Tag Archives: #BOJ

Recalibration

Posted on by

 

All week we had heard many clues
That fifty is what Jay would choose
And that’s what he cut
With only one but
From Bowman, who shuns interviews
 
The key is now recalibration
In order to tackle inflation
Without driving higher
The joblessness spire
So, trust us, it’s all celebration

 

“Recent indicators suggest that economic activity has continued to expand at a solid pace. Job gains have slowed, and the unemployment rate has moved up but remains low. Inflation has made further progress toward the Committee’s 2 percent objective but remains somewhat elevated.” [emphasis added]

Reading the opening paragraph of the FOMC Statement, it might be confusing as to why they needed to cut rates 50bps.  After all, the economy is expanding at a solid pace (In fact, after the Retail Sales data on Tuesday, the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow reading for Q3 is up to 3.0%!)  unemployment remains low and inflation is still somewhat elevated.  I know I am a simple poet, but the plain meaning of those words just doesn’t lead my thinking to, damn, we better cut 50 to get started.  But I guess that is just another reason I am not a member of the FOMC.

Perhaps the more interesting thing was the Summary of Economic Projections and the dot plot which showed that while expectations were for rates to fall far more dramatically than in June, the longer run expectations continue to rise.  In fact, Chairman Powell specifically addressed the SEP in the press conference, “If you look at the SEP you’ll see that it’s a process of recalibrating our policy stance away from where we had it a year ago when inflation was high and unemployment low to a place that’s more appropriate, given where we are now and where we expect to be, and that process will take place over time.” [emphasis added] In fact, there was a lot of recalibrating going on as that appears to be the Chairman’s new favorite word, using it 8 times in the press conference.

Source: federalreserve.cgov

Notice that their current forecasts are for GDP to slow to 2.0% with Unemployment edging only slightly higher while PCE inflation magically returns to their 2.0% target.  And take a look at the last two lines, with the Fed funds rate projections falling substantially for the next three years, far more quickly than their previous views, although they think the long-run level will be higher.  

I wonder about that last issue.  Historically, the thought was that the long run Fed funds rate would be inflation (2.0%) + real interest rate (0.5%) and they pegged it at 2.5% for years.  Now that they see it at 2.9%, is that because they think inflation is going to be higher (not according to their projections) which means that for some reason they think real interest rates are going to be higher.  However, when asked, Chairman Powell and every member of the board has been unable to explain this change.

But what really matters is how have markets responded to this earth-shattering news?  The initial movement was as expected, with stocks rallying sharply (see chart below) and yields sliding along with the dollar while commodities rallied.

Source: Bloomberg.com

But a funny thing happened on the way to the close, as can be seen in the chart.  Stocks gave back all their gains and then some, with all three major indices lower on the session while 10yr Treasury yields backed up 7bps and the dollar rebounded.  Arguably, this was a sell the news response, but we need to be careful.  Remember, there are many analysts who believe the economy is in deep trouble already and by starting off with a big cut, those with paranoia may be wondering what the Fed knows that the data, at least the headline data, is not really showing.

So much for yesterday, now let’s look at markets this morning beyond the initial knee-jerk responses.  Absent any other major news or data (Norgesbank leaving rates on hold doesn’t count as major), markets have played out far more along the lines of what would have been expected in the wake of a 50bp cut.  In other words, the dollar has fallen sharply against almost all its counterparts, equity markets have rallied around the world, commodity prices have rallied sharply, and bond yields are…unchanged? 

Which brings us to the question that has yet to be answered.  Which market is right, stocks or bonds?  They appear to be telling us different stories with stocks pushing to new highs amid rising multiples and rising profit growth expectations while bonds are pricing in another 200bps of rate cuts by the end of 2025, an outcome that would only seem to make sense in the event the economy fell into a recession.  But if we are in a recession, corporate earnings seem highly unlikely to rise as much as currently forecast and typically, P/E multiples contract.  Meanwhile, if the economy is humming along such that current equity pricing is warranted, what will be the driver for the Fed to cut rates as that will almost certainly reignite inflation.  

History has shown that the bond market tends to get these big questions right when they are pointing in different directions, but that doesn’t mean that risk assets will stop rallying right away.  In fact, this will likely take quite a while to play out.

Ok, so let’s put a little more detail on the market activity overnight.  Tokyo rocked (+2.0%) as did Hong Kong (+2.0%), Taiwan (+1.7%), Singapore (+1.1%) and even mainland China (+0.8%) managed to rally some.  It appears that investors around the world believe the Fed has opened the floodgates for a much lower interest rate environment everywhere.  European bourses, too, are sharply higher led by the CAC (+2.1%) but with strength across the board (DAX +1.5%, FTSE 100 +1.3%).  And US futures have shaken off the late selloff yesterday and are firmly higher this morning led by the NASDAQ (+2.2%).

Bond yields, though, are largely unchanged on the day, with yesterday’s backup in Treasury yields maintained and European sovereigns all within 1bp of yesterday’s close.  It appears that bond investors are less confident in a soft landing than equity investors.  Interestingly, JGB yields rose 2bps last night as Japanese markets prepare for the BOJ meeting tonight.

In the commodity markets, oil (0.75%) is continuing its recent rebound after another massive inventory draw was revealed by the EIA yesterday prior to the Fed meeting.  There is a growing concern that inventories in Cushing, Oklahoma are falling to a point where products like gasoline and diesel will not be able to be produced.  As an example, gasoline futures have risen far more than crude futures this week on that fear.  As to the metals markets, gold briefly touched $2600/oz yesterday immediately in the wake of the FOMC but sold off hard afterwards.  This morning, however, it is back pushing up to that level again and the entire metals complex is rising nicely.

Finally, the dollar, has been a whipsaw of late.  Post the FOMC, it fell sharply across the board, and then into yesterday’s close it rebounded to close higher on the day.  However, this morning it has given back all those late gains and then some, and is now sitting at its lowest level, at least per the DXY, since April 2022.  This morning, in the G10, we are seeing many currencies rally between 0.5% (EUR) and 1.3% (NOK) vs the dollar and everywhere in between.  The one exception to that is the yen (-0.2%) which is biding its time ahead of the BOJ meeting.  The working assumption is that the BOJ will do nothing tonight, but now that the Fed has cut 50bps, and given Ueda-san’s history of actively trying to surprise markets to achieve outcomes he wants, we cannot rule out another rate hike in Japan.  Monday morning, USDJPY fell below 140 for the first time in 18 months.  My take is Ueda-san is quite comfortable with it heading back to the 130 level, if not the 120 level.  If he were to surprise markets and raise the base rate by even 10bps tonight, I think we would see a sea change in sentiment and a much lower dollar.  And given inflation in Japan seems to have stalled at 2.8%, well above their 2.0% target, he has a built-in excuse.

Too, watch the CNY (+0.45%) as it is now trading at its highest level (weakest dollar) in more than a year, and is approaching the big, round number of 7.00.  the linkage between JPY and CNY is tight as they constantly compete in markets, especially now in autos and electronics.  If the Fed is really going to cut as much as markets are pricing, both these currencies should strengthen much further.

It is almost anticlimactic to discuss the data today but here goes.  First, the BOE left rates on hold, as expected and the market impact was limited.  Expectations are they will cut next in November.  As to data, we see Initial (exp 230K) and Continuing (1850K) Claims, Philly Fed (-1.0) and Existing Home Sales (3.90M).  None of that is likely to change any views.  Prior to the BOJ meeting, at 7:30 this evening we see Japanese CPI, which may change views there.

For now, the dollar is very likely to remain on its back foot as enthusiasm builds for multiple rate cuts by the Fed going forward.  However, if the data continues to impress like it has lately, that enthusiasm will need to be tempered.

Good luck

Adf

Fednesday

Posted on by

Well, Fednesday is finally here
And traders, for fifty, still cheer
But arguably
The prices we see
Account for a half-point rate shear
 
So, if they just cut twenty-five
Prepare for a market nosedive
The doves will all scream
Jay’s killing the dream
While hawks everywhere all will thrive

 

First, I did not create the term Fednesday, I saw it on Twitter but thought it quite appropriate.  In fact, looking, I cannot determine who did create it but kudos to them.

As I have already written twice on the subject of today’s meeting, I will be brief this morning, especially because not much has changed.  Yesterday’s stronger than expected Retail Sales data resulted in Fed funds futures reducing the probability of a 50bp hike during the session, but overnight, we have returned to the 65%/35% probability spectrum for a 50bp cut.  I continue to believe that will be the case based on the number of articles we have seen in the mainstream media about the merits of a 50bp cut, mostly centering on the idea that rates are “too” high despite the fact that growth continues apace, the employment situation remains solid, if cooling somewhat, and inflation remains well above target.  Perhaps the big surprise will be that there will be a dissent on the vote, something we have not seen in two years.  (In fact, the last time a governor dissented was 2006 I believe).  

But something I have not touched on is the dot plot which will give us an idea as to the members’ collective belief for the rest of the year.  For instance, if the dot plot indicates Fed funds will be at 4.5% by year end, then 25bps today will be followed by at least one 50bp cut.  That should be net equity bullish and bearish for the dollar.  If the dot plot indicates only 75bps of cuts, so 4.75% at year end, my take is that will be seen as somewhat hawkish overall, and we should see risk assets decline while the dollar rallies.  Finally, if it is more than 100bps expected, I think that could be a situation of the market asking, what does the Fed know that we don’t?  That would not be a positive for risk assets but would also hammer the dollar.  Bonds would rally as would gold.  At least those are my views.

Moving on, tomorrow brings a BOE meeting where the current expectation is for no cut, although one is priced for the next meeting in the beginning of November.  Early this morning, the UK released its inflation report which showed headline CPI at 2.2%, as expected while the core rate rose to 3.6%, a tick more than expectations and up 0.3% from the July reading.  Arguably, that is what has the BOE concerned, the fact that despite the decline in energy prices which has taken headline CPI lower, the underlying stickiness of inflation remains extant within the UK.  As well, the UK also released its PPI data, all of which showed declines greater than expected, if nothing else implying that UK corporate margins should be healthy.  The pound (+0.35%) has rallied on the news, although the dollar is weaker overall, so just how much of this move is UK related is open to debate.  I guess we can say that the short-term differences in central bank stance is likely to continue to help the pound for a while.  In fact, the pound is back to levels last seen in summer 2022 and there is a growing bullish sentiment for the currency based on current perceptions of the divergence between the Fed and BOE.  My view is the BOE will fall in line pretty quickly so this will change, but for now, especially with the dollar under broad pressure, the pound has further to go.

On Friday we’ll learn
If Ueda can once more
Surprise one and all

The other central bank meeting this week is the BOJ early Friday morning.  Currently, there is no expectation of a BOJ policy change although many analysts are looking for a rate hike by December.  However, I think it is worth looking at USDJPY in relation to the policy adjustments we have seen by both central banks over the past several years.  Hopefully you can see in the chart below that the exchange rate here has returned to the level when the Fed last raised rates in July 2023.  

Source: tradineconomics.com

Since then, after a dramatic further decline in the yen, with both policy rates on hold, the BOJ first adjusted the cap on YCC higher (from 0.50% to 1.0%) then eventually raised the policy rate from -0.1% to +0.25% where it is today.  During that time, Ueda-san has surprised markets several times, and has had help from the MOF regarding intervention, taking a completely different approach to the process than the Fed, who never wants to surprise markets. With this in mind, we must be prepared for another surprise on Friday.  One thing to remember is that the BOJ meeting announcement occurs after the market in Tokyo closes, so even though other markets, and of course the FX market will be able to respond, the Tokyo equity and JGB markets won’t be able to move until Monday.  The point is the reaction may take time to play out.  In this situation, I don’t have enough information to take a view, but I will say that if he tightens policy in any manner, USDJPY is likely to fall much further.

One other thing I realize is that I have not discussed QT/QE.  If the Fed changes that process, the current $25 billion/month of balance sheet runoff, that will be extremely dovish and be quite a boost for stocks, bonds and commodities while the dollar will get run over.

Ok, heading into this morning, and after a mixed and lackluster session yesterday in the US, Asian equity market all rallied with Japan (+0.5%) continuing its recent rally, while even mainland Chinese shares (CSI 300 +0.4%) managed a gain today.  However, European bourses are all softer this morning with the FTSE 100 (-0.6%) lagging after the higher-than-expected inflation data driving concerns the BOE won’t cut rates much.  But screens everywhere are red, albeit only modestly so.  US futures are currently (7:45) edging slightly higher as I continue to believe traders and investors are looking for a 50bp cut.

In the bond market, yields are higher across the board as the euphoria we have seen lately seems to be running into a bit of profit taking with Treasury yields higher by 3bps and European sovereign yields all higher by between 4bps and 6bps.  Perhaps the one surprise is that JGB yields are unchanged this morning as there seems to be no anticipation of a BOJ move, at least not yet.

In the commodity markets, oil (-1.0%) is giving back some of its recent gains but remains above $70/bbl.  It seems that the stories of a massive military strike by Ukraine deep in Russia have raised concerns amongst the punditry of an escalation of the war there, but it has not concerned energy markets, at least not yet.  In the metals markets, gold (+0.2%), which sold off yesterday, continues to find support while copper has been on a roll and has risen once again.  

Finally, as mentioned above, the dollar is softer overall against all its G10 counterparts and most EMG currencies as well. The one outlier here was KRW (-0.35%) where traders are starting to price in rate cuts by the BOK after yet another mild inflation report earlier this week.

Ahead of the Fed we see Housing Starts (exp 1.31M) and Building Permits (1.41M) as well as the EIA oil inventory data where expectations are for no real changes.  Until the FOMC release, look for quiet markets. Afterwards, I’ve given my views above.

Good luck

Adf

The New Norm

Posted on by

The CPI data was warm
But not warm enough to deform
The view that the Fed
Was moving ahead
With rate cuts which are the new norm
 
While fifty seems out for next week
Investors, by year end, still seek
A full percent cut
Just when, though, is what
Defines why we need Jay to speak

 

It turns out that core CPI printed a tick higher than expected on the monthly result, although the Y/Y number was right in line with most forecasts.  In the broad scheme of things, it is not clear to me that a 0.1% difference in one month matters all that much, but markets are virtually designed to overreact to ‘surprising’ data.  At least, the algorithms that drive so much trading are designed to do so, or so it seems.  However, as can be seen by the chart below, it was a pretty short-lived dip and then the march higher in equity prices continued.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

While Fed funds futures pricing has adjusted the probability of a 50bp cut next week by the Fed down to just 15%, that market is still pricing in 100bps of cuts by the December meeting which means that there needs to be a 50bp cut in either November or December as they are the only two meetings left after next week.  As @inflation_guy highlighted in his always perceptive writeups on the CPI report, yesterday’s number ought not have changed the Fed’s thinking.  And perhaps that is exactly what we saw from the equity market, the realization that 50bps is still on the table for next week, especially since there is a growing feeling that’s what Powell wants to do.  I’m confident if Powell pushes for 50bps, he will have no trouble gaining quick acceptance around the table.

Ultimately, I think the problem with focusing on CPI is that the Fed doesn’t focus on CPI, even when they are worried about inflation.  However, especially now that they seem to believe they have achieved victory in that part of their mandate, it strikes me that the numbers about which they really care are the employment numbers.  Last week’s NFP report was mixed at best, although the actual NFP data was the weakest part of the report.  This morning, we get the weekly Claims data (exp Initial 230K, Continuing 1850K), but those numbers have been very stable of late, and not pointing to serious difficulties at all.  To my eye, from the perspective of the economic data that we continue to see, there is limited reason for the Fed to cut at all, especially with inflation still well above their target, but Powell promised a cut, and we have seen nothing since his Jackson Hole speech that could have changed view.  

A better question is, are they really going to cut 250bps by the end of 2025?  That would imply, at least to me, that the economy has slowed substantially, and likely headed into recession.  And, if the data turns recessionary, I can assure you that the Fed will have cut far more than 250bps by the end of next year, probably more like 350bps-400bps.  My point is I cannot look at the market pricing of interest rates and make it fit with the economic outlook at this time.  What I can do, however, is feel confident that if the Fed starts to cut rates aggressively with economic activity at current levels (remember, the GDPNow forecast is at 2.5% for Q3), inflation is likely to pick back up more quickly than people anticipate and the dollar, and bond market, will suffer while commodities and gold rise.

In the meantime, in a short while we will hear from Madame Lagarde as she follows up the almost certain 25bp rate cut they will declare today with her press conference.  I would argue the bigger news out of Europe is the ongoing discussion about increasing Eurozone debt issuance, as suggested by Mario (whatever it takes) Draghi in his report I discussed on Monday.  A look at the recent data from the continent shows that Unemployment is currently at historic lows for Europe, although that is still 6.4%, and inflation has fallen to 2.2%, just barely above their 2.0% target.  As such, here too it seems that the data is not screaming out for action.  Now, the punditry is looking for a so-called hawkish cut, one where the commentary does not discuss future cuts as a given, and I think that would be a sensible outcome.  But not dissimilar to the US situation, where a key driver of rate cut desires is the governments who are the biggest borrowers, there is intense political pressure to cut rates and reduce interest expense.  In fact, I believe that is a key reason behind Draghi’s report, to gain support and remove some of that direct interest rate expense from certain countries’ cost structure.  Thinking it through, net this should benefit the euro in the FX market as the Fed seems hell-bent on cutting and the ECB a bit less so.  We shall see,

Ok, so let’s turn to the overnight sessions to see where things are now.  After the US rebounded yesterday afternoon on the back of strength in the tech sector, we saw a huge rally in Tokyo (Nikkei +3.4%) on the same premise.  And while the Hang Seng (+0.8%) had a good session, once again, mainland Chinese shares (CSI 300 -0.4%) did not participate.  In fact, most of Asia was in the green, once again highlighting the weakness in the Chinese market, and the perception of that weakness in the Chinese economy.  As to Europe, it too has seen strength everywhere with gains between 0.8% (FTSE 100, CAC) and 1.20% (DAX).  This story is one of following the US, hopes for a bit more dovishness from the ECB, and a growing story about the potential for bank mergers in Europe with news that Italy’s UniCredit Bank has taken a stake in, and is considering buying, Germany’s Commezbank.  As to the US futures market, at this hour (7:20) they are all very modestly in the green.

In the bond markets, yields continue to back up slowly from the lows seen earlier this week with both Treasury (+2bps) and most European sovereign (Bunds +2bps, Gilts +2bps, OATs +1bp) slightly higher this morning.  Overnight, we saw JGB yields tick up only 1bp despite a relatively hawkish speech from BOJ member Naoki Tamura.  He indicated that rates should be raised to 1.0% by the end of their current forecast cycle, which sounds like a lot until you realize that is the end of 2027!  Maybe the 1bp move is appropriate after all.

In the commodity markets, oil (+1.7%) is continuing yesterday’s rally as questions about how quickly Gulf of Mexico production will restart in the wake of Hurricane Francine are driving markets.  While the weak demand story still has proponents, the reality is that oil prices have fallen more than 12% in the past month, a pretty large decline overall, so a bounce cannot be surprising.  In the metals markets, after a solid session yesterday, metals prices are higher in both the precious and industrial spaces.

Finally, the dollar is doing very little this morning, but if forced to define the move, it would be slightly softer.  While most currencies in both the G10 and EMG blocs are just a touch firmer, between 0.1% and 0.2%, the biggest mover, ironically is a decline, ZAR (-0.4%), although other than short term trading and positioning, there doesn’t seem to be a clear catalyst for the decline.

On the data front, in addition to the Claims data noted above, we see PPI (exp headline 0.1% M/M, 1.8% Y/Y; core 0.2% M/M, 2.5% Y/Y). Of course, there are no Fed speakers, but after the ECB announcement and press conference, we will hear from some ECB speakers as well.  Right now, the dichotomy between what the bond market is expecting (much lower rates anticipating weaker economic activity) and the stock market is expecting (ever higher earnings growth amid economic strength) remains wide.  While there are decent arguments on both sides, my sense is the bond market is more likely correct than the stock market.  And that is probably a dollar negative, at least at first.

Good luck

Adf

Numb

Posted on by

It seems that nobody is willing
To trade, ere Nvidia’s spilling
The beans on their income
So, markets remain numb
Awaiting an outcome, fulfilling

 

Some days it is extremely difficult to find a noteworthy story at all, and today is one of those days.  The combination of a lack of new economic data on which to build theories and models, along with most of the central banking community taking their summer vacations has left the trading and investment communities without any new catalysts for action.  Arguably, the story that will soon drive things is this afternoon’s Nvidia earnings report, but that is far outside this poet’s lane of travel.  With this in mind, it should be no surprise that market movement overnight has been quite limited.

Perhaps the most interesting story was a speech given by BOJ Deputy Governor Ryozo Himino (the Japanese don’t typically take off all of August) describing that the BOJ would continue to “normalize” policy, albeit at an indeterminate rate.  Speaking in Yamanashi prefecture, west of Tokyo, he said [emphasis added], “The bank’s basic stance on the future conduct of monetary policy is that it will examine the impact of market developments and the July rate hike and that, if it has growing confidence that its outlook for economic activity and prices will be realized, it will adjust the degree of monetary accommodation.”  You will not be surprised after a ‘powerful’ statement like that, the Nikkei managed a 0.2% rally while JGB yields edged higher by 2bps.  Perhaps the latter qualifies as a large move although the 10yr yield there remains well below 1.00%.

Otherwise, passing comments by two different ECB bankers, one a hawk (Knot saying he wants more data before deciding on a September cut) and one a dove (Centeno saying it is clear another cut is due) were the best that we had.  Perhaps that was enough to generate some excitement as the dollar has managed to rebound from the lows seen yesterday, although that is just as likely a trading bounce as a change in sentiment.

So, with this very limited amount of new information in mind, and prospects for a quiet day ahead, let’s look at what happened overnight.  While US markets did edge slightly higher yesterday, the movement was tiny, less than 0.2%.  And that type of movement was the rule of thumb in Asian markets as well with one exception, both China (-0.6%) and Hong Kong (-1.0%) continue to lag global markets as ongoing concerns over the pace of growth in the Chinese economy weigh on markets there.  I believe one of the new concerns is that Western nations (Canada being the latest) are coming together as one with respect to tariffs on Chinese goods in an effort to prevent a massive onslaught that damages their own companies.

In fairness, European shares have seen some more positive performance, notably the DAX (+0.8%), although that is due to some slightly better than expected corporate earnings releases rather than any broader macro story.  Looking across the rest of the continent, and the UK, there is a mix of gainers and laggards with nothing more than 0.2% in either direction.  Again, not much excitement here.  As to the US, futures are essentially unchanged at this hour (7:10) as all eyes are on the tape after the close when Nvidia releases its earnings.

In the bond market, yields, which backed up a few basis points yesterday, are ceding those gains this morning.  10-year Treasuries are lower by 1bp while European sovereigns are down by as much as 4bps to 5bps.  However, that is tracking what Treasuries did yesterday afternoon after the European close.  In the end, fixed income markets in the G10 remain rangebound in yield as investors continue to try to determine the timing of the widely anticipated rate cuts.  Yields have clearly declined from levels seen in the spring, but I believe for much further movement will need to see a far more aggressive rate cutting stance by central banks.

In the commodity markets, oil (-2.0%) is giving back its recent gains as supply disruption fears that were piqued by the shutdown of part of Libya’s production seem to have dissipated, or at least have been overwhelmed by the weak demand story on slowing growth in China and Europe.  At this point, it is very difficult for me to get too bullish on oil as there appears to be ample spare production capacity in OPEC to prevent disruptions and the global economic outlook is clearly fading.  Arguably of more interest is the metals markets which are under pressure this morning with gold (-0.8%) giving back some of its recent gains, although remaining above $2500/oz, while both silver (-1.8%) and copper (-3.6%) feel far more pressure on the weak economic story.  

One other potential drag on the metals markets is the dollar, which has bounced nicely from its lows yesterday.  For instance, the euro (-0.5%) is the G10 laggard although that is after testing the round number of 1.12 again yesterday.  It seems that Klaas Knot is not seen as a viable spokesman for the ECB with visions of rate cuts coming.  But we are seeing weakness in the pound (-0.25%), yen (-0.3%) and even Swiss franc (-0.2%).  In other words, it is pretty broad-based dollar strength.  In the EMG bloc, the CE4 are all substantially weaker, more than -0.5%, while KRW (-0.6%) led most APAC currencies down.  The one exception this morning is MXN (+1.0%) which is rallying nicely on the back of Banxico comments that they will maintain restrictive monetary policy for the time being.  

The data calendar has only the EIA oil inventories coming at 10:30, with more drawdowns expected, and then much later this evening, Atlanta Fed president Bostic speaks.  As trading desks remain lightly staffed given the Labor Day holiday approaching next week and given that there is important data coming after the close as well as tomorrow (Initial Claims) and Friday (PCE), today has all the hallmarks of a sleeper.

Good luck

Adf

Like a Stone

Posted on by

When Ueda-san
Raised rates, stocks responded by
Falling like a stone
 
Now Ueda-san
Is treading lightly, lest an
Avalanche begins

 

I’m sure we all remember the day, just three weeks ago, when the Nikkei Index fell more than 12% leading to a global rout in stocks.  At that time, the proximate cause was claimed to be the combination of a more hawkish BOJ and a less dovish FOMC leading to a massive unwinding of the yen carry trade.  It was a great story, and almost certainly contained much truth.  But was it really the only thing going on?

It seems quite plausible that the dramatic market reactions at that time may have been sparked by that combination of central bank events, but the sole reason the moves were so dramatic was the fact that leverage in the markets has become a key driving force in everything that occurs.  This is the reason that central banks around the world, which continue to try to reduce their balance sheets, are forced to move so slowly.  There have already been two noteworthy accidents in balance sheet reduction processes; the September 2019 repo problem in the US and the October 2022 UK pension problem, both of which were exacerbated, if not specifically driven, by excess leverage.

With this in mind, the most recent market dislocation was the main topic of discussion last night in Tokyo when BOJ Governor Ueda was called on the carpet in a special session of the Diet to explain what he’s doing.  (As an aside, the underlying premise that cannot be forgotten is that despite all the alleged focus on economic outcomes, the only thing that gets governments exorcised is when stock markets fall sharply.  At that point, inquiries are opened!)

At any rate, last night, Ueda-san explained the following: “If we are able to confirm a rising certainty that the economy and prices will stay in line with forecasts, there’s no change to our stance that we’ll continue to adjust the degree of easing.” He followed that with, “We will watch financial markets with an extremely high sense of urgency for the time being.”  In other words, the BOJ is still set on tightening monetary policy but will continue with their major goal, which is to prevent significant market dislocation (read declines).  

The upshot here is that nothing has really changed, at least at the BOJ.  Given the pace with which the BOJ acts on a regular basis, it is not surprising that they expect to continue to tighten policy very gradually and will adjust the pace to prevent major financial market moves.  The market response to these comments was for the yen to rally initially, with the dollar falling nearly one full yen, but then reversing course as Ueda backed away from excessive hawkishness.

A graph with lines and numbers Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Which takes us to Chairman Powell and his speech this morning.

There once was a banker named Jay
Whose goal was for both sides to play
When joblessness rose
The question he’d pose
Was, see how inflation’s at bay?

It is somewhat ironic to me that the most recent market ructions were a response to the combined efforts of the BOJ on a Tuesday night and the Fed on a Wednesday morning, less than 12 hours apart.  And here we are this morning with Ueda-san having spoken on a Thursday night with Chair Powell slated to speak Friday morning, although this time a bit more like 15 hours apart.  Should we be concerned that more ructions are coming?
 
As per the above, it seems as though the BOJ is going to make every effort to tighten policy, albeit slowly, given that the inflation picture in Japan is not improving in the manner they would like to see.  In fact, last night, the latest figures were released showing that headline inflation remained at 2.8% and core rose a tick to 2.7%, although that was the expected outcome.  The one bright spot was their “super-core” reading fell to 1.9%.  In the past, I was given to understand that super-core was the number that mattered the most to the BOJ, but given Ueda seems keen to continue to tighten policy, I suspect it will not be the focus for now.
 
Which takes us to the other side of this equation, the Fed.  What will Chairman Powell tell us today?  Well, yesterday we heard both sides of the argument from FOMC members with Boston’s Susan Collins and Philadelphia’s Patrick Harker both explaining that the time for cutting rates was coming soon and that the process would be gradual.  On the other side, the host of the Jackson Hole shindig, newly named KC Fed president Jeffrey Schmid, explained, “It makes sense for me to really look at some of the data that comes in the next few weeks. Before we act — at least before I act, or recommend acting — I think we need to see a little bit more.”  
 
Based on the Minutes released on Wednesday, it certainly appears that the committee is ready to cut rates next month.  The real question is at what pace will they continue once they start.  Despite all the hubbub about the NFP revisions in the Twitterverse, none of the FOMC members interviewed explained that it altered their opinions about the economy.  As I type, three hours before Powell speaks, the Fed funds futures market is pricing a 26.5% probability of a 50bp hike with a 25bp hike fully priced in.  I have read arguments by some analysts that they need to start with 50bps because the payroll revisions paint a less positive picture of the economy.  But it is hard for me to believe that Powell will want to act more than gradually absent a major dislocation in the data still due between now and the next meeting.  If NFP is <50K or the Unemployment Rate jumps to 4.5% or 4.6%, that could see a 50bp cut, but otherwise, I believe Powell will be measured and not really give us anything new today.
 
Ok, let’s look at how markets have behaved ahead of his speech.  After yesterday’s disappointing US session, the Nikkei shook off any initial concerns about Ueda’s hawkishness and rallied 0.4% on the session.  But most of the rest of the region was in the red, with Hong Kong, Korea and Australia all sliding although the CSI 300 managed a 0.4% gain.  In Europe, though, green is the theme with every major market firmer this morning led by Spain’s IBEX (+0.7%) and Germany’s DAX (+0.65%).  There was no notable data, so it is not clear the driver here.  Of course, US futures are rallying at this hour as well, with the NASDAQ futures higher by 1.0% leading the way.  Based on these markets, there is clearly a belief that Powell will be dovish.
 
In the bond markets, Treasury yields have slipped 1bp this morning but have been hanging around the 3.85% level for several sessions.  There was a dip on Wednesday after the Minutes seemed dovish, but that reversed course before the day ended and we have done nothing since.  In Europe, investors and traders are also biding their time with virtually no change in yields there.  Finally, JGB yields did rise by 3bps in response to Ueda’s marginal hawkishness.
 
In the commodity markets, oil (+1.3%) is continuing to rebound from its recent lows in what looks like a technical trading bounce although the EIA data on Wednesday did show more inventory draws than expected.  In the metals markets, while yesterday was a terrible day in the space, with metals selling off hard during the NY session, this morning they have rebounded and are higher across the board.  Nothing has changed my view that if the Fed turns dovish, metals markets, and commodities in general, will rally sharply.
 
Finally, the dollar is under pressure this morning, slipping broadly, but not deeply.  The euro is unchanged, while the pound (+0.2%) and AUD (+0.4%) pace the gainers in the G10.  In the EMG bloc, ZAR (+0.4%), MXN (+0.3%) and KRW (+0.3%) all showed modest strength as it appears traders are looking for a somewhat dovish Powell speech as well.  The dollar will be quite reactive to Powell, I believe, so watch closely.
 
In addition to Powell, and any other FOMC members that are interviewed at the symposium, we only see New Home Sales (exp 630K).  Yesterday, Existing Home Sales stopped their declines and printed as expected at 3.95M.  Claims data was also as expected although the Chicago Fed National Activity Index printed at a much lower than expected -0.34 after a revision lower to the previous month.  That is a negative economic indicator.
 
This poet’s view is Powell will try to be as middle of the road as possible, acknowledging the likelihood of a cut in September but not promising anything beyond that.  That said, I believe the market is looking for a much more dovish speech.  If he does not provide that, I expect that we could see some market negativity overall with the dollar rebounding.
 
Good luck and good weekend
Adf

Waxes and Wanes

Posted on by

The story of note for today
Is how will the BLS play
Employment revisions
And then what decisions
Will Powell be likely to weigh?
 
For now, markets still seem assured
That rate cuts will soon be secured
The doves still want fifty
But most are more thrifty
With twenty-five likely endured
 
But what if Chair Powell decides
Inflation, just like ocean tides
Both waxes and wanes
And though they’ve made gains
No rate cuts, to Fed funds, provides

 

So, the big story today, which I briefly discussed on Monday, is that the BLS is going to make benchmark revisions to their NFP data for the year through March 2024.  These revisions come from a closer analysis of the Quarterly Census on Employment and Wages (QCEW) data, which is the most comprehensive data set on jobs available.  Remember, for their monthly reports, the BLS uses a model that incorporates samples of data from respondent companies, and then includes their own adjustments based on the birth-death model of new businesses and how many jobs they create.  But the QCEW data doesn’t model things, it counts all the data from states regarding unemployment insurance and reports required to be filed by companies regarding quarterly contributions.  It is the gold standard.

Naturally, when the QCEW is released (the most recent was released in June), the analyst community goes through everything and makes their own estimates as to the changes that will occur.  Prior to any revision, the BLS data show that the economy added 2.9 million jobs in the 12 months from April 2023 through March 2024.  But analyst estimates range from a reduction in that number ranging from 300K to as much as 1 million fewer jobs.  

Given the increased importance the Fed has placed on the employment side of their mandate lately, and given that one of the reasons, if not the key reason, Powell has been willing to leave rates at current high levels is the employment situation has remained robust, if he and his colleagues were to suddenly find out that there were one million less employed people around, that would likely have a serious impact on their views as to where rates should be.

Based on the stories that I have seen on this topic over the past several days, as well as the positioning that is being revealed by the Commitment of Traders’ reports showing massive long positions in both treasury bond futures and SOFR call options, both of which are real money expressions of expectations of lower interest rates coming soon, it strikes me that the pain trade is the opposite.  In other words, what if this revision is much smaller than the largest estimates, maybe 100K or something.  Suddenly, the idea that the Fed is going to be pressured into cutting rates despite the fact that inflation, though lower, remains well above their target, is not quite as certain.  

The thing is, based on what I keep reading and hearing, it strikes me that the market is set up for a bond sell-off and higher yields today.  Either, the number is large, about 1 million jobs removed, and then we will see profit taking on the outstanding positions, or the number is small, and the entire story needs to be rewritten regarding the timing of the first rate cut, which means that positions need to be abandoned.  I’m not sure what the goldilocks number needs to be to have traders maintain their positions ahead of Friday’s Powell speech, but given that is a wild card as well, I think that is the least likely outcome, no change in positions.

Elsewhere, the only other noteworthy thing was a story about a BOJ staff paper that discussed the idea that inflation in Japan is still structural and that higher rates are still appropriate, but that is a staff paper, and not necessarily Ueda-san’s view.  The BOJ next meets on September 20, two days after the FOMC, so Ueda-san will have lots more new information to decide just how hawkish he wants to be.  Recall, the dramatic market collapse in Japan at the beginning of the month, while completely reversed now, forced their hand to back off their hawkishness.  Perhaps, the second time, if they remain hawkish, they will be able to withstand that type of movement.

So, as we all await this BLS revision, which comes at 10:00 this morning, here is how things behaved overnight.  After the first down day in the US in 9 sessions, Japanese (-0.3%) and Chinese (-0.3%) markets were also soft although the rest of the region was mixed with some gainers (India, Indonesia, Australia) and some laggards (Hong Kong, Taiwan, New Zealand).  In Europe, though, equity markets are modestly firmer this morning, somewhere between 0.25 and 0.5%, although there has been a lack of new information seemingly to drive things.  As to the US, futures at this hour (7:30) are edging higher by about 0.1%.

In the bond market, Treasury yields have edged up 1bp this morning, although they have been trending down for the past week in anticipation of this BLS employment adjustment.  European sovereign yields are essentially unchanged this morning while JGB yields dipped 1bp.  The story there remains that 10-year JGBs are yielding well less than 1.00%, the perceived key level at which more Japanese funds flow home.  I think we will need to see a much more hawkish BOJ to get that trade going.

In the commodity markets, oil (0.0%) has stopped falling for the time being, but remains under pressure overall, down more than 6.6% in the past month.  Yesterday’s API data (the private sector version of the EIA data to be released later this morning) showed a small build of inventory as opposed to the continued draws that we have seen lately and that were expected.  However, a look at the oil chart tells me that we are much closer to the bottom of its trading range for the past 3 years, than the top, and seem likely to rebound a bit.  Gold (-0.15%) is consolidating its recent gains and remains above that big round $2500/oz level but both silver (+0.5%) and copper (+0.5%) are rallying today.  I keep reading stories about how the physical shortages in both those markets, due to increased production of solar panels and batteries, is going to become the key driver going forward.  While I have believed that story, it is always hard to ascribe a given day’s movement to something like that absent a major new piece of information, and I haven’t seen that piece of the puzzle.

Finally, the dollar is bouncing slightly this morning, although that is after a pretty straight-line decline for the past two months.  Given the hype about Fed rate cuts, especially adding in this new focus on the BLS job data adjustment, it is easy to see why traders are looking for much lower US rates and therefore selling the dollar.  But remember, in the big scheme of things, at least based on the Dollar Index, the dollar is pretty much at its long-run average, neither weak nor strong.  I will say that if the Fed does enter a serious rate cutting cycle, the dollar is likely to weaken quite a bit more, perhaps with the euro testing 1.15 – 1.20 before it ends.  However, remember, if the Fed starts cutting aggressively, so too will the ECB, BOE and BOC, so any weakness will be somewhat limited.  As to today’s price action, the dollar’s strength is universal, but pretty modest overall with the biggest mover JPY (-0.5%) although obviously there are other things ongoing there.  

Aside from that employment report revision, there is no other data to be released and there are no Fed speakers scheduled today.  Today will be driven by that revision.  The larger the revision, the more likely we see the dollar decline, although the initial reaction on interest rates may be opposite on profit taking.

Good luck

Adf

That Trade Again

Posted on by

Remember when everyone knew
That BOJ hikes would come through
The Fed would cut rates
And all the debates
Were focused on what next to do?
 
It turns out the very next thing
For those getting back in the swing
Was selling the yen
(Yes, that trade again)
And buying stuff that has more zing

 

We all know that the carry trade died two weeks ago.  After all, the BOJ hiked rates in a surprise to the markets which was followed by Chairman Powell essentially promising to cut rates.  Those actions spooked traders, and arguably algorithms as well, and we saw a dramatic decline in equity markets around the world, led by Japanese stocks.  The premise was that much of the market activity was driven by borrowing yen at near 0.0% and then converting those yen into other currencies and buying other assets, or just depositing the dollars, or Mexican pesos or Brazilian reals and earning the interest rate differential.

Now, don’t get me wrong, that was an active trade and clearly a part of the ongoing risk asset rally that was evident throughout most of the world.  But that trade took several years to build up, and the idea that it was unwound in a week is laughable.  But, that sharp move two weeks ago succeeded in doing one thing, it scared the 💩 out of the central bankers around the world.  Within days, the BOJ walked back all their tough talk about normalizing monetary policy and ending QQE.  As well, despite desperate calls from some of the punditry for an emergency rate cut, or at the very least, a guarantee of a 50bp cut in September by the Fed, the few Fed speakers we have heard continue with their mantra that while some things are looking encouraging, the time is not yet right to cut rates.

And, you know what that means?  It means that the interest rate differentials between Japan and the rest of the world remain plenty wide enough to reinvigorate that self-same carry trade that was declared dead just two weeks ago.  The obvious proof is in the equity markets which, while not quite back to the highs of July 16th, have rebounded between 6.8% (S&P500) and 8.8% (NASDAQ) from the bottoms seen at the beginning of the month.  (see chart below)

A graph of a line graph Description automatically generated with medium confidence

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But equally important to this story is the fact that the yen has declined more than 4% from its highs at the peak of the fear as investors are far less concerned about much tighter BOJ policy.  This is also evident in the JGB market, where 10-year yields, while climbing 3bps overnight, remain well below the 1.0% level that was seen as a harbinger of the new monetary framework in Japan.

A graph showing the price of a stock market Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Of course, there has been other news that has abetted this price action, namely the recent US data which showed that the employment situation may not be as dire as the NFP report at the beginning of the month.  This was demonstrated yet again yesterday when Initial Claims fell to 227K, its lowest point in 5 weeks and the second consecutive decline in the result.  As well, Retail Sales were a much stronger than expected 1.0% (although the autos component seemed a bit funky), indicating that real economic activity was still growing.  Granted, the IP (-0.6%) and Capacity Utilization (77.8%) data were soft as were both the Philly Fed (-7.0) and Empire State Manufacturing (-4.7) surveys, but none of that matters when the markets get on a roll.

If I had to describe the narrative this morning it would be, everything’s fine.  The economy is still doing well, the jobs market is not collapsing, and the Fed is still on track to cut rates next month.  Goldilocks has come out of hiding and is back headlining the show.  While there are still some doubters out there, their voices are being drowned out by all the shouting to buy more stocks.

So, as we head into the weekend, let’s see how things have performed overnight.  In Asia, markets everywhere rallied following the strength in the US yesterday.  The Nikkei (+3.6%) led the way and has now rebounded more than 20% from its nadir at the height of the fear.  But the Hang Seng (+1.9%) showed strength and we saw strength throughout the region (Australia +1.3%, Korea +2.0%, India +1.7%) with one notable exception, mainland China, where shares edged up just 0.1%.  It seems that President Xi has, at the very least, a marketing problem with respect to getting investors to put money into China. In Europe, most markets are higher between 0.25% (CAC) and 0.6% (DAX) although the FTSE 100 (-0.4%) is struggling this morning after Retail Sales data there were seen as less than stellar.  As to the US, ahead of the opening futures markets are little changed at this hour (7:15).

In the bond market, yesterday’s stock euphoria played out as a sale of bonds with the corresponding rise in yields of 7bps in the US Treasuries.  However, this morning, those yields have backed off by 5bps and we have seen similar price action throughout Europe with sovereigns there showing yield declines of between 3bps and 5bps after following Treasury yields higher yesterday.  For now, bonds are certainly behaving like a haven asset.  Also, it is worth noting that the yield curve inversion is back to -17bps, edging slowing away from normalization.

In the commodity markets, after a solid performance yesterday, oil (-2.6%) is under real pressure this morning as market participants look to the lackluster Chinese economic activity and are worried that demand is not going to pick up anytime soon.  Certainly, yesterday’s Chinese data was nothing to write home about, and this morning they released their Foreign Direct Investment data showing it had decline -29.6% YTD in July.  This does not inspire confidence.  In fact, under the rubric a picture is worth 1000 words, here is a chart of that Chinese FDI.  It seems clear that something has changed in the way the world views China.

A graph of blue and orange lines Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

As to the metals markets, gold (+0.4%) continues to find support as despite the equity rally, there remains a steady interest to hold something other than USD and fiat currencies.  However, the rest of the complex is softer this morning as weaker industrial activity would indicate less demand.

Finally, the dollar is ceding some of its gains from yesterday with some pretty substantial moves in both G10 and EMG blocs.   Versus the G10, the yen, which fell sharply yesterday, has rebounded 0.75% this morning, although remains above 148.  But we have seen strength in AUD (+0.3%), NZD (+0.7%) and GBP (+0.35%) as virtually all the G10 is firmer.  The pound is a bit odd given the equity market’s response to the UK data, but the other currencies seem to be simply retracing yesterday’s weakness.  In the EMG bloc, ZAR (+0.4%) is firmer on the back of gold and the generally weak dollar, but we are seeing MXN (-0.2%) lag the move.  CNY (+0.2%) is also benefitting today as broad dollar weakness plays out far more aggressively here than it has historically.  While the dollar’s long-awaited demise is still far in the future, today it is under some pressure.

On the data front, this morning brings Housing Starts (exp 1.33M), Building Permits (1.43M) and Michigan Consumer Sentiment (66.9).  As well, this afternoon we hear from Chicago Fed president Goolsbee.  He has been one of the more dovish FOMC members so look for him to talk up the chances of a more aggressive rate cut next month.  However, there is still a lot to learn between now and then with PCE next week, then another NFP and CPI report as well as the Jackson Hole conference.  As it stands this morning, the Fed funds futures market is pricing a 27% chance of a 50bp cut, with 25bps a lock.  But if the data continues to shine, please explain why they need to cut.  I think we are in a ‘good news is good’ scenario, so strength in this morning’s data should support the dollar and weakness impair it.  We shall see.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Scuppered

Posted on by

There once was a time many thought
That equities had to be bought
Then, darn it, Japan
It scuppered the plan
And havoc is all that they wrought
 
So, last week, not greed, but fear, won
And risk assets ended their run
But now folks are sure
In fact, it’s de jure
That rate cuts, next month, are, deal, done

 

Congratulations everyone.  You made it through the end of the world!  I must admit, though, that on this side of that extraordinary event, things don’t really seem that different.  A quick recap reminds us that on July 31st, the BOJ surprised markets and raised interest rates by 15bps, taking their overnight funding rate to 0.25%, its highest level in 15 years.  Twelve hours later, the FOMC did not cut rates, as some had been advocating, but seemed to promise that a cut was coming in September.  Then, two days later, the US employment report showed substantially weaker jobs activity than expected.  Over the ensuing several sessions, USDJPY declined dramatically, falling nearly 10 big figures as can be seen in the first chart below.

A graph with numbers and a line Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

After an initial reflexive trading bounce, it was starting to slide again when, on August 6th, BOJ vice-governor Ichida explained that the BOJ would not, in fact, be aggressively tightening policy immediately.  The result was a relief rally and now USDJPY sits about halfway between the level prior to the rate hike and the low’s plumbed afterwards.

Perhaps just as interesting is the fact that the Nikkei 225 showed virtually the identical trading pattern, with its decline last Monday, August 5th, as the second largest single-day decline in its history.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

And yet, it is not hard to see that the trading pattern for both the Nikkei 225 and USDJPY are virtually identical, with the same catalysts.  In fact, we can look at other markets, 10yr Treasury yields and the NASDAQ come to mind, and see extremely similar price action.  (Alas, I couldn’t get the BOJ and Unemployment rate points on the combined chart, but you can see it is the same pattern.)

A graph of stock market Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

The one truism that holds is that during a time of stress, all correlations go to one!

But perhaps it’s time to consider, once again, the idea of recession.  As of now, there are still two camps:

  1. Recession is already here and started sometime in the late spring.  This is based on the declining trend in manufacturing activity, the rise in the unemployment rate (the Sahm Rule), the rising number of bankruptcies and increasing size of household debt along with delinquencies.  Constant downward revisions of previous data releases also weigh on the view, and of course, the yield curve continues to point to lower interest rates going forward, the implication being growth is slowing.  One last feature is the dramatic difference between GDP and GDI, two different measures of US economic activity that should show the same thing, however currently, GDI (Gross Domestic Income) is printing below 1% real growth.
  • Meanwhile, the soft/no-landing scenario remains popular amongst a different set of analysts.  Perhaps the most comprehensive discussion comes from Apollo Research’s Torsten Slok as he highlights the fact that real-time indicators like air travel, restaurant seatings, income tax withholdings and Retail Sales remain quite strong.  As well, the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow is currently running at 2.9%, which certainly doesn’t appear to be pointing to a recession.

So, which is it?  Of course, that’s the $1 trillion question.  However, let us consider a few incontrovertible truths.  First, business cycles still exist.  Despite all the efforts by finance ministries and central banks to create an ever upward trajectory in economic activity, or more accurately because of those efforts, excesses are created and at some point, that growth is no longer sustainable.  In other words, governments and central banks blow bubbles and eventually they pop.  Second, not all parts of the economy grow at the same pace and respond to the same catalysts in a similar manner.  So, certain parts of the economy may be under pressure while others are doing fine.  Third, trees don’t grow to the sky.  There are no magic beans which grow that beanstalk ever higher.  Rather, at some point, gravity becomes a stronger force, and things return to earth. 

From this poet’s viewpoint, we are continuing to see sectoral weakness that has not yet tipped into general weakness.  We’ve all heard about commercial real estate and the problems ongoing in that sector.  As well, we’ve all heard the excitement about AI and the massive (over)investment that has been focused on that sector, supporting the companies at the heart of the story.  In between, there are many shades of grey with some areas holding up better than others.  But on an economy-wide basis, it seems likely that given the amount of ongoing fiscal stimulus that is still being pumped into the economy, overall, a recession will still be delayed further.

Perhaps the bigger problem for the economy is that inflation remains a very real phenomenon. As the WSJnoted this morning, it is the prices of things with which we cannot do without (e.g., food, shelter, insurance) that continue to rise, rather than the discretionary items, which seem to see prices ebbing.  Ultimately, the downturn will come, but you can be sure that the government, and the Fed, will do all they can to prevent it happening, at least before the election.

Ok, with that in mind, let’s look at markets overnight as well as what this week’s data releases will bring.  After modest gains in the US on Friday, with the early part of last week’s dramatic declines essentially elimiated, Asian equity markets were generally stronger (Korea, Taiwan, Australia) although Chinese shares continue to lag (CSI 300 -0.2%) as data showed that investment into China has turned to divestment from China for the second quarter of the past four. (see chart below).  This is obviously not a positive story for the Chinese economy or its equity markets.  As an aside, Japanese markets were closed for a holiday last night.

A graph of a graph showing the value of a stock market Description automatically generated with medium confidence

Source: Bloomberg.com

Meanwhile, European bourses are generally little changed, +/-0.15% or less except for the UK, where the FTSE 100 is higher by 0.5% despite hawkish comments from BOE member Catherine Mann warning against complacency on inflation and pushing back against the idea of consistent interest rate cuts.  Lastly, US futures are edging higher at this hour (7:15), up about 0.2% across the board.

In the bond market, yields are edging back up this morning, with Treasuries higher by 2bps and similar gains across all of Europe.  To the extent that government bonds are serving as havens again, the idea that equity markets are rebounding would certainly imply less demand for them.  The one place where yields continue to decline is in China, where 10-year yields are trading near the historic lows seen at the end of July, and clearly still trending lower, an indication that growth expectations are falling.

A graph with a line graph Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

In the commodity markets, oil (+1.25%) is gaining on the growing expectation that Iran is set to finally respond to Israel and launch a significant assault with fears this can grow into a wider conflagration and impact supply.  That fear seems to be bleeding into gold (+0.5%) as well, which is back toward its historic highs, and taking the entire metals complex (Ag +1.8%, Cu +1.1%) with it.

Finally, the dollar is mixed this morning, rising strongly against the yen (-0.7%) and CHF (-0.5%) but lagging the commodity currencies (AUD +0.5%, NZD +0.5%, ZAR +0.6%).  As to the more financial currencies, like EUR, GBP, CAD, they are little changed on the session.  Ultimately, the story remains driven by expectations of Fed activity with the market currently pricing a 50:50 chance of a 50bp rate cut come September.

On the data front, we do see important things this week as follows:

TodayNY Fed Inflation Expectations3.0%
TuesdayNFIB Small Biz Confidence91.7
 PPI0.1% (2.3% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (2.7% Y/Y)
WednesdayCPI0.2% (2.9% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (3.2% Y/Y)
ThursdayInitial Claims235K
 Continuing Claims1880K
 Retail Sales0.3%
 -ex autos0.1%
 Empire State Mfg Index-6.0
 Philly Fed7.0
 IP0.1%
 Capacity Utilization78.6%
FridayHousing Starts1.35M
 Building Permits1.44M
 Michigan Sentiment66.7

Source: tradingeconomics.com

In addition, we hear from several Fed speakers, with at least three on the docket, but I imagine we will get more than that.  Last week’s fears have been memory-holed.  The vibe this morning is that it was all the BOJ’s fault and that everything is going to be great.  Maybe that will be the case, but I remain a skeptic.  Just consider, if everything is great, why would the Fed cut rates?  And the one thing that seems clear to me is that a Fed rate cut is the base case for virtually everyone. I maintain if they cut, especially 50bps, the dollar will fall sharply.  But if that recession data doesn’t start to appear soon, some folks are going to need to change their views, and positions, regarding how things unfold.

Good luck

Adf

Flags at Half-Mast

Posted on by

Twas just seven days in the past
When fears of recession forecast
Were rapidly rising
And folks analyzing
The data had flags at half-mast
 
But in a remarkable twist
Turns out that recession was missed
Instead, all is great
With not long to wait
Til worries no longer exist!

 

Until this week, I had always understood the Covid-linked recession to be the shortest on record, lasting just a few months.  But apparently, that is no longer the case.  You may recall that after last Friday’s weaker than expected NFP data and the increase in the Unemployment Rate to 4.3%, the commentariat was certain that the Fed had maintained their monetary policy too tight for too long.  The result was that the US had entered a recession, or at least was on the cusp of one.  Certainly, this appeared to be the market narrative as equity markets sold off aggressively on Friday and then again on Monday.  While there was much discussion of the impact of the BOJ’s policy adjustments and that as an additional catalyst, the key is panic was rampant.

However, it appears it was nothing more than a bad dream.  As of this morning, the S&P 500 is essentially unchanged from where it was at last Friday’s close as can be seen in the chart below.  

A graph on a white background Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

All of the angst that had been felt because of that NFP print (which was still positive at 114K) and all of the clutching of pearls and gnashing of teeth that analysts suffered was unnecessary as the Fed sensibly made no policy changes and the equity market absorbed some volatility and is back to flat on the week.  

Does this imply everything is fine with the world?  Absolutely not.  There are still numerous concerns for both the economy and the financial markets, notably the bond market, but the world has not ended, and equity markets are reflecting that fact.  

All joking aside, the economy continues to show a mixed picture and arguably the biggest medium-term concern should be the willingness of investors to continue to finance the US deficit.  This is a fundamental that cannot be ignored forever and one that revealed itself again this week as both the 10-year and 30-year auctions had tails* of more than 3 basis points.  The implication of those outcomes is that demand for US Treasury debt at current levels could be waning, and that is a genuine problem.  

Consider that, already, interest payments by the Treasury on its debt exceed $1 trillion annually.  If buyers in the market demand higher interest rates and there are no expenditure reductions (which seems likely regardless of the election outcome), either yields will rise, or other buyers will need to be found.  Who might those other buyers be?  Well, obviously, the Fed is the number one suspect, although if they were to restart QE with inflation running above target, I suspect it would be very difficult to hide and the impact on inflation would likely be to push it higher, clearly not their goal.  Therefore, as I have written before, be ready for regulatory changes that require banks and insurance companies to hold larger portfolios of Treasury securities as part of their capital buffers.  This process would be far more opaque politically but would create the price insensitive bid that the Treasury needs.

To recap, the recession has not yet arrived, investors are climbing out of their foxholes and there are potential concerns regarding the bond market and natural demand for the ongoing increases in issuance.  While next week’s CPI data will be closely scrutinized, my sense is the equity narrative is going to be far more focused on production and consumption than on prices. 

In the meantime, let’s review last night’s session and see how things are behaving as we head into the weekend.  After yesterday’s impressive rally in the US, where all Monday’s fears were erased because the Initial Claims number seemed to indicate the job market wasn’t collapsing, Asian markets had a pretty good session as well.  The Nikkei (+0.6%) and Hang Seng (+1.2%) both followed the US higher as did virtually every other market in Asia except mainland Chinese shares (CSI 300 -0.35%) after Chinese inflation figures printed a touch higher than forecast.  It does seem to feel like the Chinese market is decoupling from the rest of the world.  Meanwhile, European bourses are all firmer this morning led by Spain’s IBEX (+0.9%) and the CAC (+0.5%) in Paris.  Clearly, fears over Monday’s meltdown have abated everywhere.  Lastly, at this hour (7:30), US futures are pointing slightly higher as well.  As I said above, Monday was just a bad dream.

In the bond markets, yields are declining almost everywhere with 10-year Treasuries falling 4bps and all European sovereigns seeing yields decline by between -3bps and -5bps.  Whatever fears existed during the auctions seem to have abated somewhat, at least for now.  But the bigger picture concerns over Treasury supply remain in place, if in the background today.

In the commodity markets, oil (+0.4%) continues to creep higher and has now retraced all its losses from the week.  However, the big picture here remains that oil is rangebound between $70/bbl and $90/bbl.  While the Middle East situation continues to cause some concerns, the absence of a widely anticipated strike by Iran on Israel has left traders on edge, but not actively hedging the prospects.  As to the metals markets, both gold and silver, which had very strong rebounds yesterday, are little changed on the morning, consolidating those gains.  Interestingly, copper (+1.6%) is showing a bit of life, perhaps on the view that the recession has not yet arrived, or more likely because traders who had shorted the red metal are closing positions ahead of the weekend.

Finally, the dollar is mixed this morning with a variety of gainers and laggards across both the G10 and EMG blocs.  In the former, AUD (-0.3%) is lagging as it adjusts after yesterday’s strong gains based on a more hawkish RBA view.  At the same time, JPY (+0.5%) is higher this morning although it has been trading either side of 147.00 for the past three sessions with no obvious directional bias.  Given the importance of monetary policy decisions to this currency pair, the fact that the BOJ walked back their hawkishness and the Fed speakers we have heard this week have continued the mantra of the time is not yet right for a cut, although September may be good, it shouldn’t be that surprising that it has found a new short-term equilibrium.

In the emerging markets, the chart below showing the relative moves of ZAR, MXN and BRL, the three key risk proxies, shows that all have strengthened from their worst levels on Monday, an indication that traders are returning to the carry trade.

A graph of stock market Description automatically generated

Source: tradingeconomics.com

It is also worth noting that CNY (+0.2%) continues to track the yen at a slower pace.  The idea that the PBOC is willing to let the renminbi trade in a more volatile manner as long as it does not strengthen aggressively vs. the yen remains intact.

There is no data on the docket today and once again there are no Fed speakers scheduled either.  To my eyes, the market is exhausted after the wild moves at the beginning of the week.  I expect that there is limited appetite for aggressive price action in any market today and absent either an Iranian attack on Israel or a true black swan event, my best guess is it will be a quiet session heading into the weekend. 

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

*A tail in a bond auction simply describes how much higher the actual results were than the market’s anticipation of those results prior to the auction’s completion as priced in the when-issued market.  Typically, for 10-year bonds, that tail is close to zero, and even 30-year bonds average about 1bp.  A 3bp tail is considered quite wide and concerning as it indicates a lack of buying interest by investors of all stripes.

A New Boogeyman

Posted on by

Confusion today is what reigns
As no pundit clearly explains
Why previous claims
Have gone up in flames
And how much more pain still remains
 
They still blame the Bank of Japan
With spoiling their well thought out plan
And too, yesterday
When bonds went astray
It gave them a new boogeyman

 

Yesterday started out so well for all those who were convinced that it was the BOJ’s surprising and extreme actions last week that led to an unwarranted selloff in stocks and other risk assets.  First off, the BOJ, via one of its members Ichida-san, basically apologized for their actions and said that they would not be making any other changes after all.  That led to a rally in equities and a sell-off in bonds as risk assets were suddenly back in favor.  Alas, by the end of the day, that was no longer the case.

But let’s look at what the BOJ actually did last week.  On the interest rate front, they raised their base rate to 0.25% and regarding their balance sheet, they indicated they had a plan to slow down its growth at a very gradual pace.  Remember, they did not say they were going to sell JGBs, they said that by 2026 they would be buying half as many JGBs as they do today.

Also, let’s remember that inflation in Japan is currently measured at 2.8%, so the base rate remains deeply negative in real terms.  I understand the signaling impact of what they did as any change in the status quo while there is a significantly leveraged market can have major impacts.  And that is what we saw during the past week.  It is also important to remember that given the length of time that the Japanese have maintained their ZIRP/NIRP monetary policy, the opportunity for very large institutions to build up very large positions was, to be succinct, very large.  The chart below shows for just how long Japanese interest rates have been near zero, more than twenty years.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

My point is that Japanese investors have been seeking alternative opportunities for an entire generation.  As well, the concept of the carry trade has been in place for that same amount of time.  It will take a long time for these ideas to be changed and the positions along with them.  Now, according to a Bloomberg article, JPMorgan’s analysts claimed that three-quarters of the carry trade has already been unwound.  And maybe they are right about that.  But I assure you that three-quarters of Japanese investors have not adjusted their positions in the fixed income market.  We have not come to the end of this road.

So, analysts found another cause for yesterday’s negative outcomes, the 10-year bond auction.  It turns out that investors are seeking more yield than the market had anticipated ahead of the auction.  This led to a 3 basis point tail, meaning that the auction cleared at a yield, 3.96%, 3 basis points higher than traders were pricing ahead of time (typical 10-year tails are well less than 1bp.)  There were less bids than anticipated, and generally this is not a good story for Secretary Yellen and the Treasury.  The story that circulated was that the reason stocks fell in the afternoon was the weak auction.  Alas, the timing of that does not make sense.  Equity markets had already given back their morning gains before the auction results were announced and were lower on the day at 1:00pm.  But narrative writers need a story, and that was a good one.

So, what really happened?  Who knows?  But FWIW this poet has seen enough market action during his career to recognize that while fundamentals matter in the long-run, daily changes are often completely random, or at least seemingly so.  Large orders can drive markets, especially when liquidity is lower because of holiday schedules and the time of year.  And lately, the combination of algorithmic trading and extreme retail speculation will also move markets in surprising directions.

I believe that we remain in a period of change.  Monetary policies around the world are adjusting to the realities of inflation remaining stickier than policymakers want to believe.  In addition, the political cycle continues to be difficult to forecast, notably in the US, with market perceptions of very different economic policies to be implemented depending on the next US president.  And finally, I believe the best way to describe the global economy is that it is in transition.  After a decade or more of easy money policies around the world, as those policies start to change, they impact different segments of the economy at different rates.  This means that some parts of an economy can be in recession while other parts can be doing fine.  And that gives rise to confusing data with no broad trend.  This may explain why manufacturing survey data is so weak while service survey data has held up well.  

My best guess is that we are going to continue to see confusion until policy makers are more aligned.  In fact, that is why there are so many calls for the Fed to start cutting rates soon, so they can catch up and unify monetary policies around the world.

Ok, let’s see how things looked overnight.  After yesterday’s reversal and lower closes in the US, that theme was extended largely around the world.  Japanese shares fell (-0.75%) as did shares everywhere else in Asia (Korea, India, Australia, etc.) except in China, where both mainland and Hong Kong shares were essentially flat.  The story is no better in Europe where shares are lower by between -0.7% (DAX ) and -1.1% (CAC, FTSE 100) as investors demonstrate they are concerned with the future.  As to the US, at this hour (7:15) futures are very slightly lower.

In the bond market, after yesterday’s poor auction, and ahead of today’s 30-year Treasury auction, yields have fallen from their highest points.  Treasury yields (-3bps) are pacing the European sovereign market (Bunds -3bps, OATs -3bps, Gilts -1bp, BTPs -2bps) as the fear factor on stocks seems to be encouraging some haven buying.  But the most interesting thing was that JGB yields fell -5bps overnight and are now back down to 0.84%.  The BOJ Summary of Opinions (effectively their Minutes) was released last night and clarified that they are not interested in a rapid tightening of policy.  Given GDP growth was negative last quarter, this can be no surprise.

In the commodity markets, oil is little changed this morning but has recouped most of its losses from the past week and sits back at $75/bbl.  This is still a range-bound situation, and we need something really big to change that.  Gold (+1.1%) is making a comeback and back over $2400/oz as the fear factor seems to be playing a role here today.  However, copper (-0.2%) continues to demonstrate short-term concerns over economic activity around the world.

Finally, the dollar is having a much less volatile session than we have seen recently.  AUD (+0.5%) is the biggest mover I can find after hawkish comments from the RBA, claiming they will not hesitate to raise interest rates again if inflation reappears.  However, the yen (+0.15%) seems like it has found at least a temporary home, perhaps gaining some support on what appears to be a risk off day.  Funnily, though, the major risk proxies in the EMG space, ZAR and MXN are virtually unchanged this morning.  I believe that like most markets today, more clues are sought before views are expressed.

Speaking of clues, this morning brings the other US data with Initial (exp 240K) and Continuing (1870K) Claims at 8:30.  Richmond Fed president Barkin speaks at 3:00 this afternoon, the same time we will hear from Banxico on their rate decision (no change expected).  But once again, there is not much new information expected, so markets are going to respond, in my view, to equity activity.  If US stocks can find support, look for other markets to follow along.  However, that does not feel like today’s message.  As to the dollar, against the majors, I think it has found a temporary range.

Good luck

Adf