Tag Archives: #NFP

Unchained

Posted on by

The data, on Friday, revealed
The job market’s mostly been healed
As such, any thought
The Fed really ought
Cut rates, simply must be repealed
 
In fact, two Fed speakers explained
That rate cuts were not yet ordained
Should prices keep rising
It won’t be surprising
If higher rates soon are unchained

 

Wow!  Once again, the NFP report was significantly hotter than any analysts forecast, with a top line number of 303K while the previous 2 months were revised higher as well.  The Unemployment Rate fell back a tick, to 3.8%, while wages continue to grow above 4%.  In other words, it seems quite difficult to make the case that the economy is in a state that requires rate cuts.  After all, if the Fed’s focus has turned from inflation specifically to employment now, and employment continues to rock, why cut?

However, the impression from the cacophony of Fedspeak we heard last week is that many members are still of a mind to cut the Fed funds rate, likely in June.  Just not all of them.  We heard from two more speakers Friday, Governor Michelle Bowman and Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan, and neither seemed in a cutting frame of mind.  [Emphasis added]

Bowman: “While it is not my baseline outlook, I continue to see the risk that at a future meeting we may need to increase the policy rate further should progress on inflation stall or even reverse.”

Logan: “In light of these risks, I believe it’s much too soon to think about cutting interest rates.  I will need to see more of the uncertainty resolved about which economic path we’re on.” She followed that with, “To be clear, the key risk is not that inflation might rise — though monetary policymakers must always remain on guard against that outcome — but rather that inflation will stall out and fail to follow the forecast path all the way back to 2 percent in a timely way.”

Now, it is very difficult for me to read these comments and think, damn, rate cuts are coming soon!  By now, you are all aware that I have been in the sticky inflation camp from the get-go and certainly Friday’s data did nothing to change my mind.  But my views don’t really matter. However, if we start seeing a majority of FOMC members talking about fewer cuts than expected/assumed in March, and even hikes, we need to pay attention. I don’t think it is yet a majority, and clearly Chair Powell is very keen to cut, but there is a long time between now and the June meeting, with much data to come.  Unless that data starts to really back off and hint at a substantial slowing of the economy, my sense is that June will morph into November or December, with the median dot pointing at just one cut this year.

A quick look at the Fed funds futures shows that traders are growing even less confident in those rate cuts being implemented.  As of this morning, the June probability has fallen slightly below 50% and there are a total of 61bps priced in by the December meeting, just over two cuts.  This is quite a contrast to the Eurozone, where the market has fully priced in a June cut and is beginning to consider a 50bp reduction to get things going there.  On the surface, this makes a great deal of sense as the Eurozone economy’s growth continues to lag that of the US and inflation has been ebbing more rapidly there than in the States.  And don’t forget, the ECB meets this Thursday, so at the very least we should have a better sense of what will happen in June, and we cannot rule out a cut this week, regardless of market pricing.

Trying to step back for a broader perspective on the economy and the future of policy rates as well as market movements, there continue to be several conundrums in markets compared to historical trends.  For instance, what is the meaning of the price of gold rising consistently alongside a rise in interest rates, both nominal and real?  Historically, there has been a strong negative correlation between the two, but something has changed in the past two years as evidenced by the BofA Research chart below.

Is this a signal that the market is getting indigestion over the amount of sovereign debt that is outstanding, led by Treasuries?  Is this an indication that investors are losing faith in fiat currencies and the current global monetary structure?  Or is this simply a temporary anomaly that will correct over the course of the next several years?  Unfortunately, there is no way for anyone to know the answer to these questions at this point in time.  Anyone who says otherwise is not being honest.  

However, my suspicion is that the consequences of monetary and fiscal policies around the world during the Pandemic and since has more and more people, and institutions, starting to hedge their bets on the future and its outcomes.  From a more benign view that the authorities will be able to kick the can down the road, this relationship seems to indicate more than a few folks think that the fiscal and monetary authorities are about to stub their collective toe on the next kick.  Ouch!

In many ways, I think that the change in this relationship is an excellent encapsulation of the problems currently faced by monetary and fiscal authorities.  As such, I will be watching it closely as a key indicator of market sentiment overall.

Ok, let’s look at the overnight session.  After Friday’s solid US equity performance, the picture elsewhere has been slightly less positive, although positive overall.  In Asia, the Nikkei (+0.9%) followed the US price action although Chinese shares had a less positive session, falling on the mainland with the HK market staying flat.  Treasury Secretary Yellen was in China trying to smooth things over, but the following two statements, I think, are a great description of how confused things are:

Talk about mixed messages!  Meanwhile, in Europe, most bourses are a bit higher this morning, but on the order of 0.5%, half what we saw in the US on Friday.  It seems that some traders are betting that the ECB, when it meets this Thursday, is going to cut rates.  Lastly, at this hour (7:20), US futures are essentially flat.

The bond market, though, has seen far more activity lately as it appears the bond vigilantes, last seen in the 1990’s are reawakening.  This morning, 10-year Treasury yields are back to 4.45%, their highest level since November when yields were falling in the wake of the Fed’s perceived pivot and the reduced amount of coupon issuance just announced at that time.  This is 13bps higher than the yield just before the NFP data was released, 8bps on Friday and another 5bps this morning.  Similarly, European sovereign yields hare higher by between 3bps and 5bps this morning, being dragged higher by Treasuries, but lagging as bets get made that the ECB acts sooner than the Fed.

In the commodity space, oil (-0.8%) is backing off its recent highs this morning as there appears to be an easing in some concerns over the Middle East, at least that is the story making the rounds.  Meanwhile, metals prices continue to flourish despite the rise in interest rates with both precious (Au +0.4%, Ag +0.9%) and base (Cu +0.7%, Al +0.3%) all continuing their recent climbs.  Another conundrum here is the fact that these metals prices are rising despite the dollar remaining reasonably well bid.

Turning to the dollar, it is little changed, on net, this morning although we have seen some strength against the CHF (-0.5%) and KRW (-0.4%).  The former is the only currency seemingly following the interest rate story as the recent SNB rate cut plus low inflation readings indicates that the policy divergence between Switzerland and the US is set to widen further.  The won, on the other hand, looks to be a proxy for China, which the PBOC refuses to allow to weaken despite many economic reasons it should.  On the flipside, ZAR (+0.4%) is rallying on the back of those metals’ prices.  One of the things that is confusing is the fact that the euro remains reasonably well bid despite the changing tone of the interest rate policies between the Fed and ECB.  While the single currency has generally been declining over the past month, in truth, since the beginning of April, it has rebounded about 1% and held strong since then.  Given the changing market perceptions, I would have anticipated the euro to continue its declining ways, but right now, that is not the case.

On the data front, the week starts out slowly, but we get the critical US CPI data on Wednesday.

TuesdayNFIB Small Biz Optimism89.5
WednesdayCPI0.3% (3.4% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.3% (3.7% Y/Y)
 Bank of Canada Rate Decision5.0% (unchanged)
 FOMC Minutes 
ThursdayInitial Claims215K
 Continuing Claims1792K
 PPI0.3% (2.3% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (2.3% Y/Y)
 ECB Rate Decision4.5% (unchanged)
FridayMichigan Sentiment79.0
Source: tradingeconomics.com

In addition to the data and other central bank decisions, we hear from seven more Fed speakers this week, which given the recent more hawkish commentary, could well be quite interesting.  If Wednesday’s CPI data is hotter than expected again, I suspect it will become increasingly difficult for the doves to spread their wings.  As it happens, six of the seven speak after the CPI, so we could well see things evolve further.  In the meantime, relative to other currencies, I continue to look at the rate picture and believe the dollar should remain firm.  However, versus ‘stuff’ not so much.

Good luck

Adf

Hell or High Water

Posted on by

Though Jay was as clear as a bell
That rate cuts were coming through hell
Or high water, it seems
Not all the Fed’s teams
Are ready to cut rates as well
 
A group of the regional Feds
Seems at, with Chair Jay, loggerheads
They think maybe two,
Or one, cut could do
Now, traders are sh**ting their beds!

 

Yesterday morning, I claimed that it didn’t matter what the plethora of Fed speakers were going to say given that Chairman Powell had seemed to clear the decks for a rate cut by June.  He swept away concerns about ‘too hot’ inflation and was clearly ready to go forward.  It seems that I didn’t read the market zeitgeist that well after all.

It turns out during the day, we heard from four different Fed regional presidents, Chicago’s Goolsbee, Minneapolis’s Kashkari, Cleveland’s Mester and Richmond’s Barkin, and not one of them sounded like they were ready to cut rates anytime soon.  While only two, Barkin and Mester, are voters this year, the story we consistently hear is that everybody’s voice is heard during the meetings.  Listening to those voices yesterday, it certainly doesn’t sound like everybody is ready to move in June.

Mester: “I don’t think the pace of disinflation this year will match what we saw last year as we need to see a reduction in the demand side this year.  Although if the economy evolves as I envision, we should be able to lower the Fed funds rate later this year.”   

And that was the most dovish we heard.

Barkin: “It is smart for the Fed to take our time.  No one wants inflation to re-emerge.”

Kashkari: “If inflation continues to move sideways, that would make me question whether we needed to do those rate cuts at all.”

Goolsbee: “I had been expecting it [inflation] to come down more quickly than it has.  The biggest danger to the inflation picture is continued high inflation in housing services.”

It is very hard to look at these comments and conclude that a June rate cut is a given.  And yet, the Fed funds futures market is now pricing a 64% probability of a June cut although is still pricing less than three full cuts for the rest of the year.

Risk assets were not enamored of these comments and the result was we saw a serious pullback in the equity markets in the US with all three major indices falling by between 1.25% and 1.40%.  Treasury yields fell as well, down 4bps, with its haven status making a comeback as did that status for both the yen (+0.4%) and Swiss franc (+0.6%).

Remember this, there are many different stories around the current market situation between the macroeconomics, the geopolitics of both Israel/Gaza and Russia/Ukraine and the central bank activities, not only with the Fed, but also the BOJ and ECB.  The point is markets are feeling many crosscurrents and it would not be surprising to see a more material breakout in one direction or the other on some seemingly less important piece of news.  In truth, when major moves begin, we rarely have a specific catalyst to which we can point.  I have a feeling the next big move will be confusing for a while.

While words have power
Policies ultimately
Matter much, much more
 
As summer passes
The transition to autumn
Should see prices rise

 

Adding to the cacophony of new information were comments from BOJ Governor Ueda that he believes the central bank may achieve its inflation target by late summer or early autumn as the impact of the recent wage negotiations begins to feed into the economy.  This story, Ueda’s first comments since the BOJ raised rates last month, has helped revive the yen bulls’ confidence that…this time it’s different!  Given the enormous size of the short yen positions outstanding, it is very possible that we see a sudden, sharp rise in the currency, but for the outcome to be more permanent, we will need to see much more aggressive BOJ tightening, or much more aggressive Fed easing.  Right now, I don’t believe either is in the cards, at least not until winter at the earliest.  This is especially true since when asked about the BOJ’s balance sheet, he indicated there was no reason for an immediate adjustment (sale) to ETF positions or their current, continued, ¥60 billion per month of JGB purchases.

Which brings us to this morning, when the monthly payroll report is set to be released at 8:30.  The latest consensus forecasts are as follows:

Nonfarm Payrolls200K
Private Payrolls160K
Manufacturing Payrolls5K
Unemployment Rate3.9%
Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (4.1% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours34.3
Participation Rate62.5%
Source: tradingeconomics.com

We have seen three consecutive reports above 200K, albeit replete with all types of revisions.  However, 200K new jobs per month is historically, a pretty good outcome.  It is certainly not indicative of a major decline in economic activity.  As well, yesterday’s Initial Claims data, at 221K, while a few thousand higher than expected, remains in a very comfortable place from the perspective of economic growth.  The point is the Fed’s concern over sticky inflation makes perfect sense when looking at these numbers.  After all, if people continue to work, they will continue to spend.

As it happens, my take today is we are setting up for a potential large ‘good news is bad’ type day and vice versa.  If the headline number is above 200K, and especially if the Unemployment Rate were to dip lower by a tick or two, I suspect that traders will quickly assume that the hawks are in control and any probability of a rate cut by June will dissipate.  Equity markets will not like this, nor will bond markets.  However, the dollar should continue to perform and, ironically, I see commodities doing the same thing.  We shall see how it plays out.

A quick recap of the overnight session shows that yesterday’s US selloff set the tone with declines throughout Asia (Nikkei -2.0%, China still closed) and Europe (DAX -1.45%, CAC -1.4%) as concerns grow regarding the future of monetary policy.  US futures, though, are modestly higher ahead of the data at this hour (7:00).

Ahead of the release, Treasury yields have reversed half of yesterday’s decline, currently higher by 2bps, and we are seeing similar movement across Europe with all markets seeing yields rise by between 1bp and 3bps.  Yesterday the ECB released their ‘minutes’ explaining they had seen further progress in their mission and the key elements, but that was before oil rebounded 10% from levels seen back then.  As has become the norm everywhere, there continues to be conflicting data and price movement clouding the picture for future policy actions.

Speaking of oil, this morning it is holding onto its gains from yesterday with WTI above $86/bbl and Brent crude at $91/bbl.  The ongoing tensions in the Middle East are clearly not helping things here as concerns grow that Iran is going to retaliate more directly to Israel’s actions earlier in the week, killing a senior Iranian general in Syria.  Of course, the entire combination of events continues to support gold prices, which are little changed this morning, but have absorbed all the selling pressure anyone can muster.  Copper and aluminum are also firmer this morning as the commodity sector seems on a mission right now.

Finally, the dollar is a touch higher this morning heading into the data.  While it has backed off its recent highs from Tuesday, the DXY remains above 104 and USDJPY remains above 151.  With that in mind, we must note ZAR (+0.65%) which continues to benefit from the rally across the entire metals complex and NOK (+0.3%) which is clearly benefitting from oil’s recent performance.  However, traders here are all anxiously awaiting this morning’s number alongside everyone else for more clarity on the next direction of travel.

Aside from the data this morning, we hear from three more Fed speakers to round out the week.  While Barkin is a repeat from yesterday, we also get some new perspectives from Boston’s Collins and Governor Bowman.  Yesterday’s market response to the hawkish views was quite surprising to me as I was very sure that Powell had set the tone.  If today’s data points to strength, do not be surprised to see equities sell off further alongside bonds.  However, a weak number is likely to signal the all-clear for the bulls to get back to business.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Limited Sellin’

Posted on by

After the data on Friday
Powell said, rushing’s not my way
Rates, we’ll still lower
If growth turns out slower
Least that’s what the punditry might say
 
Forget any thoughts about hikes
Old ideas that nobody likes
Other than Yellen
Limited sellin’
Suggests there will be no yield spikes

 

“The fact that the US economy is growing at such a solid pace, the fact that the labor market is still very, very strong, gives us the chance to just be a little more confident about inflation coming down before we take the important step of cutting rates.”

When Chairman Powell expressed this sentiment Friday morning, my take was he was seeking to give himself an out.  One way to read it is, since the economy remains strong, higher for longer isn’t killing us.  However, my first reading of the statement was that since the economy is strong, they can confidently cut rates.  Perhaps it is my confusion, or perhaps it is simply a badly constructed statement of the first view, but regardless, my confidence in the process has not been enhanced.

Friday’s PCE data was released pretty much in line with expectations but that is not as helpful as you might think given expectations were for a continued rebound in the numbers.  The fact that Powell is not more vociferously calling for a tougher stance is the most important piece of the puzzle.  This is what tells me that he has abandoned the 2% target.  While he will never officially admit that is the case, it has become increasingly clear that to achieve that goal, the Fed will need to push much harder on the economy and possibly drive a recession.  My read is that there are very few FOMC members who are willing to accept that tradeoff, especially in a presidential election year.

Right now, as Q2 begins, there is still time to see inflation data ebb closer to their target and allow that June rate cut that he seems to be promising.  But if the data between now and then, which includes three NFP reports, three CPI reports and two more PCE reports, does not cooperate and continues to show economic strength and sticky, if not building, price pressures, Powell and friends are going to have a very hard case to make with regards to any rate cuts.  And this really cuts to the chase as it is increasingly clear that the Fed’s true goal is not to reduce inflation, but to reduce interest rates so government borrowing becomes cheaper.  If the Treasury is going to continue to flood the market with T-bills rather than coupons (see chart below from BofA Global Research), the Fed has the ability to reduce their interest costs directly.  I expect that the pressure to do so is immense and growing.  The Fed remains in a precarious position given their credibility is on the line and so much of it is dependent on things outside their control.

There continues to be a yawning gap between views on the economy in the analyst community.  One camp remains firmly committed to the soft or no-landing scenario, expecting ongoing economic growth as inflation magically fades away (the so-called immaculate disinflation).  The other camp sees a recession on the horizon, if not already arrived, as when breaking down the data, they are able to find key aspects which indicate growth is slowing rapidly.  Right now, my guess is Powell is praying for the recession to appear more clearly, so he has a good reason to cut rates because otherwise, any rate cuts are going to be much more difficult to explain.

Beyond the Fed story, the news overnight was about China and Japan as PMI data from the former showed unexpected strength (Caixin Manufacturing PMI to 51.1) while the latter saw a mixed picture with the PMI data rising to 48.2, but still below the key 50.0 level, while the Quarterly Tankan data had some good news for large manufacturers and not-so-good news for small manufacturers.  With all of Europe still closed for the Easter holiday, a look at the markets open in Asia shows that the Nikkei (-1.4%) found no joy in the data and the index slipped back below the 40K level.  However, Chinese shares rose (+1.6%) on the data as it seems any read of recent commentary from the nation’s leaders indicates more fiscal support is on its way.

Bond markets, too, are closed throughout Europe and so the overnight saw only JGB yields edge up 1bp, Chinese yields follow suit, rising 1bp while Treasury yields are higher by 3bps this morning.  My take is there is limited information in these movements given the overall lack of market activity.

In the commodity markets, oil prices are unchanged to start the day, although they rose more than 6% in March, so there is clearly upside pressure there.  But once again, the star is gold (+0.75%) which is at another new all-time high as it seems an increasing number of investors and traders are becoming more concerned over the ongoing flood of liquidity entering the markets.  This strength is gold is mirrored today in silver, copper and aluminum as the desire to own ‘stuff’ rather than paper continues to grow.

Finally, the dollar continues to be in demand versus essentially all its major counterparts.  With Europe out of the office today, movement has been muted, but it is firmer against every one of its G10 counterparts with NOK (-0.55%) and SEK (-0.5%) the laggards, while it remains stronger vs. most of its EMG counterparts, although ZAR (+0.3%) is benefitting from the strong rally in gold and precious metals.  When looking at the macro situation around the world, right now, the US remains the proverbial cleanest shirt in the dirty laundry and so has the lowest case to cut interest rates.  I believe the ECB and BOE (and BOC and Riksbank, etc.) will all be cutting before the Fed and the dollar will benefit accordingly.  However, as I have maintained for a long time, if the Fed starts cutting with inflation remaining well above target, the dollar will decline sharply.

Looking at the data this week shows we have much to anticipate, culminating in Friday’s NFP report:

TodayISM Manufacturing48.4
 ISM Prices Paid52.6
 Construction Spending0.6%
TuesdayJOLTS Job Openings8.79M
 Factory Orders1.0%
WednesdayADP Employment130K
 ISM Services52.6
ThursdayInitial Claims214K
 Continuing Claims1822K
 Trade Balance-$67.0B
FridayNonfarm Payrolls200K
 Private Payrolls160K
 Manufacturing Payrolls5K
 Unemployment Rate3.9%
 Average Hourly Earnings 0.3% ((4.1% Y/Y)
 Average Weekly Hours34.3
 Participation Rate62.5%
 Consumer Credit$16.5B

Source: tradingeconomics.com

In addition to the data, we hear from 15 different FOMC members across 18 speeches this week.  This includes Chairman Powell on Wednesday as he discusses the Economic Outlook at the Stanford Business, Government and Society Forum.  By the time he speaks, we will have seen the ISM and ADP data, but my guess is that nothing is going to change his mind right now.  At this stage, hotter data is the Fed’s real problem as it will make cutting rates that much more difficult.  The Atlanta Fed’s latest GDPNow reading ticked up to 2.3% for Q1, certainly not indicating a slowdown is coming.  Sit back and get your popcorn out, it is going to be interesting to watch the Fed explain why rate cuts are needed if the data continues along its recent trend.

Good luck

Adf

Whispers in the Wind

Posted on by 
Whispers in the wind
Imply rates may be rising
Sooner than we thought

In the wake of Friday’s noncommittal payroll data, which I will discuss below, the topic garnering the most interest this morning is the BOJ and whether they will be adjusting monetary policy one week from today rather than in April.  There have been several articles published on the topic which is usually a sign that the BOJ is floating trial balloons.  At this point, the market is pricing about a 2/3 probability of a move next week based on current Japanese OIS swap data.  That is a significant increase compared to the pricing just two weeks ago.  In addition, we have seen a number of analysts from the major Japanese banks move their call to March from April previously

You may recall that a key discussion point on this subject has been the Spring wage negotiations and whether the new round will embed higher wages into the economy.  Last week I mentioned that Rengo, one of the labor associations, was seeking a 5.85% increase, which would be the largest such move in more than 30 years.  As it happens, the results will be released this coming Friday, so if the outcome is high enough, arguably Ueda-san and the BOJ would have enough information for a move.

One other interesting tidbit was the fact that last night, the BOJ remained out of the equity market despite the fact that the TOPIX (Japan’s other major index) fell more than 2% in the morning session.  Ever since Covid and the market panics then, on every occasion when the morning session saw the index decline that much, the BOJ was a buyer in the afternoon.  While this was not an official policy per se, it was the reality.  The upshot is that the BOJ is the largest holder of Japanese stocks in the world, owning something on the order of 8% of the market.  The fact that despite that decline, they changed their response could well be a tell that other changes are coming.

In the end, I would argue it matters less whether the first adjustment happens in March or April and more about just how far they are going to adjust policy.  I remain unconvinced that this is the beginning of a true normalization of monetary policy, or perhaps more accurately, that the BOJ is going to raise rates to bring them in line with the rest of the G10.  Rather, my sense is we will get to 0.0% at the first move, and that over the ensuing years, a move to even 0.3% in the overnight market will be difficult to achieve absent a major explosion of economic growth alongside rapidly rising inflation.  And frankly, I just don’t see that happening at all.

Keep this in mind, 2-year JGB yields, which have been edging higher steadily for the past two months, are still at only 0.2%.  That is not a sign that the market is expecting a dramatic increase in Japanese policy rates anytime soon.  Since the beginning of the month, the yen has rallied about 2.65% on this story.  Can it go much further?  Certainly, there is room for further strength given its performance over the past several years.  However, I would argue that will rely on the Fed cutting rates, and doing so aggressively, to truly narrow the yield differential.  And right now, I just don’t see that happening.

On Friday, the payroll report
In some ways, came up rather short
While headlines were strong
Revisions felt wrong
For rate hikes, more folks, to exhort

By now, you are aware that despite a much stronger than forecast headline NFP print of 275K, (exp 200K), the revisions to the prior two months were -167K, which took the luster off the headline and reverted the revision story back to negative from the surprising positive result last month.  In addition, the Unemployment Rate rose 2 ticks to 3.9% and Average Hourly Earnings only rose 0.1% on the month.  The market response here was interesting, to say the least.  While Treasury yields continued their recent slide, perhaps anticipating Fed action sooner rather than later, the equity market sold off as well, although that easily could have been simple profit taking after a huge run higher.  Of more interest is the fact that NY Fed President Williams, the last Fed speaker before the quiet period started, sounded just a touch more dovish than a number of the speakers we heard last week.

At this point, market participants are focused on a couple of things I think, with the next big thing tomorrow’s CPI print.  Thursday brings Retail Sales and then, of course, the FOMC statement and Powell presser is the following Wednesday.  June remains the odds-on favorite for the first Fed cut but that is subject to change based on tomorrow’s data.  If CPI indicates that the January number was not an aberration, and that inflation is actually stickier than many (want to) believe, I would not be surprised to see the median dot plot expectations rise to only 2 rate cuts in 2024. That is substantially fewer than the current estimate of 4+.  That will have a significant impact on markets if that is the case.  Alternatively, a very soft number tomorrow could easily bring May back onto the table for the first rate cut and may alter the dot plot in the other direction.  We shall see,

As the market awaits all the upcoming news, here’s what happened overnight.  Along with the slide in Japanese shares, most Asian markets sold off, all in the wake of Friday’s weak US equity performance.  The one exception was China, where both the Hang Seng (+1.4%) and CSI 300 (+1.25%) rallied at the end of the Chinese National People’s Congress as hopes for more stimulus remain high. In Europe, bourses are all in the red, although the declines have not been excessive, just -0.25% to -0.5%.  And at this hour (7:45), US futures are pointing slightly lower, -0.2% across the board.

In the bond market, yields are generally little changed in both treasury and European sovereign markets with all eyes on tomorrow’s data.  Last week’s ECB meeting didn’t really add too much to the conversation although it appears that expectations are cementing around a June rate cut, regardless of the Fed’s actions.  Overnight, JGB yields edged another 2bp higher, which given the increased scrutiny on a March rate hike is not that surprising.

In the commodity markets, oil (-0.5%) is sliding a bit and generally remaining right in the middle of its $75-$80 trading range for the past month.  Meanwhile, gold, while little changed this morning, is holding onto its recent gains and showing no signs of slipping back soon.  As to the base metals, copper (+0.3%) is edging higher while aluminum is unchanged on the day.  These metals markets are looking toward China to get a sense of the chances for fresh new demand.

It can be no surprise that the dollar is largely unchanged this morning with very modest gains and losses across both the G10 and EMG blocs.  In the G10, JPY (+0.3%) is the biggest mover with the rest of the bloc +/-0.1% on the day and giving no signal.  In the EMG bloc, KRW (+0.5%) is the largest mover, although it is not clear what would have driven the move as equities there fell pretty sharply overnight.  Also, CNY (+0.15%) is rallying after CPI data released over the weekend showed a monthly rise of 1.0% and that brought the Y/Y number back into positive territory at +0.7%.

On the data front, there is some other interesting data aside from CPI as follows:

TuesdayCPI0.3% (3.1% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.4% (3.7% Y/Y)
ThursdayInitial Claims218K
 Continuing Claims1911K
 Retail Sales0.7%
 -ex autos0.4%
 PPI0.3% (1.2% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (2.0% Y/Y)
 Business Inventories0.2%
FridayEmpire State Manufacturing-7.5
 IP0.0%
 Capacity Utilization78.4%
 Michigan Sentiment76.6

Source tradingeconomics.com

However, while there is a bunch of stuff coming out, I suspect that after CPI, it will all be anticlimactic.  As we are in the Fed quiet period, there will be no commentary, although in the wake of the CPI report, look for anything in the WSJ from the current Fed whisperer, Nick Timiraos.  This is especially so if the numbers are far from expectations.

In the end, today ought to be very quiet overall, with all eyes on tomorrow.  From there we shall see.

Good luck

Adf

Not Very Far

Posted on by

Said Jay, we are not very far
From when we can all wave au revoir
To higher for longer
With confidence, stronger,
Inflation will reach our lodestar
 
“We’re waiting to become more confident that inflation is moving sustainably at 2%.  When we do get that confidence — and we’re not far from it — it’ll be appropriate to begin to dial back the level of restriction.”  So said Chairman Powell yesterday in front of the Senate Banking Committee in response to some of the questions he received.  Nuff said!  Regardless of the fact that there has been limited indication of slowing economic activity (although this morning’s payroll report will be critical), it seems quite clear that Powell is under a great deal of pressure to reduce rates.  One must assume this pressure comes from the White House as in last night’s SOTU speech, President Biden even mentioned that mortgage rates were too high, and he was going to push them down.  Clearly, the only tool that Biden has is to lean on Powell to cut rates.
 
But despite what had appeared to be a concerted effort by every Fed speaker to push back against the proximity of the first interest rate cut for this cycle, it appears that Powell is blinking.  Interestingly, while the Fed funds futures markets didn’t really adjust very much, we did see the 2yr Treasury yield fall back 5bps and this morning it sits slightly below 4.50%, its first time back to this level since the surprising CPI print last month.  Of course, equity markets love the message, and we continue to see new highs on a daily basis.  But we are also continuing to see new highs in the anti-fiat monies, gold and bitcoin.  The world is not without risk.
 
An angry old fella named Joe
Last night tried explaining our woe
Was not his, to blame
Though he wouldn’t name
The culprit, throughout the whole show
 
While I try to leave politics out of this missive, the status of the SOTU is such that I don’t believe it can be completely ignored.  My takeaway from last night’s speech was that President Biden, in an attempt to show vigor, came across as the angry old man shaking his fist and yelling at the clouds.  He had a laundry list of things he claims to want to accomplish, all of which will cost trillions of dollars, and none of which are likely to be enacted before the election.  Many pundits pointed out this seemed more like a campaign speech than a SOTU and I think there is merit in that view.  In the end, while we understand where the pressure on Powell is coming from, I don’t believe this is going to change anything, certainly not from a market perspective.
 
And finally, it’s time to turn
To data for which we all yearn
The Payroll report
Which, if it falls short
Will likely give hawks great heartburn

Looking ahead, this morning brings the monthly payroll report.  Current median expectations are as follows:

Nonfarm Payrolls200K
Private Payrolls160K
Manufacturing Payrolls10K
Unemployment Rate3.7%
Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (4.4% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours34.3
Participation Rate62.6%

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Recall, last month’s number was massively higher than anticipated at 353K and had higher revisions as well.  The revisions were almost more surprising than the headline number as the trend for the entire previous year had been for revisions to be to softer data.  There will certainly be revisions to the January data as well, so there is a great deal of uncertainty.  My sense is, though, that the market really wants to see a softer number with downward revisions as that will work toward cementing the case for the Fed to cut rates even sooner.  Sub 150K and look for a bond and stock rally.  Above 250K and bonds will sell off, although stocks have a life of their own.  At least that’s one man’s view.

Ok, let’s look at how things played out overnight ahead of this key data.  Asian markets followed the US rally with green across the screen.  The Hang Seng, which is seen as the tech proxy in Asia, rallied most, 0.75%. Europe, on the other hand, is having a tougher day with most markets slightly softer although the FTSE 100 is down -0.5%, the clear laggard this morning.   Apparently, Madame Lagarde’s comments did nothing to support the hopes that rate cuts were coming soon as ostensibly, rate cuts were not even discussed in the meeting and all signs point to June as the first time by which they will have confidence in the inflation story, if it is to come.  Meanwhile, US futures are pointing a bit lower, -0.3%, at this hour (8:00).

In the bond markets, Treasuries have edged lower another 1bp this morning and we are seeing yields across the board in Europe decline by between 2bps and 4bps.  I can’t tell if that is confidence in the ECB (doubtful) or belief that the ongoing decline in economic activity (Eurozone GDP in Q4 was confirmed at 0.0% Q/Q and 0.1% Y/Y) has simply encouraged investors that rates are going to fall with no chance of a backup.  Meanwhile, JGB yields were unchanged overnight despite the ongoing excitement(?) that the BOJ may raise rates a week from Monday.

Oil prices have retreated a bit (-0.6%) but are essentially range trading and have been for the past month.  However, the star of the commodity space continues to be the barbarous relic, with gold rallying another 0.3% this morning to yet another new all-time high.  As to the base metals, copper is unchanged this morning, but has been on a roll lately while aluminum is higher by 0.65%.  Metals investors are gaining confidence that not only is there going to be no landing in the US, but that China is going to stimulate more.

Finally, the dollar remains under pressure overall as yields continue to decline.  While the euro is a touch softer this morning, virtually every other G10 currency is firmer with JPY (+0.55%) leading the way.  Remember, too, that with FY end approaching for Japan, we will begin to see Japanese corporates repatriating funds which typically sees further yen strength.  Combine that seasonal activity with the relatively new BOJ hawkishness/Fed dovishness combination and the yen could rally a lot more.  After all, it has fallen a lot in the past two years!  But, while the G10 currencies are generally having a good day, the picture in the EMG bloc is far more mixed with BRL (-0.6%) the laggard after total credit in Brazil was shown to have fallen in January for the first time since the pandemic.  On the flipside, CLP (+1.0%) is rallying after a higher-than-expected CPI report (4.5%) has traders looking for tighter monetary policy than previously anticipated.

Aside from the payroll report, there is no other data to be released and there are no Fed speakers on the calendar.  Yesterday we did hear Cleveland Fed president Mester sound more hawkish, becoming the third FOMC member to discuss only 2 cuts this year, and I maintain that when the dot plot comes out, that could be the median view.  But for now, markets and investors remain euphoric about the apparent Powell dovishness, so that will be the driver absent a huge NFP this morning.  For the dollar, that will be bad news.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

What If?

Posted on by

What if inflation’s not dead
And set to go higher instead?
Can Fed funds still fall?
Well, that’s a tough call
If not, look for trouble ahead

 

As we await Tuesday’s latest CPI data, I thought it might be a good time to review how things currently stand on a macro basis.  As I am just an FX guy, I am not nearly smart enough to see through the headlines and determine what is wrong with the narrative story of Goldilocks.  However, I can look at the actual numbers and perhaps we can draw some conclusions from that data.

Let’s start with CPI, as that is the next shoe to drop.  Looking at the last twelve months of monthly data, we see the following results on both an original and adjusted basis:

 CPI m/mannualizedCPI m/m (adj)annualized
Dec-230.33.60.22.4
Nov-230.23.00.22.4
Oct-230.12.40.12.0
Sep-230.43.00.42.7
Aug-230.53.60.53.36
Jul-230.23.40.23.2
Jun-230.2 0.2 
May-230.1 0.1 
Apr-230.4 0.4 
Mar-230.1 0.1 
Feb-230.4 0.4 
Jan-230.5 0.5 
Data tradingeconomics.com, calculations @fx_poet

Since the January 2024 data hasn’t been released, there would ordinarily be no revision yet.  However, as I wrote last week, the BLS does an annual revision which lowered the December 2023 result by a tick.  

As you can see that one tick had a big impact on the annualization trend for the past 6 months, and especially the past 3 months (highlighted), reducing it substantially.  Now, given the imperfections of the measuring process, 0.1% is probably not significant in the broad scheme of things.  But oh boy, for the narrative, it is everything.  Prior to that revision, it was pretty easy for those who believe inflation has bottomed to highlight that turn higher in the annualization rate.  This was especially true given how much the ‘inflation is dead’ crowd was relying on just that point.  But now that turn looks like a dead-cat bounce and is not nearly so impressive.  Tuesday’s outcome will be quite interesting as anything that is soft will almost certainly encourage the doves to be calling for a March cut more aggressively, and just as certainly, we will see risk assets rally sharply as the dollar declines.  A hot print, though, 0.3 or more, will have the opposite impact.

What if the ‘conomy’s state
Was built by the deficit’s weight?
And actual growth
Ain’t fast, but more sloth
Will Janet, more spending create?

 

When looking at GDP data and Federal government expenditures, it becomes pretty easy to determine why GDP continues to percolate along so well.  Given that GDP = Consumption + Investment + Government + Net eXports (Y = C + I + G + NX), a quick look at the G component shows just how much support the government has been adding to the economy despite what has been recorded as strong growth.  Or perhaps, more accurately, this is why growth has been so strong.  The below chart shows the trend of government expenditures relative to total GDP growth.  I removed the Covid years because they are extremely volatile and confusing. However, looking at the trend since the GFC in 2008/2009, there has been a step change higher in the amount of government activity measured in the economy. 

Source: data FRED St Louis Fed, calculations @fx_poet

Given the current budget deficit is running > 7% of GDP and is projected to remain at least this high going forward, it is quite clear that there is a lot of nonorganic effort to raise the GDP measures.  Look at the sharp upward turn at the right side of the chart.  It appears that the administration will do everything they can to continue to show that the economy is strong.  

Of course, this is where the rubber meets the road.  If the administration continues to pump more government spending into the economy, can inflation really decline any further?  Remember, government spending is almost entirely consumption based, with limited investment at this time.  Even the CHIPS Act only created incentives for private companies to invest, it is not government investment per se.  The point is, pumping up consumption demand without adding productive capacity is very likely to drive prices higher.  And if anything, given this administration’s war on energy markets, they are discouraging investment in critical infrastructure.  It is hard to see how this plays out for a Goldilocks outcome.  Far more likely, in my view, is that they continue to pump as hard as possible, and prices start moving higher again.  Timing is everything in life, and perhaps they can work it out so price hikes are delayed until after the election, but I am skeptical given the vast incompetence this administration has shown in virtually every sphere in which it operates.

What if employment’s a mess
And actually in some distress?
Is JOLTS data real?
And what is the deal
With households, it’s hard to assess

 

The last big macro area is, of course, the employment situation.  We all know that the NFP report was much stronger than expected for January, rising 353K, but also seeing upward revisions of the previous months for the first time in quite a while.  In fact, one of the bearish stories had been that the revisions mattered more than the headline data, and if revisions were for the worse, that was indicative of a slowing economy.  

Remember, too, that the US employment situation is measured in two ways, via the establishment survey which is a survey of companies’ (both large and small) actual hiring activity and leads to the NFP number, and the household survey, which is a telephone survey of ~60,000 households and asks the question if someone is employed and if not, whether they are looking for work.  The Unemployment Rate is calculated from the household survey, so both are clearly critical in assessing the situation on the ground.  

The funny thing is that the numbers come across pretty differently when you dig down.  While in the long-term, both data series have shown a strong correlation (96% since January 2000), the Household survey is far more volatile and in the past year has been telling a somewhat different story than the establishment survey.  Look at this chart below mapping each since the beginning of 2023:

Source: data FRED St Louis Fed, calculations @fx_poet

Doing the math shows that the establishment survey claims that 3.409 million jobs were created while the Household survey comes in at just over half that amount, 1.852 million jobs.  Now, in a nation of 330 million people, especially given the expansion of the gig economy and the dramatic changes in employment overall, maybe that is not such a big deal.  As well, simply looking at the two lines shows that the Household survey is far more volatile than the Establishment survey.  Does this mean we should ignore the household survey, given it seems to have more noise and less signal?  The problem with this is the household survey drives the Unemployment Rate, and nobody is willing to ignore that.  And these differences beg the question, is the employment situation as rosy as it seems?  With the Unemployment rate remaining so low for so long, it certainly appears that there is ample demand for workers.  Of course, that also implies that the cost of labor seems unlikely to decline very much and could well increase further and faster.  If that is the case, the impact will be seen in the inflation data as well.

Trying to sum things up here, looking at the three critical macro variables, inflation, growth and employment, there is a strong case to be made that the combination of ongoing government support and continued demand for labor into an aging workforce can lead to solid nominal GDP growth with inflation remaining far stickier than many currently anticipate.  If that is the situation, all the hopes and dreams of the interest rate doves may be delayed, if not destroyed, as it will be increasingly difficult for the Fed to ease policy into an inflationary environment.  Arguably, this is why they are seeking greater confidence that inflation is really dead.  

Now, maybe Goldilocks is real, and inflation will continue to decline on its own because…well just because.  But I find it hard to look at the data and conclude that lower inflation is our future, at least for any length of time.

Ok, this has gotten much longer than I intended but fortunately, absolutely nothing of note happened overnight in markets.  Literally.  There has been de minimis movement in stocks, bonds, commodities and currencies, and there is a distinct lack of data to be released today.  Tomorrow’s CPI is THE number of the week, so perhaps that will get the juices flowing again and drive some movement.  Until then, a quiet day is usually a good one on which to establish hedges.

Good luck

Adf

Not Quite Mawkish

Posted on by

On Friday, in quite the surprise
Our payrolls did massively rise
At least that’s what printed
But where those jobs minted?
Or will, next month’s data revise?
 
Perhaps Chairman Jay had a sense
And that’s why his press confer-ence
Was ever so hawkish
Although not quite mawkish
So, traders, more buys, did commence

 

I would contend that nobody was anticipating the NFP data on Friday which printed so much higher than forecasts it was remarkable.  A headline number of 353K with a revision up for December of 116K is huge and certainly puts paid to any thoughts of the economy slowing.  As well, Average Hourly Earnings rose a more than expected 0.6%, certainly good for workers, but another nail in the coffin of a quick rate cut by the Fed.  Of course, none of that seems to matter anymore to equity investors as despite every indication that given the recent data, the Fed will remain higher for longer, stocks rocked higher.  Bonds did not fare quite as well, though, as 10-year yields rocketed 15bps higher by the close.

Another interesting anomaly was in the Fed funds futures market where in the immediate wake of the FOMC meeting, the probability of a March rate cut (which you may recall Powell specifically took off the table) fell to 20% from a coin toss earlier.  But Friday, that closed back at 38%! (PS, this morning it is down to 15.5%, so remains quite volatile.)  Rounding out the asset classes, the dollar followed yields, with the euro falling nearly 1% and other currencies close behind.  As to oil, that slid about $1, but it has been softening all week, so there are obviously other issues there.  What gives?

The first thing to recall is that January data tends to be pretty sloppy.  My good friend, Mike Ashton (aka @inflation_guy) made the point eloquently as follows:

This is not to say that the adjustments WILL be huge, just that over time, that has been the case.  Recall that almost every reading last year was revised lower in subsequent reports.  All I’m saying is that as terrific as that number was, add at least a pinch of salt, I think.

The other thing that doesn’t seem to square is that so many other employment indicators are trending in the opposite direction.  After all, ADP was only 107K, and the employment reading in the ISM fell last month along with the employment readings in many of the regional Fed surveys.  As well, continuing claims have been trending higher for the past several months, generally not a good sign for employment.  Again, all I am trying to highlight is that this number may not be quite as robust as it seems on the surface.  At the same time, for the Fed, if they need an excuse to leave policy at current levels, the combination of strong job growth and rising wages is plenty of ammunition.

Sunday night, Chairman Powell was interviewed on 60 Minutes but really didn’t tell us anything new.  Essentially, I would say he repeated his Wednesday press conference with one exception, he did, when asked, indicate that the current fiscal profligacy would be a problem in the long run.  To date, he has been reluctant to even discuss the issue, so perhaps that is a signal of something, but of what I have no idea.

Moving on from Friday, finally, the weekend saw the Biden administration’s retaliation for the deaths in Jordan of 3 US soldiers, however, that is not a market impactful event.  Coming into the new week, the Services PMI data has been released everywhere and we are awaiting ISM Services this morning in NY.  In aggregate, the data showed that some nations are doing better than others.  In the positive camp, India (61.8 final) was by far the nation with the highest reading, but Japan, China, Spain, Italy and the UK all showed growth above 50.  On the other side of the ledger, Australia, Germany, France and the Eurozone overall remain well below 50, although seem to have found a bottom for now.  As to the US, the current forecast is for a 52.0 print, up from December’s number of 50.6.

Is this really telling us that much?  Remember, the question that is asked in these surveys is, how do things compare this month to last month?  Remember, too, that recent data has shown weakness across the surveys with strength in the hard data.  Friday’s NFP is the perfect encapsulation of that idea.  Perhaps the one thing we can consider is that if today’s ISM is quite strong, it will be enough to completely remove March from the rate cut schedule.  Of course, my question is, if today’s data is strong, why exactly will the Fed feel the need to cut rates at all?  I simply do not understand this baseline assumption that interest rates are “too high”.  In fact, based on the evidence provided by GDP and NFP data, they seem to be just fine.  And, hey, isn’t it better for all of us to earn 5% in our Money Market Fund accounts than 0.0% like we did for years?  In fact, based on the common view that there are several trillion dollars of “excess” savings in the economy, it seems the holders of those savings must be quite happy with rates where they are.

Ok, let’s tour overnight market behavior quickly before we finish up.  In the equity space, Japanese stocks continue to rise with the Nikkei up another 0.5% while Chinese stocks continue to struggle.  While the CSI 300 managed a 0.6% gain, the small-cap CSI 1000 fell 8% as small cap stocks around the world remain unloved.  However, the Chinese government is definitely concerned as rumors of another rescue package are all over the tape.  As to Europe, modest gains are the order of the day, with most markets higher by about 0.25%.  meanwhile, US futures, they are ever so slightly softer at this hour (7:15), down about -0.1%.

Turning to the bond market, apparently everybody is turning away from the bond market!  Yields are higher across the board with Treasuries leading the way, up a further 7bps, but all European sovereign yields higher by between 3bps and 5bps as well.  The story in Asia was even more impressive with JGB’s (+5bps) and Australia (+12bps) all catching up to the Treasury story.  Ultimately, the issue I see is that while growth in the US remains strong, pretty much all of Europe is in recession.  This seems likely to lead to the ECB cutting rates before the Fed as they will have a reason to do so, while as I ask above, what is the Fed’s rationale for a cut?

The higher interest rate story has weighed heavily on commodity prices with oil sliding -0.8% this morning, although it has been falling for a week.  But we see metals prices under pressure as well with gold (-0.6%), copper (-0.4%) and aluminum (-0.6%) all sliding this morning amid the move in yields.

Not surprisingly, the dollar has been a major beneficiary of the higher yield story, following Friday’s sharp rally with a continuation across the board.  The euro is back to 1.0750, a level not seen since mid-November, while USDJPY is back above 148.50 and USDCNY above 7.21.  In fact, the only currency bucking the trend today is KRW (+0.4%) which managed to rally despite any obvious macro catalysts.  Equities fell there alongside Chinese stocks, so it was not investment inflow.  Sometimes, currencies just move, that much we know.

Turning to the data this week, there is much less on the docket than we saw last week with, arguably, today’s Services ISM the most important number.

TodayISM Services52.0
WednesdayTrade Balance-$62.2B
 Consumer Credit$15.0B
ThursdayInitial Claims220K
 Continuing Claims1902K

Source: tradingeconomics.com

However, we do hear from 10 different Fed speakers this week starting with Atlant’s Raphael Bostic and then inundated rhoguhout the week.  But I ask you, will they really stray far from Powell’s message?  Especially after the blowout NFP number?  Higher for longer still lives, and if we continue to get strong data, May will soon start losing its appeal for a rate cut.  This will not help the bond market, that’s for sure, but it will help the dollar.

Good luck

Adf

Beware

Posted on by

It wasn’t all that long ago
When Powell commanded the show
At least so it seemed
But maybe we dreamed
Those attributes we did bestow
 
But now traders seem not to care
That Wednesday, Chair Jay said beware
No rate cuts next meeting
Instead, they are treating
That warning’s though it wasn’t there
 
The upshot is bonds are on fire
And stocks turned around and went higher
Today’s NFP
Will help us to see
If Jay is still leading the choir

 

Well, it seems that Chair Powell’s hawkish message resonated with investors for about 12 hours, at which point they decided to forget all he said and side with Treasury Secretary Yellen and her spending plans.  Or maybe the trading community just doesn’t believe he can pull it off, keep policy rates at 5.5% while the government needs to borrow so much money.

There are other possible explanations as well.  The NYCB meltdown yesterday may have opened some eyes regarding the commercial real estate (CRE) problems that certainly exist everywhere in the world, but notably here in the US.  If reclassifying just two loans was enough for a $100 billion bank to cut their dividend completely and increase loan loss reserves nine-fold, what about all the other CRE loans that are also under pressure on other bank balance sheets?  Perhaps the bond market is sniffing out the next banking crisis in front of our eyes.  For the conspiracy theorists, the Fed did remove the following line from their statement yesterday, “The U.S. banking system is sound and resilient.”  Perhaps that was a hint that it is not sound and resilient.

Regardless of the driver, yesterday saw a ripping rally in the bond market with the 10-year yield touching 3.82% before bouncing, nearly as low as it reached following Powell’s ultra-dovish performance in December.  That certainly doesn’t square easily with the hawkish statement and comments on Wednesday.

I have no good explanation for the movements, and I would argue neither does anyone else.  As has been the case for the past year, at least, economic data is simply a Rorschach test for your underlying views and biases.  Once again, the financial markets appear to be fighting the Fed tooth and nail.  Perhaps one clue was the fact that gold prices rallied yesterday, as did bitcoin.  Now, it is possible that is simply because lower yields enhance the willingness to hold those assets, or perhaps it is because the market smells a banking crisis coming and wants to hide.

Fortunately, we get new and important information this morning with the release of the NFP data at 8:30.  Here are the current median forecasts:

Nonfarm Payrolls180K
Private Payrolls155K
Manufacturing Payrolls5K
Unemployment Rate3.8%
Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (4.1% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours34.3
Participation Rate62.4%
Factory Orders0.2%
Michigan Sentiment78.9

Source: tradingeconomics.com

As well, the BLS will be releasing their annual revisions to their data, so everything will be a mess.  However, traders, and trading algorithms, only ever look at the headlines.  The fact that 11 of the past 12 NFP numbers have been revised lower over time seems not to be a major concern to investors, although it is certainly not a positive signal for the economy writ large.

In the end, we are all beholden to this data point and the market’s reaction function.  Based on what we have seen since the FOMC meeting I would suggest that a weak number will be seen as risk-on because it will encourage more rate cut talk and bring March back into view.  (FYI, the current probability of a March cut according to the futures market is 34.5%.  Sub 100K and I would look for that to go back to 50% at least.)  At the same time, a strong print, > 200K, and I expect a risk-on response as it will encourage the earnings growth story and reduce the probability of a recession.  In fact, after the strong earnings reports from Meta and Apple last night, the only way I think we see a risk-off outcome today is if NFP is sharply negative, enough so it forces people to put recession back on their bingo cards.  We shall see.

In the meantime, a quick look at the overnight session shows that Asian equity markets are back on the buy Japan / sell China train with the CSI 300 falling to its lowest level since 2019 as investors remain unimpressed by Xi’s efforts to fix things in China.  But away from China, the rest of the markets in Asia all had good session, up between 0.5% and 1.5%.  In Europe, green is the theme as well with every market higher on average by 0.7% or so.  Not surprisingly given the earnings reports, US futures are green as well, with the NASDAQ +1.0% at this hour (7:10).

Bond markets are all over the map this morning.  Treasury yields are unchanged from the closing level yesterday, although they bounced 5bps from that intraday low print mentioned above.  As to European sovereigns, yields have edged higher by 1bp-2bps on the continent although UK Gilts are higher by 6bps which is a bit strange given the BOE yesterday seemed far more dovish than many expected.  While leaving rates on hold, they explained they expected inflation to temporarily get back to their 2% target in Q2 before bouncing a bit, and the vote included one vote to cut rates, 6 to maintain and 2 to raise, a more dovish tilt.  And yet here we are, with Gilts selling off.  If you were interested, JGB yields have fallen as well, down 2bps and falling away from any ideas of policy changes in Tokyo.

Oil is little changed this morning after getting crushed yesterday on unconfirmed rumors of a cease-fire in the Israel-Gaza conflict.  It seems the betting is that if there is a cease-fire, the Houthis will stop attacking ships in the Red Sea and things will improve everywhere.  However, as of yet, no cease-fire has been reached.  As to the metals markets, gold is little changed after a more than 1% rally yesterday, while both copper and aluminum are softer this morning, although the movements have been small and may be meaningless.

Finally, the dollar is a bit softer this morning with AUD (+0.5%) the leading G10 gainer on the back of the ASX 200 reaching a new all-time high closing level overnight.  But the movement here is broad and shallow, most currencies are a bit stronger vs. the dollar, but that 0.5% move is the largest by far.  My take is that as long as US yields remain under pressure, the dollar will be on its back foot as well.  Hence, a strong NFP this morning could see yields bounce and the dollar along with it.

And that is all we have today.  It has been quite a week between the QRA, the FOMC and Powell presser and now today’s NFP.  While there was a great deal of uncertainty as the week began, at this point, it seems clear that the market has decided that rates are coming lower regardless of what Powell has to say.  We have yet to hear from any other Fed speakers, although I imagine we will be getting a full dose next week.  And Sunday night, on 60 Minutes, Powell will be interviewed so that will be closely watched for any clues.  Until then…

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Ending QT

Posted on by

The lady from Dallas explained
The balance sheet might be constrained
So, ending QT
Is likely to be
The way the Fed’s goals are attained
 
However, investors ain’t sure
That ending QT is the cure
So, worries abound
As traders have found
Most stocks have now lost their allure

Over the weekend, Dallas Fed President Lorie Logan, whose previous role was head of markets at the NY Fed and so knows a thing or two about the monetary plumbing, explained in a speech that QT, at its current pace, is likely going to be too restrictive going forward.  While she threw in the obligatory line about the idea the Fed may still need to raise the Fed funds rate if inflation remains too robust, I would contend that this is another sign the Fed is coming to the end of its tightening regime.  She explained that the swift decline in the Reverse Repo (RRP) facility indicated there may be a significant decline in liquidity in markets and that could have a detrimental impact on equity prices the economy’s future path and derail the widely assumed soft-landing scenario.

For some context, the RRP facility peaked almost exactly one year ago, touching about $2.55 trillion as the Fed was paying more on excess reserves than was available in short-term paper and Treasury bills.  But as the government has flooded the market with T-bills of late, and there is no indication that pace is going to slow down, the yield on bills rose above the IOER rate the Fed was paying.  As such, money market funds have pushed funds from the RRP into purchasing bills and the RRP facility now has “just” $694 billion as of Friday.  A look at the chart below from the FRED database of the St Louis Fed shows the sharp downward trajectory of the facility’s balances.  But also notice that prior to March 2021, this facility basically was at $0 for its entire history.  My point is that this facility does not have a long history of supporting market activities or liquidity, rather it is a recent construct designed to help smooth out temporary fluctuations.  It’s just that the concept of temporary here seems akin to the Fed’s concept of transitory when it comes to inflation.

At any rate, the FOMC Minutes also mentioned the idea that QT would likely need to slow down, and the committee needed to discuss the proper timing of these things.  Logan’s comments were exactly in this vein as the Fed seem like they are working very hard to prepare market participants for the beginning of an easing cycle.  It’s kind of funny that throughout November and December, the Fed seemed a bit concerned that markets were overexuberant, but after a modest equity market sell-off to start the year, much of which can probably be put down to profit-taking on a tax advantaged* basis, they seem suddenly concerned that things are falling apart.

Logan’s comments were in the wake of Friday’s data which showed NFP stronger than expected, although another month of downward revisions for previous readings, and showed wages gaining a bit more than expected.  The initial move here was that further tightening was on the way, or certainly that easing was delayed, but then the ISM Services index was released at 10:00am and it was much worse than expected, 50.6, with the Employment sub-index printing at a horrible 43.7, its lowest level excluding the Covid months, and indicative that perhaps the job market is not quite so robust.  This helped unwind the tightening discussion and Friday’s markets ultimately closed little changed.

Which brings us to this morning, where the most noteworthy price action is in the commodity space with oil (-2.8%) sharply lower after Saudi Arabia cut its pricing indicating that demand is slow, and gold (-1.25%) falling sharply although a rationale there is far harder to find given the dollar is essentially unchanged on the day and it certainly doesn’t appear that peace is breaking out in either Israel/Gaza or in Ukraine.

While there has been a bit of data released from Europe, none of it was substantially different from expectations and it showed that the status quo remains there, overall, a weak Eurozone economy with prices still on the sticky side.  As well, there have been no speakers this morning which just leaves us all unsure of the next big thing.

Now, in fairness, we do have the next big data point coming on Thursday, CPI in the US, which I am assured by so many analysts is THE critical data point.  I was also confident that NFP was critical, so perhaps CPI will be less exciting than forecast.  In the meantime, a look at the rest of the overnight session shows that Japan was on holiday so there was no market activity, but Chinese shares have continued their weak ways, falling more than -1.3% across all the indices there.  It seems to me that despite some very real efforts to inculcate fear of China by certain politicians, President Xi has an awful lot of domestic issues to address.  European shares, though, are little changed with a few very modest gainers (DAX +0.15%) and a few very modest decliners (FTSE 100 -0.2%) and everything else in between.  US futures are softer this morning as the weekend story regarding Boeing’s 737 Max being grounded is weighing on the stock and the market as a whole.

In the bond market, Treasuries are unchanged on the day while European sovereigns are all seeing yields climb between 4bps and 5bps.  This move seems like a catch-up to Friday’s US price action, which if you remember saw a sharp decline in yields early and a rebound later on.  Ultimately, this space will continue to be driven by the central banks with the Fed funds futures market still pricing in a > 60% probability of a 25bp cut in March with Europe seen likely to follow shortly thereafter.

Having already touched on commodities, a look at the dollar shows that while the euro, pound and yen are all little changed, there is a bit more movement in the dollar’s favor amongst some less liquid currencies with AUD (-0.4%), NOK (-0.85% on weak oil prices) and KRW (-0.4%) leading the way.  I continue to see the FX markets as an afterthought to the broad economic picture right now but have not changed my view that if the Fed does lead the way in easing policy, the dollar is likely to slide.

On the data front, here is what this week brings:

TodayConsumer Credit$9B
TuesdayNFIB Small Biz Optimism91.0
 Trade Balance-$65.0B
ThursdayInitial Claims210K
 Continuing Claims1853K
 CPI0.2% (3.2% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (3.8% Y/Y)
FridayPPI0.1% (1.3% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (1.9% y/Y)

Source: tradingeconomics.com

As well, we do hear from several Fed speakers this week starting with Bostic today and then Williams and Kashkari as the week progresses.  At this stage, I expect that we are likely to see less volatility as my guess is most profit adjustments have been made and all eyes are turned to CPI on Thursday.  Until then, it is likely to be a dull week (famous last words!)

Good luck

Adf

*This tax advantage is simply that taxes will not be due until April 2025, so perhaps tax deferred is a better description.

Quite Frail

Posted on by

While everyone’s waiting to see
How high or low payrolls might be
The news from elsewhere
Is starting to wear
Quite thin, look at China’s Zhongzhi
 
This bankruptcy sounds the alarm
That others there might come to harm
The soft-landing tale
Which still is quite frail
Has started to lose its quaint charm

Before we start on the payroll report, I think it is important to mention a significant issue that was revealed last night in China, where Zhongzhi, one of the largest non-bank financial and investment companies on the mainland, filed for bankruptcy and liquidation.  It has been missing both interest and principal payments for the past several months and it simply became too great a problem to ignore any longer.  The data released indicates that the company had ~$31 billion more in liabilities than assets and has become one of the largest bankruptcies in China’s history.  

The company was a major player in the property market there, although its main business was high yielding investment products, essentially structured notes, where much of the property backed collateral has fallen dramatically in value and where cash flows that had underpinned the notes have now ceased amid the property collapse.  This is hardly an advertisement for the Chinese economy and another sign that things there remain in a downtrend.  While the renminbi is marginally firmer this morning, up 0.2%, that is a consequence of the PBOC establishing the CFETS fixing at a much stronger than expected level in their effort to prevent substantial weakness in the currency.  

The upshot is that the Chinese economy remains in difficult straits, and the government’s reluctance to increase fiscal support is being felt everywhere.  (On the other hand, the PBOC has added $600 billion in liquidity to the economy in the past week.)  Ongoing weakness in Europe is another problem for Chinese exporters and the ongoing disagreements and tariff wars with the US simply add additional pressure to President Xi.  Next Saturday the first big election of 2024 will be held, in Taiwan, and if the incumbent party retains control, currently the betting favorite, Xi may find himself with quite a few problems to address this year.  A weak economy, rising geopolitical tensions globally and a rejection of his entreaties to the people of Taiwan is a bad look for a megalomaniacal dictator like Xi.  Just sayin’.

OK, let’s turn to this morning’s big story, the NFP report.  Here are the analyst consensus estimates according to tradingeconomics.com:

Nonfarm Payrolls170K
Private Payrolls130K
Manufacturing Payrolls5K
Unemployment Rate3.8%
Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (3.9% Y/Y)
Average Weekly Hours34.4
Participation Rate62.7%
ISM Services 52.6
Factory Orders2.1%

Now, yesterday we saw two other pieces of employment data, the ADP (164K and much higher than expected) and Initial Claims (202K and much lower than expected).  These numbers have many in the market looking for a strong print although the correlation between ADP and NFP has been underwhelming for quite a while.  While we can discuss the merits of the estimates and the overall strength of the economy, I think we are better served, this morning, to focus on the potential impacts of a given number and how that has been evolving so far this week/year.

This morning, the 10-year yield is up to 4.04%, some 25bps above the lows touched post-Christmas, and starting to indicate that some people are having second thoughts on the idea of the Fed aggressively cutting rates this year.  As an example, while I never believed there to be a chance of a rate cut at the end of January, the market was pricing a 17.5% chance of that just a week ago.  This morning the probability is down to 4.7%.  As well, just last week the market was pricing in 6 rate cuts in 2024.  That is now down to 5 cuts and fading. One of the big stories around this morning is that someone has put on a very large option position expiring later today that the 10-year yield will be above 4.15%.  To profit, this trade will require one of the largest yield moves seen in months.

The point is that the nirvana belief set that had been driving markets since the beginning of November is clearly under a significant amount of pressure here.  After all, the NASDAQ has had 5 consecutive negative closes, bond yields, as mentioned, have rallied sharply and are breaking through short-term technical resistance, the dollar is rallying, and the bulls are feeling quite unloved.

Is this the end of the bull story?  Frankly I don’t believe that is the case.  However, risk assets got a bit overexuberant during November and December and have come a long way in a short time.  It is not surprising to see a retracement of prices to help unwind some of the froth.  Ultimately, I believe the question that matters in the medium and long term is the state of the economy and whether the recent growth trajectory will continue, or if we have peaked for now.

One of the things that has me concerned in the medium term is the fact that the government continues to run a massive fiscal deficit despite what appears to be a reasonably strong economy.  Recall, Keynes instructed governments to spend during recession, but tighten their belts during good times.  However, the new mantra is far more in line with Modern Monetary Theory, which is spend as much as you can at all times.  

A quick thought experiment regarding the underlying economy might look like this: GDP = $27 trillion, Federal spending = $10 trillion, Federal deficit = $1.7 trillion.  What if the government didn’t run a deficit, but was neutral?  Removing that much stimulus from the economy would have a significant negative impact on the US economy’s growth trajectory, which is the reason no politician wants to do that.  But the question at hand is how healthy is the economy on its own?  And are growth prospects there really that substantial?  One of the keys to the recent employment picture is that government jobs continue to grow rapidly (look at the gap between NFP and private payrolls).  As long as the US government can continue to borrow money cheaply to fund its profligate ways, it is completely realistic to expect the economy to continue to grow.  However, the reason the bond market story is so important is that the bond market is the place where it will become clear if this is possible.  If Treasury yields continue their recent climb, the pressure on the economy will increase, and the pressure from the government on the Fed to support the bond market will increase.  Forget ending QT.  If the Fed were to find itself in a place where they needed to restart QE to support the bond market, that would be an incredibly important signal that inflation was going to accelerate again, and likely commodity prices would follow.  That would also be a very negative sign for the dollar.  So, lower bonds, lower dollar, higher commodities and likely a nominal rise in equities, at least initially.  My point is there is much about which we need be concerned and wary.

In the quickest of recaps possible, equities around the world have mostly been under pressure with only Japan managing to rally but weakness in China and across all of Europe.  The same is true with US futures, all in the red this morning by about -0.3%.

Bond yields are also rising around the world (except in Japan) with gains on the order of 6bps-8bps across the continent, similar to what we saw in Australia overnight. 

Oil prices are rebounding this morning, up 1.3%, despite much larger than expected inventory builds shown in yesterday’s IEA data, but the metals markets are continuing under pressure for now with the base metals weak and gold edging lower.

And finally, the dollar is continuing its rebound led by USDJPY, where the yen is down a further 0.4% and back above 145 for the first time since early December.  In the G10 space, I would say the movement has been about -0.3% overall, but in the EMG space, things are a bit more active with average declines here of about -0.7% across the three main geographic blocs.

That’s really it.  Now we just wait for the payroll report and later this morning the ISM Services number, and then we get to hear from Tom Barkin again, but it would be shocking if his view changed from just two days ago.  For some reason, I have a feeling the payroll data will fall short this morning, but that’s just a feeling.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf