Tag Archives: #Fed

Clearly the Rage

Posted on by 
While AI is clearly the rage
Where Mag 7 try to engage
Consider the fact
That during this act
They’re fighting each other backstage

Just a little aside regarding the situation in equity markets, which in the US really means the Magnificent 7 these days.  One of the key features of their cumulative success was that these companies had no significant overlap regarding their business models.  Online shopping, iphones, EV’s, search, GPUs, streaming services and a social network clearly intersected to some extent, but the main focus of all these companies was spread out in different directions.  Yes, Amazon prime competes with Netflix, as does Apple TV, and yes, Amazon Web Services, Microsoft Azure and Google Cloud are all in the same business, but there is a huge amount in that particular segment that is still unfulfilled, so competition but not cutthroat.

But AI is a different kettle of fish.  All of them are actively investing in their own AI programs and working to integrate them into their current services and products.  And we are already seeing announcements of new GPU’s to directly compete with Nvidia and bring that supply chain in-house for the other users.  The point is, there is going to be a lot more investment, if not overinvestment, in this space with, arguably, quite a while before whatever AI does starts to really help the bottom line.  In other words, do not be surprised to see margins start to decline in these companies which is unlikely to help drive their share prices higher.  As well, with investment focused on this new area, we need to expect to see a reduction in share repurchases, removing one of the key bids to the market.

All I’m saying is that even in a soft or no landing scenario, it strikes me that the Magnificent 7 may be running out of room to continue their amazing run of share price gains.  And if they start to stumble, just the very nature of the equity indices, where their capital weightings are so large combined, > 30%, I suspect the indices themselves may find themselves under a lot of pressure, regardless of whether the Fed cuts rates or not.  And if the Fed cuts rates because the economy is slipping into recession, or has already gotten there, that cannot be good for margins either.  While timing is everything in life, this is something that needs to be on everyone’s radar, because it will change the risk narrative, and that matters for all markets.  Just sayin’.

While last week was mercif’ly free
Of Fedspeak, the FOMC
This week will explain
Again and again
Why higher for longer’s the key

As the market returns to full strength, at least from a staffing perspective, post the Thanksgiving holiday, things are opening fairly quietly.  A quick recap of the data since I last wrote shows that the mix of good and bad continues to leave prospects uncertain going forward.  This has allowed both the soft/no landing camp and the recession camp to point to specific things and claim they are on the right track.  So, Durable goods were pretty lousy in October and Michigan Sentiment also fell sharply, but Initial Claims fell as well, indicating that the labor market remains robust overall.  In other words, uncertainty continues to reign.  

One of the interesting things is that different markets appear to be pricing very different outcomes.  For instance, commodity markets, or at least energy markets, are clearly in the recession camp as oil prices remain under pressure, falling another 1.5% this morning as the market awaits the outcome of Thursday’s delayed OPEC+ meeting.  Talk is that there could be another 1 million bbl/day production cut to help support prices, but nothing is yet certain.  At the same time, both copper and aluminum remain under pressure, sliding a bit further last week and this morning while gold (+0.5%) is back firmly above $2000/oz, hardly a sign of a positive future.

However, as dour as the commodity markets feel, equity markets remain quite resilient overall.  Although this morning, we are seeing modest declines around the world, with European bourses lower by -0.2% or -0.3%, and US futures are currently (8:00) down by -0.15%, the month of November has been a big winner almost everywhere.  Gains, ranging from 5% – 11% are the order of the month as equity investors have gone all-in on the idea of a soft landing and that the major central banks are going to be slowly reducing interest rates to ensure economic growth continues.

In truth, bond markets are of a similar mind as equities with 10-year yields lower by between 25bps and 40bps during November throughout the G10 (Japan excepted but even there lower by 10bps).  Clearly, all this can be traced back to the QRA released back on November 1st when Treasury Secretary Yellen let it be known that there would not be as much coupon issuance as had been anticipated, and that more of the Federal government’s borrowing would take place in the T-Bill market.  That was the starting gun for the bond market rally and the ensuing stock market rally. 

So, which of these two views is correct?  That, of course, is the $64 trillion question, and one with no clear answer yet.  As I have written numerous times, and as we saw last week, the data continues to be mixed, with both positive and negative signs.  While the Fed, and virtually every other G10 central bank continues to harp on the idea that they will not be cutting rates anytime soon, markets are pricing in rate cuts starting in early Q2 of 2024.

Ultimately, there will be a winner of this battle, but the game is still afoot.  FWIW, while I have long been concerned that the imbalances in the economy were going to lead to a more significant correction in equity prices, there is another side to the story that is worth exploring, and that is the concept of fiscal dominance.  

According to the St Louis Fed, a good definition of fiscal dominance is: “…the possibility that accumulating government debt and deficits can produce increases in inflation that dominate central bank intentions to keep inflation low.”  The corollary here is that the Fed is losing its power over one of its key mandates, stable prices, because the Federal government’s fiscal impulse is so great as to overwhelm the Fed’s actions.  

With 2024 a presidential election year, and with the TGA currently at $725 billion plus negotiations for more spending on Ukraine, Israel and the southern border, there will be no shortage of additional Federal moneys flowing into the economy.  Add to this the fact that the surge in T-Bill issuance will move savings from a “dead zone” in the standing RRP facility, which is still at $935 billion, to more active money, able to be used in the real economy, and it is easy to see how economic activity is going to be supported throughout 2024.  Whatever your views on the appropriateness of these policies, the reality on the ground is that the current administration will do everything in its power to be re-elected and that includes spending as much money as possible.  Remember, too, that there is no operable debt ceiling, so they can issue as much debt as they want to fund whatever they can get legislated.  

If the Fed has lost control of the narrative, and it does appear to be slipping through their fingers, then we will need to start to focus elsewhere to find market drivers. Of course, if the Fed is losing its grip, do not think for a moment they will go meekly into the sunset.  Instead, I could see several more rate hikes as they continue to try to fight for price stability amid an economy flush with cash.  In other words, this story is nowhere near finished.

At this point, let’s take a look at this week’s data, which will bring updated GDP and PCE readings amongst other things.

TodayNew Home Sales723K
 Dallas Fed Manufacturing-17
TuesdayCase Shiller Home Prices4.0%
 Consumer Confidence101.0
WednesdayQ3 GDP5.0%
 Goods Trade Balance-$85.7B
ThursdayInitial Claims220K
 Continuing Claims1872K
 Personal Income0.2%
 Personal Spending0.2%
 Core PCE0.2% (3.5% Y/Y)
 Chicago PMI45.4
FridayISM Manufacturing47.6

Source: Tradingeconomics.com

Despite Friday being the first of December, payrolls are not released until next week due to the holiday last week.  Plus, in addition to the data above, we hear from seven different Fed speakers over ten venues including Chairman Powell Friday morning.  That will be the last Fed speaker until the next FOMC meeting, so it will be keenly watched.  However, I would wager a great deal it will continue to harp on progress made but higher for longer to prevent any resurgence in inflation.

As to the dollar, right now, it is softening as market participants focus on the idea of Fed cuts and simultaneously reduce large, long USD positions.  For now, I feel like lower is the way forward, but if we start to see increased hawkishness again because there is no landing, merely continued growth, look for the dollar to return to its winning ways.

Good luck

Adf

Markets No Longer Have Fear

Posted on by 
The CPI data made clear
That markets no longer have fear
But Jay and his team
Will still push the theme
That cuts in Fed funds just ain’t near

As such markets have been persuaded
It’s time for the Fed to be faded
The bulls are on top
And they just won’t stop
Til new record highs have been traded

By now, you are all well aware that yesterday’s CPI data came in a bit softer than the forecasts with the headline printing at 3.2% Y/Y while the core printed at 4.0% Y/Y.  Both of these were 0.1% lower which doesn’t seem to be that big a difference.  But the bulls are stampeding on the idea that if you look at the recent trend, the annualized rate for the past 6 months is lower still (3.0% and 3.1% respectively) and the implication is that inflation is dead and the Fed has achieved the impossible, reducing inflation without causing a recession.  And maybe they have, but boy, that is a lot to take away from a single data point that printed a smidge lower than expectations.

Two weeks ago, in the wake of the last FOMC meeting, I wrote (Bulls’ Fondest Dreams) that the Fed changed their tune and despite all the pushback we have received from Fed speakers in the interim, they definitely saw the end of the hiking path coming into view.  Yesterday’s data seemed to confirm this view, at least in the markets’ eyes.  As such, we saw a massive rally in both stocks and bonds, with 10-year yields falling 20 basis points at one point in the day before closing lower by about 17bps.  They are 2bps higher this morning on the bounce.  Interestingly, European sovereign yields also fell quite sharply despite the lack of local news as the price action once again proved that the 10yr Treasury yield is the only bond price that really matters in the world.

So, to me the question is now, is this view correct?  Has the Fed actually threaded the needle and successfully reduced inflationary pressures without causing a meaningful economic slowdown?  If so, Chairman Powell will rightly be hailed as a brilliant central banker, even if there was some luck involved.  How can we know, and more importantly, when will we be certain this is the case?

I think it is important to try to separate the markets and the economy as the two are really quite different.  The economy is where we all live.  From an individual perspective, I would contend it is a combination of one’s employment situation(and whether there is concern over losing one’s job or finding a new one), the true cost of living, meaning the ability to afford the mortgage/rent as well as put food on the table, and then to see if there is any additional money left to either save or spend on desires rather than necessities.  It seems abundantly clear that from this perspective, there is a large segment of the population that doesn’t feel great about things.  This was made clear in an FT survey that showed just 14% of those surveyed thought things had gotten better economically under the Biden Administration’s policies.

However, if this poet has learned nothing else in his time trading in, and observing, financial markets, it is that policymakers do not care one whit about those issues.  Despite periodic attempts to seem down-to-earth, the reality is they all exist within a policy bubble with no concerns about the rent or their next meal.  In this bubble exist only numbers like yesterday’s CPI or today’s Retail Sales (exp -0.3% headline, 0.0% ex autos).  GDP, to them, is not a measure of people’s confidence or belief in the state of the current world, it is a policy variable that they are trying to manage or manipulate so they can make positive pronouncements.

There is obviously quite a gulf between those two views of the world and the markets are the connection, trying to interpret the reality on the ground through the lens of the data.  Well, the policymakers must be thrilled today because the extraordinary bullishness that is now evident across all risk markets, in their minds, means that their jobs are secure.  When things are going well, reelection/reappointment are the expected outcomes.  However, that FT survey was clearly a warning shot across the bow of their Good Ship Lollipop that everything was going to be great going forward.

So, what’s it going to be?  As I wrote after the FOMC meeting, I believe the market is prepped to rally through the rest of the year.  After yesterday’s data, that seems even clearer.  But do not forget that one of the key rationales for the Fed’s change of heart was that the market was doing the Fed’s work for them, tightening policy by raising rates and watching risk assets drift lower, thus tightening financial conditions.  Let me tell you, financial conditions loosened a lot yesterday, and if this rally continues, you can be certain that Powell and friends will grow more concerned about a rebound in inflation.  The market has completely removed any probability of a December rate hike, or any further rate hikes by the Fed as of yesterday with the first cut now priced for May 2024.  At this stage, it seems probable that the October PCE data will be on the soft side so much will depend on the next NFP and CPI readings, both of which are released before the next FOMC meeting.

And there is one more thing that must be remembered when it comes to the bond market.  The US is still going to issue an enormous amount of debt going forward between refinancing ($8.3 trillion though 2024) the current debt and the new $2 trillion budget deficit that needs to be funded for next year.  Can bonds continue to rally in the face of that much supply?  Maybe they can, but it would seem to require a reengagement of foreign buyers rather than relying entirely on domestic savers.  Either that or the Fed will need to end QT and possibly even restart QE.  In the latter case, inflation would almost certainly become a major issue again.  The point is, while everyone is feeling great this morning, there are still numerous perils to be navigated in order to maintain economic growth with a low inflation regime.  I hope Jay and all the central bankers are up to the task, but a little skepticism seems in order.

Ok, the overnight session can be summed up in one word: BUY!  Equity markets everywhere rallied with strong gains in Asia (Hang Seng +3.9%) and Europe, after rallying yesterday, continuing higher by nearly 1% this morning.  US futures are also all green this morning, generally +0.5% at this hour (7:30).

Bond markets have mostly held onto yesterday’s impressive gains with some trading activity, but movements all within a basis point or two from yesterday’s close.  The exception was Asian government bond markets, where prices rallied sharply, and yields tumbled there as well, following the US lead.

Metals prices are ripping higher again this morning, with gold, silver, and copper all up nicely after strong gains yesterday.  The outlier here is oil, which is a touch lower (-0.4%) this morning after a very lackluster session yesterday.  Now, in fairness, it has been creeping higher for the past several sessions, but compared to other markets, oil is remarkably quiet right now.

Finally, the dollar got smoked yesterday, with the euro rallying 1.5% and similar moves across the other European currencies.  Meanwhile, AUD rallied more than 2% yesterday as the combination of rocketing metals prices and a broadly weaker dollar were just the ticket for the currency.  In the EMG bloc, ZAR (+3.0%) and MXN (+1.5%) were the big winners yesterday although, interestingly, most of the APAC currencies had much more muted runs, on the order of 0.5%-1.0% gains.  This morning, price activity is much more subdued as FX traders are trying to get their bearings again.  It was, however, a 3-sigma day, a rare occurrence.

On the data front, as well as Retail Sales, we also see PPI (exp 2.2% headline, 2.7% ex food & energy) and the Empire Manufacturing Survey (-2.8) along with EIA oil information where inventory builds are forecast.  There is only one Fed speaker, vice chairman of supervision Michael Barr, and I don’t expect he will be able to sway any views today.

For now, the die is cast, and the bulls are in the ascendancy.  We will need to see some very big changes in the data trajectory for the current momentum to stall, and quite frankly, I don’t see what that will be for now.  So, go with the flow here, higher stocks, lower yields and a softer dollar seem to be the trend for now.  There will be some trading back and forth, but you can’t fight City Hall.

Good luck

Adf

The Bond, or Not the Bond

Posted on by 
The bond, or not the bond, that is the question:
Whether ‘tis nobler for the Fed to consider
That long-term yields have offered outrageous fortune,
Or to take Arms against a Sea of inflation
And in opposing it: hike rates yet again

(with deepest apologies to William Shakespeare)

For some reason, the ongoing cacophony of Fedspeak regarding whether the rise in long-term yields is helping the Fed in their efforts, or whether it is merely incidental, brought this famous soliloquy to mind.  We have had no less than eight different Fed speakers from the time Dallas Fed president Logan first mentioned the idea several weeks ago through yesterday discuss the subject with the majority continuing to latch on to the benefits for the Fed, although some dismiss the issue.  Now, in any definition of financial conditions I have ever seen, long-term yields are part of the construction, so it is perfectly reasonable to take them into account.  Clearly, the Fed is aware of this as QE was created entirely to ease financial conditions and consisted of simply buying bonds to lower long-term yields.  However, now that the Fed is in QT mode, their ability to control the long end of the curve has vanished.  In fact, if anything it is simply pushing those yields higher by removing themselves, a price-insensitive buyer, from the mix.

The problem for Chairman Powell is that whatever the Fed’s reaction function is with respect to data, the market’s reaction function to any hint that the Fed has finished tightening policy is well understood by one and all; BUY STONKS!!  The reason I believe this is a concern for Powell and co. is that they fear a rally in equities will signal an all-clear on the inflation front.  And it is abundantly clear that there is nobody on the FOMC who is prepared to claim victory over inflation.  That is exclusively the stance of the CNBC bulls and the administration sycophants who are paid to make that case specifically.  Reality, however, continues to demonstrate that inflation remains a feature of our everyday lives and I suspect that the FOMC mostly understands that.  Remember, too, that the Fed is data dependent, or so they say, which implies that they are not in a position to anticipate the death of inflation, rather they will only accept that premise when they see the body.

Where does this leave us now?  I suspect that the ongoing dance between the Fed and the markets with respect to the future of inflation will continue to play out for at least another year.  In fact, nothing has changed my view that inflation will remain well above their 2.0% target for the foreseeable future, likely finding a new home in the 3.5% +/- range.  And as long as Powell is Fed Chair, I see no indication he is willing to reverse course.  While the Fed may not hike rates again, certainly the market does not believe that is going to be the case with just a 9.6% probability of a hike in December now priced, I find it extremely difficult to believe they will cut rates anytime soon absent clear signs that we are already in a recession.

Though soft-landing bulls have all scoffed
The fact that the data was soft
In China implies
It cannot surprise
If growth worldwide can’t stay aloft

So, is a recession coming soon to an economy near you?  That is the $64 trillion question and one where there are myriad views expressed daily.  The most recent inkling that economic activity is slowing more sharply than had previously been thought was the surprisingly weak Chinese trade data, where not only did their trade surplus decline substantially (to a still robust $56.5B) but exports fell in absolute terms, they did not merely rise more slowly than imports.  The implication is that global growth is slowing more rapidly than the narrative explains.  

We already know that Europe is in a world of trouble with Germany the current sick man of the continent, but we also have seen the latest Atlanta Fed GDPNow data showing that growth in the US is slowing as well with the latest reading at 1.2%.  The UK is struggling as are many Asian nations, notably South Korea and Taiwan, or at least their export industries which are the key economic drivers there.

Another clue is the recent sharp decline in the price of oil, which has fallen -5.0% this week and ~-10% in the past month.  Clearly, a part of this price decline is based on the growing belief (hope?) that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict will not spread into a wider Middle East conflagration that affects oil production.  But part of this is the fact that oil inventories are building as are gasoline and diesel inventories with the result that prices are falling sharply.  Given it wasn’t that long ago when there were shortages in these products, it appears that demand is falling sharply as well.  Remember, diesel fuel is what drives the world as essentially no industry or commerce could continue without its use.  The fact that less is being used is a clear signal of slowing activity.

Putting it all together shows that amidst what appears to be a slowing global growth impulse, markets are pricing out further central bank monetary policy tightening.  Equity markets have been looking at the second part of that equation, less tightening and potential easing, while ignoring the first part, slower growth leading to lower profits.  It is very easy, at least for me, to accept the idea that markets have not yet understood that slower economic activity will lead to lower profits and subsequently, lower equity prices.  Alas, I understand that sequence so remain quite cautious overall.

Ok, how has this translated overnight?  Well, after a modest rally in the US yesterday, equity markets in Asia were a bit softer, declining on the order of -0.35% while European bourses are edging slightly higher this morning, maybe +0.1%.  US futures at this hour (7:45) are basically unchanged as we all await Chairman Powell’s dulcet tones at 10:15 this morning.

Bond yields are also quiet this morning with Treasuries (+2bps) one of the larger movers as European sovereigns are almost all unchanged right now.  It seems that the market has found a new temporary home around the 4.60% level and the yield curve inversion continues to deepen, now at -36bps.  JGB yields, which have fallen from their recent YCC-tweak induced highs, have edged up overnight by 3bps, but are at 0.85%, still far from the 1.00% target or cap or concept, whatever they are calling it now.

We already know that oil is under pressure, having fallen sharply yesterday and another -1.2% this morning.  In fact, at $76.35/bbl, it is trading at its lowest level since mid-July.  Gold, too, has been suffering, down -0.3% this morning and drifting further away from the $2000/oz level as those Middle East fears seem to dissipate.  Copper and aluminum are also under pressure on the slowing growth story worldwide.  Foodstuffs, however, are generally bid lately, as we can all discern every time we go grocery shopping.

Finally, the dollar is back to its dominant ways again, rallying vs. almost all its counterparts in both the G10 and EMG blocs.  USDJPY is marching back toward 151 this morning, the euro is back below 1.07 and the pound back below 1.23.  Meanwhile, in the EMG space, ZAR (-1.1%) is the laggard although it has competition from CLP (-0.9%), KRW (-0.7%) and HUF (-0.7%) as virtually the entire bloc is under pressure.  In fact, CNY (-0.15%) is about the best performer as the PBOC continues to prevent any significant further declines.

Aside from Powell’s speech this morning, we hear from Williams, Barr and Jefferson, but there is absolutely no data to be released.  Given the dearth of new data on the calendar, this week is going to continue to be all about the Fedspeak.  In fact, Powell speaks again tomorrow and there are 5 more speakers as well by Friday, so rather than data, this week is about parsing language.  Of course, Powell will set the tone today, and I am confident he will continue to push back on the idea the Fed is done.  But we shall see.

In the end, it still seems to me that a higher dollar is the path of least resistance.  Manage accordingly.

Good luck

Adf

News Not to Like

Posted on by 
Before we all hear from Chair Jay
This morning we’ll see QRA
The question is will
The bond market kill
The vibe all things are okay

While no one expects a rate hike
Of late, there’s been news not to like
Both housing and wages
Have moved up in stages
Though as yet, there’s not been a spike

We are definitely in a period where there is a huge amount of new information to digest on a daily basis, whether it is data or policy actions by central banks and finance ministries.  During times like this, we have historically seen slightly less liquidity in markets as the big market-makers reduce their activity to prevent major blowups.  Of course, the result is that we have periods that are quite punctuated by sharp moves on the back of the latest soundbite.

So, with that in mind, let’s look at today’s stories.  Starting last night, we saw JGB yields rise to yet another new high for the move, touching 0.98%, before the BOJ executed an unscheduled bond-buying exercise to push back a bit.  Ultimately, the 10-year JGB closed back at 0.94%, but despite the brave words from Ueda-san yesterday, it is clear there will be no collapse in the JGB market.  They simply will not allow anything like that to happen.  At the same time, USDJPY retraced about 0.3% of its recent decline, but continues to hold above 151 for now.  We did hear from Kanda-san, the new Mr Yen, that they were watching carefully, but given the rise in JGB yields has been matched by the rise in Treasury yields, it is hard to get too bullish, yet, on the yen.  

This is the first big assumption that has not played out as anticipated.  Prior to the BOJ meeting, the working assumption was that when they adjusted YCC the yen would start to rally sharply.  My view has always been that the yen won’t rally sharply until the Fed changes their tune, and that is not yet in the cards.  If the BOJ intervenes, it is probably a good opportunity to sell at those firmer yen levels as until policies change, a weaker yen remains the most likely outcome.

Turning to the US, at 8:30 this morning the Treasury is due to announce the makeup of the $776 billion of debt they will be borrowing this quarter.  The key issue is how much will be short-dated T-bills and how much will be pushed out the curve.  The higher the percentage of long-dated issuance, the more pressure we will see on the bond market going forward.  The 10-year yield is already back to 4.90% this morning, rising another 3bps, and we are seeing pressure throughout Europe as well with yields there up between 1bp and 3bps except for Italian BTPs which have seen yields rise 9bps this morning.  That has taken the Bund-BTP spread back to 200bps, the place where the ECB starts to get concerned.

But back to the US, where a second key narrative assumption has been that housing prices would be falling, thus reducing pressure on the inflation metrics over time.  Alas, that assumption, too, has been called into question after yesterday’s Case Shiller home price data showed a rise in home prices across the country, back toward the peak seen in June 2022.  While the number of transactions continues to decline, given the reduction in both supply and demand it seems that it is still a sellers’ market.  If housing prices don’t decline, then it seems even more unlikely that rents will decline and that means that inflation is going to remain much stickier than the Fed would like to see.  This does not accord well with the thesis that a slowing economy is going to help bring down housing demand followed by slowing inflation.  

As well, there was another data point yesterday, the Employment Cost Index, which rose a more than expected 1.1% Q/Q, and looking at the chart of its recent movement, shows little inclination that it is heading lower.  This is a key data point for the Fed as rising wages is something of which they are greatly afraid given the belief in its impact on prices.  While the White House may have celebrated the UAW’s ability to extract significant gains from the big three automakers, I’m guessing the Fed was a bit more circumspect on the effects those wage gains will have on overall wages in the economy and inflation accordingly.  

Adding all this up tells me that the ongoing belief that inflation is going to be declining steadily going forward, thus allowing the Fed to reduce the Fed funds rate and achieve the highly sought soft-landing is in for a rude awakening.  Rather, I remain quite concerned that monetary policy is going to remain much tighter for much longer than the market bulls believe.  And that means that I remain quite concerned equity multiples will derate lower along with equity markets overall.

Turning to the overnight price action, after a late rebound in the US taking all three major indices higher on the day, though just by 0.3% or so, we saw a big boost in Tokyo, with the Nikkei jumping 2.4%, as it seems there is joy in the idea that the BOJ may allow yields to rise further.  Either that or they were happy to see the BOJ buy bonds, I can’t tell which!  Europe, though, is a touch softer this morning with very marginal declines and US futures markets are looking to reverse yesterday’s gains, all -0.35% or so, at this hour (8:00).

Oil prices are higher this morning, up 1.8% as concerns about escalation in the Middle East seem to be growing after some comments about a wider war and further attacks by both Iranian and Hamas leaders.  Gold is little changed today but did suffer in yesterday’s month end activity although copper is firmer this morning in something of a surprise given the continuing weak PMI data we have been seeing.

Finally, the dollar continues to flex its muscles as the DXY is back just below 107 with both the euro and pound lower this morning by about -0.25%, and virtually all EEMEA currencies under pressure as well.  Other than the yen’s modest rebound, the dollar is higher vs. just about everything.

On the data front, in addition to the QRA and the FOMC later this afternoon, we see ISM Manufacturing (exp 49.0), Construction Spending (0.5%) and JOLTS Job Openings (9.25M).  Overnight we saw weaker PMI data from Japan (48.7) and China (Caixin 49.5), although for some reason, European PMI data is not released until tomorrow.

At this point, it is very much a wait and see session but as far as I can tell, the big picture has not yet changed.  Inflation remains stickier than the Fed wants, and the market seems to believe which leads me to believe we are going to see yields remain higher for quite a while yet.  I would estimate we will see 5.5% 10-year yields before we see 4.5% yields and if that is the direction of travel, equity markets are going to have a tough time while the dollar maintains its bid.

Good luck

Adf

Aghast

Posted on by 
The BOJ did
Absolutely nothing new
Can we be surprised?

The last of the key central bank meetings finished last night with the BOJ not only leaving policy on hold, as expected, but not even hinting that changes were in the offing.  Much had been made earlier this month about a comment from Ueda-san that they may soon have enough information to consider policy changes.  This was understood to mean that YCC might be ending soon.  Oops!  If that is going to be the case, it was not evident last night.  Rather, the status quo seems the long-term view in Tokyo right now.  Not surprisingly, the yen suffered accordingly, selling off another -0.5% overnight and is now back at its weakest point (highest dollar) since October 2022 when the BOJ intervened actively.

Also, not surprisingly, after the yen weakened further, we started to hear from the MOF trying to scare the market.  FinMin Shunichi Suzuki once again explained that he would not rule out any actions with respect to the currency market if volatility (read depreciation) increased too much.  But as of yet, there have been no BOJ sightings and I suspect they will not enter the market until 150.00 is breached once again.  Maybe next week.

With central bank meetings now past
The markets’ response has been fast
It seems there’s a pox
On both bonds and stocks
And owners of both are aghast

While further rate hikes may be rare
Investors feel some small despair
No rate cuts are planned
Throughout any land
And bond yields are now on a tear

Turning to the rest of the G10, what was made clear over the past two weeks is that policy rates are not anticipated to fall anytime soon.  While some central banks seemed to finish for sure (ECB, SNB, BOE) others seem like there may be another in the pipeline (Fed, Riksbank, Norgesbank, BOC, RBA), but in no case is there a discussion that inflation has reached a place of comfort for any central bank.  Rather, even those banks on hold seem comfortable that policy rates need to remain at current levels in order to continue to battle the scourge of inflation.  If anything, the hawks from most central banks continue to push for further tightening, although I suspect that will be a difficult hill to climb given the inherent dovishness of most central bank chiefs.

So, what are we to expect if this is the new home for interest rates rather than the ZIRP/NIRP to which we had become accustomed for the past 15 years?  The first thing to consider is that despite the higher rate structure, the financial position of the private sector, at least in the US, remains strong.  Corporates termed out debt and tend toward being cash rich, so for now, they are benefitting from high interest rates as they locked in low financing and are earning the carry.  Many households are in the same position, having refinanced home mortgages at extremely low rates so are not feeling the pain of the recent rise in mortgage rates.  Of course, this has reduced the amount of activity in the housing market and is a problem for first-time buyers, but that is not the majority, so net, the pain is not so great.

However, the US is unique in this situation as most of the rest of the world are beholden to short-term rates in their financing.  This is true in the commercial sector, where bank lending is a far more important part of the capital structure than public debt.  Those loans are floating, which is also true in the household sector where most mortgages elsewhere have 5-year fixed terms and so are already repricing higher and impacting homeowners.  In fact, if you want one reason as to why the US is likely to outperform the rest of the world, this would be a good place to start.  Despite much higher interest rates, the pain is not being felt across much of the US economy while it is being felt acutely throughout Europe and the UK.  

The upshot of this process is that inflation is likely to remain with us for quite a while going forward.  This means that central banks are going to have a great deal of difficulty reversing course absent a major crash in economic activity.  Given the US tends to lead the world’s capital markets, it also means that the combination of continuing gargantuan issuance by the Treasury to finance the never-ending budget deficits along with the stickiness of inflation implies that interest rates need to be higher.  We saw this price action yesterday with 10yr Treasury yields jumping to 4.5%, another new high for the move, and importantly, a larger move than the 2yr yield.  This is the ‘bear steepening’ that I have been writing about, with longer end yields rising faster than shorter yields.  Ultimately, this will be quite a negative for risk assets, especially paper ones, although hard assets ought to benefit.  The world that we knew has changed, so we all need to adjust accordingly.

Turning to the overnight session, yesterday’s US weakness was followed by Japan (-0.5%) but Chinese shares bucked the trend, rising strongly on hopes that the recent data shows the worst is past for the mainland.  That seems odd given the lack of additional stimulus forthcoming from the government, but that is the story.  European shares are mostly a bit lower this morning after flash PMI data was released showing growth in the Eurozone remains elusive.  Germany is still in dire straits with its Manufacturing PMI <40, but the whole of Europe is sub 50 for the past four months at least.  Finally, US futures are bouncing slightly this morning, but that seems like a trading reaction to two consecutive days of sharp losses rather than new optimism.

Other than YK Gilts, which traded at much higher levels back in August, European sovereigns are following Treasury yields to their highest level in more than a decade.  And despite the weak economic story, the fact remains that sticky inflation is the clear driver for now.  Consider that the ECB has essentially explained they have finished raising rates with their policy rate at 4.0% while CPI is running at 5.2% headline and 5.3% core.  Those numbers do not inspire confidence that the ECB has done its job.  I continue to look for higher long-term yields going forward.

Part of the reason for this is that oil (+0.9%) continues to find support.  While it had a couple of days of a modest pullback, we are back above $90/bbl and the news remains bullish the outcome.  The latest is the Russia is halting deliveries of diesel fuel, a particular sore spot as there are already tight supplies around the world, especially here in the US.  I see no reason for oil to decline structurally, and that is going to continue to pressure inflation higher.  Perhaps of more interest is the fact that the metals complex is rallying today, despite the rise in interest rates.  Gold (+0.3%), silver (+1.3%), copper (+0.8%) and aluminum (+1.1%) are all in the green.  Again, I would say that owning hard assets is going to be a better outcome than paper ones.

Finally, the dollar is mixed this morning, showing gains against the euro, pound and yen, but softer vs. the commodity bloc with AUD, NZD, CAD and NOK all firmer this morning.  As well, EMG currencies are having a better session, rising a bit vs. the greenback, but recall, the dollar has had quite a good run lately.  My take is there is a lot of profit-taking as we head into the weekend given the lack of fundamental stories that would undermine the buck.  Nothing has changed my view it has further to rise.

On the data front, the only releases are the flash PMIs here (exp 48.0 Manufacturing, 50.6 Services) and we get our first Fed speaker, Governor Lisa Cook, a confirmed dove.  We have already had a lot of activity this week so I suspect that heading into the weekend, it is going to be a quiet session as traders and investors start to plan for next week’s excitement.

Good luck and good weekend
Adf

Problems Galore

Posted on by 
The story continues to be
The China of President Xi
Has problems galore
With more still in store
So, traders, as such, want to flee

The issue for markets elsewhere
Is knock-on effects aren’t rare
Protecting the yuan
Means it is foregone
Bond sales will send yields on a tear

For yet another day, China is offering the biggest market stories.  In no particular order we have seen the following overnight; China Evergrande filed for Chapter 15 bankruptcy, a process by which foreign entities can access the US bankruptcy court system, regarding $19 billion of their offshore debt; the PBOC set their CFETS fixing more than 1000 pips lower than market expectations, the largest gap since the process began in 2018, in their effort to arrest the yuan’s consistent decline; and Chinese police visited the homes of the protesters who were complaining about Zhongzhi’s missed payments (I wrote about these Monday in Risks Were Inbred).  And this doesn’t include the fact that Country Garden, the largest property developer in China is losing money quite rapidly and may also be on the brink of bankruptcy.  It seems the Chinese property bubble is deflating.

Ultimately, there appear to be two main impacts of the gathering storm in China, market participants are increasingly leery of taking on risk in general, and the PBOC’s efforts to stem the decline of the yuan means they must sell their holdings of Treasuries to generate the dollars to deliver into the FX market thus adding downward pressure to the bond market.  Of course, one of the typical outcomes of a risk-off attitude is that bond markets rally as investors exit equities and run to bonds.  This stands at odds to the recent bond market behavior, although it is quite evident this morning.  In fact, after touching yields above 4.30% in the 10yr Treasury yesterday, this morning we have seen a half-point rally with yields declining about 5bps in the US.  In Europe, the yield declines have been even greater, mostly around -10bps, so this is a real reprieve for bond markets everywhere.

The key question here is whether we have seen the worst, or if other potential selling catalysts will appear.  Consider for a moment the fact that between China and Japan, they represent >26% of foreign owned US Treasury debt, and that both of these nations are dealing with rapidly weakening currencies.  Not only that, but both have demonstrated they are quite willing to intervene in FX markets to arrest those declines, and as mentioned above, that typically requires selling Treasuries.  It’s a self-reinforcing cycle as higher yields beget currency sales which beget Treasury sales to intervene, which results in higher yields starting the cycle all over.  

With this in mind, we need to consider, what can break the cycle?  Well, if the Fed were to turn dovish and indicate they agreed with the futures markets that rate cuts are coming early next year, I suspect the dollar would fall against most currencies, especially these two, and the cycle would break.  Alternatively, China could step up and guarantee the debt of Countrywide and Evergrande thus removing the investor risk and reduce pressure dramatically.  Finally, I suppose the Fed could make a deal with the BOJ and PBOC and directly absorb their bond sales, so they never hit the market while restarting QE.  That, too, would likely end the cycle.  It is possible there are other ways to break the cycle, but I doubt we will see any of these occurring anytime soon and so the cycle will have to wear out naturally.  That will occur when either or both of the currencies decline far enough so the market believes the trade has ended and unwinds their short positions.  In other words, none of this has changed my view that 7.50 is on the cards for USDCNY as the year progresses, very possibly with 10yr yields getting to 4.5% or more.  And don’t be surprised if we see another move to 150.00 in USDJPY.

But, away from the China connection, things are very much in the summer doldrums.  Equity markets have been treading fearfully and continue to do so this morning.  However, while we have seen several days of declines, there has been no panic selling of note.  So, yesterday’s US weakness was followed by selling throughout Asia and this morning in Europe with most markets down about -1.0%.  US futures, too, are softer, down about -0.5% at this hour (8:00).

Oil prices (-0.85%) which stabilized yesterday, are back under a bit of pressure on the overall negative risk sentiment as they continue to trade either side of $80/bbl.  Metals prices, meanwhile, are mixed with precious metals finding a bit of support while base metals suffer today.  The most interesting story here I saw today was that CODELCO, the world’s largest copper miner in Chile, may be going bankrupt as previous projects didn’t pan out.  That strikes me as a very large potential problem, but one for the future.  

Finally, the dollar is mixed this morning.  It had been softer overall in the overnight session, but as risk is getting marked down, the dollar is gaining strength.  The biggest mover has been PHP (+1.1%) which rallied after the central bank indicated they were going to put a floor under the currency and adjust rates accordingly.  After that, the EMG bloc has not done very much, +/- 0.25% type activity.  However, just recently, G10 currencies started to slide with NOK (-0.8%) the laggard as oil slides, but the entire bloc now coming under pressure.  This is all about risk off.  

There is no US data today nor are there any Fed speakers.  As such, the dollar will take its cues from the equity markets, and the bond market to some extent.  Right now, equity weakness is driving the risk attitude and that means the dollar is likely to remain bid into the weekend.  Next week brings the Fed’s Jackson Hole meeting where everybody will be looking for any policy hints by Chairman Powell on Friday morning.  But for now, the dollar is on top of the mountain.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Finding a Cure

Posted on by 
Apparently President Xi
Is keen to continue to be
The story du jour
While finding a cure
For China and its ‘conomy

But elsewhere, the market’s fixation
Is central bank communication
Tomorrow, Chair Jay
Seems likely to say
They’ve not yet defeated inflation

The story in China continues to be one of weakening economic activity and a government that is increasingly desperate to address the situation while maintaining their iron grip on everything that occurs in the country.  Of course, the problem with this thesis is that economic activity works far better without government interference, but that is the bed they have made.  At any rate, the word out of the CCP’s Politburo is that more support is coming with expectations now for lower interest rates as well as still looser property investment policies.  While it seems they don’t want to make direct cash injections into the economy yet, that appears to be the next step.

However, the announcements last night were sufficient for a bullish slant on everything China along with positive knock-on effects for those nations that are heavily reliant on a strong China for their own economic progress.  The result is that we saw dramatic strength in Chinese equity markets with the Hang Seng (+4.1%) and CSI (+2.9%) both having their best days in months.  Even with these moves, though, the Hang Seng remains more than 37% below its 2021 highs while the CSI is about 34% off those levels.  The point is that while last night’s session was quite positive, belief in the Chinese economic story remains a bit suspect yet.

Elsewhere, however, the PBOC is doing its level best to prevent the renminbi from declining sharply as they set the fix nearly 1% stronger than expected based on analysts’ models, and ultimately, the currency closed 0.6% stronger on the session.  Now, it remains well above the 7.00 level, but it seems quite clear that Pan Gongsheng, the freshly appointed PBOC governor, is making a statement that the renminbi should not fall dramatically.  I suspect that if the Chinese economy continues to flounder, that attitude may change, but for now, that is the party line.  As such, it should be no surprise that the rest of the APAC currency bloc performed well last night, along with AUD (+0.3%) the best G10 performer.

But away from that story, the market’s attention is turning almost entirely to the trio of central bank meetings that are starting with announcements due tomorrow afternoon (Fed), Thursday morning (ECB), and Thursday night late (BOJ).  Let us begin with the Fed, where the meeting commences shortly, and they are set to discuss the current situation in the economy as well as how things have changed since their June meeting and what their forecasts for the future look like.  

One area that is worth discussing is the Fed’s Reverse Repurchase Program (RRP or reverse repo) which serves as a low-risk investment outlet for excess funds in the system.  Prior to the debt ceiling crisis, there was a great deal of concern that when the Treasury started to issue T-bills to refill the Treasury General Account, the government’s checking account, the liquidity to buy those bills might come out of the stock market and undermine the stock market rally.  But there was another potential source, the RRP program, which prior to the debt deal had more than $2.3 trillion parked, mostly cash held by Money market funds.  However, since the TGA bottomed at the end of May, and the Treasury has been issuing T-bills at a record rate, it turns out that the entire TGA balance has been filled by a reduction in RRP.  In other words, there has been no liquidity drain from the markets, writ large, hence the equity markets continued ability to rally.  That amount has been approximately $500 Billion.  (See chart below with data from Bloomberg and the poet’s calculations)

Of course, there is a cost to this, and that is that the Treasury has been paying a higher yield on T-bills than those money market funds could get in the RRP market, and that, my friends, is adding to the already gargantuan budget deficit.  Since the start of this process, 3mo T-bill yields have risen 50bps, right alongside the Fed funds rate.  In essence, the Treasury is paying to keep the stock market higher.  

There is another short-dated money issue and that is Interest on Reserves, the rate the Fed pays banks for excess reserves that are held at the Fed.  That is currently set at 5.15%, between the Fed’s 5.00% to 5.25% band for Fed funds.  One subtle tweak the Fed could make is to alter that relative level when they raise rates tomorrow in an attempt to adjust the amount that is held there.  After all, other uses for those funds could be satisfying loan demand assuming that existed.  Arguably, a lowering of that rate would imply the Fed is seeking fewer excess reserves in the system, somewhat of a tightening exercise.  

At this stage, the 25bp rate hike is baked in the cake and is assumed by virtually every analyst with just 5 of the 108 analysts surveyed by Bloomberg calling for no hike.  Futures markets are pricing a 97% probability as well, so the reality is that all the action will be in the press conference as well as any new tweaks to the statement.  In my view, there has not yet been enough evidence of a considered slowing in inflation for the Fed to change its tune, but by the September meeting, we will have seen a lot more data and depending on how that plays out, things could be different.  But not this month.

Heading into this morning’s session, that Chinese stock rally was not really widely followed elsewhere as the Nikkei was unchanged and most of Europe is higher by just basis points.  That minimal movement is true in US futures as well.

Bond yields are a touch firmer, about 2bps across Treasuries and virtually the entire European space with only Italy (+4bps) an outlier.  The only data of note was the German IFO report, which was on the soft side, but not dramatically so.  I suspect that the yield move is in anticipation of the coming central bank activities.

In the commodity space, after another rally yesterday, oil is essentially unchanged and consolidating its recent gains.  However, the base metals have rallied sharply on the back of the China news with copper higher by almost 2% and aluminum by 1%.  Meanwhile, gold continues to trade in a very narrow range just below $2000/oz.

Finally, the dollar is slightly firmer this morning overall as the China story did not bleed over into any other areas and traders seem to be adjusting positions ahead of the Fed meeting.  Surprisingly, NOK (-0.6%) is the worst performer despite oil’s recent gains, but elsewhere, in both the G10 and EMG, it is modest dollar strength around.

This morning we see Case Shiller Home Prices (exp -2.35%) and then the Consumer Confidence reading (112.0) although typically, these do not move markets.  With no Fed speakers, the ongoing earnings calendar is likely to be the key driver of markets, although it is not until later this week when we hear from some of the Megacap names that people are getting excited.  I suspect there will be little net movement today ahead of tomorrow’s FOMC announcements.

Good luck

Adf

Quite a Surprise

Posted on by 
While many are looking ahead
To Europe, Japan and the Fed
Today’s PMI’s
Were quite a surprise
As weakness was truly widespread

Meanwhile, from Beijing, what we heard
Was policies they now preferred
Included support
For housing to thwart
The story that weakness occurred

While most market participants are anxiously awaiting this week’s central bank meetings for the next steps in monetary policy by the big 3 (Fed, ECB & BOJ), we did see a bit of surprising news from two sources this morning which has led to some market reactions.  The first thing to note was that the Chinese remain very disappointed that they cannot will their economy to grow faster in isolation and so have announced yet another round of policies intended to foster economic growth.  

The key plank of this policy is to further relax property investment rules, the so-called three red lines from several years ago, in order to encourage people to start buying houses again.  The property slump in China was first recognized when China Evergrande, one of the largest property development companies in the country, started down its road to bankruptcy nearly 2 years ago.  Since then, it has been a slow-motion train wreck with many more firms needing to halt debt payments, restructure debt and even go out of business.  Naturally, this didn’t sit well with the Chinese government, especially since property was a key part of the social safety net.  (Chinese families bought property as a nest egg investment since price appreciation had been so strong for so long.  Price declines have scared new investment away at the same time that many families need to cash in on their investment, adding further downward pressure to the housing market.)

The other main plank of this policy change was a renewed effort to deal with local government debt.  Historically, local governments would issue debt to fund economic investment and would repay that debt by selling property to investors and home buyers.  But with the property market in such a slump, these local governments no longer have the cash flow available to stay current on the debt, let alone repay it.  As such, the Chinese government is going to step into the market and restructure the debt in some manner with simple restructuring on the table as well as debt-swaps, where I assume debt holders will wind up with equity ownership of some extremely illiquid assets.  Neither of these things points to economic strength in China so I would continue to look for further measures as well as more direct fiscal support as we go forward.  As well, although CNY is little changed today, do not be surprised to see it continue its weakening trend.

The other major news this morning came from the Flash PMI data across Europe, which was, in a word, putrid.  While the initial data overnight from Australia and Japan was a bit soft, the continent redefined weakness.  Manufacturing remains mired in a serious recession in Europe as evidenced by Germany’s 38.8 reading, far below expectations and the second lowest print in the series, exceeded only by the Covid lows in April 2020.  But the weakness was widespread with France (44.5) underperforming expectations and the Eurozone as a whole (42.7) even worse.  Services data, while better than Manufacturing is also softening, and the Composite readings show are sub 50 across the board.  UK data was also soft, just not quite as awful, but the general takeaway is growth is slowing in the Eurozone and the UK.

Later this morning we see the US numbers (exp 46.2 Mfg, 54.0 Sevices) as well as the Chicago Fed National Activity Index (exp -0.13), which will help flesh out the story of US economic activity as well.  But the big picture remains that economic activity around the world is suffering, of that we can be sure.

And yet, despite this weakening growth story, expectations for rate hikes by both the Fed and ECB remain a virtual lock although the BOJ seems likely to remain on hold for a while yet.  We will delve into the central banking story tomorrow though.  For today, markets continue to respond to the PMI data as well as the China story.

And how have they reacted you may ask?  Well, starting in Asia, Chinese shares did not seem to like the announcements coming from Beijing as both the Hang Seng (-2.1%) and CSI (-0.45%) suffered although the Nikkei (+1.25%) embraced the idea that the BOJ was going to continue to print as much money as possible.  It should be no surprise that European bourses are in the red after that data with a particular note for Spain (-0.8%) which is also dealing with an election outcome that seems destined to result in another hung parliament.  But don’t worry, US futures continue to point to modest gains at this hour (8:00) although that remains highly earnings dependent I believe.

In the bond market, yields are lower across the board with Treasuries (-3.3bps) that laggard as virtually all the European sovereigns have seen yields slide by 6bps or so.  Apparently, the European investment community is not willing to believe the ECB will continue to raise interest rates into a very obvious recession on the continent.  We shall see if they do so.  As to JGB’s, they saw yields rise 2.4bps, but are still not too close to the YCC cap.  I expect that we will see a little more volatility in the JGB market ahead of Friday’s BOJ announcement as speculators try to get ahead of any potential policy change.

In the commodity space, oil (+0.75%) continues its recent winning ways and is up more than 11% in the past month.  Given the economic news, this has to be a supply driven story.  I have written many times about the structural deficit in oil that we are likely to face given the ESG movement’s systematic underinvestment in oil production.  The problem is that even with a recession, oil demand continues to grow and even the IEA, a complete convert to ESG and net-zero ideas, admits that oil demand will grow to a new record this year in excess of 102 million bbl/day globally.  Rising demand and static or falling supply will drive prices higher, that much is clear.  The base metals are under a bit of pressure, though, this morning, responding as would be expected to the weaker economic story and gold (+0.3%) continues to find support, arguably today on the basis of lower yields around the world.

Finally, the dollar is mixed, although I would argue leaning slightly stronger today.  The worst performer is CZK (-0.8%) which is suffering from weakness in its largest export market, Germany, as well as continuing to respond to central bank comments from late last week about policy ease.  On the flip side, ZAR (+0.7%) as there is a growing influx of investment into rand bonds given the huge yield advantage.  In the G10, JPY (+0.45%) is today’s leader, although if the BOJ stands pat, I have to believe that further weakness is in the future.  Meanwhile, EUR (-0.3%) is the laggard on the back of that terrible PMI data.

There is a lot of data out there this week in addition to the 3 big central bank meetings.

Today	Chicago Fed National Activity	-0.13
Tuesday	Case Shiller Home Prices	-2.40%
	Consumer Confidence	112.0
	Richmond Fed	-10
Wednesday	New Home Sales	725K
	FOMC Decision	5.50% (current 5.25%)
Thursday	ECB Decision	3.75% (current 3.50%)
	Initial Claims	235K
	Continuing Claims	1750K
	GDP Q2 (2nd look)	1.8%
	Durable Goods	1.0%
	-ex Transport	0.1%
Friday	BOJ Decision	-0.1% (current -0.1%)
	Personal Income	0.5%
	Personal Spending	0.4%
	Core PCE Deflator	0.2% (4.2% Y/Y)
	Michigan Sentiment	72.6
Source: Bloomberg

Obviously, there is plenty of information to be gleaned this week, although there are no scheduled Fed speakers after the meeting and press conference on Wednesday.  I guess they are all going on vacation!  

My read on the current situation is that economic activity continues to slow, although perhaps not yet to a recessionary level.  As well, I fear that inflationary pressures will remain stickier than we would like and that for now, the Fed is not feeling any pressure to end their current higher for longer policy.  In fact, it will be next week’s NFP data that is the first really critical release, as a weak number there will start to give weight to the idea that the terminal rate has been reached.  However, if we see strength in job growth, pencil in at least one more hike past Wednesday.  As to the dollar, I am confident that if the US is ending their tightening cycle, the other major central banks will be ending theirs soon as well.  I see no dollar collapse, nor even significant weakness for quite a while yet.

Good luck
Adf

Cause Regret

Posted on by 
Again China’s leading the news
With stories ‘bout financing blues
So, terms on old debt
Which now cause regret
Have lengthened, more pain to defuse

Meanwhile, from the FOMC
Three speakers were clear as can be
Rate hikes are in store
This month, and then more
On this much, they all did agree

One of the key themes earlier this year that was supposed to have a big market impact was the China reopening story.  You may recall back in February when President Xi Jinping responded to the mass protests with blank papers held aloft, by deciding that permanently locking down a billion people was no longer an effective strategy, and a tacit declaration was made that there were no more Covid restrictions to be imposed or enforced.  Everybody assumed that the Chinese economy would vault out of the gates and that commodity demand would rocket higher while overall global economic activity increased.  Alas, that is not how things played out at all.  Instead, Chinese economic activity has disappointed at every turn with an initial blip higher and then a gradual slide back to less substantial activity.

 

Part of the problem has clearly been the efforts made by companies and countries around the world to reduce or eliminate China’s impact on supply chains.  But part of the problem, and arguably the larger part, was self-inflicted.  That was the massive debt buildup on the back of a two decades long leveraging of the Chinese property market.  You may recall China Evergrande, the first of the big property companies to come under pressure, but it has been an ongoing process for several years now.  The problem, in a nutshell, is that the model that had been used, buy huge swathes of land from city governments with leverage, promise to build housing (whose price had been rising nonstop for two decades) and then sell these flats to people on a highly leveraged basis, collapsed along with the covid lockdowns.  Suddenly, Chinese home buyers were out of work and could no longer afford the previously purchased homes.  As well, the construction companies could not complete the projects given all the workers were locked up in their own homes and unable to get to the construction sites.  However, debt remained a constant and was due regardless of the other issues.

 

The outcome was a significant slowdown in Chinese construction activity, an enormous number of unfinished (or even not yet started) apartment projects, and a lot of losses for both individuals and the property companies.  Now, as China emerged from its covid lockdowns, the government did try to relax some of its previous policy strictures but things in the property sector remain quite soft.  For China, where the property sector represented more than 25% of GDP, this is a problem.  As such, last night we saw the next steps by the Chinese government in this process with further easing on repayment terms by extending the maturity of a large amount of debt by one year, from 2024 to 2025.  It seems that the Chinese were paying attention to the Biden administration’s efforts regarding student loan payment delays and thought, we’ll do that too.  Of course, there is no Supreme Court in China to overturn this policy.  Do not be surprised if next summer, we hear about a further extension of these loans as can kicking is a government’s true superpower. 

 

A perfect encapsulation of this policy was the Chinese loan data released last night where new loans rose by CNY 3.05 trillion, far more than expected and aggregate financing also exploded higher, by CNY 4.2 trillion.  These are strong indications that the Chinese government is back offering substantial fiscal support to the economy in order to help get things moving again.  It should be no surprise that Chinese share prices rallied, nor that the renminbi has rallied a bit as well, pulling away from its recent multi-month lows.  It seems that the market has pushed things far enough to get a policy reaction rather than merely words.  At this point, the big question is, have we seen the end of the recent CNY weakening trend?  If the dollar continues its recent broad decline, then that is a quite probable scenario.  However, if the Fed continues to hew to its higher for longer mantra, and keeps pushing rates higher, be careful, of assumptions of a dollar collapse.

 

Speaking of the Fed, yesterday saw three Fed speakers, Barr, Daly and Mester, all explain that more tightening was still needed to push inflation back to their target. [emphasis added.]

Michael Barr: “we’ve made a lot of progress in monetary policy, the work that we need to do, over the last year.  I would say we’re close, but we still have a bit of work to do.”

Mary Daly: “We’re likely to need a couple more rate hikes over the course of this year to really bring inflation back into a path that along a sustainable 2% path.”

Loretta Mester: “in order to ensure that inflation is on a sustainable and timely path back to 2%, my view is that the funds rate will need to move up somewhat further from its current level and then hold there for a while as we accumulate more information on how the economy is evolving.”

 

It’s almost as if they are all reading from the same script!  At any rate, it seems very clear that regardless of tomorrow’s CPI print, they are going to hike by 25bps later this month.  The real question is, will the data continue to show the strength necessary to drive several more hikes after that?  As I have repeatedly explained, NFP is the most important number.  As long as Powell and the Fed can point to the employment situation and say there is no jobs recession, they will have cover to continue to tighten policy, maybe much higher.  6% or even higher is not out of the question.

 

And yet, despite the ongoing hawkishness from the Fed, the market is no longer concerned, at least that seems to be the case today.  Equity markets in the US managed to eke out gains yesterday and overnight saw Asia with bolder moves higher (Japan excepted as the strengthening yen is weighing on Japanese corporate profitability.). European bourses are higher, although the FTSE 100 is under pressure after mildly disappointing UK labor data this morning where the Unemployment Rate jumped to 4.0% for the first time since December 2021 when it was falling post covid.  US futures are a touch higher at this hour (8:00) but seem to be biding their time for tomorrow’s CPI data.

 

Bond markets, though, have rallied with 10-year Treasury yields lower today by a further 3bps and now back below the all-important 4.0% level, albeit just barely.  European sovereigns are also seeing some demand with yields sliding between 1bp and 2bps across the continent.  Even JGB yields edged a bit lower in a global bond buying spree.

 

Commodity prices are broadly higher with oil (+0.6%) continuing its rebound of the past week, while gold (+0.5%) is feeling a little love on the back of the dollar’s broad weakness today.  As to the base metals, they are ever so slightly firmer, retaining yesterday’s gains.

 

And finally, the dollar is softer across the board this morning as it seems to be following treasury yields lower and ignoring the Fed commentary.  The dollar’s weakness is evident in both the G10 and EMG blocs with JPY and NOK (both +0.6%) the leading gainers while only NZD (-0.4%) is under any pressure as traders prepare for the RBNZ meeting this evening and seem to be reducing their positions.  As to the emerging markets, KRW (+1.0%) was the leading gainer on the back of the Chinese fiscal policy story, although we saw strength throughout the APAC bloc.  Both EMEA and LATAM are a bit more mixed with much less significant movement, so seemingly following the bigger trend.

 

Today’s only data point has already been released, the NFIB Small Business Optimism Index, which printed at a higher than expected 91.0.  While this is a good sign, it is important to understand that the long history of this index shows an average near 100 and the current readings still mired near the lowest levels in its history, only surpassed by the massive recessions of 1980-1982 and the GFC in 2009.

 

There are no Fed speakers scheduled today, although we get a bunch more tomorrow after the CPI report is released.  For now, the market is looking askance at the dollar while Treasury yields sink.  My take is there is further upside in yields and therefore in the dollar.  However, that is not today’s trade. 

 

Good luck

Adf

Confusion Reigns

Posted on by 
Investors and traders are caught
Twixt data which shows that they ought
Be uber concerned
Although they have learned
That fighting momentum is fraught

And so, it’s confusion that reigns
Reminding us of Maynard Keynes
Though logic dictates
We’re in dire straits
That doesn’t prevent further gains

One of the remarkable things about the current situation across markets and macroeconomics is that every piece of new information seems to add to the confusion rather than any sense of clarity.  As such, both the bulls and the bears, or perhaps the hawks and the doves, have constant reinforcements for their views.  As John Maynard Keynes famously told us all in 1920, “the market can stay irrational longer than you can stay solvent,” and right now, there are many who are flummoxed by the seeming irrationality of the markets.

 

Data continues to print demonstrating economic weakness, with this morning’s German IFO results simply the latest.  Expectations fell sharply to 83.6, a level whose depths had only been plumbed in the past during the GFC, at the beginning of Covid and when Russia invaded Ukraine.  Too, the Business Climate fell to 88.5, mirroring the Expectations index in futility.  In other words, this is an indication that businesses in Germany are not merely in a recession currently but see no escape soon.  And why would they?  After all, Madame Lagarde promised another rate hike next month and there is talk of further hikes later.  So, it appears there will be no short-term relief for the citizens there.   And yet, despite a very modest amount of equity market selling at the end of last week, most equity markets remain solidly higher halfway through 2023.

 

This morning’s data begs the question, can the global economy, or really any industrialized nation’s economy, avoid a recession if the manufacturing sector is declining.  We are all aware that most of the G10 economies are services oriented, while we see much larger proportions of GDP driven by manufacturing in larger emerging markets.  The following table, with data from the World Bank shows what these proportions as percentages of GDP were in 2021 (latest data available):

 

Australia

6

Brazil

10

Canada

10

China

27

Germany

19

India

14

Ireland

35

Japan

20

Korea

25

Mexico

18

South Africa

12

Spain

12

Sweden

13

UK

9

US

11

 

It should be no surprise that China, given their mercantilist policies, are at 27%, nor that South Korea (25%) and Mexico (18%) have relatively large manufacturing sectors.  But both Germany (19%) and Japan (20%) are also quite manufacturing focused.  As such, it should not be that surprising they both had run large trade and current account surpluses given that’s what mercantilist policies generate.  The point is, if manufacturing is heading into a slump, or perhaps already in one, can the broader economy maintain overall growth? 

 

Arguably, there is a significant portion of the services economy that is highly dependent on manufacturing as well.  Consider things like financial services for those companies, transportation of manufactured goods as well as raw materials to factories and food and janitorial services at factories.  Those are not part of the equation, but if factories close down in ‘service oriented’ economies, all those services will shrink as well.  The point is even in the US, where manufacturing technically represents only 11% of GDP, a slump in that sector will have wide ranging impacts.   And what we have seen just this month is a litany of lousy data on the manufacturing side.  ISM Manufacturing (46.9), Kansas City Fed (-12), Philly Fed (-13.7), Dallas Fed (-29.1) and Chicago PMI (40.4) all point to severe weakness in the US manufacturing sector.  Can the US economy really grow strongly with a key sector under such pressure?  Can any economy?  Germany is already in a recession, and we know that their manufacturing sector is sliding.  China, too, has shown weaker data consistently and the government there is trying to figure out how to support the economy to prevent a severe slowdown.  These are the arguments for why an official recession is coming to the US and all of Europe and probably the world. 

 

And yet, equity market bullishness remains intact.  At least based on the major indices.  Despite the fastest set of interest rate hikes in history by the Fed, ECB and BOE amongst others, equity indices are higher throughout the G10 this year, led by the NASDAQ’s remarkable 29% rally.  In addition, as we approach month/quarter end this week investment managers who have not been willing to close their eyes and buy are finding themselves forced into that situation.  Meanwhile, inflation data, while slowing from its peak seen 6mo-9mo ago remains well above central bank targets indicating that there is further monetary policy tightening to come.

 

So, who do you believe?  The data that shows key sectors of the global economy are slowing?  Or the data that shows ongoing strong employment means overall economic activity is continuing to rise?  It is easy to understand why so many analysts are forecasting a recession.  It is also easy to understand why investors don’t respond that way as they watch market performance.  And this, of course, is why Keynes’ words were so prescient, right now, markets do not seem rational, but they are what they are.

 

Arguably the one thing that is not frequently discussed but has been shown to be true over time is that G10 governments do not like to see recessions at all and will do anything they can and spend any amount, to prevent one from occurring.  As long as central banks continue to monetize the debt required to do so, this structure can continue.  But at some point, the debt will overwhelm the system and a correction will occur.  It is anybody’s guess as to when that might happen, but it certainly feels like that day is slowly coming into view.  At some point, investors will ignore what the central banks say and there will be a very significant correction.  But there’s nothing to say it can’t wait five more years.  As I said, confusion reigns.

 

Turning to the market activity overnight, After Friday’s down session in the US, Asia continued that trend with Chinese equity markets the weakest of the bunch, but screens red across the region.  Europe, which had been uniformly negative earlier in the session has now seen a very modest bounce back to basically unchanged although US futures remain slightly in the red.

 

That risk-off feeling is being seen in bond markets with yields lower across the board this morning as both Treasuries and European sovereigns find themselves with yields sitting between 3bps and 4bps softer than Friday’s closing levels.  The 2yr-10yr yield curve inversion remains -102bps, certainly not a positive economic sign, and we are seeing European curves invert as well.  Even JGB yields are a touch lower this morning.

 

Oil prices are a touch higher this morning although WTI remains below $70/bbl and metals prices are also a bit firmer, bouncing off recent lows.  However, that seems more to do with dollar weakness than commodity strength.

 

Which is a bit odd as during a classic risk-off session, the dollar tends to do quite well, yet today it is softer vs. all its G10 counterparts led by NOK (+0.9%) and many EMG currencies.  Forgetting TRY (-2.7%), the other losers are CNY (-0.7%) which is catching up after a few days of Mainland holidays, and TWD (-0.3%).  However, there is a long list of gainers led by ZAR (+0.9%) and HUF (+0.6%).  Arguably, falling Treasury yields are hurting the dollar somewhat, but quite frankly, I’m not convinced that is the driver here.

 

On the data front, as it is the last week of the month, we will get updated GDP and PCE figures as well as an array of things:

 

Today

Dallas Fed

-20.0

Tuesday

Durable Goods

-0.9%

 

-ex transportation

0.0%

 

Case Shiller Home Prices

-2.60%

 

New Home Sales

675K

 

Consumer Confidence

103.8

Thursday

Initial Claims

264K

 

Continuing Claims

1772K

 

Q1 GDP

1.4%

Friday

Personal Income

0.3%

 

Personal Spending

0.2%

 

Core PCE Deflator

0.3% (4.7% Y/Y)

 

Chicago PMI

44.0

 

Michigan Sentiment

63.9

Source: Bloomberg

 

On the speaker front, the ECB has their summer confab in Sintra, Portugal this week with Powell, Lagarde, Ueda and Bailey all speaking on Wednesday and Thursday.  It will certainly be interesting to hear them all together as they try to convince themselves they are in control.

 

I remain skeptical as to the potential for further gains in risk assets, but I have been skeptical for months and been wrong.  As to the dollar, if yields are going to decline, I could see the dollar slide further, but if risk does get jettisoned, I expect the dollar to find a bid.

 

Good luck

Adf