Author Archives: fxpoet

Bad News is Good

Posted on by 
It seems that when bad news is good
Some things are not well understood
So, risk assets rally
And traders who dally
Miss out making gains that they could

But that was the story last week
And looking ahead we shall seek
The narrative changes
That altered the ranges
Of assets that used to look bleak

It has been a pretty quiet session overall and, in truth, the upcoming week does not look all that interesting from a market perspective.  While we do get the RBA policy announcement tonight (exp 25bp hike to 4.35%), and a great deal of Fedspeak including Powell on both Wednesday and Thursday, from a data perspective, there is nothing of note on the horizon.

As such, I feel like it is a good time to review the recent data and policy decisions that have led to the market gyrations through which we have been living.  If you recall, heading into last week, the narrative had been focused on the continued bear steepening of the yield curve as bond yields were rising on the anticipation of a significant increase in supply.  This movement was weighing on equity markets, which had just finished an awful week.  While risk was under pressure, we saw dollar strength although oil markets were in the midst of pricing out an expansion of the Israeli-Hamas conflict into a wider Middle East war impacting oil production or shipments.  Generally, the mood was bearish and there were many questions as to the timing of the much-anticipated recession.

And then last week turned almost everything on its head.  Starting with the BOJ, which adjusted its YCC policy again, although in a more flexible manner, removing the hard cap on yields at 1.00% and instead calling that a goal, rather than a cap.  Not surprisingly, the first move was for JGB yields to rise sharply, although they have not yet touched 1.00%, and, also, not surprisingly, the BOJ was in the market with an unscheduled round of JGB purchases the next day.  In the end, I think it is fair to say that while the BOJ is still running the easiest monetary policy in the world, it is somewhat tighter at the margin.

Meanwhile, the Fed’s reaction function seems to have been adjusted by the bond market’s bear steepening price action.  Several weeks prior to the FOMC meeting last week, Dallas Fed President Lorrie Logan was the first to mention that higher long-dated yields were tightening financial conditions and doing some of the Fed’s work for them.  Subsequently, we heard several other Fed speakers reiterate that idea, with some going as far as saying they thought it was worth between 50bps and 75bps of tightening.  At the FOMC press conference last Wednesday, Chairman Powell jumped on that bandwagon, and though he attempted to sound somewhat hawkish, claiming that they remained data dependent and if inflation remained hot, they would hike again, nobody really believes him anymore.  According to the Fed funds futures market, the current probability of a rate hike in December is down to 9.8%.  That was nearly 30% just before the FOMC meeting and has been sliding ever since.

It seems fair to ask, what has changed all these attitudes?  I would argue that the Treasury’s Quarterly Refunding Announcement (QRA) which is generally completely under the radar, was the big news that altered the narrative.  Then, adding to the new momentum, we got clearly weaker than expected employment data, implying that the Fed’s data dependence was going to be heading toward rate cuts sooner rather than rate hikes at all.

Briefly, the QRA is, as its name suggests, the document the Treasury issues each quarter to inform the market of how much new Treasury debt will be issued for the next two quarters, as well as the anticipated mix of issuance between T-bills and longer dated coupons.  In the most recent version, Secretary Yellen indicated that the Q4 issuance would be lower than had previously been expected, and she also indicated that a greater proportion would be in T-bills than expected.  The combination of these two features cut the legs out from under the oversupply issue, at least temporarily (there is still an enormous amount of debt coming) and combined with what had clearly been developing short bond positions by the hedge fund and CTA communities, saw a major reversal in bond prices with yields declining > 40bps last week.

It should be no surprise that stock markets took that news and ran with it.  Part of the previous narrative was the continuous rise in yields was devaluing future earnings in the equity market.  As well, earnings season saw decent numbers, but lots of lower guidance by company management downgrading future assessments.  While Q3 GDP was a hot, hot, hot 4.9%, the Atlanta Fed’s first look at Q4 GDP is for a much more sedate 1.2%.  If that is what Q4 is going to look like, it is hard to get excited about earnings growth.  So, prior to last week, equity markets had declined ~10% from their recent highs, a very normal correction, and the big question was, is this the beginning of the next leg lower in a longer-term bear market, or was this just a correction?

Taken together, and adding in a much weaker than forecast NFP report on Friday, where the headline number fell to 150K, and there were revisions lower for the previous two months by an additional 40K while the Unemployment Rate ticked up to 3.9%, its highest print since January 2022 and 0.5% higher than the cycle lows, the new market narrative seems to be as follows: the Fed is done hiking and the only question is when they will start to cut rates.  The high in longer-term yields has been seen as well since the data is starting to roll over.  This will lead to further downward pressure on inflation and the soft landing will be completed.  The upshot of this narrative is, of course, BUY STONKS!!!

And that was the outcome from Wednesday on last week, a major reversal in equity market weakness, a huge rally in bond prices and decline in yields and a general warm and fuzzy feeling.  And who knows, maybe they will be correct.  But…

  1. The combination of higher stocks and lower bond yields has eased financial conditions considerably in just the past week.  This implies the Fed may be forced to act to continue their program lest inflation reasserts itself.
  2. The idea that slowing growth is a positive for equity prices seems a bit skewed as slowing growth typically leads to weaker profits.
  3. Inflation is not dead yet, and the most recent Core PCE reading did not indicate that it is slowing that rapidly.  As can be seen from the chart below, 0.3% M/M PCE equates to 3.6% annual, well above the Fed’s target.

While I believe that the market is going to run with this narrative for a while, and we could easily see stocks continue to rebound and yields grind a touch lower, I fear that reality will set in soon enough and these moves will prove ephemeral.

Tying this up with a bow on the dollar leaves me with the following view; as long as this current narrative holds, the dollar will remain under pressure.  I suspect this can last through the end of the year, although much beyond that I am far less certain.  I would contend there are two ways things can evolve from here:

  1. This relaxation in financial conditions forces the Fed to reassert themselves and they start hiking rates again.  In this case, the dollar will once again rise as no other central banks will have the ability to keep up with a newly hawkish Fed, or
  2. The much-anticipated recession finally shows up, perhaps in Q1 2024, and the Fed, after a little hesitation starts to ease policy.  However, by that time, I suspect that the rest of the world will also be in recession and central banks elsewhere will be cutting rates even more quickly.  While the dollar is likely to slide initially, I don’t think it will decline very far as in that situation, it seems likely that the US will remain the proverbial ‘cleanest shirt in the dirty laundry.’

As for today, it is hard to get excited about anything really, at least with respect to the FX market.

There will be no poetry tomorrow, but I will return on Wednesday.

Good luck

Adf

No Longer a Threat

Posted on by 
Opinions are already set
The Fed is no longer a threat
Today’s NFP
Will help all to see
That buying stocks is the best bet

At least that’s the narrative tale
The talking heads want to prevail
The question’s, will Jay
Have something to say
If finance conditions, up, scale

To conclude what has already been a tumultuous week, this morning brings the monthly payroll report, a key piece of evidence for the Fed to determine the health of the economy.  Expectations for the readings are as follows:

Nonfarm Payrolls180K
Private Payrolls158K
Manufacturing Payrolls-10K
Unemployment Rate3.8%
Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (4.0% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours34.4
ISM Services53.0

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Apparently, the whisper number is a bit above 200K, but we also must pay close attention to the revisions.  Recall last month had a blowout 336K result, which was much larger than expected.  If that number retains its strength, it would certainly be indicative of a still healthy labor market.  This matters a great deal as after Powell’s press conference on Wednesday and the surprising QRA that shortened the duration of upcoming Treasury bond issuance, the market is all in on the goldilocks story, solid growth with low inflation.  The corollary to this is that the market is looking for the Fed to back off the current rate policy and begin to reduce the Fed funds rate, thus helping all the DCF models pump up the value of equities.

But even though I have been highlighting the importance of the NFP number for the past two years as a key for the FOMC, it is not clear to me that today’s is so important.  I only say this because the Fed just met two days ago, and we will see another NFP before they meet again.  Arguably, this one will get lost in the fog of memory.  

If that is the case, then it is probably a good time to recap what we have seen this week and how it has affected market sentiment.  The bulls are on a roll right now as we have seen a significant pullback in Treasury yields with 10yr down to 4.66%, down 36bps from their peak back on October 23rd.  While that is certainly a large move in a short period of time, it is in line with the types of movement we have been seeing all year, so hardly unprecedented.  But Powell’s comments, which have been read as dovish despite his best efforts to prevent that view, and the bond market movement have many market participants licking their chops for a massive equity rally going forward.

Interestingly, one of the things the talking heads have been using to pump their story has been the tightening in financial conditions that were a result of declining stock and bond prices.  The whole issue of tighter financial conditions doing the Fed’s work for them has been a key story for the past several weeks since it was first mentioned by Dallas Fed President Lorrie Logan.  However, the big rally in both stocks and bonds, as well as the decline in the dollar, are all critical features in the calculation of those financial conditions, and they are all pointing to easier conditions.  The point is, if tighter conditions was a reason for the Fed to have stopped tightening further, the fact that they are now easing implies the Fed may feel the need to raise rates again in December, although that is clearly not the consensus view.

At any rate, right now, momentum is on the bulls’ side, and it is tough to overcome.  Certainly, the economic data continues to point to a resilient economy which implies, to me at least, that the Fed will not feel any urgency to cut rates soon.  There has also been a great deal of discussion regarding the fact that the average time the Fed has held rates at a peak before cutting is just 7 months.  We are now three months into the most recent hold, and, by definition, since the next meeting is not until December, we will be at 5 months then.  My observation about Chairman Powell, though, is at this point he is unconcerned with statistics of that nature and is far more focused on achieving their objective of 2% inflation.  

One last thing about inflation before we touch on markets.  There has been a growing chorus that deflation is on its way because M2 money supply growth is currently declining.  However, for the economics majors out there, recall that the key monetary equation is M*V = P*Q.  P = prices, and Q = quantity of goods, or, combined economic output.  M = Money supply and V = Velocity of money.  It is the last piece that is often ignored but remains quite important.  My good friend @inflation_guy, has just published a piece which is well worth reading.  The essence is that while M2 may be declining, V is rising rapidly, offsetting that impact and creating conditions for much stickier inflation than many believe.  I have a feeling the Fed is going to stay on hold, if not tighten further, for a much longer time than currently anticipated.  While this week’s news has clearly been seen as bullish, the long-term trends have not yet changed in my view.

Ok, so a quick look at markets shows that after another gangbusters day in the US, where all three major indices were higher by 1.7% or more, Asian markets followed suit, with virtually every index there higher by at least 1.0%.  Europe, however, has been more circumspect with markets essentially unchanged this morning, just +/- 0.1% on the day.  US futures are ever so slightly softer at this hour (7:30) down about -0.15% on average, as investors and traders await this morning’s data.

At this point, bonds seem to be taking a rest after a huge price rally / yield decline over the past several sessions and we are seeing very little movement on the day with Treasuries and European sovereigns all within 1 basis point of yesterday’s closing.  Even JGB yields slid a bit yesterday but remain above 0.90% as of now.  As to the shape of the yield curve, that inversion is starting to show its head again, with the current 2yr-10yr spread back to -32bps.  Remember, two days ago that was at -18bps.  Broadly speaking, yield curve inversions are not signs of economic strength.

In the commodity space, oil is creeping back higher, up 0.4% this morning although still lower on the week.  Gold is basically unchanged this morning, continuing to hang out just below $2000/oz, which continues to surprise me given the sharp decline in yields, at least nominal yields.  As to the rest of the space, base metals are mixed amid small changes this morning and foodstuffs, something I have not mentioned in a while, have actually been declining with the FAO’s world food price index falling to its lowest level in more than 2 years last month.  It may not seem that way in the grocery store, but perhaps future price rises will be more muted.

Finally, the dollar is generally biding its time ahead of the data, although leaning lower overall.  In the G10, the average gain of a currency is about 0.2% while in the EMG bloc we have seen a few outliers, notably KRW (+1.2%) but a more general rise of 0.4% or so.  You already know that my view has changed given the seeming change in the underlying drivers.  For now, and likely through the end of the year at least, I think the dollar will be under pressure.

Aside from the data this morning, we get our first Fed speaker, Supervision Vice-Chair Michael Barr, this afternoon, but the topic is the Community Reinvestment Act, which makes it unlikely he will swerve into monetary policy.  So, as is often the case, the data will see a flurry of activity at 8:30 and then I suspect the recent trends will reassert themselves in a slower session overall.  We will need to see an extraordinarily strong NFP print to help reverse the dollar’s current malaise.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Bulls’ Fondest Dreams

Posted on by 
While everyone focused on Jay
The earlier news of the day
Showed Janet would not
The long bond, allot,
Too much, thus yields faded away

Combining that news with the Fed
And all of the things that Jay said
It certainly seems
The bulls’ fondest dreams
Are likely to still be ahead

While most of the headlines yesterday afternoon and this morning revolve around the FOMC meeting and, more importantly, Powell’s press conference, I would argue that as I discussed yesterday, the biggest story was the QRA early in the morning.  Historically, the Treasury has tried to keep T-Bill issuance between 15% and 20% of total Treasury issuance.  However, a look at the current mix shows that Secretary Yellen already has that ratio up to 22.6%.  One of the big questions was how that would play out going forward.

Recall, one of the narratives that has been invoked for the Treasury bond sell-off with corresponding rising yields, has been the supply story.  You know, the US is running massive budget deficits and needs to issue more debt to fund it, so there is a lot more supply coming.  A key assumption in this story was that the mix of debt, which already favored T-Bills, would not change much so the new debt would be forced into the back end of the curve.  Well, that’s not how things worked.  The QRA indicated that the Treasury was going to issue a lot more T-Bills, a total of $1.1 trillion over the next two quarters, raising the proportion of T-Bills to 23.2%, even further above the old ceiling.  Of course, the result is much less issuance in the 5yr and longer space, thus undercutting the excess supply argument.

The results cannot be surprising as even before Powell started speaking, 10-year yields had fallen 11bps although they continued to decline afterwards as well, finishing the day lower by 16bps or so.  All in all, an impressive bond rally.  But let’s consider for a moment a different consequence of yesterday’s announcements, the shape of the yield curve.  Prior to the QRA and the Fed, the yield curve, as measured by the 2yr-10yr spread had fallen from a low of -108bps to just -15bps and it seemed almost certain that it would normalize soon.  However, now that the QRA has shown there will be more issuance out to 2yrs and less beyond, the immediate impact is the curve is going to go back to inverting further, (it is already back to -22bps) at least until such time as the Fed actually does cut rates.  I have a feeling that we are going to hear a lot more about recession again even though Powell explicitly said the Fed was not expecting one.  In fact, Powell and the Fed may be the only people not expecting a recession at this point!

A quick look at the Fed funds futures market shows that for the December FOMC meeting, the market is currently pricing a 20% probability of a 25bp rate hike.  That is slightly lower than before the FOMC meeting yesterday, but within the margin of error.  However, at this point, the market has a 43% probability of a rate cut in May, with that probability growing as you head out further in time.  One of the things Powell reiterated yesterday is that the committee is not even discussing the idea of a rate cut.  Of course, he also said that they don’t believe a recession is coming so it is not surprising the market has a different rate view than the Fed.

In the end, I think this is a seminal shift in policy with the combination of Treasury and Fed actions indicative of a much easier policy stance going forward.  I have built my views based on the Fed maintaining its higher for longer stance and continuing to stress the system which remains massively leveraged.  However, if he is no longer going to follow that path, and I think we learned yesterday that the inflection point is here, then we need to rethink the future.  One consequence of this policy change, though, is that inflation, which I have maintained is going to remain far stickier than many anticipate, is going to become an even bigger problem down the road.  I just don’t know how far down the road that will be.  But for now, I think we are going to continue to see equities rebound into year end, bond yields fall, the dollar fall, and commodity prices rebound.  This is going to be a classic risk-on scenario through the end of the year in my view.

And despite, or perhaps because of, continued weaker data, that is what we are seeing in markets around the world.  Yesterday’s ISM Manufacturing data was quite soft at 46.7, and this morning the PMI data from the rest of the world was generally awful with all European readings between 40 and 45.  Yesterday’s ADP Employment data was soft, at 113K which just added fuel to the policy easing fire and though the JOLTS Job Openings data was still strong, the net perception is slower times are ahead, and with them, lower interest rates.

A look around markets shows that after yesterday’s US rally, with the NASDAQ leading the way higher by 1.6%, Asian shares rallied (Nikkei +1.1%, Hang Seng +0.75%) and we are seeing strength across the board in Europe with all major indices higher by at least 1.25%.  And don’t worry, US futures are pushing higher again, up about 0.5% at this hour (7:15).

It is, of course, no surprise that bond yields around the world are lower with European sovereigns declining by between 7bps and 12bps after both Australia and New Zealand saw yields tumble 16pbs and 25bps respectively.  Even JGB yields are softer by 3bps.  In fact, Dutch central bank president Klaas Knot, one of the most hawkish ECB members, is on the tape this morning with the following quote, “We should be a little patient and not raise rates too much.”  That may be the most dovish thing he has ever said.  The point here is that until such time as inflation really comes roaring back (and I fear that day will come), the direction of travel in interest rates is lower.

Oil prices, which remained under some pressure in the past week, have bounced 1.4% this morning with the movement seeming to be a response to the policy changes while gold (+0.3%) is also climbing, although a bit slower than I might have expected.  But we are seeing strength throughout the commodity complex on the lower rate story with copper (+0.5%) rallying despite the prospects of a recession.

Finally, the dollar is under pressure across the board with the DXY down -0.7% led by the euro (+0.6%), AUD (+0.7%) and NZD (+0.95%).  The yen (+0.4%) is a bit of a laggard today, though remains above the 150 level, but I suspect that we are going to see dollar weakness continue going forward.  Against EMG currencies, we are also looking at a weaker greenback with KRW (+1.0%) leading the way, but strength through APAC and EEMEA and MXN (+0.6%) firmer as the only representative of LATAM that is trading at this hour.  Yesterday Banco Central do Brazil cut their SELIC rate by 50bps to 12.25% as widely expected and BRL rallied 2% on the day.  Again, the theme is now a weaker dollar going forward.

To show how big a deal yesterday was, the BOE meets this morning, and nobody is even discussing it.  Expectations are for no policy change, although perhaps given the sudden dovishness breaking out worldwide, they will consider a cut!  We also see a bunch of US data as follows: Initial Claims (exp 210K), Continuing Claims (1800K), Nonfarm Productivity (4.1%), Unit Labor Costs (0.7%) and Factory Orders (2.4%).   There are no Fed speakers on the schedule today, but they get started again tomorrow.  Remember, tomorrow we also see NFP, so still some fireworks potentially.

For now, though, the new trend is risk on, dollar down.  

Good luck

Adf

News Not to Like

Posted on by 
Before we all hear from Chair Jay
This morning we’ll see QRA
The question is will
The bond market kill
The vibe all things are okay

While no one expects a rate hike
Of late, there’s been news not to like
Both housing and wages
Have moved up in stages
Though as yet, there’s not been a spike

We are definitely in a period where there is a huge amount of new information to digest on a daily basis, whether it is data or policy actions by central banks and finance ministries.  During times like this, we have historically seen slightly less liquidity in markets as the big market-makers reduce their activity to prevent major blowups.  Of course, the result is that we have periods that are quite punctuated by sharp moves on the back of the latest soundbite.

So, with that in mind, let’s look at today’s stories.  Starting last night, we saw JGB yields rise to yet another new high for the move, touching 0.98%, before the BOJ executed an unscheduled bond-buying exercise to push back a bit.  Ultimately, the 10-year JGB closed back at 0.94%, but despite the brave words from Ueda-san yesterday, it is clear there will be no collapse in the JGB market.  They simply will not allow anything like that to happen.  At the same time, USDJPY retraced about 0.3% of its recent decline, but continues to hold above 151 for now.  We did hear from Kanda-san, the new Mr Yen, that they were watching carefully, but given the rise in JGB yields has been matched by the rise in Treasury yields, it is hard to get too bullish, yet, on the yen.  

This is the first big assumption that has not played out as anticipated.  Prior to the BOJ meeting, the working assumption was that when they adjusted YCC the yen would start to rally sharply.  My view has always been that the yen won’t rally sharply until the Fed changes their tune, and that is not yet in the cards.  If the BOJ intervenes, it is probably a good opportunity to sell at those firmer yen levels as until policies change, a weaker yen remains the most likely outcome.

Turning to the US, at 8:30 this morning the Treasury is due to announce the makeup of the $776 billion of debt they will be borrowing this quarter.  The key issue is how much will be short-dated T-bills and how much will be pushed out the curve.  The higher the percentage of long-dated issuance, the more pressure we will see on the bond market going forward.  The 10-year yield is already back to 4.90% this morning, rising another 3bps, and we are seeing pressure throughout Europe as well with yields there up between 1bp and 3bps except for Italian BTPs which have seen yields rise 9bps this morning.  That has taken the Bund-BTP spread back to 200bps, the place where the ECB starts to get concerned.

But back to the US, where a second key narrative assumption has been that housing prices would be falling, thus reducing pressure on the inflation metrics over time.  Alas, that assumption, too, has been called into question after yesterday’s Case Shiller home price data showed a rise in home prices across the country, back toward the peak seen in June 2022.  While the number of transactions continues to decline, given the reduction in both supply and demand it seems that it is still a sellers’ market.  If housing prices don’t decline, then it seems even more unlikely that rents will decline and that means that inflation is going to remain much stickier than the Fed would like to see.  This does not accord well with the thesis that a slowing economy is going to help bring down housing demand followed by slowing inflation.  

As well, there was another data point yesterday, the Employment Cost Index, which rose a more than expected 1.1% Q/Q, and looking at the chart of its recent movement, shows little inclination that it is heading lower.  This is a key data point for the Fed as rising wages is something of which they are greatly afraid given the belief in its impact on prices.  While the White House may have celebrated the UAW’s ability to extract significant gains from the big three automakers, I’m guessing the Fed was a bit more circumspect on the effects those wage gains will have on overall wages in the economy and inflation accordingly.  

Adding all this up tells me that the ongoing belief that inflation is going to be declining steadily going forward, thus allowing the Fed to reduce the Fed funds rate and achieve the highly sought soft-landing is in for a rude awakening.  Rather, I remain quite concerned that monetary policy is going to remain much tighter for much longer than the market bulls believe.  And that means that I remain quite concerned equity multiples will derate lower along with equity markets overall.

Turning to the overnight price action, after a late rebound in the US taking all three major indices higher on the day, though just by 0.3% or so, we saw a big boost in Tokyo, with the Nikkei jumping 2.4%, as it seems there is joy in the idea that the BOJ may allow yields to rise further.  Either that or they were happy to see the BOJ buy bonds, I can’t tell which!  Europe, though, is a touch softer this morning with very marginal declines and US futures markets are looking to reverse yesterday’s gains, all -0.35% or so, at this hour (8:00).

Oil prices are higher this morning, up 1.8% as concerns about escalation in the Middle East seem to be growing after some comments about a wider war and further attacks by both Iranian and Hamas leaders.  Gold is little changed today but did suffer in yesterday’s month end activity although copper is firmer this morning in something of a surprise given the continuing weak PMI data we have been seeing.

Finally, the dollar continues to flex its muscles as the DXY is back just below 107 with both the euro and pound lower this morning by about -0.25%, and virtually all EEMEA currencies under pressure as well.  Other than the yen’s modest rebound, the dollar is higher vs. just about everything.

On the data front, in addition to the QRA and the FOMC later this afternoon, we see ISM Manufacturing (exp 49.0), Construction Spending (0.5%) and JOLTS Job Openings (9.25M).  Overnight we saw weaker PMI data from Japan (48.7) and China (Caixin 49.5), although for some reason, European PMI data is not released until tomorrow.

At this point, it is very much a wait and see session but as far as I can tell, the big picture has not yet changed.  Inflation remains stickier than the Fed wants, and the market seems to believe which leads me to believe we are going to see yields remain higher for quite a while yet.  I would estimate we will see 5.5% 10-year yields before we see 4.5% yields and if that is the direction of travel, equity markets are going to have a tough time while the dollar maintains its bid.

Good luck

Adf

A Loose Upper Bound

Posted on by 
One percent is now
A loose upper bound, rather
Than a key level

Yen participants
Saw a signal to sell.  Is
Intervention next?

Below is what appears, to me at least, to be the critical comment from the BOJ after last night’s policy meeting.  As well, that graphic comes straight from the BOJ presentation.

“It is appropriate for the Bank to increase the flexibility in the conduct of yield-curve control, so that long-term interest rates will be formed smoothly in financial markets in response to future developments.”

The essence of this is that YCC as we knew it, where the control part was the key, is now dead.  Instead, Ueda-san is going to allow a great deal more leeway for the market to determine the yield on the 10-year JGB, and the entire yield curve there.  While they have not yet adjusted the policy rate, which remains at -0.10%, I imagine that change is only a matter of time.  Remember, though, the BOJ currently owns somewhere around 56% of the outstanding JGBs in the market.  It is very clear they are not going to sell any.  To me the question, which I did not see answered last night, is whether they will replace the bonds in their portfolio when old ones mature.  There was no mention of QT, but I guess we will have to see.  Based on their history, however, I would expect that the current balance of JGB’s they own will remain pretty constant going forward, at least on a nominal basis.  Given the Japanese government continues to run deficits, that will eventually reduce the percentage of holdings.  Of course, I suspect that this is subject to change if things get politically uncomfortable, but we shall see.

The market response was somewhat counter to what might have been expected.  Arguably, many were looking for a yen rally as higher yields in Japan would create a greater incentive for Japanese institutional investors to bring their money home.  But that is not what happened at all.  This morning, USDJPY is firmly above 150.00 with no hint that there is intervention coming anytime soon.  It seems, at least for now, that the MOF and BOJ are going to allow markets to find a new level by themselves.  If that is the case, I expect that USDJPY is going to revert to form and follow USD interest rates.  In fact, that is really the key, and something about which I have written in the past.  When the Fed turns their policy toward easier money, at that time the dollar will come under significant pressure.  However, until then, the dollar remains the place to be.

In China, the data has shown
The ‘conomy’s not really grown
Will Xi add more cash
To try for a splash
Or will he leave things on their own?

The other news overnight was from China where their PMI data proved weaker than expected for both manufacturing and services with the former falling back below the key 50.0 level at 49.5 and the latter falling to its lowest print since last December during the zero-Covid policy Xi had implemented.  It seems that slowing growth around most of the world plus a limited domestic economic impulse combined with the ongoing collapse of the Chinese property market is just too much to overcome right now.  Expectations are that Xi will agree to yet more stimulus (remember earlier this month they put forth a CNY 1 trillion (~$137 billion) plan, but that has not seemed to have had the desired impact.  At least not yet.  While Japanese equities rallied on the back of the BOJ activity, Chinese equities came under pressure, especially the Hang Seng (-1.6%) although mainland shares fell as well.  As to the renminbi, it continues to grind lower (dollar higher) and remains pegged at the 2% boundary vs. the PBOC’s daily fixing rate.  Nothing has changed my view of further weakness in the renminbi going forward, at least as long as the Fed retains its current policy stance.

If I were to sum up the situation in Asia at this time, I would suggest that the two major economies there are both very busy dealing with substantial domestic economic questions, although those questions are different in nature.  Japan is trying to come to grips with rising inflation absent substantial economic growth while China has a problem defined by weakening growth with inflation not a current issue.  But lack of growth is the common denominator here and as we have seen countless times around the world, I suspect we will see further fiscal stimulus in both nations before long.  

Of course, when it comes to fiscal stimulus, China and Japan are mere pikers compared to the US which has completely rewritten the record books on this matter.  And there is nothing that indicates the US is going to back off, at least while the current administration is in place, and likely the next regardless of the letter after the president’s name.  

On this subject, though, while yesterday I described the QRA as critical, the first part of the Treasury story was revealed yesterday morning when they announced that the funding requirement for Q4 would be $776 billion, some $75 billion less than the consensus estimates before the announcement.  But the key difference was that Secretary Yellen is aiming for an average TGA balance of “only” $750 billion, far less than some estimates of $1 trillion, and less than the current balance of $835 billion.  In fact, the difference between the current balance and the target is what makes up for the difference in the issuance estimates.  Under no circumstances should anyone believe that fiscal prudence is coming soon.

But this lower number has relieved some pressure in the bond market where we have seen yields slide a few more basis points this morning with the 10-year now trading at 4.83%.  This movement has been followed by the European sovereign market, where yields have fallen by between 4bps and 6bps across the board in sympathy.  In fact, the only major market that saw yields rise was the JGB market, where the 10yr yield is now at 0.93%, up 5 more bps from yesterday’s closing levels.  I suspect that we will be trading at 1.00% soon enough, and it will be quite interesting to see just how ‘nimble’ the BOJ will be if yields start to run higher more quickly.

As to equity markets, yesterday’s US rally has been followed by the European bourses, all up between 0.6% and 1.2% despite somewhat soft economic growth data released this morning.  However, Eurozone inflation data was also slightly softer than forecast and it seems traders are looking for the ECB to reverse to rate cuts sooner rather than later.  US futures, meanwhile, are very marginally firmer this morning as all eyes now turn toward tomorrow afternoon’s FOMC outcome.

Oil prices have bounced a bit, up 0.9%, but this seems to be a trading move rather than anything either fundamental or geopolitical.  Regarding the latter, the fact that the beginnings of the Israeli ground invasion of Gaza have not produced nearly the pyrotechnics feared, nor that the conflict has spread throughout the Middle East, at least not yet, has resulted in traders returning their attention to inventories and demand.  Slowing growth in most places around the world is likely the key driver right now.  As to gold, it has maintained its recent gains and is trading right at the $2000/oz level.  Clearly, there is a fear factor there, but remember, if the equity bulls are correct and the Fed is going to tell us they are done, that will be seen as dovish and we should see a reversal in the dollar, a rally in commodities, including gold, and an initial rally in stocks and bonds.  That is not my base case, but you cannot ignore the possibilities.

Finally, the dollar is best described as mixed today as the strength in USDJPY (+1.1%) has been offset by weakness in the greenback vs the euro (+0.4%) and the pound (+0.2%), as well as a number of EMG currencies (MXN +0.4%, PLN +0.5%, ZAR +0.6%).  If one considers the DXY, that is virtually unchanged on the day.

On the data front, this morning brings the Employment Cost Index (exp 1.0%), Case Shiller Home Prices (1.6%), Chicago PMI (45.0) and Consumer Confidence (100.0).  obviously, there are no Fed speakers as their meeting starts this morning and runs through tomorrow afternoon when we will see the statement and Powell will meet the press at 2:30.  

It seems to me like traders will be cautious ahead of the FOMC tomorrow.  I would think they would want more confirmation that the Fed has finished before running back into bonds as well as reversing the recent stock declines.  While the Fed is unlikely to do anything tomorrow, it will be all about the statement and press conference.  Til then, I suspect a quiet time.

Good luck

Adf

A Havoc Nightmare

Posted on by 
While real wages fall
Kishida’s polls fall faster
Will Ueda act?

The first big thing this week is tonight’s BOJ meeting where many in the market are anticipating another tweak to the current YCC framework.  I have seen several analysts calling for a widening of the band to +/- 1.25% from the current +/- 1.00%.  While current yields have yet to reach the cap, they continue to grind higher and are currently at 0.88%, new highs for the move.  Ironically, it is likely the BOJ will need to buy even more JGB’s if they make an adjustment as the wider band would give the green light for speculators to short bonds even more aggressively.  Recall, since they widened from 0.50% to 1.00%, there have been at least five unscheduled bond buying episodes by the BOJ, with the last one, just a week ago, being the largest to date.

One thing to remember about the BOJ is that the concept of central bank independence is not as strong in Japan as it is, perhaps, elsewhere in the Western world.  (Of course, it is not that strong elsewhere either, but Japan is closer to China on this front than the US).  At any rate, the most recent polls in Japan show that PM Kishida’s approval ratings have fallen to new lows for his tenure, with an approval of just 33% according to the most recent Nikkei poll.  And this was after the announcement that he was cutting taxes to help people deal with the consistently rising inflation in Japan.  While it has not grown to levels seen in the US or Europe, it is clearly far higher than they have seen there in more than a generation.

But it doesn’t seem to be enough.  Now, there is no requirement for an election until sometime in 2025, but that doesn’t mean Kishida-san won’t feel the pressure to do more.  And arguably, one of the things they can do to fight inflation is raise rates and see if the yen can recapture some of the 35%+ that it has declined over the past two years.  

So, will they act?  My one observation on this is that unlike the Fed, which never likes to surprise the market, the BOJ has figured out that they only way they can have an impact is if they do surprise the market.  Given that an increasing number of people are starting to look for this outcome, I think the probability of a BOJ policy change tonight is quite low.  I would not be surprised, if I am correct, to see USDJPY head back through 150 and start to grind to new highs above the 152+ peak seen just before the intervention last year.

Meanwhile, for the rest of the week
Both meetings and data might wreak
A havoc nightmare
So, traders, beware
Of comments or data that’s bleak

Beyond tonight’s BOJ meeting, the week is jam-packed with other potential market moving catalysts between central bank meetings (FOMC on Wednesday, BOE on Thursday) and important data including ISM (Wednesday) and NFP on Friday.  However, there is one other thing set to be released Wednesday morning, well before the FOMC announcement and that is the Quarterly Refunding Announcement (QRA).  While, as its name suggests, this is released every quarter, it has generally been relegated to the agate type of market information as a technical feature for bond traders.  But this time, it has gained far more interest given the combination of the bond market’s performance since the last QRA (yields are higher by 80ish basis points) and the fact that the government budget deficit is continuing to grow with many new forecasts for a $2 trillion deficit this year thus a need for even more borrowing. 

Back in August at the last QRA, the Treasury increased issuance more than anticipated which has been seen as one of the drivers of the recent bond market decline.  If they were to increase it significantly again, there is certainly concern that bond yields can move much higher still.  Now, the Treasury could issue more short-term T-bills to take pressure off the bond market but bills already represent about 22% of the total debt outstanding.  That is a couple of points higher than the top of the historic range of 15%-20% and may be seen as a point of contention.  The positive is that given T-bill yields are all above 5.3%, there will be plenty of demand for their issuance.  However, on the flip side, that means that refinancing will need to occur far more frequently and that makes it subject to market dislocations and disruptions.

Another key part of the discussion will be just how large Secretary Yellen wants to keep the Treasury General Account (TGA), which is the government’s ‘checking’ account at the Fed.  As of Thursday, it held $835 billion and there has been talk she wants to increase it to $1 trillion to make sure the government has ample liquidity going forward, especially if there is another issue regarding government financing in Congress.  Historically, the Treasury has issued bills when they are seeking to build up balances in the TGA, which would tend toward seeing even more bills issued rather than substantial growth in the longer-dated maturities.  All in all, it is possible the QRA is going to have the largest potential impact on markets this week so beware.

In truth, the overnight session has been somewhat dull.  While the Israeli-Palestinian situation has seemed to enter a new phase regarding Israel’s incursion into Gaza, markets are non-plussed over the matter with bond yields little changed across the board, the dollar little changed across the board and oil prices sliding (-1.5%) this morning.  Even gold (-0.6%), which has been the best performer in the wake of the middle east crisis, has slipped back below the $2000/oz level, although remains higher by almost 10% in the past month.

In fact, the one area where things are moving is in equity space where we are seeing gains across the board in Europe, somewhere between 0.5% and 1.1%, in the major bourses as inflation data there showed that price rises have begun to slow down and Germany’s economy “only” shrunk by -0.1% in Q3, a much better than expected outcome!  US futures are also higher at this hour (7:15), up by 0.5% or so after a pretty awful week last week.  In fact, the only real outlier was Japan where the Nikkei slid -0.5% as Chinese shares were stronger along with most of the APAC markets.

As mentioned earlier, though, we do have a lot of news coming out this week so let’s go through it here:

TuesdayBOJ Rate Decision-0.1% (unchanged)
 BOJ YCC+ / – 1.00% (unchanged)
 Case Shiller Home Prices1.6%
 Chicago PMI45
 Consumer Confidence100
WednesdayADP Employment150K
 QRA$114 billion (+$11 billion)
 ISM Manufacturing49.0
 JOLTS Job Openings9.2M
 Construction Spending0.4%
 FOMC Decision5.5% (unchanged)
ThursdayBOE Decision5.25% (unchanged)
 Initial Claims210K
 Continuing Claims1795K
 Nonfarm Productivity4.0%
 Unit Labor Costs0.8%
 Factory Orders1.9%
FridayNonfarm Payrolls188K
 Private Payrolls145K
 Manufacturing Payrolls0K
 Unemployment Rate3.8%
 Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (4.0% Y/Y)
 Average Weekly Hours34.4
 ISM Services53.0

Source: tradingeconomics.com

So, as you can see, there is a lot of stuff coming our way starting tonight in Tokyo.  What that tells me is that we are not likely to see very much movement today as traders and investors await the plethora of new information that is due.  However, by the end of the week, we could have a very different narrative.  

Good luck

Adf

A Rough Week

Posted on by 
Investors have had a rough week
As both stocks and bonds sprung a leak
The hope is, today
The data will say
Inflation is well past its peak

The thing is, Q3’s GDP
Described a robust ‘conomy
Will that push the Fed
When looking ahead
To restart their tightening spree?

I imagine most of us are a little tired of the negativity in markets on a daily basis of late.  Yesterday was just another in a series of negative equity market sessions with the US indices declining between -0.75% (DJIA) and -1.75% (NASDAQ).  And this happened despite (because of?) a significantly higher GDP report than most analysts had forecast.  The print, 4.9%, was truly impressive and it was accompanied by stronger than expected Durable Goods orders (4.7%) and continuing solid Initial Claims data (210K).  In other words, the data points to a robust US economy which, one might conclude, would be a positive for risk assets.  One would be wrong.

It seems there are many possible explanations for this seeming conundrum although I favor the following: ongoing elevated interest rates are putting pressure on earnings multiples and driving them lower.  The fact that GDP growth remains robust implies the Fed will be in no hurry to cut rates thus maintaining its higher for longer attitude for even longer.  In this situation, the discount cash flow model, which underlies much, if not most, stock market analysis, tells us that companies growing at 10% cannot be valued at 50x earnings, the math just doesn’t work.  Hence, despite solid performance, investors are rerating the value of these companies lower.  The bigger problem is that the current market multiple remains well above its long-term average so there is further, potentially, to fall.

One other thing to note regarding the economy is that it is quite common for there to be very strong quarterly GDP prints just before a recession begins.  Clearly yesterday’s number was quite strong, in fact the strongest (excluding the post-covid rebound) since Q1 2014.  However, that does not preclude the fact that we may still be headed toward a recession.  Now, arguably, a recession, or at least if the data starts to look like a recession is upon us, would get the Fed to change their tune and consider relaxing their current policy stance.  However, recessions tend to come with much lower earnings and historically are not that good for risk assets either.  It is this concern that has so many praying calling for a soft landing.  Alas, I would not wager on that outcome.

I think it is important to remember that market movements do not have to be driven by outside catalysts but can happen of their own volition.  In fact, that is my point on the rerating of market multiples.  This can occur regardless of any data, whether good or bad.  If the investor community is becoming nervous, and if there is an alternative like we have today with short-dated Treasuries yielding 5% or more, equity prices can decline much further around the world, whatever their current valuations are.  While we all try to rationalize movements in the markets after the fact, on any given day, no specific catalyst is needed from outside the market itself.

With this in mind, though, the rest of the world has not followed yesterday’s US market lead and instead we have seen a rebound in Asian shares with the Hang Seng (+2.1%) leading the way but the rest of the space mostly higher by at least 1%.  European bourses are more mixed with a combination of mostly small gains and losses although the CAC in Paris is an outlier (-1.0%).  US futures, though, are mostly in the green with the NASDAQ the leader (+0.6%) at this hour (7:45).

The bond story, though, is quite interesting as there has been a great deal of volatility in this space of late.  You may recall that I mentioned the abysmal 5-yr auction on Wednesday.  Well, yesterday the Treasury auctioned 7-year paper and the results were outstanding with the best bid-to-cover ratio since March 2020.  This led to a major rally in the bond market with yields continuing their yoyo movement and falling 14bps although this morning they are bouncing from those levels and are higher by 3bps.  European sovereigns did not come along for the Treasury ride yesterday showing much less movement and this morning they are edging lower by between 1bp and 3bps. This is in the wake of yesterday’s ECB meeting where Madame Lagarde left policy on hold for the first time after eleven consecutive rate hikes, and tried to explain that they would be completely data dependent for the time being.  Not for nothing but the recent data from Europe looks pretty awful, so if that is the case, I would expect to see cuts on the horizon there.

Volatility continues apace in the oil market as well with yesterday’s decline followed by 1.5% rally this morning.  It seems that yesterday’s story about a potential de-escalation of the Israeli-Palestinian crisis was trumped by news that the US had bombed several sites in Syria in response to attacks on US bases in Iraq last week.  Ostensibly these sites are controlled by Iranian proxies indicating the possibility of a widening conflict in the Middle East.  I suspect that we are going to continue to see volatility here, but net, the structural issues remain beneficial for oil in my view.  As to gold, it is little changed this morning and simply maintaining its recent gains as fear continues to be a market driver right now.  Base metals were clearly cheered by the strong US data as both copper (+1.1%) and aluminum (+0.25%) are firmer this morning.

Looking at the dollar, it should be no surprise that it continues to perform well overall.  Between the risk issues and the strong economic data, the US certainly seems a better place to put your money than most others right now.  USDJPY continues to trade above 150 but is not running away and there is no indication the BOJ has been involved at all.  The euro keeps pushing toward 1.05 and the pound looks like it is headed down to 1.20 soon.  USDCNY is back near its recent highs as the perceived benefits of Chinese fiscal stimulus are not seen as yuan positives at this point, especially given the divergence between US and Chinese monetary policy.  It is very difficult, at this time, to come up with a reason for the dollar to decline in any substantial way.

On the data front, this morning brings Personal Income, (exp 0.4%), Personal Spending (0.5%), and the all-important Core PCE (0.3%, 3.7% Y/Y) with Michigan Sentiment (63.0) coming later at 10:00.  At this point, all eyes remain on the FOMC meeting next week where there is essentially no expectation of a rate move.  We would need to see a REALLY hot PCE number this morning to change that.  As such, I expect that a consolidation in risk markets is quite possible with little movement in the dollar overall.  Beware, however, if stocks sell off later today as that could be a tell that there is more pressure to come.  I clearly recall that the Friday before Black Monday in October 1987, stocks sold off aggressively, just not as aggressively as they did on the Monday!.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Many More Pains

Posted on by 
Reporting of real GDP
Is what most investors will see
But nominal data
Is what could create a
New narrative reality

Combining both growth and inflation
This number could be the foundation
For further yield gains
And many more pains
Inflicted on stock adoration

After another lousy day in the equity markets, today the first Q3 GDP data will be released.  The current consensus forecast is for a 4.3% gain while the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow number is up to 5.4%.  And that’s the real GDP (rGDP) number, which removes inflation from the discussion.  However, given all that is ongoing, it may be worthwhile to take a look at nominal GDP (nGDP), which is simply the change in total activity including price changes and economic output.  As you can see from the below graph (data source, FRED database), in the post-WWII era, we’ve had 10 periods where rGDP fell below zero, better known as recessions, but only 3 periods where nGDP was negative, with the GFC in 2009 being the worst at -2.0%.  The gap between the two lines is inflation, and you can also see how that has ebbed and flowed over time.

But turning to the current period, it is noteworthy that in the wake of the GFC, which was rightly called the worst financial crisis since the Great Depression and up through the Covid recession in 2020, nGDP had been pretty modest overall.  In fact, a quick look at the data shows that the average nGDP during that decade was just 3.4%.  This compares quite unfavorably with the long-term historical average of 6.4% since 1946.  Looking at rGDP data, the average between the GFC and Covid was just 1.8%, again comparing quite unfavorably to the long-term growth of 2.9%.

The thing is, we have all gotten quite used to that economic environment of slow growth and low inflation and there are many professional investors, let alone non-investment professionals, who believe that is the way the world works.  Well, let me tell you, that was the exception, not the rule.  Instead, if you look at the very right side of the chart, you can see that both nGDP and rGDP have risen sharply in the wake of the Covid recession as the deluge of fiscal spending combined with, first supply chain constraints and now reshoring/deglobalization efforts, has changed the framework.  In fact, I would contend that it is in the government’s best interest to continue down this path of high nominal growth and high inflation in order to try to outgrow the increase in debt.  After all, if nGDP can grow faster than the fiscal deficit, the real value of US debt will ultimately decline.  Of course, while it would be fantastic if the bulk of that high growth was a function of gains in productivity and high real growth, the FAR more likely outcome will be persistent high inflation.

What does this mean for markets?  As we have seen over the past several sessions, equities can quickly come under pressure in this scenario, and I believe they have further to decline.  While top-line revenues can continue to grow, the problem will come from a market that is going to derate the market multiple, especially in the tech sector, from its current nosebleed levels.  High inflation will also continue to press on bond prices and the value of the long-term 60/40 portfolio is likely to continue to be eroded.  In my view, the best place to hide will be in commodities as during inflationary periods, they tend to hold their value.

An anecdote from my early days in trading is that bond traders used to believe that the “natural” yield for 10-year Treasuries was right around nGDP.  If yields rose above that level, bonds were probably a buy, and below that level, they would have a short bias.  Nominal GDP for the past two years has been 10.7% in 2021 and 9.1% in 2022.  On this basis, there is considerably further for bond prices to fall and yields to rise.  Something to keep in mind as the talking heads work to convince you to catch the falling knife that is the bond market.

Ok, so how have things behaved ahead of today’s data, and ahead of the ECB’s rate decision this morning?  Equity markets around the world have been under pressure with the Nikkei (-2.1%) leading the way as most regional markets fell sharply, notably in South Korea and Taiwan, although Chinese shares held their own on the back of still more stimulus promised by the government there.  It is clear that President Xi is growing increasingly worried about the financial situation at home.  In Europe, we are also seeing weakness, with red across the screen on the order of -1.0% or more and US futures are also pointing lower at this hour (7:30) down by -0.75% or so across the board.

Bond markets are little changed this morning with most seeing yields creep very slightly higher, maybe 1bp or so, but that is after another bond sell-off yesterday which saw Treasury yields continue their rebound from Monday’s sharp drop.  As I type, we are back at 4.97% on the 10-year and the curve inversion is down to -15bps.  As an FYI, the 2yr-30yr curve is back to flat now and I expect it is only a matter of days before the 2yr-10yr is there as well.  Yesterday’s 5yr auction was particularly poorly received with a very wide tail and concern is growing that will be the case for all coupon auctions going forward.  Yields are heading higher folks.

Oil prices are falling this morning, down -1.8%, which has basically reversed yesterday’s rally.  EIA data showed inventory builds and it seems the longer Israel holds off on its ground invasion of Gaza, the more people are willing to believe that there will be no escalation.  However, gold prices continue to rally, up another 0.4% this morning and getting ever closer to the $2000/oz level.  Meanwhile, this morning, ahead of the GDP data, both copper and aluminum are in good spirits and rising.

Finally, the dollar is clearly back in the ascendancy with USDJPY finally breaking through that 150.00 level with no sign of intervention yet, while the euro is pressing back toward 1.05 and the pound is below 1.21.  We are seeing strength across the board for the greenback, against both G10 and EMG currencies as the yield story continues to be the driver.  As to the ECB today, expectations are for no change in policy, and the real question will be whether Madame Lagarde can maintain a hawkish bias, or if the obvious weakening in the data will reveal her inherent dovishness.  If it is the latter, look for the euro to break below 1.05 before tomorrow’s close.

In addition to the rGDP data (exp 4.3%), we see Initial (208K) and Continuing (1740K) Claims as well as Durable Goods (1.7%, 0.2% ex transports).  The ECB Press conference starts at 8:45 and will be carefully watched.  Yesterday’s New Home Sales data was much stronger than expected and the BOC left rates on hold with a hawkish commentary, although the CAD was unable to gain much in the wake.  The world continues to point to higher yields to fight structural inflationary pressures.  At the same time, the dollar will retain its status and remains in demand.  While it may not rally that sharply, I see very little case for any substantive weakness in the near and medium term.

Good luck

Adf

Bad Dreams

Posted on by 
In China, the property bubble
Continues to cause Xi much trouble
So, they will add on
A trillion more yuan
Of debt, as help efforts redouble

And though Chinese markets did rise
They finished well off of their highs
Investors, it seems
Are having bad dreams
‘bout growth there and seek to downsize

Poor President Xi!  Instead of focusing all his energy on his saber rattling in the South China Sea and hinting at a Taiwanese invasion, he finds himself essentially forced to deal with the economy.  This was made clear yesterday when he made a surprise visit to both the PBOC and the SAFE (State Administration of Foreign Exchange), the two top Chinese financial institutions, and then today when the government announced an effective supplemental budget spend of CNY 1 trillion (~$137 billion) to support further infrastructure investment in the country.  

This move will increase the national government’s budget deficit for the year to 3.8%, well above the 3.0% target they had been shooting for, but obviously, the concern of continuing slow growth is being seen as a growing problem for Xi.  This is also a change from the previous process where local governments would issue debt to fund infrastructure investment and ultimately repaid that debt by selling land.  Of course, that is what led to the inflation of the massive property bubble in China, so that model is now clearly broken.

Arguably, the biggest worry is that if the domestic situation continues to deteriorate, Xi will get more adventuresome internationally as the standard national leadership political playbook is to seek to distract the population from the economic failures of a government by stoking nationalism and instigating conflict overseas.  We just saw it in Russia, and quite frankly, given the support for intensifying the war effort in the US, it is also being executed here in the US.

In the end, though, a 0.8% of GDP budget boost is unlikely to have a huge impact on the economy.  The problem the Chinese have is that they, too, have a very high debt level and are trying quite diligently to prevent it from growing out of hand.  The tradeoff there is that the amount of support is going to be restricted.  Initial economist estimates are that the package will raise GDP growth by 0.1% in Q4 and up to 0.5% in 2024 overall.  

It can be no surprise that shares in China rose on the news with the Hang Seng jumping 2.5% on the news while the CSI 300 jumped 1.3% initially.  However, both faded fast and closed higher by about 0.5%, not bad, but certainly not a huge vote of confidence.  Meanwhile, the yuan just continued is weak performance, falling another 0.2% and continuing to push against its 2% band vs. the daily CFETS fixing.

Away from that news, however, it has been dullsville this morning with pretty modest movement across both equity and bond markets around the world.  Yesterday’s PMI data indicated that the massive amount of fiscal stimulus that has been enacted in the US compared to elsewhere in the world is having the desired impact, at least from a statistical point of view, as US data continues to show relative strength compared to Europe, Japan and the rest of the G10.  However, despite those efforts, the political accolades remain absent as the national attitude is consistently measured in downbeat terms. 

And consider, if the data here are relatively better and the government is not gaining any ground, how bad it is for governments elsewhere in the world where the data is clearly worse and falling.  We continue to see populist parties from both sides of the aisle gaining in strength.  Do not be surprised to see quite a few new governments around the world over the next several years as support for incumbents continues to fall.  (It will be quite interesting to see the results of the Argentine election in a few weeks and see how Javier Milei, the upstart “anarcho-capitalist” who has promised to take a chainsaw to the government and shutter the central bank while dollarizing the economy, performs.)  A victory there could well be a harbinger of future shakeups everywhere.

Turning to markets, yesterday’s solid US performance was ultimately followed by 0.5% ish gains in China and Japan, although weaker performances elsewhere in Asia with a number of regional markets declining.  European bourses are showing very modest gains this morning, on the order of 0.1% while US futures are mostly softer at this hour (8:00), down roughly -0.4%.

The massive reversal in bonds seen on Monday is now history and we are seeing yields begin to creep back higher with Treasury yields up 3bps and similar rises throughout Europe, although Italian BTPs are the true laggard with yields there rising 6bps.  JGB yields also rose 2bps last night but have been largely capped at 0.85% by the market as there was no sign of extra intervention by the BOJ.  The yield curve inversion remains at -24bps, not quite at its tightest levels but still clearly trending toward normalization.

One thing to consider about the Treasury market is the fact that the US trade deficit has been steadily shrinking amidst the efforts at reshoring and all the CHIPS act spending on manufacturing capacity, as well as the simple fact that US energy exports continue to be quite robust.  The point is that one of the key demands for Treasury bonds in the past was the recycling of all those deficits, but if the deficits shrink, then there is less to recycle and therefore less demand for Treasuries.  Combine this process with the fact that the government continues to increase the amount of issuance and it is not hard to conclude that bond yields have further to rise over time.  The fact that an oversold market responded to a major psychological level does not mean the bond market move has ended.  Rather I would argue it has simply paused and yields will once again climb going forward.

Turning to the commodity markets, oil is marginally higher this morning, up 0.3%, but that is after another sharp decline yesterday as the market appears to believe that the odds of a widening of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict are shrinking amid growing pressure from organizations around the world.  Add to that the signs of weaker economic activity which implies reduced demand, and it is easy to understand why oil has retraced. However, inventories fell again last week, and the structural issues of supply remain in place.  The big picture remains for further strength over time in my eyes.  As to the metals markets, gold continues to benefit from its haven status, edging higher by 0.25% this morning while copper is suffering on the weaker growth story, falling -0.4%.

Finally, the dollar is stronger overall with the euro > 1% lower than its recent highs Monday afternoon which were seen in the wake of the bond market rally that day.  USDJPY is right back below 150.00 although it has not yet touched the level since early this month which was followed by what appeared to be intervention.  But generally, we are seeing the dollar gain against both G10 and EMG rivals as US rates once again edge higher, 2yrs as well as 10yrs.

On the data front today, New Home Sales (exp 680K) are due at 10:00 as well as the Bank of Canada rate decision where no change is expected.  We also see EIA oil inventory data later this morning and then Chairman Powell speaks late this afternoon.  I continue to believe it is unlikely that he will add anything to his message from last week.  As such, it is a status quo day.  If yields continue higher, look for the dollar to follow.  But I have a feeling that there will be very little movement today overall.

Good luck

Adf

Waved Adios

Posted on by 
There once were two gents, both named Bill
Whose market views oft could be shrill
Now Ackman and Gross
Have waved adios
To shorts, with positions now nil

When others all learned of this action
The bond market really gained traction
So, does five percent
In truth, represent
The highs? Or is this a distraction?

It ought to be no surprise that the bond market had a significant hiccup yesterday after the 10-year yield finally breached the 5.0% level for the first time in more than 15 years given the market’s penchant to focus on big round numbers.  However, as can be seen in the chart below, the response by traders and investors was dramatic as it appears many were waiting for that level to ‘buy the dip’ in bonds.  As such, after climbing to a high of 5.025%, the market reversed sharply with yields falling nearly 20bps at one point, although they closed slightly off the lows.

Source: Tradingeconomics.com

Ostensibly, a key driver of this move was a Tweet by hedge fund manager Bill Ackman explaining he had covered his bond short positions.  “We covered our bond short.  There is too much risk in the world to remain short bonds at current long-term rates. The economy is slowing faster than recent data suggests.”  Similarly, former bond king, Bill Gross, tweeted that he was buying bonds across the curve after calling for a recession in the 4th quarter (that’s now!).  And that’s all it took to reverse a substantial portion of the recent sell-off in Treasuries.  Perhaps more interesting was the fact that the ongoing normalization of the yield curve was not impacted much at all.  Yesterday, the 2yr-10yr spread had fallen to -18bps and this morning it is -22bps, so not all that different.

The question, of course, is what can we expect going forward?  The thing that continues to bother me is the ongoing supply question, and at what price will the Treasury be able to sell new bonds to price sensitive buyers rather than the Fed.  Nothing has changed that part of the equation and until the Fed ends QT, let alone restarts QE (which I do expect at some point in the future), I continue to believe bond yields will trend higher.  And this view considers the fact that some further economic slowing seems highly probable to me.  However, the supply issue is going to continue to be the dominant feature going forward.

One other issue is the ongoing Israeli-Palestinian conflict and how that could evolve, with many talking heads concerned that growth in that conflict will result in demand for more safety.  Certainly, the gold price has been a huge beneficiary of that situation with the barbarous relic having gained more than $120/oz in price since the attack while bond yields are actually higher by 6bps, even after yesterday’s sharp decline in yields.  However, my experience indicates that after the immediacy of any conflagration, whether Russia in Ukraine, or even 9/11, market behavior tends to move off that narrative and back to whatever was deemed relevant before the news.  I see no reason for this to be different, and before the attack, yields were rising on the supply story and robustness of the US economy.  That is the narrative that needs to change to reverse bond yields.

So, is there going to be a change in that narrative soon?  Well, depending on one’s view of the value of PMI data, the flash releases this morning were all pretty crummy with all of Europe and the UK remaining below the key 50.0 level and last night’s Australian and Japanese data also quite weak, although Japanese Services data did manage to hold above the 50.0 level.  As well, German GfK Consumer Confidence fell to -28.1, down from last month and below consensus expectations, so perhaps some economic weakness is coming our way.  

However, first, those are not US numbers and second, the US data has consistently shown hard data (NFP, Retail Sales, IP, etc.) firmer than any of the survey data.  So, while there continues to be gloom and doom on people’s minds, their actions have not yet matched those views.  Now, a case can certainly be made that the US hard data is all lagging and the current situation is far worse than those numbers imply, but the Fed is not going to respond to that story.  As long as the hard data offers cover for the Fed to maintain their current policy stance as they fight inflation, they are going to do so.  

Summing it all up leads me to believe that nothing has changed the big picture.  While yesterday’s bond move was certainly exciting, the fact that one hedge fund manager took profits is not enough to change the investment landscape.  I continue to expect stickier inflation going forward as well as a grind higher in 10yr yields as the curve normalizes.  

So, how did markets respond to all the new information?  Well, after a mixed day in the US yesterday, we saw a similar picture in Asia with the Hang Seng falling -1.0%, but most other markets edging a bit higher.  European bourses are slightly firmer this morning, but really no great shakes and US futures at this hour (8:30) are firmer by 0.6% or so.  Fear is not that evident today.

On the bond side, this morning has seen a modest bounce in US yields, just 2bps, but we are seeing a continuation lower in Europe with most sovereigns seeing yields fall about 2bps.  JGBs have also edged away from their recent high in yields, although that was after the BOJ had yet another unscheduled bond buying session, this one the largest of the five unscheduled ones so far implemented after they adjusted the YCC cap to 1.00%.  

On the commodity front, oil is essentially unchanged this morning although that is after a sharp decline yesterday which wiped out the previous week’s gains.  Gold, while still holding up reasonably well, is softer by -0.4% this morning and copper is bucking this trend, rising 0.6%, although still hovering just above 1yr lows.

Finally, the dollar, which fell yesterday a bit as yields decline sharply in the US, is bouncing this morning with the euro sliding back toward 1.06 and the DXY back at 106.00.  Neither JPY nor CNY really responded to yesterday’s price action, it was mostly European currencies doing the damage to the buck.  One thing to note is the question of whether the 10-year yield is still a key driver of the dollar or is it something else?  Brent Donnelly, a well-respected FX analyst, has an excellent article out discussing how the dollar appears to be more linked to the 2-year yield than the 10-year.  I had mentioned last week how that relationship between the dollar and yields seemed to be breaking down and his analysis shows that if you look at the 2yr yield, which hasn’t moved much at all compared to the 10yr lately, it makes more sense.  It is well worth the read.

With that in mind, then perhaps the dollar’s strength is unlikely to manifest itself as it did while the Fed was aggressively raising rates earlier in the year and 2yr yields were rising rapidly.  Instead, it is quite possible we are in for a period of relative quietude in the dollar, at least against the majors.  Emerging market currencies have a clear life of their own, and hedging decisions there need to be independent of views on the euro or pound.

On the data front, the Flash PMI’s are due here as well (exp 49.5 Manufacturing, 49.8 Services) and then the first look at oil inventories late this afternoon.  Interestingly, despite the Fed’s ostensible quiet period, Chairman Powell will be making Introductory Remarks at the 2023 Moynihan Lecture in Social Science and Public Policy tomorrow at 4:30pm.  Given the quiet concept, I find it difficult to believe he will focus on monetary policy but be aware.

All signs point to a quieter session today and perhaps for a while going forward, at least in the G10 currencies.  However, hedging is always a good idea!

Good luck

Adf