doubled in the intervening period, equity markets having made 70 record highs in the past twelve months and the 10-year bond yielding half what it was back then. Inflation is raging, as opposed to the situation back then, and GDP, while higher than back then, has clearly peaked and is reversing some of the pandemic-induced policy giddiness.  But human nature is still the same.  Greed and fear remain the constants and investor and trader responses to policy decisions are pretty cut and dried.  You can be confident that if longer date interest rates rise, whether in a steepening or flattening yield curve, the rationale for the mega cap stocks to maintain their value is going to diminish quickly.  And as they are the ‘generals’ of the equity market rally, when they start to fall, so will everything else, including the indices.  Ask yourself how long the Fed, whose members are virtually all multi-millionaires and hold large equity portfolios, are going to sit by and allow the stock market to correct just because some Austrian school monetary hawks believe in sound money.  Exactly.

However, we have not yet reached the point where the markets have started to decline substantially, as, of course, the Fed has not yet started to even raise interest rates, let alone shrink the balance sheet.  But that is the growing consensus view amongst the punditry, that today’s FOMC Minutes from the December meeting are going to reveal the level of interest to begin that part of policy normalization.  Many analysts continue to highlight the fact that inflation is becoming such a problem that the Fed will be forced to stay the course this time.  I wish it were so, but strongly believe that history has shown they will not.  Rather, they will change the inflation calculations and continue to explain that the alternative is worse.

Yesterday, Minneapolis Fed President Neel Kashkari, the most dovish of all FOMC members, explained that he believes the Fed Funds rate needs to rise 0.50% this year as, “…inflation has been higher and more persistent than I had expected.”   It is comments such as this that have the analyst community convinced the Fed is really going to tighten this time.  But we have heard these before as well.  This is not to say that the Minutes won’t hint at QT, they very well could do so.  However, when the rubber meets the road and risk assets are falling sharply in price, the Fed will exhibit its underlying Blepharospasm, and tighter policy will be a thing of the past (as will a stronger dollar!)

Now, leading up to the Minutes, let’s take a look at what happened last night.  In the wake of a bit of equity market schizophrenia in the US, we have seen a mixed picture.  Yesterday saw the NASDAQ fall sharply (there’s that concern over higher rates) while the Dow managed to rally.  Overnight saw the Nikkei (+0.1%) bide its time but the Hang Seng (-1.6%) and Shangahi (-1.0%) both suffer on a combination of the ongoing property sector problems as well as more lockdowns in country.  Europe, on the other hand, has managed to stay in the green (DAX +0.6%, CAC +0.5%, FTSE 100 +0.2%) after PMI Services data was released a little bit softer than forecast, but still seen as quite positive.  In a way, this was a ‘bad news is good’ idea as softening growth means the ECB doesn’t need to respond to Europe’s very high inflation readings so dramatically.  Alas, US futures are flat except for NASDAQ futures, which are lower by -0.4%.

In the bond market, while yesterday saw an early sell off in Treasuries, it was mostly unwound by the end of the day and this morning yields are little changed at 1.645%.  As to Europe, yesterday also saw Gilt yields rally sharply, 12.5 bps, but they have consolidated today, falling 1bp while the rest of the continent has seen much less movement.  Clearly, there is far less concern over ECB activity than either Fed or BOE.

As to the commodity space, oil (+0.3%) is edging higher and NatGas (+2.3%) is firming on the cold weather in the Northeast.  (Of course, compared to what happened in Kazakhastan, where the government was kicked out by the president because of high energy prices, this seems rather tame!)  Metals prices are mixed with gold (+0.2%) still hanging around $1800, while copper (-0.6%) is clearly less enamored of the current economic situation.

Finally, the dollar is under modest pressure this morning, with SEK (+0.5%) the leading G10 gainer after printing the strongest PMI data around, while JPY (+0.4%) has simply rebounded from its very sharp decline yesterday, although it remains in a very clear downtrend for now.  the rest of the G10 is modestly firmer vs. the dollar at this hour, but nothing to write home about.

In the EMG space, ZAR (+0.9%) is the leader, also seeming to benefit on the back of last week’s liquidity induced decline and seeing a rebound.  We are also seeing strength in PHP (+0.7%) and CZK (+0.6%) with the latter benefitting from expectations for further rate hikes while the former benefitted from a much lower than expected CPI print of just 3.6%.  Meanwhile, on the downside, IDR (-0.4%) was the worst performer as the infection rate rose sharply and KRW (-0.25%) fell after North Korea launched another ballistic missile and rejected further talks with the US.

On the data front, ADP Employment (exp 410K) leads this morning and then the Minutes are released at 2:00pm.  Aside from the Minutes, there are no speakers scheduled, so the dollar will need to take its cues from other markets.  Keep an eye on the 10-year as a continued rally in yields should see further dollar strength.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

Somewhat Misleading

Posted on by

The latest inflation’ry reading
Showed price rises kept on proceeding
But bond markets jumped
While dollars were dumped
This movement seems somewhat misleading

The two market drivers yesterday were exactly as expected, the CPI report and the FOMC Minutes.  The funny thing is it appears the market’s response to the information was contrary to what would have been expected heading into the session.

Starting with CPI, by now you are all aware that it continues to run at a much hotter pace than the Fed’s average 2.0% target.  Yesterday’s results showed the M/M headline number was a tick higher than forecast at 0.4%, as was the 5.4% Y/Y number.  Ex food & energy, the results were right on expectations at 4.0%, but that is cold comfort.  Here’s a bit of bad news though, going forward for the next 5 months, the monthly comps are extremely low, so the base effects (you remember those from last year, right?) are telling us that CPI is going to go up from here.  Headline CPI is almost certain to remain above 5.0% through at least Q1 22 and I fear beyond, especially if energy prices continue to rise.  The Social Security Administration announced that benefits would be increased by 5.9% next year, the largest increase in 20 years, but so too will FICA taxes increase accordingly.

The initial market movement on the release was perfectly logical with the dollar bouncing off its lows while Treasury yields backed up.  Given the current correlation between those two, things made sense.  However, that price action was relatively short-lived and as the morning progressed into the afternoon, the dollar started to slip along with yields.  Thus, leading up to the Minutes’ release, the situation had already turned in an unusual direction.

The Minutes explained, come November,
Or possibly late as December
The time will have come
Where QE’s full sum
Ought fade like a lingering ember

The Minutes then confirmed what many in the market had expected which was that the taper is on, and that starting in either mid-November or mid-December the Fed would be reducing its monthly asset purchases by $15 billion ($10 billion less Treasuries, $5 billion less mortgages).  This timeline will end their QE program in the middle of next year and would then open the way for the Fed to begin to raise rates if they deemed it necessary.

Oddly enough, the bond rally really took on legs after the Minutes and the dollar extended its losses.  So, while the correlation remains intact, the direction is confusing, at least to this author.  Losing the only price insensitive bond buyer while the government has so much debt to issue did not seem a recipe for higher bond prices and lower yields.  Yet here we are.  The best explanation I can offer is that investors have assessed that less QE will result in slowing growth and reduced inflationary pressures, so much so that there is the beginning of talk about a recession in the US early next year.  Alas, while I definitely understand the case for slowing growth, and have been highlighting the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow trajectory lower, there is nothing about the situation that I believe will result in lower inflation, at least not for quite a while yet.  Thus, a bond market rally continues to seem at odds with the likely future outcome.

Of course, there is one other possible explanation for this behavior.  What if, and humor me here for a moment, the Fed doesn’t actually follow through with a full tapering because equity prices start to fall sharply?  After all, I am not the only one to have noticed that the Fed’s reaction function seems to be entirely based on the level of the S&P 500.  Simply look back to the last time the Fed was trying to remove policy accommodation in 2018.  You may recall the gradual reduction in the size of their balance sheet as they allowed bonds to mature without replacing them while simultaneously, they were gradually raising the Fed funds rate.  However, by Christmas 2018, when the equity market had fallen 20% from its highs, Chairman Powell pivoted from tightening to easing policy thus driving a reversal higher in stocks.  Do you honestly believe that a man with a >$100 million portfolio is going to implement and maintain a policy that will make him poorer?  I don’t!  Hence, I remain of the belief that if they actually do start to taper, still not a given in my mind, it won’t last very long.  But for now, the bond market approves.

Thus, with visions of inflation dancing in our heads, let’s look at this morning’s market activity.  Equity markets are clearly of the opinion that everything is under control, except perhaps in China, as we saw the Nikkei (+1.5%) put in a strong performance and strength throughout most of Asia.  However, the Hang Seng (-1.4%) and Shanghai (-0.1%) were a bit less frothy.  Europe, though, is all in on good news with the DAX (+0.8%), CAC (+0.9%) and FTSE 100 (+0.7%) having very positive sessions.  This has carried over into the US futures market where all three major indices are higher by at least 0.6% this morning.

Bonds, meanwhile, are having a good day as well, with Treasury yields sliding 0.7bps after a nearly 5bp decline yesterday.  In Europe, given those markets were closed during much of the US bond rally, we are seeing a catch-up of sorts with Bunds (-3.7bps), OATs (-3.1bps) and Gilts (-1.6bps) all trading well as are the rest of Europe’s sovereign markets.

On the commodity front, pretty much everything is higher as oil (+1.25%), NatGas (+2.1%) and Uranium (+21.7%!) lead the energy space higher.  Metals, too, are climbing with gold (+0.4%), copper (+0.7%) and aluminum (+3.4%) all quite firm this morning.  Not to worry, your food is going up in price as well as all the major agricultural products are seeing price rises.

As to the dollar, it is almost universally lower this morning with only two currencies down on the day, TRY (-0.9%) and JPY (-0.15%).  The former is suffering as President Erdogan fired three more central bankers who refuse to cut interest rates as inflation soars in the country and the market concern grows that Turkey will soon be Argentina.  The yen, on the other hand, seems to be feeling the pressure from ongoing sales by Japanese investors as they seek to buy Treasury bonds with much higher yields than JGBs.  However, away from those two, the dollar is under solid pressure against G10 (SEK +0.9%, NOK +0.8%, CAD +0.55%) and EMG (THB +0.7%, IDR +0.7%, KRW +0.6%).  Broadly speaking, the story is much more about the dollar than about any of these particular currencies although commodity strength is obviously driving some of the movement as is positive news in Asia on the Covid front where some nations (Thailand, Indonesia) are easing restrictions on travel.

On the data front, this morning brings the weekly Initial (exp 320K) and Continuing (2.67M) Claims numbers as well as PPI (8.7%, 7.1% ex food & energy).  PPI tends to have less impact when it is released after CPI, so it seems unlikely, unless it is a big miss, to matter that much.  However, it is worth noting that Chinese PPI (10.7%) printed at its highest level since records began in 1995 while Korean import and export prices both rose to levels not seen since the Asian financial crisis in 1998.  The point is there is upward price pressure everywhere in the world and more of it is coming to a store near you.

We hear from six more Fed speakers today, but it would be quite surprising to have any change in message at this point.  To recap the message, inflation is proving a bit stickier than they originally thought but will still fade next year, they will never allow stock prices to fall, inflation expectations remain anchored and tapering will begin shortly.

While I still see more reasons for the dollar to rally than decline, I believe it will remain linked to Treasury yields, so if those decline, look for the dollar to follow and vice versa.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

To Taper’s Ordained

Posted on by

The Minutes on Wednesday explained
That QE would still be sustained
But ere this year ends
Some felt that the trends
Implied that, to taper’s, ordained

But ask yourself this, my good friends
What happens if tapering sends
The stock market down
Will they turn around
And restart QE as amends?

Remember all the times the Fed tried to tell the world that their current policy stance, notably the massive amount of QE purchases, were not the driving force in the equity market?  Stock market bulls played along with this as well, explaining that historically high valuation measures were all appropriate given the huge corporate profit margins, and had nothing to do with the Fed’s suppression of interest rates along the entire yield curve.  The bulls would point to 30-year interest rates below 2.00% and explain that when you discounted future cash flows at such low levels, it was only natural that stock valuations were high.  The fact that it was the Fed that was simultaneously buying up all the net Treasury issuance, and then some, thus driving rates artificially lower, as well as promising to do so for the foreseeable future was seen as a minor detail.

Perhaps that detail was not as minor as the bulls would have you believe!  Yesterday, the FOMC Minutes were released and the part that garnered all the attention was the discussion on the current asset purchase framework and how it might change in the future.

“Most participants judged that the Committee’s standard of “substantial further progress” toward the maximum-employment goal had not yet been met. At the same time, most participants remarked that this standard had been achieved with respect to the price- stability goal. (my emphasis) A few participants noted, however, that the transitory nature of this year’s rise in inflation, as well as the recent declines in longer-term yields and in market-based measures of inflation compensation, cast doubt on the degree of progress that had been made toward the price-stability goal since December.”

So, it seems they are in sync on the fact that the employment situation has room to run, and they don’t want to act too early because of that.  But what I find more interesting is that they can use the term ‘price stability’ when discussing inflation running in the 4.0%-5.0% range.  As well, it is apparent that many of the committee members are drinking their own Kool-Aid on the transitory story.

“Looking ahead, most participants noted that, provided that the economy were to evolve broadly as they anticipated, they judged that it could be appropriate to start reducing the pace of asset purchases this year because they saw the Committee’s “substantial further progress” criterion as satisfied with respect to the price-stability goal and as close to being satisfied with respect to the maximum employment goal. Various participants commented that economic and financial conditions would likely warrant a reduction in coming months. Several others indicated, however, that a reduction in the pace of asset purchases was more likely to become appropriate early next year because they saw prevailing conditions in the labor market as not being close to meeting the Committee’s “substantial further progress” standard or because of uncertainty about the degree of progress toward the price-stability goal.” (my emphasis)

But this was the money line, the clear talk that most of the committee expected tapering to begin before the end of the year.  While we have not yet heard any of the three key leaders (Powell, Williams and Brainerd) say they were ready to taper, it seems that most of the rest of the committee is on board.  Jackson Hole suddenly became much more interesting, because if Powell discusses tapering as likely to occur soon, it will be a done deal.  But if he doesn’t explain that tapering is coming soon, it is possible that we see four dissents, at the next meeting.  And how about this for a thought, what if those three are the only votes to stand pat, and the other six voting members want to start the taper?  That would truly be unprecedented and, I think, have major negative market ramifications.  I don’t expect that to occur, but after everything that has occurred over the past 18 months, I wouldn’t rule out anything anymore.

At any rate, the tapering talk remains topic number one in every market, and one cannot be surprised that the market’s reaction has been a clear risk-off response.  Equity markets around the world are lower, substantially so in Europe; bond markets are rallying as risk is jettisoned; commodity prices are falling, and the dollar is king!

So, let’s take a tour and see where things are.  Starting in Asia, we saw equities decline throughout the region with the Nikkei (-1.1%), Hang Seng (-2.1%) and Shanghai (-0.6%) all under pressure.  But the real pressure was felt in Korea (KOSPI -1.9%) and Taiwan (TAIEX -2.7%).  In fact, the only markets in the region to hold their own were in New Zealand.  Turning to Europe, it is a uniform decline with the DAX (-1.6%), CAC (-2.5%), and FTSE 100 (-2.0%) all falling sharply, with the lesser known indices also completely in the red.  I guess the prospect of less Fed largesse is not seen as a positive after all.  Meanwhile, ahead of this morning’s opening, US equity futures are all sharply lower, on the order of 0.75%.

Turning to the bond market, the prospect of less Fed buying is having an interesting outcome, bonds are rallying.  Of course, this is because Treasuries remain the ultimate financial safe-haven trade and as investors flee risky assets, bonds are the natural response.  So, 10-year Treasury yields have fallen 3.5bps, and we are seeing yields decline in the European market as well, at least those countries that are deemed solvent.  So, Bunds (-1.4bps), OATs (-1.1bps) and Gilts (-3.4bps) are all seeing demand.  Yields for the PIGS, however, are unchanged to higher on the day.

Commodity prices are uniformly lower, except for gold, which is essentially unchanged on the day.  Oil (-3.7%) leads the way down, but we are seeing weakness in base metals (Cu -3.3%) as well as the Agricultural space (Wheat -1.5%, Soybeans -1.2%).

Finally, the dollar is on top of the world this morning, as investors are buying dollars to buy bonds, or so it seems.  In classic risk-off fashion, only the yen (+0.1%) has managed to hold its own vs. the dollar as the rest of the G10 bloc is weaker led by NOK (-0.95%) and AUD (-0.95%).  NZD (-0.7%) and CAD (-0.7%) are also suffering greatly given the commodity weakness story.  But do not ignore the euro (-0.15%) which while it hasn’t moved very far, has managed to finally trade below the key 1.1704 support level, and is set, in my view, to head much lower.

In the EMG space, ZAR (-1.3%) is the leading decliner, falling alongside the commodity complex.  KRW (-0.7%) has given back all of yesterday’s gains as equity outflows continue to dominate the market there, but we are seeing weakness across the board with most currencies falling between 0.3%-0.6% purely on the dollar’s overall strength.

On the data front, this morning brings the weekly Initial Claims (exp 364K) and Continuing Claims (2.8M) as well as Philly Fed (23.1) and Leading Indicators (+0.7%).  There’s no scheduled Fedspeak, but what else can they say after yesterday’s Minutes anyway?  If you recall, Monday’s Empire Mfg was quite weak, so I would not be surprised to see Philly follow suit.  In fact, I think the biggest problem the Fed is going to have is that the data is rolling over and looking like a slowing economy, despite high inflation.  If they keep seeing economic weakness, are they really going to taper into a weakening economy?  They may start, but I doubt they get two months in before they stop, especially if equities continue to revalue (fall).  As to the dollar, for now, I like its prospects and suspect that we are going to trade to levels not seen since June of last year.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf