Tag Archives: #dollarstrength

You’d Better Think Twice

Posted on by

If you thought Lagarde doesn’t care
About how her euros compare
To dollars in price
You’d better think twice
‘Cause she is acutely aware

This morning, her colleague, Klaas Knot
Was clear when explaining they’ve got
The tools they may need
To help them succeed
In cooling a euro that’s hot

With the FOMC meeting on tap for later today, the market is mostly biding its time until they hear if anything will be changing at the Mariner Eccles Building.  However, that seems highly unlikely at this time given the following factors:  first, the last we heard from Chairman Powell was that now is not the time to consider removing any policy accommodation, even if things seem to be looking up; and second, it is not clear that things are looking up.  While certainly there are some parts of the economy that are doing well, notably housing and manufacturing, the service sector remains under severe pressure as lockdowns pervade the country.  True, it appears that some of the more draconian lockdowns may be coming to an end, but the hit to the employment situation has been turning much worse.  Recall, the December NFP data printed at a much worse than expected -140K, and Initial Claims data has been running higher lately than back then.  Too, remember that the Fed modified their mandate to seek to achieve “maximum employment” which means declining NFP data is more likely to drive further policy ease than tightness.

So, in truth, today’s FOMC meeting is likely to be a pretty dull affair, with limited market expectations for any movement of any sort.  On the other hand, the ECB, which met last week and took no further action, remains concerned about the euro’s strength.  I have been quite clear in my warnings that the ECB would not allow the euro to trade higher without a response as they simply cannot afford that outcome.  Remember, the ECB’s playbook (and in truth, most central bank playbooks) defines the reaction function for specific conditions.  According to the book, too low inflation requires lower interest rates and a weaker exchange rate.  In fact, one of the primary reasons to lower interest rates is to weaken the exchange rate.  The idea is that a weak currency can help import inflation while simultaneously helping the competitive stance of that nation’s export community.  The problem with this strategy is that it was designed to be used in isolation.  So, if one country is behaving in that manner, it has a chance to succeed.  Unfortunately, the Covid pandemic has resulted in virtually every country trying to use these tools at the same time, thus canceling out each other’s efforts.

Of course, one player is much larger than the others, namely the Fed.  The Fed’s ability to ease policy seems to be outstripping that of the ECB, and every other country as well.  Adding to that has been the extraordinary fiscal policy ease we have seen here, which has been larger than elsewhere, and with the still robust expectations of another $1.9 trillion of fiscal support coming, has been one of the defining features of the bearish dollar outlook.

Which brings us to this morning’s comments from Klaas Knot, the Dutch Central Bank President and ECB Governing Council member.  He was quite clear in explaining the ECB has the necessary tools, including interest rate cuts, to prevent any further strengthening of the euro which could undermine inflation.  “That is something we, of course, monitory very, very carefully.  It’s one of the factors, not the exclusive factor, but one of the factors we take into account when arriving at our assessment of where inflation is going.”  In other words, euro bulls need to understand the ECB is not going to sit by and watch the single currency rally unabated.  It should be no surprise that the market responded to these comments by selling off the single currency, which is now down 0.4% on the day.  Adding to the bearish euro scenario was the release of the German GfK Consumer Confidence survey, which printed at -15.6, its third lowest reading in history, trailing only the May and June readings post the start of the Covid crisis last year.  Once again, I will reiterate my view, while eventually the dollar will decline more sharply as real yields in the US fall into further negative territory later this year, for now, the dollar’s decline seems to be on hold.

Ok, let’s quickly look at markets.  Risk is starting to become more suspect as the morning wears on, with European equity markets now all sharply in the red vs. their earlier little changed price action.  In the wake of the Knot comments, the DAX (-1.55%), CAC (-1.0%) and FTSE 100 (-0.8%) have all sold off hard.  Asian markets, which had closed before the comments, had a more mixed day, with the Nikkei (+0.3%) recouping a little of yesterday’s losses, but the Hang Seng (-0.3%) and Shanghai (+0.1%) doing little overall.  As to US futures, the DOW (-0.9%) and SPU (-1.0%) lead the way down with the NASDAQ (-0.25%) still outperforming after some pretty good earnings data last night from Microsoft.

It should be no surprise that bond markets have found a bid, with Treasury yields lower by 1.4bps, while Bunds (-1.4bps) and OATs (-1.0bps) are also now trading higher.  Again, earlier in the session, yields had actually crept a bit higher, so this reversal of risk attitude is growing.

Commodity markets are being impacted as well, with oil back to flat on the day from early session gains of 0.5% and gold is actually lower by 0.5%.  Only the ags remain well bid, as I guess everyone needs to eat, even during a pandemic.

Finally, the dollar is stronger across the board, with the strength becoming more evident after the Asian close.  In the G10, NOK (-0.9%) is the leading decliner as oil prices have turned, but we are seeing weakness throughout the commodity bloc (AUD -0.6%, NZD -0.4%, CAD -0.4%) as well.  In fact, even the havens are weaker today with both JPY and CHF off by 0.2%.  Today is just a dollar positive day.  In the EMG bloc, the few green spots on the chart are all APAC currencies with very modest gains (KRW +0.2%, TWD +0.1%).  On the other hand, all the markets that are currently open are showing sharp declines led by ZAR (-0.9%), MXN (-0.85%) and RUB (-0.8%).  It is remarkable how closely these three currencies trade to each other.  But really, everything else is weak as well.  There are no specific stories of note here, it is just a day to reduce risk.

On the data front, this morning brings Durable Goods (exp 1.0%, 0.5% ex transport) and then the FOMC statement at 2:00 followed by the Powell press conference at 2:30.  It seems unlikely that the market will react to the Durables data, so things seem to be shaping up as a dollar up day, at least until we hear from Jay.  However, I don’t foresee the dollar exploding higher, just continuing this drift, at least vs. the G10.  EMG is always a different story, so be careful there.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

If Things Cohere

Posted on by

Said Madame Lagarde, it’s not clear
If the PEPP need extend past next year
It could be the case
We’ll slow down the pace
Of purchases if things cohere

Yesterday’s ECB meeting presented mixed messages to the market as it has become evident there is a growing split between the hawks and doves.  While policy was left unchanged, as universally expected, the question of the disposition of the PEPP was front and center.  Once again, Madame Lagarde indicated that they would continue supporting the economy, but that the need to utilize the entire amount of authorized spending power could be absent.  Despite the fact that she admitted Q1 GDP growth would likely be negative, thus causing a second recession, she would not commit to full utilization, let alone any additional monetary stimulus.  Rather, she discussed “financing conditions” which need to remain “favorable” for the ECB to be happy.  Alas, there is no definition of what those conditions are, nor how to track them.   She mentioned a number of indicators they monitor including; bank lending, credit conditions, corporate yields, and sovereign bond yields, but not which may have more or less importance nor how they combine them.  There doesn’t appear to be an index of any sort although as part of their ongoing strategic review, they are investigating whether or not to create one.  In the end, though, it appears they are very keen to insure they don’t get pinned down to a mechanical reaction function based on either economic or financial indicators.  Instead, they will continue to wing it.

As to the growing split, it is becoming evident that the hawkish contingent, almost certainly led by Germany but likely including the Frugal Four, has been pushing back on any additional stimulus as they already see sufficient money in the system.  Remember, German DNA has been informed by the hyperinflation of the Weimar Republic in the 1930’s and Bundesbankers, like Jens Weidmann, everywhere and always see the specter of too much money leading to a recurrence of that outcome.  While that hardly seems like a possible outcome in the current situation, especially with most European countries extending lockdowns through February now, thus further stressing the economy, they know that debt monetization is the first step toward hyperinflation. And while the ECB will never explicitly monetize the debt, they can pretty easily do it implicitly.  All that has to happen is for them to permanently reinvest the proceeds of maturing sovereign debt into the same securities, and that money will be permanently in the system.

Consider, because of the ECB’s construction, with 19 central bank members, the way policy is promulgated is that each national central bank is instructed to purchase sovereign bonds issued by their own country in a given amount. So, the Banca d’Italia buys BTP’s and the Bundesbank buys bunds.  If instructions from the ECB council are to replace maturing debt with newly issued debt constantly, then the country never has to repay the bond, and therefore, the money injection is permanent, i.e. debt monetization.  It seems likely, this is the hawks’ major concern.  It is almost certainly why they insist on repeating the idea that full utilization of the PEPP is not a given, and why Lagarde cannot follow her instincts to throw more money at the second recession.  But of course, this is anathema to the hawks, who want to see the collective ECB balance sheet slowly wound down.  In the end, this tension will inform the ECB’s actions going forward, which implies, to me, that the ECB will be less dovish than some other central banks, namely the Fed, and which implies the euro could well head somewhat higher over time.

And perhaps, despite a clear risk-off theme for today’s trading activity, that is why the euro is retaining a better bid than its G10 brethren.  As equity markets around the world pare back some of their recent gains (Nikkei -0.4%, Hang Seng -1.6%, Shanghai -0.4%, DAX -0.85%, CAC -1.2%, FTSE 100 -0.7%), the clear message is risk is to be reduced heading into the weekend.  And yes, US futures are all pointing lower as well, between -0.5% and -0.8%.  Meanwhile, bond markets are playing their part, true to form, on this risk-off day, with Treasury yields lower by 1.9bps, Bunds by 2.0bps and Gilts by 2.5bps.  However, Italian BTPs have seen yields climb 3.6bps as the market responds to this newly created concern that the ECB will not be supporting Italy as they had in the past.  Add to that the ongoing political concerns in Italy, where PM Conte has just indicated he may be forced to call a new election, and the fact that today’s PMI data showed the recent lockdowns have really been crushing the economy there, and BTP’s are behaving like the risk asset they truly are, rather than the haven asset they aspire to be.

Commodity prices are under pressure across the board this morning, led by oil (-2.5%) but seeing the same in gold (-1.1%) and the entire agricultural bloc, with prices down between 0.8% (cotton) and 2.4% (soft red wheat).

This brings us back to the dollar, which is broadly higher this morning in both G10 and EMG space.  The euro (+0.1%) is the star performer today, as per the above discussion, but beyond that and the CHF (+0.05%), the rest of the bloc is weaker.  NOK (-0.8%) leads the way down with the rest of the commodity bloc (AUD -0.7%, NZD -0.5%, CAD -0.5%) not quite as badly impacted.  At the same time, EMG currencies are also under broad pressure led by RUB (-1.4%) on weaker oil, MXN (-1.0%) and BRL (-1.0%) both on weaker commodities and general risk aversion, and ZAR (-0.9%) as its main export, gold, falls. As to the positive side of the ledger, only minor East European currencies, BGN and RON (both +0.05%), have managed to eke out any gains, apparently tracking the euro ever so slightly higher.

The data picture has not helped inspire any risk taking this morning as preliminary PMI data for January showed weakness throughout.  As we have seen, manufacturing continues to hold up fairly well, but services have seen no respite.  Of all those countries reporting today, the UK was in the worst shape (PMI Services 38.8, down from 49.4) but the Eurozone as a whole (Services 45.0) was no great shakes.  It is abundantly clear that Europe is in the midst of a double-dip recession.  On the US calendar, the preliminary PMI data is released (exp Manufacturing 56.5, Services 53.4) and then Existing Home Sales (6.56M) at 10:00.  One thing we learned yesterday is that the housing market in the US remains quote robust.

But, with the Fed still in its quiet period until the meeting next Wednesday, and Yellen’s testimony done and dusted, FX is going to be reliant on other markets for direction.  If risk continues to be shed, the dollar should be able to hold its own, and even edge a bit higher.  But if equity markets manage to reverse course, then the dollar could well head back lower.

Good luck, good weekend and stay safe
Adf

Truly Sublime

Posted on by

The Chairman said, now’s not the time
To offer a new paradigm
More debt we will buy
Til we certify
The data is truly sublime

Then later, with, kudos, widespread
The new president clearly said
He’d give out more dough
To soften the blow
We’ll suffer from lockdowns ahead

It appears that the question of whether or not the Fed will consider tapering bond purchases by the end of this year has been answered…No!  Yesterday, Fed Chair Powell made it crystal clear that it was way too early to consider the idea of reducing QE purchases, and that eventually, if such time arrives, the Fed would be signaling their actions well in advance of any changes.  This is broadly the message that we heard from vice-Chairman Clarida two days ago, as well as from Governor Brainerd and some of the more dovish regional presidents.  Thus, the comments of the four regional presidents from earlier this week, indicating that tapering could happen as soon as the end of 2021, are likely to seem diminished in the eyes of the market, and the idea of a much more rapid sell-off in Treasuries needs to be rethought.

Beyond that specific question, the Chairman waxed about the good job the Fed has been doing, all the tools they have available to address any future issues, and, remarkably, that the record high levels of debt in the non-financial sector are really no big deal at all given the current level of interest rates.  Low rates obviously allow more debt to be serviced easily.  The problem, of course, is that if rates do rise in the future, servicing that debt will not be so easy, and the ramifications for the economy would be quite negative.  This is the primary factor in the thought that the Fed may never raise rates again, because doing so would result in significant economic stress throughout the country, and truly, the world.

The market response to Powell’s comments was modest at best, with the dollar softening a bit, while equity and bond markets didn’t really react at all.  Then last night, President-elect Biden made his first policy speech promising a new approach to things.  But one thing that is clearly not set to change is the political view that spending more money is always the right action.  He thus unveiled a $1.9 trillion spending program designed to address the ongoing economic impacts of Covid and the concurrent lockdowns around the country.  As well, he talked about another $3 trillion program for longer term needs like infrastructure and environmental issues that need to be addressed.

Interestingly, the market appears a bit disappointed in this proposed spending bill, and not because it is going to increase the debt load.  Rather, it appears expectations were high for more immediate spending to help goose the economy and by extension, the profit profile of the market.  However, the combination of Fed confirmation only that they would not be tightening, rather than expanding programs, and the disappointing cash outlay in the Biden proposal has forced a bit of reconsideration about the future trajectory of the economy and equity markets.  After all, if the Fed is not adding to the size of its balance sheet, where is the money going to come from to support buying more stocks?  Of course, it could simply be that the Friday before a holiday weekend has encouraged a bit of profit-taking by traders, who will be back in force on Tuesday, but whatever the cause, this morning is opening with a clear risk-off tone.

Looking at equity markets in Asia, the Nikkei (-0.6%) was the laggard, but Shanghai (0.0%) and the Hang Seng (+0.3%) hardly inspired.  Meanwhile, European screens are filled with red, led by the CAC (-0.95%) but seeing both the DAX and FTSE 100 falling -0.8%.  It is interesting to note that there was a bit of data this morning which arguably could have been construed as positive, yet clearly has not been seen that way.  UK November GDP fell only -2.6% M/M, a better than expected performance, especially given the ravages of Covid on that economy. While IP was a bit softer than forecast Services was clearly better, which for the UK economy will be crucial going forward.  The other data point showed French CPI at 0.0% in December, which remarkably, helps raise the Eurozone number!  But equity investors are having none of it today, and shedding positions into the weekend.  As to US futures markets, they are pointing lower as well, between -0.35% and -0.5% at this hour.

One cannot be surprised that Treasury prices are rallying given the risk stance, with the 10-year up ¼ of a point and yields lower by 2.7bps.  While I continue to believe that there is a near term cap in yields, at least at 1.1%, the idea of the bond offering safety makes a bit more sense than when the yield was 0.7% like most of the summer.  Remember, part of the safety of the bond is that it pays a steady income stream.  As to European markets, the big 3 are essentially unchanged at this hour, although all of them have rallied from early session lows where yields had climbed a bit.  This behavior is a bit unusual as I would have expected increased demand for these havens, but markets can be perverse on a regular basis.

Oil prices are under pressure this morning, with WTI lower by 1.3%, although that remains simply a consolidation of the large move higher we had seen over the past two plus months.  As to gold, it is little changed on the day, firmly in the middle of its recent trading range.

Finally, the dollar is definitely the beneficiary of today’s risk stance, rising against most currencies, with only the havens of JPY (+0.1%) and CHF (+0.05%) managing to eke out any gains.  However, the commodity bloc is weak; NOK (-0.6%), AUD (-0.6%) and CAD (-0.5%), and the euro (-0.3%) and pound (-0.45%) are under pressure as well.  There doesn’t need to be a more specific story than risk-off to explain these movements.

Emergers, too, are broadly under pressure led by the commodity linked currencies there.  ZAR (-0.9%), BRL (-0.8%) and CLP (-0.6%) are leading the charge lower, although pretty much every currency in the space has fallen except IDR (+0.3%).  The story here was that exports climbed a more than expected 14.6% leading to a larger trade surplus.  The indication that the economy could weather then Covid storm better than many peers has increased the attractiveness of the rupiah, especially given the yield there, which is amongst the highest in the world these days at 3.75%.

On the data front, yesterday saw much worse than expected Initial Claims data, a potential harbinger of weaker data to come.  This morning brings PPI (exp 0.8% Y/Y, 1.3% Y/Y -ex food & energy), Retail Sales (0.0%, -0.2% -ex autos), Capacity Utilization (73.6%), IP (0.5%), and Michigan Sentiment (79.5).  So, lots of things, but really Retail Sales is the one that matters most here, I think.  Certainly, yesterday’s Claims data has put the market on notice that things slowed down in Q4 and are likely starting Q1 in the same state.  However, do not be too surprised if a bad number is met with a rally as expectations grow that the Fed could, in fact, step up the pace of purchases.  We shall see.

Beyond that, Minneapolis Fed president Kashkari, the uber-dove, is the last Fed speaker before the quiet period begins ahead of the January 27 meeting.  But we already know he is going to say not enough is being done.

As long as risk remains on the back foot, the dollar can certainly maintain its modest bid here.  However, if things turn around, notably if equities climb into the green, look for the dollar to give up its gains.  At this point, the dollar’s strength does not seem to be built on a strong foundation.

Good luck, good weekend and stay safe
Adf

What Will the Fed Do?

Posted on by

To taper, or not, is the new
Discussion.  What will the Fed do?
One group sees next winter
As when the Fed printer
Will slow down if forecasts come true

But yesterday doves answered back
It’s premature to take that tack
There’s no need to shrink
QE, the doves think
‘Til growth has absorbed all the slack

Remember just last month when the Fed tightened the wording in the FOMC statement to explain they would buy “at least $80 billion per month” of Treasuries and “at least $40 billion per month” of agency mortgage-backed securities “until substantial further progress has been made toward the Committee’s maximum employment and price stability goals.”  This was clearly more specific than their previous guidance of buying securities at “the current pace” to achieve the same ends.  It would be easy to read that December statement and conclude that reducing asset purchases was quite a long way off in the future, arguably years.  This is especially so when considering the fact that the US government cannot afford for interest rates to rise very far given the extraordinarily large amount of debt they have outstanding and need to service.  After all, it is much easier to service debt when interest rates are 0.25% than when they are 2.5%.

Granted, the first Covid vaccine had just been approved the weekend before that meeting, so the question of how it would be rolled out was still open, but it had to be clear that the vaccine was going to become widely available in the following months.  And yet, the statement seems to imply QE could increase going forward if there was to be any change at all.  Yet here we are just four weeks later, and we have heard a virtual chorus of Fed regional presidents explaining that tapering purchases may be appropriate before the end of the year.  In the past seven days, Chicago’s Evans, Philly’s Harker, Dallas’s Kaplan and Atlanta’s Bostic all said tapering purchases would be appropriate soon, with Harker explaining it could easily be this year.

That’s pretty powerful stuff, if the Fed is truly considering changing its stance on policy and the ramifications are huge.  Arguably, if the Fed truly announced they were going to be reducing purchases, the bond market would sell off much harder than recently, the stock market would sell off quite hard and the dollar would reverse course and rally sharply.  But of those three reactions, the only thing ongoing is the steepening of the yield curve, with stocks continuing their slow move higher and the dollar, while consolidating for the past week, hardly on a tear.

Naturally, there is a counterpoint which was reiterated by St Louis’s Bullard and Boston’s Rosengren yesterday, and earlier this week by Cleveland’s uber-hawk, Loretta Mester and Fed vice-Chair Richard Clarida, that there is no sign a taper is appropriate any time soon, and that the Fed will have the printing presses running at full tilt until the pandemic is behind us.

So, which is it?  Well, that is the question that will be debated in and by the markets for the foreseeable future, or at least until the Fed tells us.  This week, we will hear from nine more Fed speakers, including Chairman Powell, but then the quiet period starts and there will be no word until the FOMC meeting two weeks from today.  The list of speakers spans the spectrum from hawkish to dovish, but arguably, all eyes will be on Powell.  Many analysts have highlighted the 2013 Taper Tantrum, which resulted after then Fed Chair Bernanke mentioned that the Fed would not be buying bonds forever.  The market response then was to drive 10-year Treasury yields from 1.62% on May 1 2013 to 2.99% on September 15 2013!  I find it incredibly hard to believe that the current Fed will allow anything like that at all.  As I pointed out earlier, the US government simply cannot afford that outcome, and the Fed will prevent it from happening.  The implication is that at some point soon, the Fed is going to discuss yield curve control, likely as a method to help finance all the mooted infrastructure spending that is supposed to be coming from the new Administration and Congress.  Or something like that.  But they will not allow yields to rise that much more, they simply can’t.

How has this argument discussion played out in the markets today?  The picture has been mixed, at best, with perhaps a tendency to reduce risk becoming the theme.  Looking at equities, the Nikkei (+1.0%) was the outstanding performer overnight, while we saw marginal declines in the Hang Seng (-0.2%) and Shanghai (-0.3%).  European bourses, which had been slightly higher earlier in the session, have slipped back to either side of unchanged with the DAX (-0.15%) and FTSE 100 (-0.1%) a touch lower while the CAC (+0.1%) has edged higher.  The CAC has been supported by the news that Alimentation Couche-Tarde is bidding for Carrefours, the French grocery store chain, and a key member of the index.  In truth, this performance is a bit disappointing as well, given comments from ECB member Villeroy that they would be supporting the economy with easy money as long as necessary, and that they were carefully watching the exchange rate of the euro. (more on this later).  Finally, US futures, which had been slightly higher earlier in the session, are all slightly lower now, but less than 0.1% each.

As to the bond market, safety is clearly in demand, at least in Europe, where yields have fallen by between 1.8bps (Gilts) and 2.7bps (Bunds) with most other markets somewhere in between.  Treasuries, meanwhile, have edged higher by just a tick with the yield a scant 0.3bps lower at this time.  As I said, this is going to be the battle royal going forward.

In the commodity space, oil is basically unchanged this morning, holding on to recent gains, while gold is also unchanged, holding on to recent losses.

And finally, the dollar is somewhat higher this morning, seeming to take on its traditional role of haven asset.  It should be no surprise the euro (-0.3%) is under pressure, which is exactly what the ECB wants to see.  Remember, the other sure thing is that the ECB cannot afford for the euro to rally very far as it will negatively impact the Eurozone export community as well as import deflation, something they have been trying to fight for years.  Elsewhere in the G10, SEK (-0.95%) is the worst performer after the Riksbank announced they would be selling SEK 5 billion per month to buy foreign currency reserves, and coincidentally weaken their currency.  And they will be doing this until December 2023, which means they will be creating an additional SEK 180 billion in the market, a solid 13.5% of GDP.  Look for further relative weakness here.  But beyond SEK, the rest of the G10 has seen lesser moves, all of a piece with broad dollar strength.

In the emerging markets, CLP (-2.1%) is today’s big loser after announcing that they, too, would be selling CLP each day to increase their FX reserves to the tune of 5% of the Chilean economy.  Of course, liquidity in CLP is far worse than that in SEK, so a larger move is no surprise.  Regardless, we can expect continued pressure on this peso for a while.  But away from this story, the overnight session saw modest strength in most APAC currencies led by IDR (+0.5%) and KRW (+0.4%), while the morning session has seen CE4 currencies suffer alongside the euro, and LATAM currencies give up some ground as well.  BRL (-0.6%) seems to be responding to the extremely high inflation print seen yesterday, while HUF (-0.7%) is reacting to the news of an increase in QE there as the central bank expanded its corporate bond purchases to HUF 1.15 trillion from HUF 750 billion previously.

On the data front, today brings CPI (exp 0.4% M/M, 0.1% core) and the afternoon brings the Fed’s Beige Book.  With the inflation story gaining traction everywhere, all eyes will be on the data there.  If we see a higher than expected print, the pressure will increase on the Fed, but so far, they have been quite clear they are unconcerned with rising prices and are likely to stay that way for quite a while.  Ultimately, I fear that is one of the biggest risks out there, rising inflation.

Looking ahead, I believe the dollar’s consolidation of its losses will continue but would be surprised if it rallied much more at all.  Rather, a choppy day seems to be in store.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

Compelled

Posted on by

Just last week the narrative spoke
And told us the world would soon choke
On dollars they held
Thus, would be compelled
To sell them, ere they all went broke

But funnily, this week it seems
The selling had reached its extremes
So, shorts are now squeezed
And traders displeased
As they now must look for new themes

It had been the number one conviction trade entering 2021, that the dollar would sell off sharply this year.  In fact, there were some who were calling for a second consecutive year of a 10% decline in the dollar versus its G10 counterparts, with even more gains in some emerging market currencies.  The market, collectively, entered the new year short near record amounts of dollars, riding the momentum they had seen in Q4 of last year and looking for another few percentage points of decline.  Alas, one week into the year and things suddenly seem quite different.

The first thing to highlight is that while a few percent doesn’t seem like much of a move, certainly compared to equities or bitcoin, the institutional trading community, consisting of hedge funds and CTA’s, lever up their positions dramatically.  In fact, 10x capital is quite common, with some going even further.  So, that 2% move on a 10x leverage position results in a 20% gain, certainly very respectable.  The second thing to highlight is that if a short-term trading reversal is able to cause this much angst in the trading community, conviction in the trade must not have been that high after all.

But let us consider what has changed to see if we can get a better understanding of the market dynamics.  Clearly, the biggest change was the run-off election in Georgia, which had been expected to result in at least one seat remaining in Republican hands, and thus a Republican majority in the Senate.  This outcome of a split government was seen to be a general positive for risk, as it would prevent excessive increases in debt financed stimulus, thus force the Fed to maintain low US interest rates.  And of course, we all know, that low rates should undermine the currency.

But when the Democrats won both seats, and the Senate effectively flipped, the new narrative was that there would be massive stimulus forthcoming, encouraging the reflation trade.  The thing is, the reflation trade is part and parcel of the steepening yield curve trade based on the significant amount of new Treasury debt that would need to be absorbed by the market, with the result being declining prices and higher Treasury yields.  (One thing that I never understood about the weak dollar trade in this narrative was the idea that a steeper yield curve would lead to a weaker dollar, when historically it was always the other way around; steep curve => strong dollar.)

Last week, of course, we saw Treasury yields back up 20 basis points in the back end of the curve, exactly what you would expect in a reflation trade.  And so, it cannot be surprising that the dollar has found a bottom, at least in the short-term, as higher yields are attracting investors.  But what does this say about the future prospects for the dollar?

My thesis this year has been the dollar will decline on the back of declining real yields in the US, which will be driven by rising inflation and further Fed support.  Neither the US, nor any G10 country for that matter, can afford for interest rates to rise as they continue to issue massive amounts of debt, since higher rates would ultimately bankrupt the nation.  However, inflation appears to be making a comeback, and not just in the US, but in many places around the world, specifically China.  Thus, the combination of higher inflation and capped yields will result in larger negative real rates, and thus a decline in the dollar.  Last week saw real yields rise 15 basis points, so the dollar’s rally makes perfect sense.  But once the Fed makes it clear they are going to prevent the back end of the curve from rising, the dollar will come under renewed pressure.  However, that may not be until March, unless we see a hiccup in the equity market between now and then.  For now, though, as long as US yields rise, look for the dollar to go along for the ride.

Of course, higher US yields and a stronger dollar do not encourage increased risk appetite, so a look around markets today shows redder screens than that to which we have become accustomed.  The exception to the sell-off rule was Tokyo, where the Nikkei (+2.35%) rallied sharply as the yen continues to weaken.  Remember, given the export orientation of the Japanese economy, a weaker yen is generally quite positive for stocks there.  The Hang Seng (+0.1%) managed a small gain, but Shanghai (-1.1%), fell after inflation data from China showed a much larger rebound than expected with CPI jumping from -0.5% to +0.2%.  Obviously, that is not high inflation, but the size and direction of the move is a concern.

European markets, however, are all underwater this morning, with the DAX, CAC and FTSE 100 all lower by 0.5%.  US futures are pointing down as well, between 0.4%-0.6% to complete the sweep.  Bond markets are modestly firmer this morning, with Treasury yields slipping 1.5 bps, while Bunds, OATS and Gilts have all seen yields fall just 0.5bps.  Do not be surprised that yields for the PIGS are rising, however, as they remain risk assets, not havens.

In the commodity space, oil is under modest pressure, -0.65%, while gold is essentially unchanged, although I cannot ignore Friday’s 2.5% decline, and would point out it fell another 1.5% early in today’s session before rebounding.  Since I had highlighted Bitcoin’s remarkable post-Christmas rally, I feel I must point out it is down 17% since Friday, with some now questioning if the bubble is popping.

Finally, the dollar continues its grind higher, with commodity currencies suffering most in the G10 (NOK -1.1%, NZD -0.7%, AUD -0.6%) as well as the pound (-0.6%) which is feeling the pain of Covid-19 restrictions sapping the economy.  In the EMG space, we are also seeing universal weakness, with the commodity focused currencies under the most pressure here as well.  So, ZAR (-1.0%), MXN (-0.85%) and BRL (-0.8%) are leading the pack lower, although there were some solid declines out of APAC (IDR -0.75%, KRW -0.7%) and CE4 (PLN -0.75%, HUF -0.7%).

On the data front, this week brings less info than last week, with CPI and Retail Sales the highlights:

Tuesday NFIB Small Biz 100.3
JOLTs Job Openings 6.5M
Wednesday CPI 0.4% (1.3% Y/Y)
-ex food & energy 0.1% (1.6% Y/Y)
Fed’s Beige Book
Thursday Initial Claims 785K
Continuing Claims 5.0M
Friday Retail Sales 0.0%
-ex autos -0.2%
PPI 0.3% (0.7% Y/Y)
-ex food & energy 0.1% (1.3%)
Empire Manufacturing 5.5
IP 0.4%
Capacity Utilization 73.5%
Business Inventories 0.5%
Michigan Sentiment 80.0

Source: Bloomberg

Aside from that, we also will hear a great deal from the Fed, with a dozen speakers this week, including Powell’s participation in an economics webinar on Thursday.  Last week, you may recall that Philadelphia’s Patrick Harker indicated he could see a tapering in support by the end of the year, but the market largely ignored that.  However, if we hear that elsewhere, beware as the low rates forever theme is likely to be questioned, and the dollar could well find a lot more support.  The thing is, I don’t see that at all, as ultimately, the Fed will do all they can to prevent higher yields.  For now, the dollar has further room to climb, but over time, I do believe it will reverse and follow real yields lower.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

Chaos Prevailed

Posted on by

In Washington, chaos prevailed
As Congress’s job was derailed
Investors, though, thought
‘Twas nothing, and bought
More stocks with the 10-year was assailed

One of the more remarkable aspects of the chaotic events in Washington, DC yesterday was the fact that the market reaction was completely benign.  On the one hand, given the working assumption that the theatrics would not affect the ultimate outcome, it is understandable.  On the other hand, the fact that there continues to be this amount of discord in the nation in the wake of a highly contentious election bodes ill for the ability of things to quickly return to normal.  In the end, though, market activity indicates the investment community firmly believes there will be lots more fiscal stimulus as the new Biden administration tries to address the ongoing pandemic driven economic issues.  Hence, the idea behind the reflation trade remains the current narrative, with more stimulus leading to faster economic growth, while increased Treasury supply to fund that stimulus leads to higher long end yields and a steeper yield curve.

However, now that the formalities of the electoral vote counting have concluded, focus has turned back to the narrative on a full-time basis, with the ongoing argument over whether inflation or deflation is in our future, as well as the question of whether assets, generally, are fairly valued or bubblicious.  The thing is, away from the politics, nothing has really changed very much lately.

Covid-19 continues to spread and the resultant lockdowns around the world continue to be expanded and extended.  Just last night, for instance, Japan declared a limited state of emergency in Tokyo and three surrounding prefectures in an effort to stem the spread of Covid.  That nation has been dealing with its highest caseload since April, and the Suga government was responding to requests for help from the local governments.  Meanwhile, in Germany, on Tuesday lockdowns were extended through the end of January and restrictions tightened to prevent travel of more than 15km from one’s home.  And yet, this type of news clearly does not dissuade investors as last night saw the Nikkei rally 1.6% while the DAX, this morning, is higher by 0.4% after a 1.75% rally yesterday.  In the end, the narrative continues to highlight the idea that the worse the Covid situation, the greater the probability of further fiscal and monetary stimulus, and therefore the bigger the boost to growth.

At the same time, the reflation piece of the narrative continues apace with Treasury yields continuing to climb, edging higher by one more basis point so far this morning after an eight basis point rise yesterday.  Something that has received remarkably little attention overall is the fact that oil prices have been rallying so steadily of late, having climbed more than 40% since the day before the Presidential election, and given the pending supply reductions, showing no signs of backing off.  This, along with the ongoing rallies in most commodities, is part and parcel of the reflation trade, as well as deemed a key piece of the ultimate dollar weakness story.

Regarding this last observation, there is, indeed, a pretty strong negative correlation between the dollar’s value and the price of oil.  Of course, the question to be answered is the direction of causality.  Do rising oil prices lead to a weaker dollar?  Or is it the other way round?  If it is the former, then the dollar’s future is likely to be one of weakness as the supply reductions in US shale production alongside the Saudi cuts can easily lead to further gains of $10-$15/bbl.  However, the dollar is impacted by many things, notably Fed policy, and if the dollar is the driver of oil movement, the future of the black, sticky stuff is going to be far less certain.  If, for example, inflation rises more rapidly than currently anticipated, and forces the market to consider that the Fed may react by reducing policy ease, the dollar could easily find support, especially given the massive short positions currently outstanding.  Would oil continue to rise into that circumstance?  The point is, correlations are fine to recognize, but as a planning tool, they leave something to be desired.  Understanding the fundamentals underlying price action remains critical to plan effectively.

As to today’s session, the risk picture has turned somewhat mixed.  As mentioned above, Asian equity prices had a pretty good day, with Shanghai (+0.7%) rising alongside the Nikkei, although the Hang Seng (-0.5%) struggled.  European bourses are mixed, with the DAX (0.4%) leading and the CAC (+0.1%) slightly higher although the FTSE 100 (-0.5%) is under pressure.  There is one outlier here, Sweden, where the OMX has rallied 2.1% this morning, although there is no general news driving the movement.  In fact, PMI Services data was released at its weakest level since the summer, which hardly heralds future strength.

We’ve already discussed Treasury weakness but the picture in Europe is more mixed, with bunds (-1bps) and OATs (-0.5bps) rallying slightly while Gilts (+1.7bps) are under pressure alongside Treasuries.

And finally, the dollar is showing some solid gains this morning, higher against all its G10 counterparts and most of the EMG bloc.  Despite ongoing strength in the commodity space, AUD (-0.75%) leads the way lower with NZD (-0.6%) next in line.  Clearly, the market did not embrace the Japanese news on the lockdown, as the yen has declined 0.6% as well.  As to the single currency, it has fallen 0.5%, with a very strong resistance level building at 1.2350.  It will take quite an effort to get through that level in the short run.

Emerging markets declines are led by CLP (-1.85%) and ZAR (-1.0%), although the weakness is nearly universal.  Interestingly, the Chile story is not about copper, which continues to perform well, but rather seems to be a situation where the currency is being used as a funding currency for carry trades in the EMG bloc.  ZAR, on the other hand, is suffering alongside gold, which got hammered yesterday and is continuing to soften.

On the data front, today brings Initial Claims (exp 800K), Continuing Claims (5.2M), the Trade Balance (-$67.3B) and ISM Services (54.5).  Remember, tomorrow is payrolls day, so there may be less attention paid to these numbers this morning.  One cautionary tale comes from the Challenger Job Cuts number, which is released monthly but given limited press.  Today, it jumped 134.5% from one year ago, a significant jump on the month, and a bad omen for the employment picture going forward.  With this in mind, it seems highly unlikely the Fed will do anything but ease policy further in the near term.  One other thing, yesterday the December FOMC Minutes were released but had no market impact.  Recall, the December meeting occurred prior to the stimulus bill or the Georgia run-off election, so was missing much new information.  But in them, the FOMC made clear that the bias was for a dovish stance for a long time to come.  Based on what we heard from Chicago’s Evans on Tuesday, it doesn’t seem that anything has changed since then.

Given the significant short dollar positions that are outstanding in the investment and speculative communities, the idea that the dollar could rally in the near term is quite valid.  While nothing has changed my longer-term view of rising inflation and deeper negative real yields undermining the dollar, that doesn’t mean we can’t jump in the near term.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

Less Than Two Weeks

Posted on by

There once was a tow-haired PM
Who rallied supporters ‘gainst ‘them’
At first ‘them’ was Labour
But now it’s their neighbor,
The EU, they need to condemn

With less than two weeks to agree
A deal leaving much of trade free
It’s come down to fish
Which both sides do wish
Were subject to their own decree

Today will be the last poetry of 2020.  Come January 4, 2021, FXPoetry will return with prognostications for 2021.  As such, let me wish all my readers a happy and healthy New Year.

One of the biggest benefits of 2020 coming to an end is the fact that the Brexit story should finally be put to bed.  Whether or not a trade deal is agreed by December 31st, it is unambiguous that the UK will have a changed relationship with the EU going forward.  As such, there will be no more histrionics regarding negotiations and investors and traders will return to valuing UK assets and the pound based on more fundamental views.  But we are not there yet, and so the ongoing Brexit negotiations continue to have a significant impact on markets.  If you recall, just one week ago, rumors were flying that the talks were going to collapse, and the UK was going to walk away.  Of course, that didn’t happen, and now it appears that fishing rights are the last remaining issue to be agreed.

In a nutshell, the EU want unfettered access to the UK’s fishing grounds, which are amongst the richest in the world, and which they have enjoyed for the past 47 years, ever since the UK joined the EU in 1973.  At the same time, the UK wants to control its sovereign waters, which was part of the entire rationale for Brexit in the first place, for the nation to regain its sovereignty.  It is also important to remember that from an economic perspective, fishing represents 0.1% of the UK economy and even less of the EU’s economy.  The point is, this is a symbolic issue, as opposed to a critical economic outcome.  Apparently, the UK has offered a 3-year transition period with no changes, and then want to review/renew licenses every 3 years thereafter.  The EU, meanwhile, wants no change in the current situation.  It seems to me, that of all the issues that have been addressed, this would be one of the easier ones to solve, and I remain confident it will be solved.  Perhaps 5 years or 7 years will be agreed, but some number will be agreed.

However, with both sides still full of bluster on the issue, threats of the talks breaking down are daily events, and today, it seems the market is in a more credulous mood.  As such, after a week where the pound, along with almost every other currency, rallied pretty sharply, we are seeing some profit-taking that has seen the pound retreat 0.45%, making it the worst performer in the G10.  None of this, however, has changed my view that a deal will be reached before the end of the year.

On a different note, the BOJ completed their last meeting of the year and surprised the market by explaining they were going to conduct yet another review of their policies, to be completed in March.  While leaving interest rates and asset purchase targets unchanged, they did extend their special pandemic related support programs by an additional six months.  But the news of the review is the talk of the market, with initial speculation that they may adjust their yield curve control policy to target a different tenor (currently they target 10-year yields at 0.00% +/- 0.20%) in their efforts to stoke inflation.  Alas, as demonstrated by last night’s data, they continue to fail miserably in this task.  CPI was released at -0.9% on both a headline and ex fresh food basis.  While a review may well be a good idea, it will only be useful if they actually define a policy that helps them achieve their goal of 2.0% inflation.  Unfortunately, for the past twenty-eight years, they have not really come close.  As to the yen, which has been strengthening this week along with most currencies, it too has softened overnight, down by 0.25%.

And those are really the stories of note this morning.  Risk sold off across Asia (Nikkei -0.2%, Hang Seng -0.7%, Shanghai -0.3%) although European bourses are marginally higher at this time (DAX, CAC and FTSE 100 all +0.1%).  US futures, meanwhile, are essentially flat on the day, as traders prepare for triple witching day today, when stock options, stock index futures and stock index options all expire.  Historically, they have been known to see some large moves, but right now, that doesn’t seem the case.

Bond markets, despite the lackluster stock performance, are under pressure as well, with most European bonds seeing yields rise (Bunds and OAT’s +1bp, PIGS +2bps to+6bps), although with the concern over Brexit, Gilts have seen haven demand and yields have decline 2bps.  Treasuries, meanwhile, are essentially unchanged, and continue to hover just below the 1.0% yield level that so many expect to be breeched shortly.

Both oil and gold prices are little changed on the day while the dollar is benefitting from what is almost certainly profit-taking and position adjustment heading into the weekend.  As such, it is higher vs. most of the G10, albeit only marginally, and firmer vs. most of the EMG bloc.  The noteworthy moves in EMG are RUB (-1.1%), which fell ahead of the central bank meeting, where they left policy unchanged, and has not seen any recovery since, and HUF (-0.6%) which has seen selling interest after the budget deficit there topped expectations.

Data-wise, yesterday’s Initial Claims data was a bit worse than expected, which doesn’t bode well for Q4 GDP in the US, but Housing Starts and Building Permits remain strong.  Philly Fed also disappointed, another indication that growth here is moderating.  This morning’s only number is Leading Indicators (exp 0.5%), but that seems unlikely to have an impact.  Rather, consolidation is today’s theme, and while the trend remains firmly for a lower dollar, it would not be surprising if it finishes the week on a high note.

Until 2021…good luck, good weekend and stay safe
Adf

Grovel and Kneel

Posted on by

Said Boris, prepare for the worst
Despite all our efforts, the first
Of Jan may result
In quite a tumult
If Europe’s stance isn’t reversed

Said Ursula, we want a deal
But England must grovel and kneel
If French boats can’t fish
Wherever they wish
This rift will have no chance to heal

Brexit remains the top story in the markets as we have heard from both sides that preparations for a no-deal outcome are necessary.  From what I can glean, it appears the fishing rights issue is the final sticking point.  And, in fairness, it is pretty easy to see both sides’ point of view.  From the UK’s perspective, these are their territorial waters, and if Brexit was about nothing else, it was about regaining complete sovereignty over itself, including its canon of laws, and the disposition of its territory.  I’m pretty confident that had the roles been reversed, and British fishing boats were making their living in French waters, the French would be equally adamant about controlling access.  On the flip side, given the UK has been a member of the EU since 1973, there are two generations of French fishermen who have only known unfettered access to UK waters, and assumed it was their birthright.  Losing that access will obviously be a devastating blow to their livelihoods, and one in which they played no part of the decision.  Of course, with that in mind, it still seems like a periodic review of access would be able to satisfy both sides.  Alas, that has not yet been agreed.

The upshot of this change in tone is that the market has begun to price in a more serious probability of a no-deal outcome.  This is obviously evident in the pound, which has fallen a further 0.8% this morning and is now back to levels last seen a month ago.  In fact, versus the euro, the pound is at its weakest since mid-September, although still several percent below the pandemic lows, and more than 6% from its all-time lows seen in the wake of the GFC.  But we are seeing this change in the interest rate markets as well, where UK debt yields are tumbling across the curve. For instance, 10-year Gilt yields have fallen 4.5 basis points today and now sit at 0.15%, just a few ticks above their all-time lows seen in August.  And all shorter maturities have turned negative, with 7-year breaking below 0.0% this morning.  As to the short end, the market is now pricing a base rate cut to 0.0% by the February meeting latest, and a further cut, into negative territory by next summer.

This Brexit gloom also seems to be seeping into other markets as we are seeing a pretty widespread risk-off move today, with European equity markets all pretty substantially lower and US futures pointing in the same direction. Perhaps part of this gloom is the fact that the ECB arguably disappointed markets yesterday.  While Madame Lagarde lived up to her word regarding recalibrating the ECB programs, there was no shock or awe, something markets learned to anticipate under the previous regime.  The PEPP was increased, but by exactly the amount expected.  It was also extended in time, but all that was offset by the comment that it may not need to be fully utilized.  But there was no addition to the asset mix, no junk bonds or equities, anything to demonstrate that the ECB was going to continue to support the markets aggressively.  And with that missing, and growing concern over Brexit, it appears investors are deciding to hunker down a bit going into the weekend.

At this point, both sides in the Brexit talks claim Sunday is the final deadline, so perhaps we will see something this weekend to move markets on Monday.  But right now, there is a palpable air of despair in the markets.

Touring all markets this morning shows that Asian equities were mostly lower (Nikkei -0.4%, Shanghai -0.8%) although the Hang Seng (+0.35%) managed a gain.  However, that is really the only green number on the boards this morning as every European exchange is lower, led by the DAX (-2.0%) and followed by the CAC (-1.3%) and FTSE 100 (-1.1%).  The idea that the FTSE 100 will benefit from a no-deal Brexit seems sketchy, at best, given whatever benefit may come from a weaker pound Sterling, it would seem to be offset by the larger economic hit to the UK economy as well as the thought that many of those companies may find their export markets crimped without a deal, and therefore their profits negatively impacted.  As to the US, futures markets have been trending lower all evening and are now pointing down about 0.8% across the board.

Bond markets are on the same page, with rallies everywhere as yields decline.  Treasury yields are lower by 2 basis points, and all of Europe has seen yield declines of between 1 and 4 basis points, with the PIGS the laggards here.  You may notice I never discuss JGB’s but that is only because the BOJ has effectively closed that market, now owning nearly 50% of outstanding securities, and thus yields there never really move as almost no volume transacts on any given day.

Commodity markets are showing very minor declines with both oil and gold looking at dips of just 0.2% or so.  In other words, this is more about financial issues than economic ones.

And finally, the dollar is definitely stronger this morning, with only the yen (+0.15%) outperforming in the G10 space.  While the pound is the leading decliner, NOK (-0.8%) is right there with it.  This is a bit surprising, as not only has oil not really moved today, but Brent crude rose back above $50/bbl yesterday for the first time since the initial Covid panic in March and remains there this morning.  Given growing expectations that next year is going to bring a lot of growth, it would seem that NOK has a lot of positives on its side.  As to the rest of the bloc, the losses are more moderate, ranging from AUD (-0.15%) to SEK (-0.35%), and all simply following the risk story.

Emerging market currencies are also largely weaker, led by BRL (-0.95%) which really appears to be a reaction to yesterday’s remarkable 3.0% rally.  With spot approaching 5.00, there seems to be a lot of two-way activity in the currency.  But the other laggards are all commodity based, which fits with the overall risk-off theme.  So, ZAR (-0.8%) and MXN (-0.65%) are leading the pack while the bulk of the bloc has declined a more manageable 0.2%-0.3%.  On the flip side TWD (+0.7%) is the biggest gainer despite modest foreign equity outflows.  This is especially odd given the ongoing decline in TWD bond yields.  But whatever the driver, demand for TWD remains robust.

Yesterday’s CPI data was a tick higher than expected, which has become the norm for the second half of the year.  This morning we get PPI (exp 0.7%, 1.5% ex food & energy) although given CPI has already been released, it will largely be ignored.  Perhaps the 10:00 preliminary Michigan Confidence (76.0) reading will garner more interest.  but in the end, neither seems likely to move the needle.  Rather, with risk appetite waning, and concerns over Brexit growing, it does feel like the dollar has further room to run today.

Good luck, good weekend and stay safe
Adf

A New Paradigm

Posted on by

Awaiting a new paradigm
The market is biding its time
Will Brexit be hard?
Or will Ms. Lagarde
Do something that’s truly sublime?

And what of next week and the Fed?
Are traders now looking ahead?
Will Jay make a change?
And thus rearrange
The views that are now so widespread

Come with me now, on a trip down memory lane.  Back to a time when hope (for a vaccine) sprung eternal, the blue wave was cresting, and investors were sidling up to the all-you-can-eat risk buffet with a bottomless appetite.  You remember, November.  Reflation was on the menu, along with a massive fiscal stimulus bill; progress was concrete with respect to Brexit negotiations; and the prospect of another wave of government shutdowns, worldwide, was just a gleam in petty tyrants’ politicians’ eyes.  Well, it turns out that those expectations were somewhat misplaced.  While we did, indeed, get that vaccine announcement, with the milestone first injection made today in the UK, many of those views turned out differently than expected.  As we are all aware, there was no blue wave in the US election.  Regarding Brexit, it appears that the time has finally come for the leaders of both sides to sit down and hash things out.  This morning brought news that Boris and Ursula will be meeting tomorrow to see if they can agree on what each side is willing to accept as their top negotiators have clearly reached their limits.

As to risk appetite, certainly November was beyond impressive, with massive risk rallies in equities around the world while haven assets, notably Treasuries and gold, suffered significant losses.  Since then, however, the euphoria has been far less prevalent, with some sessions even winding up in the red.  Lockdowns?  Alas, those have returned in spades, with seemingly new orders each and every day by various governmental authorities around the world.

The upshot of this mixture of news is that the market is now searching for the next big thing.  Don’t misunderstand, the 2021 conviction trades remain on the table.  Thus, expectations for a much weaker dollar, huge returns in emerging markets, both bonds and stocks, and continued strength in the US market are rife.  Just not right now.  The short-term view is more muddled which is why the price action we are currently experiencing is so mixed and until that new view develops, choppy markets with no net directional movement is the most likely outcome.  For instance, let’s look at today’s activity, which is a perfect example of the situation.

Equity markets around the world are softer, but not aggressively so.  Asian markets sold off modestly last night (Nikkei -0.3%, Hang Seng -0.75%, Shanghai -0.3%), but look simply to be consolidating what have been impressive gains since the beginning of November.  European markets are also a bit softer this morning, led by the CAC (-0.65%) although the DAX (-0.3%) and FTSE 100 (-0.4%) are drifting lower as well.  We did see some data from Europe, with ZEW readings from Germany turning out bi-polar (Expectations were strong at 55.0, Current Situation was weak at -66.5), thus showing how financial markets continue to focus on the post-covid economy while ignoring the current situation.  Meanwhile, US futures are all pointing a bit lower, between 0.4%-0.5%, after a mixed performance yesterday.  In other words, all that risk appetite from last month appears to have been satisfied for now, although we are, by no means, seeing serious risk reduction.

In the bond market, surprisingly, 10-year Treasury yields have actually edged higher by 0.7bps this morning, despite the modest risk-off theme, whereas in Europe, we see marginal yield declines across Germany, France and the UK. Bonds from the PIGS, however, are definitely feeling a little stress as they are trading with yields nearly 2bps higher than yesterday.  And that is a bit surprising given that Thursday, the ECB is going to announce their latest expansion of monetary policy, thus guaranteeing to buy yet more debt from these nations.  (We will cover the ECB tomorrow).

Commodities?  Well, gold has been rocking since its nadir on November 30, having rebounded more than 6% since then, and while unchanged on the day, remains in a short-term uptrend.  Oil, meanwhile, is ever so slightly softer this morning, just 0.5%, but also remains in its powerful uptrend, which has seen it rally more than 33% since its nadir on November 2nd.  In fact, metals and energy overall remain well bid and in strong uptrends.  Clearly, they are looking ahead to stronger growth (or possibly higher inflation) once the pandemic finally fades.

And lastly, the dollar, which can best be described as mixed today, remains the linchpin for many market expectations in 2021.  Remember this; given the dollar’s place in the world economy, as the financing vehicle of choice, a too strong dollar is generally associated with broad economic underperformance.  As debt loads worldwide have exploded, even at remarkably low interest rates, the need for foreign issuers, whether private or government, to acquire dollars to service that debt is perpetual.  When the dollar is strong, it crimps the ability of those foreign debtors to both invest and repay the outstanding debt, with investment suffering.  So, while a strong dollar may signal growth in the US economy, given that the US economy now represents only about 20% of the global economy, well down from its previous levels, and that trade continues to represent such a small portion of the US economy, just 12%, these days, a strong dollar simply hurts foreign economies without the previous benefits of knock-on global growth.  This is the key link between the views of a weaker USD and strong EMG performance next year, the two are tightly linked on a fundamental basis.

But as for today, the proper description of the dollar would be mixed.  In the G10, SEK (-0.45%) and GBP (-0.45%) are the leading decliners, with the latter clearly under pressure from the ongoing concerns over Brexit while the former seems to be feeling the sting of hints from the Riksbank that ZIRP will remain longer than previously expected.  On the plus side, the gains are less impressive, with CHF (+0.2%) the leader, while the euro has edged higher by 0.1%.  However, trying to explain a movement that small is a waste of time.

EMG currencies, on the other hand, are showing a little life, led by ZAR (+0.55%) and RUB (+0.5%) as commodity prices continue to hold the bulk of their gains.  INR (+0.5%) also had a good evening after the FinMin there explained that there would be no reduction in fiscal support for the economy for the foreseeable future, and that the government would continue to work with the RBI to insure a return to sustainable growth.  On the downside, KRW (-0.3%) is the laggard after the president there urged people to cancel holiday plans and stay home.

On the data front, NFIB Small Business Optimism fell to 101.4, a bit weaker than expected, but given the stories of closures around the nation, this cannot be that surprising.  A little later we get Nonfarm Productivity (exp 4.9%) and Unit Labor Costs (-8.9%), although neither is likely to excite the market.  There are no speakers on the docket, so the dollar will be taking its cues from the equity markets in all likelihood.  Right now, with futures pointing lower, that implies the dollar may have a bit of a rebound coming.  However, until that new narrative forms, I don’t anticipate too much movement.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf

Slipping Away

Posted on by

Last week it appeared conversations
On Brexit, had built expectations
To broker a deal
That both sides would feel
Was fruitful for all Europe’s nations

Alas, based on headlines today
That good will is slipping away
Concern has now grown
That both sides condone
No deal, to the market’s dismay

Apparently, Brexit talks have reached their denouement, with the weekend efforts of PM Johnson and European Commission President Von der Leyen unable to bridge the final gaps.  The key issues regarding fishing in UK waters and state support for UK companies remain outstanding and neither side has yet been willing to budge.  There is clearly a great deal of brinksmanship ongoing here, but with the timeline so compressed, the chance for a No-deal outcome is still remarkably high.  In fact, as of a bit past 6am in NY, the headlines claim that negotiations might end by this evening in Europe, after one final call between the two leaders.

So, is this the end?  Is Brexit upon us, three weeks early?  And if so, what can we expect going forward?

The first thing to remember about international negotiations is they are never over, even when they have ended, especially in a situation of this nature.  The economic impact in both the UK and throughout Europe will be significant in a no-deal outcome, and this is something that neither side really wants to occur, despite any rhetoric to the contrary.  The most recent analyst estimates indicate that the UK’s economy will suffer a long-term reduction of 3.0% in GDP compared to the situation if a deal is completed.  Meanwhile, the EU’s impact will be a much smaller 0.5% of GDP, but that impact will be unevenly distributed, with Ireland expected to suffer a 6% decline in economic activity, while various other nations see much smaller effects.  Germany, too, will feel the pain, as German auto exports to the UK are one of the most lucrative parts of German industry, and with tariffs imposed, they will certainly decline.

And, ultimately, that is why the best bet remains that a deal will be done.  Especially given the economic disruption of the pandemic, the ability for either the UK or EU to blithely sit by and allow a critical trade relationship to crumble is virtually nil.  So, even if the talks ostensibly end later today, they will not have ended.  Both sides will still be seeking a deal, as both sides desperately need one.

However, investors are clearly worried, as evidenced by this morning’s price action across markets.  Perhaps the most obvious outcome is that of the pound, which has fallen 1.3% on the news.  Last week I was making the case that the market had not fully priced in a positive deal, and any agreement was likely to see the pound rally.  At the same time, a true collapse in talks with a no-deal outcome is likely to see a further decline, with 5%-7% seen as a reasonable result.  This morning’s movement is just a down payment on that, if no deal actually is the outcome.

But this news seems to have forced investors across markets to reconsider their current positioning and potential market responses to negative news.  Perhaps you are not old enough to remember what negative news actually is, so I will give a brief refresher here.  Negative news is a situation where not only is the economic impact indisputably harmful to a (country, company, currency), but that a central bank response of further policy ease will be unable to change the outcome.  Thus, Friday’s weaker than expected NFP number was not really negative because it encouraged the view that the Fed will ease further next week, thus offsetting any bad economics.  But Brexit changes the structure, not just the data, and no matter what the BOE does, customs checks are still going to slow down trade and commerce.

It is with this in mind that we look at markets this morning and see that risk is broadly being reduced.  Asian equity markets started the move as the Nikkei (-0.75%), Hang Seng (-1.25%) and Shanghai (-0.8%) all showed solid declines.  And this was despite Chinese data showing that exports from the mainland had increased a much greater than expected 21% and fostered a record large trade surplus.  In Europe, the situation is similar with one real exception.  The DAX (-0.3%) and CAC (-0.8%) are leading the Continent lower as investors react to the potential crimp in economic activity.  However, the FTSE 100 (+0.5%) is higher as most members of the index will benefit greatly from a weaker pound, and so are responding to the pound’s market leading decline.

Speaking of the pound, it has fallen 1.3% from Friday’s closing levels and is the leading decliner across all major currencies.  But weakness is evident in the commodity bloc as AUD (-0.5%), NZD (-0.4%) and CAD (-0.2%) are all suffering alongside oil (WTI -0.9%) and gold (-0.4%).  EUR (-0.1%) has been a relative outperformer as the market continues to estimate a much smaller impact of a no-deal scenario.  Meanwhile, in the EMG bloc, losses are virtually universal, but the magnitude is not that substantial.  For example, MXN (-0.7%) is the worst performer today, obviously suffering from oil’s decline, but we have also seen weakness throughout the CE4 (HUF -0.4%, CZK -0.3%, PLN -0.2%) along with ZAR and RUB, both having fallen 0.3%.  In fact, the one bloc that has outperformed today is APAC, where only two currencies (MYR -0.2% and SGD -0.15%) are in the red.  Given the genesis of the problems is in Europe, this should not be that surprising.

Bond markets are taking the risk-off theme seriously with Treasury yields lower by 2.2 basis points and European govvies seeing substantial demand.  Gilts lead the way, with a 5.6bps decline, but Bunds (-3.0bps) and OAT’s (-2.6bps) are also rallying nicely.  Remember, too, that the ECB meets Thursday with expectations built in for a €500 billion increase in PEPP as well as a maturity extension of between six and twelve months in addition to an increase in the TLTRO program, with a maturity extension there as well.  One other thing to watch from the ECB is whether or not they mention the euro and its recent rally.  Madame Lagarde and her colleagues cannot countenance a significant rally from current levels, and I expect they will make that clear.

As to data this week, aside from the ECB, CPI is the biggest thing in the US:

Tuesday NFIB Small Business 102.5
Nonfarm Productivity 4.9%
Unit Labor Costs -8.9%
Wednesday JOLTs Job Openings 6.325M
Thursday Initial Claims 725K
Continuing Claims 5.27M
CPI 0.1% (1.1% Y/Y)
-ex food & energy 0.1% (1.6% Y/Y)
Friday PPI 0.1% (0.7% Y/Y)
-ex food & energy 0.2% (1.5% Y/Y)
Michigan Sentiment 76.0

Source: Bloomberg

With the last FOMC meeting of the year next Wednesday, the Fed is in their quiet period so there will be no commentary on that front.  With this in mind, the dollar, which continues to trend lower, will likely need some new catalyst to take the next step.  At this point, the biggest surprise is likely to be a positive conclusion to the Brexit talks, but given what we have seen over the past eight months, it is pretty clear that investors remain hugely bullish on the idea of the post-pandemic economy and will not be denied in their belief that stocks can only go up.  My gut tells me that US equities, where futures are currently lower by 0.3% or so, will finish the day higher, and the dollar will cede much of its overnight gains, even without a deal.

Good luck and stay safe
Adf