Category Archives: Uncategorized

Soothsay

Posted on by

On Monday, we heard the first five
Fed speakers, as all of them strive
To make a clear case
As why there’s no place
For cuts, lest they see a crash-dive
 
Amazingly, later today
We’ll hear seven others soothsay
Inflation’s still falling
Although it was stalling
Last quarter, much to our dismay

 

As Queen Gertrude noted in Shakespeare’s Hamlet, “The lady doth protest too much, methinks.” This is the first thing that comes to mind as we face yet another seven Fed speakers today (at eight venues, Mr Bostic will speak twice) in their effort to effectively communicate their current strategy, whatever that may be.  The very fact that we will have heard from a dozen of the nineteen FOMC members in the first two days of the week implies to me that the FOMC has absolutely no confidence that market participants are on the same page as they are.

My first observation is they really don’t have any idea what to do to achieve their goals.  Whatever their models are telling them, it is not aligned with the reality on the ground around the nation.  This is the most benign explanation I can see for their actions.  History has shown that the Fed PhD’s all believe very strongly in their models and when the models don’t accurately describe the economy, their first instinct is that the economy is wrong and that the people who make up the economy are not behaving properly because they don’t understand the beauty of the models and why the model should be correct.  This is akin to the government complaining that things are great and those who say otherwise just don’t understand things well enough.  Not surprisingly, this leads to overcommunication as the in-house view is the messaging is the problem, not the reality.

A less benign view is that they are politicking quite hard to ensure that the current administration is re-elected because they have a significant fear of a change of control at the White House.  As such, they believe that a constant drumbeat of ‘things are going to get better, and we are doing a great job’ will allay any fears that the current administration’s policies have resulted in the inflation that has been the main feature of the nation’s very clear unhappiness.

Perhaps the thing I understand less, though, is why any market participants even care about what Fed speakers say right now.  After all, yesterday’s comments were so closely aligned that a single speech would have sufficed.  I am quite certain that today’s messages will be similarly aligned both amongst themselves and with yesterday’s message.  The one thing that is very clear is that Chairman Powell has them all singing from the same hymnal.

And for those of you who have not been paying close attention, the message, in a nutshell, is that Q1 inflation was disappointingly high and so while April’s data was a bit better, they still do not have confidence that inflation is going to quickly head back to their 2% target so will maintain the current, restrictive, policy for as long as necessary.  It strikes me as unnecessary to have a dozen FOMC members repeat this message in a short period of time.

At any rate, given the remarkable lack of new information, other than the Fedspeak, which as I explain above is hardly new, let’s look at the markets overnight.  Yesterday’s US equity markets mixed performance was followed by weakness throughout Asia with Japan (-0.3%) slightly lower and Hong Kong (-2.1%) sharply lower and a lot more red than green throughout the region.  Of course, given the recent rally we have seen, it is not that surprising to see some consolidation.  European bourses are all lower this morning with losses ranging from Spain (-0.25%) to France (-1.0%) and everything in between.  There has been precious little new information here either, so again, given most of these indices are near record highs, some consolidation is inevitable.  Finally, US futures are little changed at this hour (7:30) as the market awaits idiosyncratic news for individual stocks as well as Nvidia earnings later this week.

In the bond market, quiet is the name of the game with Treasury yields edging lower by 2bps this morning, but really, just back to where they were yesterday morning.  Across Europe, the sovereign market is mixed with Switzerland (+3bps) the worst performer and the UK (-2bps) the best but most markets unchanged on the day.  Unchanged also describes the Asian session as JGB yields didn’t budge.

In the commodity markets, oil (-1.5%) is under pressure this morning, following yesterday’s modest declines as clearly there are no concerns over the situation in Iran regarding the death of the president there yesterday.  As to the metals markets, which in fairness have been FAR more exciting, more record highs yesterday are seeing a bit of consolidation this morning, although the declines in precious, (both Au and Ag -0.25%) are modest.  However, copper (+0.7%) knows no top as it continues to rally on the growing understanding that there is a long-term supply/demand mismatch, and it will be a sellers’ market going forward.

Finally, the dollar is basically unchanged this morning as while it has fallen from the recent highs at the beginning of the month (DXY at 106.40), there is very little follow through selling of the dollar now that US yields have stopped declining.  Recall, Treasury yields are lower by about 25bps in the same period but have stopped their decline as well.  The largest movers overnight have been KRW (-0.3%), which suffered after a weaker than expected Consumer Confidence reading and NOK (+0.3%) which is odd given oil’s recent weakness but absent any other related news.  Sometimes, markets simply move.

And that’s all there is today.  The Fedspeak starts at 9:00 with Richmond’s Thomas Barkin and Governor Chris Waller at separate venues, and last all day into the evening when Bostic, Collins and Mester speak at 7:00pm.  My money is on the idea that there will be nothing new learned from any of them.

As such, we remain in a holding pattern, I think.  US rates are finding a home around 4.4% and the dollar index at 104.50 seems pretty comfortable as well.  While later in the week we start to see some new information, I fear that until next week’s PCE data, we could well be stuck in a pretty narrow range.

Good luck

Adf

None Be Unique

Posted on by

When looking ahead to this week
The noteworthy thing is Fedspeak
At least fifteen times
They’ll give us their dimes’
Worth of knowledge, though none be unique
 
For instance, we already know
Their confidence is rather low
So, absent new data
Do they have schemata
Designed to get ‘flation to slow?

 

Arguably, the biggest news this morning is the death of the Iranian President and Foreign Minister in a helicopter crash overnight as it opens a range of possibilities regarding the future stance of Iran in the Middle East.  Will it remain the strict theocracy that it has been?  Or will a new leadership recognize the people appear to be growing tired of that stance and want something different.  While it would seem unlikely that there will be a major change, at least from this view thousands of miles away, if one were to come about, it would have a major impact on the Middle East and the ongoing conflict in Gaza.  After all, if Iran stopped funding terrorist groups, that would de-escalate things dramatically and potentially see a significant decline in the price of oil.  At this time, however, there is no information as to who will step into the role and what policies will be followed, so it is a wait-and-see period.  As it happens, oil prices (-0.35%) have edged lower this morning, but this is hardly a sign of anything new.  This will be quite critical to watch going forward.

However, beyond that, there has been vanishingly little new information about which to speak regarding the macroeconomic situation around the world.  The Chinese left their policy rates unchanged, as universally expected, and there has literally not been any other data from any major nation since Friday.  In fact, looking ahead at the calendar for the week, arguably the most significant piece of data to be released is Canadian CPI, or perhaps UK CPI and then on Friday we see the Flash PMI reports. 

Which brings us back to the Fedspeak.  It is staggering to think that the FOMC believes they need to be so visible at this time, especially after Chairman Powell explained that rate hikes were off the table and that while it may take a little longer than they had initially expected, they were still certain that inflation was going to head back to their 2% target.

Speaking of inflation, over the weekend I was reading some analysis (sad, I know) that highlighted if the US used the European HICP calculation the core reading would already be below their target with April’s data coming in at 1.9%.  To me this is a similar stance to what we heard at the end of 2023 when numerous pundits were explaining that the 3-month trend or the 6-month trend was already at 2.0% so why wait to cut?  Of course, the sticky inflation camp (this poet included) was quick to hoist them on their own petard as the recent 3-month and 6-month trends are pointing to 4+% CPI readings going forward.  

In this particular instance the question I would ask is, other than the fact that the reading is lower, why would anyone think that the European HICP inflation reading is a more accurate representation than the BLS representation?  The difference lies in the fact that HICP doesn’t incorporate housing price changes, which given they remain stubbornly high, have been supporting higher CPI readings.  But don’t people pay for their housing?  Certainly, it would be easy to create a lower CPI if you simply remove all the items that are going higher in price.  Unfortunately, that process doesn’t really tell you anything about reality.

Below is a very interesting chart I found on X (nee Twitter) created by Professor Alberto Cavallo of Harvard and Oleksiy Kryvtsov, a Bank of Canada economist, which may be a better description of inflation as felt by the average person.

The fact that prices are rising fastest for the least expensive goods indicates that inflation is a major problem for Joe Sixpack, and no matter how pundits seek to adjust the measurement, so the numbers look better, reality is a harsh mistress.  (If you want to know why President Biden’s numbers are so bad, you needn’t look further than this chart.)  

Alas, there is no escaping the plethora of blather that will be coming from the Fed this week, although I sincerely doubt any of it will change anyone’s opinions about anything.  Ok, it was another generally quiet session overnight with the exception being the ongoing blast higher in metals markets.

Equity markets have performed well across the board, although the gains have not been too dramatic.  Japan (Nikkei +0.7%) was the best performer although the entire region was in the green to a lesser extent, about 0.35% or so.  In Europe, all the bourses are higher as well, but here the gains are even smaller, on the order of +0.25% across the board while US futures are essentially unchanged at this hour (6:30).

In the bond market, Treasury yields, which backed up 2bps on Friday are unchanged this morning while European sovereigns are higher by roughly 1bp across the board.  ECB speakers have conceded that a rate cut is coming in June, but many are pushing back hard against the idea that a July cut is a sure thing, preferring to wait until September.  However, the really interesting thing is in Japan, where JGB yields have traded up to 0.98%, a new high yield for this move and a level not seen since March 2012.  At this point, it would seem that 1.00% is a foregone conclusion so it will be interesting to see how the BOJ responds when that ‘magic’ number is finally traded.

But, as I mentioned above, it is a metals day with gold (+0.9%), silver (+1.1%) and copper (+0.9%) all continuing last week’s strong gains with gold making yet further new highs, copper pushing its historic highs and silver breaking above a key technical resistance level at $30/oz last week and now extending those gains.  While there have been many explanations for this price movement, I think you need to consider precious and industrial metals separately.  For precious, there continues to be a growing concern in the ongoing debasement of the fiat currency universe and both individuals and central banks are seeking to hold alternative assets.  On the industrial side, though, especially copper and silver which are both critical to electronics, the ten-year hiatus in investment due to the ESG cult combined with the recent recognition that all the new-fangled tech wizardry like AI is going to require gobs of power and electrical capacity has simply skewed the supply/demand curve to much more demand than supply.

Finally, the dollar is little changed this morning, pretty much at the same level overall since Thursday.  Given the lack of movement in the rates space, this ought not be a surprise.  It also ought not be surprising that the best performing currencies of the past week have been CLP (+3.5%) as it has simply traveled alongside its major export, copper, and ZAR (+5.1%) as it rallies alongside the precious metals complex.  Meanwhile, there has been no movement in the interest rate narrative with, perhaps, the exception of Japan, but what we have learned there lately is that higher JGB yields lead to a weaker yen.  Go figure!

On the data front, as I said earlier, it is extremely light this week,

WednesdayExisting Home Sales4.22M
 FOMC Minutes 
ThursdayInitial Claims220K
 Continuing Claims1799K
 New Home Sales680K
FridayDurable Goods-0.7%
 -ex Transport0.1%
 Michigan Sentiment67.6
Source: tradingeconomics.com

It is not clear, given how much we have already heard from Fed speakers since the last FOMC meeting, that the Minutes will be very informative.  Perhaps the discussion about QT will change some minds, but I doubt it.  Otherwise, if stocks continue to rally, market players will be happy and not try to rock the boat.  Meanwhile, the dollar will need a new impetus to break out of this narrow range, but that may not come until next month’s NFP data.

Good luck

Adf

Naught to be Gained

Posted on by 
It now seems inflation has stalled
Which has bond investors enthralled
But Fedspeak explained
There’s naught to be gained
By cutting ere its, further, falled

Meanwhile, data China released
Showed Retail Sales nearly deceased
But factories still
Produce stuff at will
Thus, exports have widely increased

It has been quite a week with respect to the data that has been released as well as regards the ongoing commentary onslaught from central bank speakers around the world.  A quick recap shows that market participants have decided they know what is going to happen in the future (the Fed is going to start cutting rates and continue doing so) while every member of the Fed who has spoken has claimed just the opposite, that there is no reason for the Fed to adjust policy at this time given the still too high inflation readings and the seeming appearance of ongoing economic strength.  I continue to marvel at the ‘narrative’ which for 15 years warned, ‘don’t fight the Fed’ which was in its historic process of driving rates to and maintaining them at essentially 0.00%.  And yet now, those very same pundits listen to every Fed speaker with bated breath and conclude that despite their insistence that rate cuts are not coming anytime soon, rate cuts are just around the corner so ignore the Fed and buy risk assets.

My observations on this conundrum are that first, the market is much bigger than the Fed or any central bank or even all the central banks put together.  So, if the market is of the mind to continue to add risk to their portfolios for whatever reason, risky assets will increase in price.  However, the central banks are not irrelevant to the process as they do control short-term interest rates (aka funding costs) directly and can have great sway on long-term interest rates through both commentary and the ability to intervene in those markets a la QE or QT.  In other words, the battle has been joined and while I expect the market will ultimately go wherever it wants to, the central banks will have something to say about the path taken to get there.  So, do not be surprised if there are some downdrafts along the way to higher prices.

Remember, too, that central banks have a great deal to do with creating inflation, not merely fighting it, and if they continue to add money and liquidity to both the economy and markets, the real value of assets will not climb nearly so far and could well decline.  While this is an age-old battle, arguably having been ongoing since the first central banks were created in the 1700’s, it does have the feeling as though we are coming to a point in time where things could get out of hand in the near future.  Perhaps not Weimar Republic out of hand, but certainly 1970’s stagflation out of hand.

Turning to the only real news overnight, Chinese data was released and the dichotomy in the Chinese economy continues to be evident to one and all.  While IP printed at a better than expected 6.7%, highlighting that Chinese factories are humming, Retail Sales fell to a 2.3% Y/Y reading, far below both last month and expectations.  In other words, while China continues to build lots of stuff, it is all for export as the domestic population is not in the mood to buy.  This has led to two consequences of note.  The first is that as the Chinese trade balance continues to expand, we have seen, and will likely see more, tariffs imposed by destination markets like Europe and the US thus straining economic ties further.  Too, this is in direct opposition to the idea of reshoring of manufacturing which continues to be the political goal throughout the West.

The second impact is that President Xi has clearly recognized that a major impediment to further Chinese economic growth is the ongoing disaster otherwise known as the Chinese property market.  This is the driving force behind the recent efforts to support things via government purchase of unfinished and unsold homes with the goal of those being converted into public housing. 

Alas, there are a few problems with this plan which may hinder a smooth application of the idea.  The first problem is that the reason these homes are unfinished or unsold is that the developers have run out of money or cannot sell them at a profit.  In other words, somebody needs to take some big losses and absent a directive from Beijing I assure you none of the developers will willingly do so.  The proposed fixes of reducing the minimum mortgage rate and size of the down payment necessary to purchase a home may help at the margin but will not solve the problem.  The problem is that the losses likely approach $1 trillion, a large amount for even the national government, and so finding those who can afford to absorb those losses is a difficult task.  Certainly, some of the state-owned banks will be in the spotlight here, but they are already insolvent (if one takes a realistic look at their non-performing loans) so don’t have that much capacity to do more. 

The critical feature here is that more time is needed for companies and banks to grow via their other businesses such that they can eventually absorb those losses.  But time is not on Xi’s side here.  All told, the underlying situation in China remains fraught, in my view, and so must be viewed with care.  While the PBOC is clearly willing to prevent the renminbi from collapsing, such an unbalanced economy is going to display a great deal of volatility going forward.

Ok, did markets do anything interesting overnight?  In truth, not really.  After yesterday’s modest declines in the US equity markets, Asian markets were mixed with Japan, Australia, Korea and Taiwan all under pressure while Chinese and Hong Kong shares rallied sharply on the back of the property proposals.  This morning, European bourses are mostly a bit softer as it seems that while a June rate cut is baked in, there has been significant push-back against a following cut in July, a story which had gained great credence lately.  Meanwhile, at this hour (6;45) US futures are ever so slightly lower, -0.1% across the board.

In the bond markets, after the post CPI yield decline in the US on Wednesday, yields have been backing up since their nadir and are now nearly 8bps higher from the bottom with 2bps this morning’s contribution.  European yields have shown similar price action, falling through Wednesday evening and bouncing since then.  As to the JGB market, yields there have backed up a bit as well, now trading at 0.95%, but have not yet been able to touch the big 1.00% level.  The irony is that USDJPY has been trading in sync with JGB yields, so as they climb, so does the dollar!  That is not what the narrative had in mind; I assure you!

In the commodity space, oil is little changed this morning but that is after rallying $1 during yesterday’s session as the market absorbed the larger than expected draw in inventories described on Wednesday.  As well, the idea that the Fed is soon going to cut rates and stimulate economic activity has pushed bullishness on the demand side.  As to the metals markets, they are edging higher again this morning with copper seeming to consolidate after its rocket higher and collapse earlier this week.  Adding to the copper story is that Goldman Sachs commodity analyst, Jeff Currie, said he was more bullish on copper than anything else during his career!  Based on my view that debasement of currencies remains a key feature of the current monetary regime globally, I expect metals to continue to rise as well.

Finally, the dollar continues to rebound from its lows seen Wednesday night late with the DXY having regained 0.8% since the bottom and the greenback higher versus nearly every one of its counterparts this morning.  I believe the dollar story remains closely tied to the Fed for now, and as long as the Fed maintains that rate cuts are a distant prospect, at best, it will retain its value.

The only data release this morning is Leading Indicators (exp -0.3%) which has been in negative territory for nearly two years and still no recession.  We also hear from Governor Waller, but all four Fed speakers yesterday were consistent that they do not yet have confidence inflation is falling to target and so higher for longer remains the base case.

It has been a volatile week and I expect that today will see far less activity as the lack of critical data and the fact that traders are tired from all the activity so far this week will lead to many leaving for an early weekend.  But the big trends remain intact, a higher for longer Fed will help support the dollar while the narrative will not be dissuaded and continue to buy risk assets.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Losing His Doubt

Posted on by 
The jury is no longer out
And Jay may be losing his doubt
That ‘flation is slowing
So, bulls are now crowing
Let’s end, soon, this rate-cutting drought!

I am old enough to remember when Chairman Powell explained that he did not have confidence inflation was falling back to the target level and so maintaining the current, somewhat restrictive, policy stance would be appropriate for longer than had been originally anticipated.  In other words, higher for longer was still the operating thesis.  That is soooo two days ago!  Apparently, when CPI prints at 0.3% M/M for both headline and core with the Y/Y readings at 3.4% and 3.6% respectively, that means the inflation fight is won.  Now, I will grant that the headline monthly number was 0.1% below expectations, but everything else was right on the money.  On the surface, it is not clear to me that this signaled the all-clear for the end of inflation.  As my good friend Mike Ashton (@inflation_guy) said in his write-up yesterday, “the sticky stuff is not yet unstuck.”  But the market saw this news and combined with a clearly weaker than expected Retail Sales print (0.0%) and weaker than expected Empire State Manufacturing print (-15.6) and was off to the races.

So, risk is back in vogue and bond yields are tumbling.  Hooray!  This is the perfect encapsulation of how the actual data may not mean very much per se, but the framework of how investors and traders were positioned and anticipating the data is the key driving force.  So, not only did equity markets in the US rally 1% or more, but Treasury yields fell 10bps in the 10yr and 8bps in the 2yr.  Meanwhile, September is now the odds-on favorite for the first interest rate cut, politics be damned.

At this point, the question becomes will the Fed respond to this small sample of data in the same way the market has?  The first comments from Fed speakers seemed more circumspect than the market opinions.  Chicago Fed president Goolsbee, who was not on the calendar, said the following in an interview, “[inflation showed] some improvement from last time, pretty much what we expected, but still higher than we were running for the second half of last year, so there’s still room for improvement.”  Meanwhile, Minneapolis Fed president Kashkari explained, “The biggest uncertainty in my mind is how much downward pressure is monetary policy putting on the economy? That’s an unknown. And that tells me we probably need to sit here for a while longer until we figure out where underlying inflation is headed before we jump to any conclusions.”

To my eye, there is no indication that the Fed has changed their tune, at least not yet.  If we continue to see data that indicates the long-awaited recession is actually closing in, I expect that we will begin to hear more of a consensus view regarding the initial rate cuts other than the current higher for longer stance.  Of course, if a recession is making an appearance, my sense is that will not be a huge benefit for risk assets either, but what do I know, I’m just a poet. Ok, I don’t think we need to spend any more time on that subject for today so let’s see what is happening elsewhere. 

In Japan, the economic news remains less positive than the Kishida administration would like to see.  Last night, Q1 GDP was released at a worse than expected -0.5%, its second negative print in the past three quarters with Q4 a ‘robust’ 0.0% in between.  While not technically a recession, the situation there certainly does not have a positive feel.  Making things even worse, of course, is the fact that inflation remains higher than their target of 2%, although it has been slowly drifting lower over the past year. 

The interesting thing about this situation is that the BOJ does not have a dual mandate regarding prices and employment; but is focused only on price stability.  However, if economic activity continues to slow there, can Ueda-san really tighten policy further?  And what of the yen?  It has drifted higher (dollar lower) alongside the dollar’s broad down move on the back of the recent decline in US yields.  However, it feels to me like Ueda’s path to tighter policy just got a lot narrower if economic activity in Japan is going to remain so lackluster.  Many pundits have decided that the yen’s weakness reached its peak ahead of the recent bout of intervention two weeks ago.  I am not so sure.  Absent a significant slowdown in the US, I’m sensing that the policy divergence may even widen going forward, not narrow, and the yen would not respond well to that outcome.

With all that in mind, let’s survey the overnight session to see what else is happening.  Asian equity markets followed the US rally with solid gains across the board.  Clearly, the prospect of lower US rates was seen as a positive.  However, the same is not true in Europe, where bourses are all lower this morning albeit not dramatically so.  Declines of between -0.25% and -0.5% are universal.  My take is that this is a bout of profit-taking as to much less fanfare than US markets, many European bourses have just touched all-time high levels, so a little pullback should be no surprise.  This is especially true given there was neither data nor commentary that would indicate something in Europe has changed.  The situation remains slow growth, slowing inflation and rate cuts next month.  Lastly, US futures are essentially unchanged at this hour (6:45) as traders await more data and, perhaps more importantly, 4 more Fed speakers.  I think the trading community is looking for Fed confirmation of their response to the CPI data yesterday which, as mentioned above, was not forthcoming.

Bond markets, which all rallied yesterday following the Treasury move, are little changed this morning with virtually no movement in the US or Europe.  Overnight, JGB yields slipped 3bps in the wake of the US data, but this market is entirely focused on the US economy and the Treasury marker for its lead.

In the commodity markets, oil is a touch softer this morning, but remains firmly toward the middle of its recent trading range as conflicting reports regarding expected demand continue to confuse practitioners.  FWIW any report that indicates demand for oil is going to decrease makes no sense to me given how many people on this earth are energy poor and will do as much as they can to get hold of energy.  But that’s just my view.  The IEA continues to forecast reductions in demand because they are desperately pushing their transition thesis because their models are old and unreliable.  As to metals markets, yesterday saw a major rally in gold and silver, with the latter making a push for $30/oz for the first time since 2013.  Copper, however, may have seen a blow-off top yesterday as it has fallen back sharply from its peak and is now back below $5.00/lb.  In truth, the demand story here remains attractive, but the price action did seem to get out of hand there.

Finally, the dollar, which sold off hard yesterday on the CPI and Retail Sales news is bouncing slightly this morning.  Those sharply lower yields in the US, even though they were matched by Europe, were a signal to sell dollars across the board.  Thus, this morning’s 0.2% ish bounce should not be that surprising.  It is in this segment of the market that I believe the opportunity for the biggest structural changes exist.  After all, the dollar’s strength over the past 3 ½ years has been built on the Fed being the most hawkish central bank around as they belatedly fought inflation.  While they have made clear they want to start to cut interest rates, the data has not been supportive of that move.  If yesterday’s data is the beginning of a more consistent slowdown in the US, those rate cuts may be coming sooner than currently priced and regardless of what happens to risk assets, the dollar would suffer.  We shall see.

On the calendar today we have a bunch more data and four more Fed speakers (Barr, Harker, Mester and Bostic).  The data brings the weekly Initial (exp 220K) and Continuing (1780K) Claims, Housing Starts (1.42M), Building Permits (1.48M) and Philly Fed (8.0) all at 8:30 then IP (0.1%) and Capacity Utilization (78.4%) at 9:15.  As Chairman Powell has repeatedly explained, he and his colleagues look at the totality of the data, so another wave of soft numbers here would likely get risk asset markets excited.  However, listening to what they have all continued to say informs me that the Fed is not nearly ready to cut rates.  September remains the odds-on favorite for the first cut, but I still suspect that they could be here all year long.  If I am right about that, the dollar will retain its bid overall.

Good luck

Adf

Missing in Action

Posted on by 
The PPI data was shocking
Though previous months took a knocking
So, what now to think
Will CPI sink?
Or will, rate cuts, it still be blocking?

One of the features of the world these days is that the difference between a conspiracy theory and the truth has shortened to a matter of months.  I raise this issue as yesterday’s PPI data was remarkably surprising in both the released April numbers, with both headline and core printing at MUCH higher than expected 0.5%, while the revisions to the March numbers were suspiciously uniform to -0.1% for both readings.  The result was that despite the seeming hot print, the Y/Y numbers for both core and headline were exactly as forecast!

One of the things we know about data like PPI and CPI is that they are calculated from a sampling of data of the overall economy and there are fairly large error bars for any given reading.  In that sense, it cannot be surprising that the data misses forecasts regularly.  As well, given the sampling methodology, the fact that there are revisions is also no surprise.  But…it would not be hard for someone to suggest that the Bureau of Labor Statistics, when it saw the results of the monthly readings, manipulated the data to achieve a more comforting (for the current administration, i.e., their bosses) result.  I am not saying that is what happened, but you can see how a committed conspiracy theorist might get there. Now, in fairness, a look at the headline reading, on a monthly basis, for the past year, as per the below chart, shows that this is the 4th month in 12 that there was a negative reading.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

So, the fact that the revision fell to a negative number cannot be that surprising.  But it certainly got tongues wagging!  FWIW, I continue to believe that the process is where the flaws lie and that the BLS workers are trying to do their job in the best way they can.  In the end, though, much more attention will be paid to this morning’s CPI than to yesterday’s PPI.

For Jay and his friends at the Fed
His confidence ‘flation is dead
Is missing in action
Henceforth the attraction
That higher for longer’s ahead

Which brings us to Chairman Powell and his comments at the Foreign Bankers’ Association in Amsterdam yesterday.  In essence, he didn’t change a single thing regarding his views expressed at the last FOMC meeting, explaining he still lacked confidence that inflation would be reaching their 2.0% target soon.  As such, there is no reason to believe that the Fed is going to cut rates anytime soon.  As of this morning, the Fed funds futures market has a 9% probability of a rate cut priced for June, up from 3% yesterday, and a total of 45bps of cuts priced for the year.  There is obviously still a strong belief that the Fed will be able to act, although I am not sure why that is the case.  Interestingly, on the same panel, Dutch Central Bank president Klaas Knot essentially guaranteed an ECB cut in June.  As well, yesterday morning we heard Huw Pill, the chief economist at the BOE also talk up the probability of a June cut.  From a market response perspective, though, given these cuts are largely assumed, it will take new information to drive any substantive movement in the FX markets.

Here’s one thing to consider for everyone pining for that rate cut.  Given the history of the Fed always being behind the curve when it comes to policy shifts, if they realize they need to cut it is probably an indication that things in the US economy have turned down rather rapidly.  We may not want to see that either.  Just sayin!

In China, a new idea’s floated
Though not yet officially quoted
In thinking, quite bold
All houses, unsold,
Will soon be, for homeless, devoted

Ok, let’s move on from yesterday to the overnight session and then this morning’s CPI and Retail Sales reports.  The first thing to note was the story from Beijing that in an effort to deal with the ongoing property crisis in China, the government, via regional special funding vehicles that borrow more money, is considering buying all the unsold homes from developers, at a steep discount, and then converting them into low-cost affordable housing.  In truth, I think this is an inspired idea on one level, as it would allocate a wasted resource to a better use.  On the other hand, the idea that the government would issue yet more debt seems like a potential future problem will grow larger.  As of now, this is not official policy, but the leak was clearly designed as a trial balloon to gauge the market’s response.  Not surprisingly, the response was that the Shanghai property index rose sharply, but the rest of the Chinese share complex was in the red.  At the same time, the PBOC left rates on hold last night, as expected, but the CNY (+0.3%) managed to rally nicely on the combination of events.

But away from that China story, very little of note happened as all eyes await the CPI later this morning.  After yesterday’s somewhat surprising rally in the US, Asia beyond China had a mixed performance with some gainers (Australia, Taiwan, South Korea) and some laggards (Hong Kong, New Zealand, Singapore) as investors adjusted positions ahead of the big report.  In Europe, too, the picture is mixed although there are far more gainers than laggards.  In the end, none of the movement is that large overall, so also indicative of waiting for the data.  Finally, it will be no surprise that US futures are basically flat at this hour (6:30).

In the bond market, traders decided that the hot April number was to be ignored and instead have accepted the idea that inflation is not really that hot after all.  At least that is what we might glean from the price action yesterday and overnight where yields initially jumped a few basis points before grinding down over the session and closing lower by 4bps.  This morning, that decline has continued with a further 2bp drop in Treasuries.  In Europe this morning, sovereign yields are seeming to catch up to the Treasury price action with declines across the board of between 6bps and 8bps.  Part of that is also a result of changing expectations for Eurozone growth and inflation with a growing belief that inflation is headed lower and the ECB is set to cut and continue to do so going forward. 

In the commodity markets, the big story has been copper (+2.4%), which has rallied parabolically and is currently above $5.00/lb, a new all-time high.  This takes the movement this week to more than 10% and more than 36% in the past year.  The electrification story is gaining traction again, and I guess the fact that nobody is digging new mines may finally be dawning on traders.  Precious metals are coming along for the ride with gold rebounding (+0.4%) on this story as well as the dollar’s recent weakness.  As to the oil market, it is little changed this morning in the middle of its recent trading range.  Perhaps today’s EIA inventory data will drive some movement.

Finally, the dollar is under modest pressure this morning after slipping a bit during yesterday’s session as well.  The combination of the Powell comments being seen as dovish and the interpretation of the PPI data in the same manner (which seems harder for me to understand) weighed on the greenback against virtually all its counterparts.  It should be no surprise that CLP (+0.9%) is the biggest winner given the move in copper.  But JPY (+0.5%) has also performed well with no new obvious catalysts.  In fact, the movement has been quite broad with the worst performers merely remaining unchanged vs. the dollar rather than gaining.  However, this morning’s data is going to be critical to the near-term views, so we need to wait and see.

As to the data, here are the current forecasts: CPI (0.4% M/M, 3.4% Y/Y), core CPI (0.3% M/M, 3.6% Y/Y), Retail Sales (0.4%, 0.2% ex autos) and Empire State Manufacturing (-10.0).  In addition, we hear from two Fed speakers, Minneapolis Fed president Kashkari and Governor Bowman.  However, on the Fed speaker part, especially since Powell just reinforced his post-FOMC press conference message, it seems hard to believe that there will be any changes of note.

And that’s all she wrote (well he).  A hot print will likely be met with an initial risk-off take with both equity and bond markets suffering, but I suspect that it will need to be really, really bad to change the current narrative.  However, a cool print seems likely to result in a major rally in both stocks and bonds and a much sharper sell-off in the dollar.

Good luck

adf

Less Stout

Posted on by 
Suzuki-san and
Ueda-san are clearly
Flocking together

Events continue to unfold in Japan that appear to point to a more concerted effort to address the still weakening yen.  The problem, thus far, is that it hasn’t yet really worked, absent the direct intervention we saw at the beginning of the month.  For instance, last night, 10-yr JGB yields rose to their highest level since June 2012, trading up to 0.969% and finally looking like they are going to breech that 1.00% level that had so much focus back in October.  At the same time, the two key players in this drama, FinMin Suzuki and BOJ Governor Ueda are actively speaking to each other as they try to coordinate policy.  The problem for Suzuki-san is that Q1 GDP fell back into negative territory again, thus bringing two of the past three quarters down below zero.  While that is not the technical definition of a recession, it certainly doesn’t look very good.

And yet, the yen remains under pressure, slipping another 0.1% last night, and as can be seen from the chart below, continuing its steady decline (dollar rise) from the levels seen immediately in the wake of the intervention.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Another interesting thing is that our esteemed Treasury Secretary, Janet Yellen, seems to be concerned over any intervention carried out by the Japanese, at least based on comments she recently made in a Bloomberg interview, “It’s possible for countries to intervene.  It doesn’t always work without more fundamental changes in policy, but we believe that it should happen very rarely and be communicated to trade partners if it does.” 

There have been several analysts of late who have made the case that Yellen’s trip to Asia last month included a ‘secret’ Plaza Accord II type arrangement, where there was widespread agreement that the dollar needed to come down in value.  First off, secrets like that are extremely difficult to keep secret, and history shows that doesn’t happen very frequently.  But more importantly, based on the fact that inflation is one of the biggest problems that her boss has leading up to the election, a weaker dollar is the last thing she would want.  I suspect if we continue to see the yen decline, the BOJ/MOF will be back at the intervention game again, but the US will not be helping.  Keep in mind, though, Japanese yields.  If the BOJ is truly going to allow yields to rise in Japan, that would have a significant impact on the yen’s value in the FX markets.  While 1.00% is a big round number, I think we will need to see the BOJ demonstrate a more aggressive stance overall…or we need to see the data turn softer in the US to allow the Fed to get on with their much-desired rate cuts.  We will need to watch this closely going forward.

While everyone’s waiting to see
How high CPI just might be
One cannot rule out
An outcome less stout
Where bond and stock bulls are set free

Which brings us to the inflation story.  By this time, everyone is aware that tomorrow’s CPI data is seen as a critical piece of the puzzle.  I continue to read coherent arguments on both sides of the debate regarding the trend going forward.  (Let’s face it, the error bars are far too wide to be confident in a specific forecast.)  For the inflationistas, they continue to look at things like the housing market, which while frequently expected to see declining price pressures, has maintained an upward trend for the past several years.  As well, things like the dramatic rise in certain commodity prices (coffee comes to mind) and the substantial rise in the price of insurance (something of which I speak from personal experience!), there is ample evidence that prices continue to climb. 

Part of this puzzle may be the result of the fact that companies continue to successfully raise prices, or at least had been doing so for the past two years, as evidenced by the continued strong earnings, and more importantly, still high gross margins they are able to achieve.  So, as input prices have risen, they have passed those costs along to the consumer quite successfully.  Now, the comments from Starbucks and McDonalds at their earnings reports indicating business is slowing down and attributing that slowdown to rising prices may well be a harbinger that companies have lost the ability to keep this up.  But two companies, even large ones, are not nearly the whole economy.  As well, much has been made, lately, of the K-shaped economy, where the haves continue to benefit from the rise in asset prices and are far less impacted by rising prices as they can afford them.  This has led to continued strong demand for luxury goods, which while a smaller sector of the economy, remain highly visible. Meanwhile, the less fortunate lower 90% of the population find themselves struggling to make ends meet as real wages remain stagnant and there continues to be a switch from full-time to part-time employment ongoing as companies adjust their staffing needs.  PS, those part time jobs don’t pay as well and generally don’t have benefits, so any price increases are very tough to swallow.  In the end, it appears that housing, insurance services and food remain in upward price trends.

On the flipside, there are many who see that while Q1’s inflation data was sticky on the high side, things should begin to improve going forward.  They point to things like M2, which has fallen dramatically over the past two years, although has recently inflected higher again.  However, the argument is that the lag between the movement in M2 and inflation is somewhere in the 16-24-month period, and we are now due to see prices decline.  In addition, they point to things like loan impairments and credit card delinquencies rising as signs that companies have lost their pricing power and prices will reflect that by slowing their ascent.

Now, today we see the PPI, which may give clues as to tomorrow’s outcome and the following are the median expectations:  headline 0.3% M/M, 2.2% Y/Y; core 0.2% M/M, 2.4% Y/Y.  Looking at the chart, it certainly appears that this statistic has bottomed out just like CPI.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But here’s the thing…I have a feeling that regardless of the outcome, the market is going to rally in both stocks and bonds.  Certainly, if it is a softer than forecast number, the rate cut narrative is going to be going gangbusters and stocks will rocket while yields fall.  If it is on the money, my sense is the market is still in the camp that despite what we continue to hear, especially with Powell having removed the possibility of a rate hike, that the view will turn to rate cuts are coming as the Fed’s underlying dovishness will prevail.  But if the numbers are hot, while the initial reaction will almost certainly be a decline in risk asset prices, I have a feeling it will be short-lived.  Positioning is not overly long here, at least according to the fear/greed indicators, and the theme that the administration will do all it can to get re-elected, meaning lots more fiscal support, is going to work in favor of risk assets.  One other thing, if there is some trouble in the bond market, the one thing we know for sure is that Powell will come to the rescue and support the whole structure.

Net, while the timing of each outcome may differ, I sense the end result will be the same.  As to the dollar, I remain in the camp that international investors will continue to buy dollars to buy the S&P.  As well, given it seems very clear that both the ECB and BOE are going to cut rates in June while the Fed remains a much lower probability to do so, that should prevent any sharp dollar decline, although it may not push it any higher.

Overnight, basically nothing happened as everybody is holding their collective breath for tomorrow.  Maybe today will be a harbinger, but I expect a generally slow session overall absent a HUGE surprise in PPI.

Good luck

adf

Bears Will Riposte

Posted on by

With CPI later this week

And many Fed members to speak

The news of the day

Is China’s array

Of debt issues they will soon seek

 

However, what matters the most

For markets is Wednesday’s signpost

If CPI’s cool

The bulls will still rule

But hot and the bears will riposte

 

While we all await Wednesday’s CPI data with bated breath, there are, in fact, other things happening in the world that can have an impact on markets and economies as well as on the narrative.  The story that seems to be getting the most press today is the leaked plans of China’s ultra-long bond issuance that was first hinted at two weeks ago.  The details show they are planning to issue, as soon as next Friday, the first tranche of 20-year bonds, with 50-year bonds coming in June and then the lion’s share of the issuance, 30-year bonds, due by November.  The total amount to be issued is CNY 1 trillion split as CNY 300 billion of 20-yr, CNY 600 billion of 30-yr and CNY 100 billion of 50-yr.

The reason this story is getting so much press is that the natural consequence of this issuance is that the national government is going to be spending that money on numerous projects, mainly infrastructure it seems, in an effort to ensure they achieve President Xi’s 5% GDP growth target for 2024.  This has knock-on implications for inflation, as it is unlikely that China’s disinflationary impulse can extend greatly with all this additional spending, and for markets as there will be clear impacts on Chinese interest rates, the CNY exchange rate and Chinese equity markets.  After all, CNY 1 trillion (~$138 billion) is a lot of money to push through in a short period of time so there will undoubtedly be some leakage from real economic activity into financial actions, and ultimately, that money will impact the performance of many companies to boot. 

A funny thing about leaked information is often the timing of those leaks.  After all, I’m pretty sure that it was no accident that this news managed to escape into the wild on the day after China’s loan data showed some pretty awful results.  For instance, what they term Total Social Financing, which is defined as a broad measure of credit and liquidity in the economy, FELL CNY 200 billion in April, the first decline in the history of the series since it began in 2002.  As well, New Yuan loans fell to CNY 730 billion, far below forecasts of CNY 1.2 trillion and down substantially from March’s data.  While this was not a historic low amount, it was definitely in the lower decile of readings and an indication that economic activity is just not doing much there.

As it happens, given the news was more about the specific timing than the idea of the issuance, the impact on the yuan was limited as it has barely moved.  Onshore Chinese equity markets did erase some early losses to close flat on the day after the news leaked into the market and Hong Kong shares rallied nicely, up 0.80%. 

But in truth, beyond this story, there has been very little of interest as all eyes turn to Wednesday morning’s CPI release.  I will offer my views on how that may play out tomorrow, so for now, let’s just quickly survey the overnight session and take a look at what is on deck this week, especially given the number of Fed speakers we shall hear.

Away from the Chinese markets, the only other equity market in Asia with a major move was Taiwan’s TAIEX (+0.7%), clearly benefitting on the idea that some of that money would head across the Strait, with the rest of the region +/- 0.2% or less.  Again, waiting for CPI is still the major idea.  This is true in Europe as well, although the bias is for very small losses, on the order of -0.2% or less, rather than the small gains seen in Asia.  Not surprisingly, US futures are virtually still asleep at this hour (6:45) and unchanged from Friday’s levels.

In the bond market, yields are edging lower by 2bps pretty much across the board, with Treasuries leading the way and virtually every European sovereign following suit by the same amount.  As always, the US market remains the dominant player here.  In Japan, though, yields crept higher by 3bps after the BOJ explained that they would be reducing their QQE purchases to ¥425 billion, from ¥475 billion last month.  Perhaps they really are trying to tighten policy!

In the commodity markets, oil (+0.6%) is edging higher after a generally rough week last week.  There has been no new news here, so this is all simply trading machinations.  Of more interest are the metals markets with copper (+0.9%) continuing its recent rally as it responds to the Chinese infrastructure spending news.  However, precious metals are under pressure today with gold (-0.75%) having a great deal of difficulty finding a bid as the market argument of whether inflation is picking up or not remains untested.

Finally, the dollar is mostly little changed with only a few currencies showing any life this morning, all in the EEMEA bloc.  ZAR (+0.4%) is firmer despite gold’s decline, as traders focus on hints that the SARB is going to maintain its tight monetary policy for even longer, not following the ECB when they cut in June.  Meanwhile, CZK (+0.5%) rallied on stronger than expected CPI data with the M/M number coming at +0.7% and talk that the central bank will be holding firm for longer than previously anticipated.

Looking at this week’s data and commentary, there is much ground to cover although we start off slow with nothing today:

TuesdayNFIB Small Biz Optimism88.1
 PPI0.3% (2.2% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (2.4% Y/Y)
WednesdayCPI0.4% (3.4% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.3% (3.6% Y/Y)
 Empire State Mfg-10
 Retail Sales0.4%
 -ex autos0.2%
ThursdayInitial Claims220K
 Continuing Claims1790K
 Housing Starts1.41M
 Building Permits1.48M
 Philly Fed7.7
 IP0.1%
 Capacity Utilization78.4%
FridayLeading Indicators-0.3%
Source: tradingeconomics.com

In addition to all that, we hear from, count ‘em, 11 Fed speakers during the week, including Chair Powell Tuesday morning (before CPI although he will probably know the number).  As well, he speaks again next Sunday afternoon.  I maintain they all speak too much and too often, and we would be far better off if they simply adjusted policy as they saw fit and ended forward guidance!

But we know they will never shut up, so we must deal with it as it comes.  As to today, it is hard to get excited about anything happening of note given the perceived importance of the rest of the week.  So, look for a quiet day today, a perfect day to initiate some hedges amid benign market conditions.

Good luck

Adf

Not Harebrained

Posted on by

While here in the States there’s no chance
That rate cuts, by June, will advance
In England, we learned
They’re growing concerned
The ‘conomy’s still in a trance

So yesterday, Bailey explained
By June, a rate cut’s not hairbrained
But, closer to home
The Frisco Fed gnome
Said cutting rates will be restrained

You can tell that very little continues to happen in the macro world when the key stories that are in the discussion regard secondary players and their commentary.  While it is true that Andrew Bailey is the governor of the Bank of England, the reality is that the UK is just a secondary player on the world stage.  However, after their meeting yesterday, much digital ink has been spilled over the potential for the BOE to cut rates at the June meeting.  Prior to this meeting, it seemed that the BOE was tracking the Fed rather than the ECB, but that idea has now been dispelled.  Governor Bailey indicated that come June, a rate cut “is neither ruled out nor a fait accompli.”  However, he did comment that cuts were likely “over the coming quarters” and the market took him up on the news, with yields sliding and stocks rallying.

A key to the discussion is the fact that the BOE will see two more CPI reports between now and the next meeting on June 20th.  As well, both the ECB and the Fed will have met and potentially acted before they next meet.  As such, despite the fact that the BOE’s own forecasts showed improvement in both GDP and CPI over the next 3 years with current policy, the market is all-in on the cuts for June.  Well, maybe not all-in, but has increased the probability to 50%, up from just under one-third prior to the meeting.  Regarding the pound, if we continue to hear more dovish cooing from the Old Lady, especially given the fact that the Fed is clearly on hold, I expect it could drift back toward 1.20 over time.

Which brings us to the Fed, and an unscheduled appearance by San Francisco Fed president, Mary Daly, yesterday afternoon.  The two key comments she made were as follows: “There’s considerable, now, uncertainty about what the next few months of inflation will be and what we should do in response,” and “It’s far too early to declare that the labor market is fragile or faltering.”  In essence, this is repeating everything that we have heard consistently since the FOMC meeting last week.  I would boil it down to ‘as much as we are desperate to cut rates, neither prices nor the labor market are falling quickly enough to allow us to do so soon.’

Add it all up and you get a picture of a still tight Fed with no indication of a policy ease in the next quarter, at least, while another major central bank elsewhere has opened the doors to cutting rates.  Arguably, this should be a positive for the dollar except for the fact that this has been known, and the basic narrative for a while, so is already in the price.  If these policy divergences maintain for a much longer time, through the end of the year or beyond, then perhaps we will see more aggressive dollar strength.  But for now, I think the FX markets are going to be a dull affair.  The caveat here is if we see US data move away from its current trajectory, either picking up and pushing price pressures higher, or falling more rapidly resulting in a worse employment situation.

One last thing on the prospects for the US economy; there is still a large contingent of analysts who have been parsing the data and looking at secondary indicators and sub-indices of headline data, and who believe that a recession is much closer than the market is currently pricing.  Things like credit card delinquencies and the growing number of bankruptcies, as well as the discrepancy between the establishment and household surveys in the employment data have reached levels consistent with recessions in the past.  While last year I expected that would be the case, at this point, I believe that the ongoing massive fiscal spending (budget deficits >6% of GDP) and the ongoing availability of cheap energy continuing to draw investment into the US will prevent any substantive downturn for the rest of the year, at least.

As to market activity, yesterday’s higher than expected Initial Claims data (231K, highest since October) got the bulls all excited and drove a risk rally in stocks in the US which has been followed all around the globe.  Asian markets saw gains in Japan (+0.4%), Hong Kong (+2.3%) and almost everywhere else in the region except China which was flat on the day.  Meanwhile, European bourses are all green as well, led by the UK (+0.7%) on the back of stronger GDP data as well as the hopes for lower rates in the near future.  But the entire continent is higher as well, mostly on the order of 0.5%.  As to US futures, higher by 0.25% at this hour (7:30).

In the bond market, while Treasury yields drifted lower yesterday after that claims data, this morning they are higher by 1 basis point.  In Europe, though, sovereign yields are slipping 2bps to 3bps as traders and investors get more convinced of rate cuts coming soon.  Overnight, JGB markets did nothing.

In the commodity markets, Wednesday’s declines are a distant memory as we have seen oil (+0.7%) rally again this morning despite modest inventory builds which may be being offset by concerns that Israel is ignoring the recent pressure to stop its Rafah incursion.  However, the precious metals are not ignoring that story with both gold and silver higher by more than 1% this morning and copper rising 2.4%.  The day-to-day vagaries of these markets remain confusing, but the long-term trend, I believe, remains strongly intact, and that is higher prices going forward.

Finally, the dollar is little changed this morning but maintaining its gains from earlier in the week.  Looking across my screen, no currency has moved more than 0.3% in either direction, a clear sign that very little of note is happening.  As I wrote above, absent a major change in policy, I think the dollar is range bound for now.

On the data front, this morning brings only Michigan Sentiment (exp 76) and then a few more Fed speeches from Kashkari, Bowman, Goolsbee and Barr.  Regarding the data, I believe it will need to be a big miss in either direction to get much market reaction.  Regarding the Fedspeak, given the consistency with which every speaker has thus far explained they lack the confidence that 2% is in view, I see very little is likely to be newsworthy.

For today, don’t look for much at all.  For the longer term, the dollar’s future depends on how much longer the Fed maintains its relative tightness, and if that spread widens because either the Fed brings hikes back on the table or other central banks cut more aggressively.  But for now, as we enter the summer, I don’t see much at all.

Good luck and good weekend
Adf

Adrift

Posted on by

Investors are biding their time
As Fedspeak continues to rhyme
It’s higher for longer
As long as growth’s stronger
Defining today’s paradigm

So, how might the narrative shift?
Are Jay and the Fed just adrift?
Next week’s CPI
If it prints too high
Might well, for the bears, be a gift

As promised on Monday, this week remains quite innocuous in terms of both market information and market movement.  There have been precious few pieces of news that have worked to alter the current situation.  The Fed speakers we have heard, when they discussed monetary policy, seem to be reading from the same text.  It can be boiled down to, the policy rate will remain at current levels until such time that something changes with respect to inflation or employment.  We will not rule out a hike, (despite the fact that Powell apparently did so last week) but are nowhere near ready to cut given the current inflation status.

With this in mind, it should be no surprise that markets remain extremely quiet.  After all, how can one change a view if nothing has changed?  So, the US story is pretty well understood for now and until CPI is released next Wednesday, I see no reason for any major movement in either equities or bonds here, and by extension elsewhere in the world.

Moving on from the US, Ueda-san continues to hint that the BOJ may do something, but last night’s Summary of Opinions from the BOJ (effectively their Minutes) almost implied, if you squint hard enough, that they could do it sometime soonish.  Clearly there is a bit of concern over the yen (-0.35%) which continues to drift back toward the levels seen when they intervened.  However, the very fact that just a week after they were aggressively selling dollars, it has pushed back to 156.00 tells you that absent a policy move, nothing is going to change.

As an aside here, this is quite important for the global economy, and certainly global markets.  Ultimately, Japanese monetary policy has been the driver of a huge amount of global liquidity flowing into asset markets around the world.  My understanding is that Japanese households also have somewhere on the order of $7 trillion in cash available to invest still at home, which historically was never a concern there given the complete absence of inflation in the country.  But now that inflation is rising there, and yields remain so paltry compared to elsewhere in the world, especially the US, if even a portion of that starts to flow more rapidly out of Japan, it will have an enormous impact everywhere.  On the flipside, Japan is also the largest international investor around, as a nation, and if the BOJ does allow rates to rise and that capital flows back home, that too would be a dramatic shift in global markets.  Ultimately, this is the reason we all care so much about what the BOJ does…it impacts us all.

The only other thing of note today is the BOE meeting where no change is expected in policy, but all will be searching for clues as to when they will cut rates.  The last vote was 8-1 to remain on hold with the lone holdout seeking a cut.  While expectations are for that to continue today, there is some discussion that a second dove may raise their hand for a cut.  It is widely accepted that cuts are the next move, and the real question is will they be following the ECB and cutting in June or wait until August.  FWIW, I expect a June cut by pretty much all the central banks other than the Fed (and of course the BOJ).  Economic activity is bumping along at effectively stagnation levels elsewhere in the G10 and inflation has been consistently softening everywhere except in the US.  While CPI is still higher than all their targets, central banks are desperate to get back to cutting rates and so will move with alacrity once they get started.

And that’s really all we have today.  Yesterday’s lackluster US session was followed up with a mixed bag in Asian equity markets (Nikkei -0.35%, Hang Seng +1.2%, CSI 300 +0.95%) and we are seeing a similar mixed picture in Europe with gainers (Germany, Switzerland) and laggards (Spain, Italy) while the rest are basically unchanged on the day.  However, at this hour (7:00), US futures are pointing a bit lower, down -0.3% across the board.

In the bond market, yesterday’s 10-year Treasury auction was met with mediocre demand and this morning yields are higher by 2bps.  There continues to be a great deal of discussion as to whether 10-year yields are going to head back above 5.0%, where they briefly touched last October as inflation reignites fears, or whether the oft mooted recession will finally arrive, and yields will tumble as the Fed cuts.  While my take is the former is more likely, at this point, there is no conclusive evidence for either view.  It should be no surprise, however, that European sovereign yields are also higher this morning, on the order of 3bps to 4bps, as they track Treasury yields closely.  Perhaps more surprising is that JGB yields rose 3bps overnight, and are now 0.91%, once again tracking toward their highs seen in October.  Clearly, there is a growing belief that the BOJ is going to do something sooner rather than later, but I will believe it when I see it.  Of course, if they do alter policy, that will change my views on many things.

In the commodity markets, oil (+0.85%) is rising again this morning and just about touching $80/bbl again. While some will say this is being driven by the Israeli incursion into Rafah, my take is this is simply the ebb and flow of a market that is in a trading range.  Since the summer of 2022, WTI has traded between $70/bbl and $90/bbl and I believe we will need to see some major changes in the situation for that to change.  Do not be surprised to see the Biden administration tap the SPR again in the lead up to the election in an effort to depress gasoline prices.  And do not be surprised to see OPEC+ cut production further if they do.  Consider this, though, if Trump is elected, there will be a major reversal in US energy policy and ‘drill baby drill’ will be back in vogue.  I suspect energy prices may decline then.

Turning to the metals markets, after a soft session yesterday, we are seeing a modest rebound led by silver (+1.3%) with gold, copper and aluminum all barely creeping higher by 0.1% or 0.2%.

Finally, the dollar cannot be held back.  As Treasury yields edge higher, the dollar is following and this morning is firmer against most of its counterparts, albeit not dramatically so.  Aside from the yen’s ongoing weakness, the pound (-0.3%) is not responding favorably to the fact that the BOE left rates on hold, and as I suspected, hinted at cuts to come with the vote coming out 7-2 as I proposed above.  Otherwise, most movement is extremely modest with one outlier, ZAR (+0.3%) rallying on the back of the metals rebound.

On the data front, this morning we see Initial (exp 210K) and Continuing (1790K) Claims and that is all she wrote.  We don’t even have any Fed speakers today, so it is shaping up as another very quiet session.  The big picture remains the same so until the Fed turns dovish, the dollar should hold its own.

Good luck
Adf

Towards the Stars

Posted on by

As the yen declines
Pressure on the BOJ
Climbs up towards the stars

 

Intervention in the currency markets has a long and undistinguished history.  At least that is true for nations that have open capital accounts.  In fact, a key reason that countries impose and maintain capital account restrictions is to avoid the situation of having their currency collapse when the locals fear future loss of purchasing power, i.e. inflation is rising. While there have been situations where a central bank has been able to prevent a significant movement in the past, it has almost always been in an effort to prevent too much currency strength, never weakness.  

A great example is Switzerland in January 2015.  As you can see from the chart below of the EURCHF cross, Switzerland was explicitly targeting a level, 1.20, in the cross as the strongest the Swiss franc could trade (lower numbers indicate a stronger CHF).  This was in an effort to support the export sectors of the economy during a period shortly after the Eurozone crisis when Europeans were quite keen to convert their funds to Swiss francs as a more effective store of value.  

Source: tradingeconommics.com

The upshot was that the Swiss National Bank wound up effectively printing and selling hundreds of billions of francs, receiving dollars and euros and then investing those proceeds into the US stock market.  At one point, they were the largest shareholder in Apple!  But even in this case, where you would expect a nation could prevent their currency from rising too far or too fast, the process overwhelmed the SNB and one day in January 2015 they simply said, enough.  That 25% appreciation in the franc took about 15 minutes to accomplish and as evidenced by today’s exchange rate of 0.9768, it has never been unwound.

And that’s what happened to a central bank that is trying to prevent its own currency from strengthening.  For central banks to prevent weakness is an entirely different story and a MUCH harder task.  As I have repeatedly explained, the only way to change the trajectory of a currency is to alter monetary policy.  At this time, given the Fed’s commitment to higher for even longer, the only way Japan can prevent more substantial yen weakness is for the BOJ to tighten policy even further.  This is made evident in the below chart of the price action in USDJPY for the past month.  In it, you can see when it spiked above 160 on April 28th, and the subsequent intervention that day and then two days later.  

Source: tradingeconomics.com

However, in both cases, despite spending upwards of $60 billion intervening, the yen immediately resumed its downtrend (dollar uptrend) and this morning it is back above 155.  It is this price action that appears to have finally awoken Ueda-san as last night, in an appearance at the Japanese parliament, he explained the following, “Foreign exchange rates make a significant impact on the economy and inflation.  Depending on those moves, a monetary policy response might be needed.”  Ya think!  Ueda-san was followed in parliament by FinMin Suzuki who repeated something he said last week, “Since Japan relies on overseas markets for food and energy, and a large portion of its transactions are denominated in dollars, a weaker yen could raise prices of imported goods.”  While those comments are self-evident, the fact that he needed to repeat them is indicative of the idea that Japan is getting increasingly uncomfortable with the current yen exchange rate.

So, will Ueda-san raise rates at the next meeting in June?  Will he alter their QQE policy and explicitly explain they will no longer be buying JGBs?  Certainly, the market is on edge right now given the two bouts of intervention from last week, but not so on edge that it isn’t continuing to sell the currency and capture the carry.  At this point, you cannot rule out a third wave of intervention, and certainly we should expect more jawboning.  But in the end, if they are serious about the yen being too weak, Ueda-san will have to move.  At this point, I am not convinced, but the meeting is on June 14th, so there is plenty of time for things to become clearer.

And other than that, quite frankly, not much is going on.  So, let’s take a tour of markets to see how things stand this morning.

Yesterday’s equity markets in the US were tantamount to being unchanged across the board, at least that is true of the major indices.  There were certainly individual equities that moved.  In Asia, it was a mixed picture with both Japanese (Nikkei -1.6%) and Chinese (CSI 300 -0.8%) shares in the red, which dragged down HK shares.  But elsewhere in the region, we saw more gains than losses, albeit none of the movement was that large overall.  Meanwhile, in Europe, all the markets are looking robust this morning with gains ranging from 0.5% (DAX, FTSE 100) to 1.0% (CAC) and everywhere in between.  The Swedish Riksbank cut rates by 25bps, as anticipated this morning, and perhaps that has encouraged investors to believe the ECB is going to embark on a more significant easing campaign starting next month.  Certainly, the limited data we saw this morning, (German IP -0.4%, Spanish IP -1.2%, Italian Retail Sales 0.0%) are not indicative of an economy that is growing strongly.  Finally, US futures are just a touch lower, -0.2%, at this hour (7:15).

Despite the weakness in Eurozone data, and the absence of US data, yields are rebounding a bit this morning with Treasuries higher by 3bps and the entire European sovereign spectrum seeing yields rise by 3bps to 4bps.  It seems unlikely that the weak Eurozone data is the driver and I suspect that this movement is more a trading reaction based on the recent decline in yields.  After all, just one week ago, yields were more than 20 basis points higher, so a little rebound can be no surprise.

In the commodity markets, oil (-1.1%) is under pressure as rising inventories outweigh ongoing concerns over Israel’s Rafah initiative.  While the EIA data is generally considered the most important, yesterday’s API data showed a build of more than 500K barrels vs. expectations of a 1.4M barrel draw.  At the end of the day, this is still a supply/demand driven price, and if supply is more ample, prices will fall.  In the metals markets, precious metals continue to trade choppily around recent levels, but we are starting to see some weakness in the industrial space with both copper (-1.25%) and aluminum (-1.6%) under pressure this morning.  Certainly, if economic activity is starting to wane, these metals are likely to suffer.

Finally, in the FX markets, the dollar is continuing to rebound from its recent selloff, gaining against virtually all its counterparts, both EMG and G10.  SEK (-0.5%) is the biggest mover in the G10 after the rate cut, but JPY (-0.45%) is not far behind.  We are also seeing weakness in AUD (-0.4%) on the back of those metal declines.  As to the EMG bloc, ZAR (-0.7%) is the laggard there, also on the metals weakness, but we saw KRW (-0.5%) suffer overnight as well amidst the general dollar strength.

Once again, there is no US data on the calendar although we hear from three more Fed speakers, Boston’s Collins as well as governor’s Cook and Jefferson.  Yesterday, Mr Kashkari did not give us any new information, indicating that higher for longer still makes the most sense and even questioning the level of the neutral rate, implying it may be higher than previously thought.  But there have been no cracks in the current story that the Fed is not going to alter policy soon.

While day-to-day movements remain subject to many vagaries, the reality is that the trend in the dollar has been higher all year and as long as monetary policies around the world remain as currently priced, with the Fed the most hawkish of all, the dollar should grind higher over time.

Good luck

Adf