Tag Archives: investing

Remarkable Fragility

Posted on by

JGB yields have
Risen to multi-year heights
Is this why stocks fell?

 

Yesterday I highlighted that 10-year JGB yields had risen to their highest level since 2008.  As you can see below, the same is true for 30-year JGBs and essentially the entire curve there.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Ostensibly, this move was triggered by comments from BOJ Governor Ueda indicating that a rate hike was coming this month.  However, the thing I find more interesting is that this move in JGB yields has become the bête noire of markets, now being blamed for every negative thing that happened yesterday.  

For instance, Treasury yields yesterday rose 7bps despite ISM data indicating that manufacturing activity remains sluggish at best.  In fact, the initial response to that data was that it confirmed the Fed will be cutting rates next week.  But the narrative seems to be that Japanese investors are now willing to repatriate funds, selling Treasuries to buy JGBs, in order to invest locally because they are finally getting paid to do so.  Certainly, looking at the chart above shows that Japanese yields had been tantamount to zero for a long time prior to 2024, and even then, have only started to show any real value in the most recent few months.  Of course, real 10-year yields in Japan remain significantly negative based on the latest inflation reading of 3.0%.  The upshot is, rising JGB yields are deemed the cause of Treasury market weakness.

Turning to risk assets, the story is the same for both stocks (which saw US equities decline across the board yesterday) and cryptocurrencies, notably Bitcoin.  Ostensibly, the rise in yields, and the prospect of a rate hike by the BOJ (to just 0.75% mind you) has been cited as the driver of an unwinding in leveraged trades as hedge funds seek to get ahead of having their funding costs rise thus crimping their margins.  

There is no doubt in my mind that the yen has been a critical funding currency for a wide array of carry trades, that is true.  In fact, that has been the case for several decades.  But is 25 basis points really enough to destroy all the strategies that rely on that process?  If so, it demonstrates a remarkable fragility in markets, and one that portends much worse outcomes going forward.  

If we look at the relationship between Bitcoin and 10-year JGBs, it appears that there has been a significant change in tone.  For the past two months, while JGB yields have continued to climb, BTC has broken its correlation with JGBs and has fallen dramatically instead. (see below chart from tradingeconomics.com). When it comes to crypto, I am confident that leverage levels are higher than anywhere else, in fact that seems part of the attraction, so it should not be as surprising to see something of this nature.  But again, it speaks to a very fragile market situation given there was no discernible change in the Japanese yield trend to drive a Bitcoin adjustment.

The upshot here, too, is that rising JGB yields are claimed to be the reason Bitcoin is declining.  In fact, nearly all the commentary of late seems to be focusing on JGBs as the driver of everything.  While I concede that Japanese yields are an important part of the USDJPY discussion, it is difficult for me to assign them blame for everything else.  I have seen numerous commentators explaining that the Japanese have been selling Treasuries because they don’t trust the US, and this has been ongoing for years.  I have also seen commentators explain that because Japanese surpluses had been invested internationally for years and funding so much of the world’s activity, now that they can invest at home, liquidity everywhere will dry up, and asset prices will fall.  

Responding to the first issue, especially with new PM Sanae Takaichi, I do not believe that is a concern at all.  If anything, I expect that the relationship between the US and Japan will deepen.  As to the second issue, that may have more import but the one thing of which we can be sure is that central banks around the world will not allow liquidity to dry up in any meaningful fashion.  Remember, the Fed ended QT yesterday and it won’t be long before the balance sheet starts to grow again, adding liquidity to the system.  One thing I have learned in my many years observing and trading in markets is, there doesn’t need to be a catalyst for markets to move in an unexpected direction.  Certainly not a big picture catalyst.

And with that, let’s look at how markets responded overnight to yesterday’s risk-off session in the US.  Looking at the bond market first, yesterday’s rise in yields was nearly universal with European sovereigns all following the Treasury market’s lead.  And this morning, across the board sovereigns are higher by 1bp, the same as Treasury yields.  While JGB yields didn’t budge overnight, we did see Australia and other regional yields catch up to yesterday’s rise.  I fear bond investors are stuck as they see the potential for inflation, but they also see weakening economic activity as a moderator there.  As an example, the OECD just reduced its US GDP forecast for 2026 to 2.9% this morning, from 3.2%.  Personally, I don’t think anything has changed the run it hot scenario.

In the equity markets, Asian bourses were mixed with Korea (+1.9%) and Taiwan (+0.8%) the notable gainers while elsewhere movement was much less substantial (Japan 0.0%, HK +0.2%, China -0.4%).  There was no single story driving things there.  As to Europe, things are brighter this morning led by Spain (+1.0%) and Italy (+0.5%) although there is no single driving issue here either.  US futures are edging higher at this hour as well, +0.2%, so perhaps yesterday was more like a little profit taking after last week’s strong rally, than anything else.

In the commodity sector, oil (-0.3%) is slipping after yesterday’s rally.  I suppose the potential peace in Ukraine is bearish, but that story has been dragging on for a while so I’m not sure when it will come to fruition.  In the metals markets, after a gangbusters rally yesterday, with silver trading to $59/oz, we are seeing a modest retracement this morning across the board (Au -0.6%, Ag -1.2%, Pt -2.0%) although copper (+0.4%) is holding its gains.  Nothing indicates that these metals have topped.

Finally, the dollar is little changed as I write, giving back some early modest strength.  JPY (-0.3%) continues to be amongst the worst performers, and although it has bounced from its recent lows, remains within a few percent of those levels.  My take here is we will need to see both a more aggressive Fed and a more aggressive BOJ to get USDJPY back to 150 even, let alone further than that.  If we look at the DXY, it is sitting at 99.45, and still well within its trading range for the past 6+ months as per the below.  For now, the dollar remains a secondary story.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

On the data front, here’s what comes the rest of this week:

WednesdayADP Employment 10K
 IP0.1%
 Capacity Utilization77.3%
 ISM Services52.1
ThursdayInitial Claims220K
 Continuing Claims1960K
 Trade Balance -$65.5B
FridayPersonal Income (Sep)0.4%
 Personal Spending (Sep)0.4%
 PCE (Sep)0.3% (2.8% Y/Y)
 -ex food & energy0.2% (2.9% Y/Y)
 Michigan Expectations51.2
 Consumer Credit$10.5B

Source: tradingeconomics.com

As the Fed is in its quiet period, there are no Fed speakers until Powell at the presser next week.  Given the age of the PCE data, I don’t see it having much impact.  Rather, ADP and ISM are likely the things that matter most for now.

Ultimately, I believe more liquidity is going to come to the market via central banks around the world, and that will support risk assets, as well as prices for the things we buy.  Nothing has changed in my view of the dollar either.

Good luck

Adf

The Narrative’s Turned

Posted on by

Last Friday it certainly seemed
The bears had achieved what they’d dreamed
Most bulls were in hell
As stock markets fell
While bears felt that they’d been redeemed
 
But since then, the narrative’s turned
And short-sellers all have been burned
In fact, round our sphere
Investors all cheer
For Jay to cut rates, Fed hawks spurned

 

The holiday spirit is alive and well this morning, and in truth has been all week.  And not just in the US, but around the world.  Literally, I am hard-pressed to find a stock market that has declined in the past twenty-four hours, with most on multi-day rallies.  And so, I must wonder, has everything really gotten that much better in the world?

A quick tour around the world of problems extant includes:

  • Russia/Ukraine war
  • Chinese property deflation
  • Net zero insanity
  • TDS
  • K-shaped economies
  • Rise of Socialism
  • Excessive global debt/leverage
  • Cost of living

I’m sure there are others, but I just wanted to touch on a few and try to figure out why investors have turned so positive.  After all, a look at the S&P 500 chart below shows that we are less than 2% from the historic highs set back on October 29th.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

So, let’s run through the list.

  • The war in Ukraine continues apace, although we cannot ignore the uptick in ostensible peace talks that have been occurring in the past week.  I’m game to accept those talks as a positive.
  • The Chinese economy continues to overproduce amid weakening domestic demand as property prices show no signs of bottoming.  This is one of the major reasons for the massive global imbalances we have experienced over the past two decades and President Xi has basically proven that they only model he understands is mercantilism.  With President Trump addressing that directly, this will continue to generate uncertainty and volatility, so there will be up days, but also plenty of down ones.
  • The ongoing waste of resources in this Quixotic effort, especially by the Europeans will serve only to further depress their economies while adding debt to pay for their ill-advised policies.  As long as this continues, Europe will be poorer in the future and that doesn’t bode well for their equity markets.
  • Nothing will change TDS but its bifurcation of the population, and not just the US but globally, is likely to be a net negative for everything.
  • The K-shaped economy is a major problem, and not one restricted to the US.  As long as this remains the case, it will breed social unrest, as we continue to see, and have encouraged policies that have proven time and again to be disastrous, but sound good to those in the bottom leg of the K, i.e. Socialism.  I assure you, Socialism will not enhance market capitalization.
  • See above
  • The global debt problem continues to hang over the global economy like the Sword of Damocles, ready to decimate economies with just the right (wrong?) catalyst.  Of course, this is why rate cuts are so favored, and QE more so, but while those may be solutions for government accounts, they will simply exacerbate the last on this list
  • I specifically point to the cost of living since the economists’ concept of inflation, the rate of change of prices, is irrelevant to most people.  The price level is the key, and there is no world where the price level will decline absent a major depression, which is why run it hot is the favored plan.  If growth can be raised sufficiently so that people believe life is affordable again, it will alleviate the K-shaped problem as well as the socialism problem.  But that is a big IF.

And yet, as you can see from this screenshot from Bloomberg.com, as I type, every market is in the green.

My conclusion is that either investors have grown to believe that the key short-term problems, like Russia/Ukraine will be effectively addressed, or under the guise of YOLO, they are all in on AI and the stock market and see it as the only way forward.  I wish I could be so sanguine, but then I am just an old misanthrope.  I hope they are right!

Ok, well, absent any real new news, and leading up to the Thanksgiving holiday here in the US, market signals are telling me everything is right with the world.  You see the equity markets above, and US futures are higher as well at this hour (7:30), albeit only about 0.2%.  

In the meantime, with risk in such demand, it is no surprise that bond yields are edging higher with Treasuries +2bps, after trading below 4.0% during yesterday’s session on a weak ADP weekly employment report (-13.5K) as well as PPI data that seemed less concerning.  European sovereign yields have all edged higher by 1bp this morning, again synchronous with risk on, and JGB yields also edged higher by 1bp after the government there explained they would be borrowing ¥11.5 trillion (~$73.5 billion) in extra debt to fund Takaichi-san’s supplementary budget.  The big outlier is Australia, where AGBs rose 10bps after CPI rose a hotter than expected 3.8% in October, not only putting paid any thoughts of a further rate cut but bringing rate hikes back into view.

In the commodity markets, oil (-0.2%) continues to slide lower, now below $58/bbl, and following its recent trend as per the below tradingeconomics.com chart.

Javier Blas, the widely respected Bloomberg oil analyst, put out an op-ed this morning explaining that he saw higher oil prices in the future.  That is at odds with my view, but I have linked it here so you can help determine if his reasons make sense.  I believe he underestimates both the impact of technology making it ever cheaper to get oil, and the political incentives to drill for more of the stuff by those nations that have it.  Net zero will not survive much longer in my view.

In the metals markets, prospects for lower interest rates have helped encourage further buying and this morning we see the entire complex higher (Au +0.7%, Ag +1.5%, Cu +1.3%, Pt +1.0%).  To the extent that the leverage story remains, and governments are going to continue to print money to pay their debts, metals prices across both precious and base, should continue to appreciate in price.

Finally, the dollar, which slipped a bit yesterday, is mixed this morning.  the yen (-0.3%) is sliding along with KRW (-0.6%), but really, there seem to be more gainers than that.  The biggest mover was NZD (+0.8%) after the RBNZ cut its base rate, as expected, but indicated the cutting cycle is over.  AUD (+0.3%) has also rallied on that inflation report.  I haven’t focused much on the renminbi (+0.1%) lately, largely because the daily movement is typically small, but if you look at the chart below, you can see that the trend has been steady all year, with CNY appreciating nearly 4% since the beginning of the year.  There are many analyses that indicate the renminbi is massively undervalued, so perhaps this is part of the trade deal with the US.  But it will be difficult for Xi to countenance too much strength as it will negatively impact his mercantilist policies.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Lastly, the pound is gyrating this morning as Chancellor Rachel Reeves offers her budget.  The highlights are a larger than expected fiscal buffer of £22 billion achieved by raising taxes by more than £29.8 billion on gambling and real estate.  However, the recent history of tax hikes in the UK, as they try to tax the wealthy, is that the wealthy simply leave and the result is tax deficits.  Maybe it really is different this time!

And that’s what we have going into the weekend.  Data today brings September Durable Goods (exp 0.3%, 0.2% ex transport), Initial Claims (225K), Continuing Claims (1975K) and Chicago PMI (44.3).  I see no reason for this recent rebound to end as clearly everybody is feeling good into the holiday.  As I highlighted above, there remain myriad problems around, none of which will be solved soon, but apparently, that doesn’t matter.  So go with it!

There will be no poetry tomorrow or Friday so Monday, we will see how things have evolved.

Good luck and have a great holiday weekend

Adf

Basically Fictive

Posted on by

For Fedniks it must be addictive
To say rates are “somewhat restrictive”
It seems like a show
As how can they know
Since R-star is basically fictive
 
Investors, though, lap up this stuff
In fact, they just can’t get enough
Of comments that hint
There is a blueprint
For policy, though that’s a bluff

 

Yesterday, both Richmond Fed president Barkin and Governor Jefferson explained that current Fed policy is “somewhat restrictive”.  This takes to seven the number of FOMC members who have used this phrase with Powell, Kugler, Hammack, Schmid and Collins all having used it before, as did Jefferson two weeks ago.  And they are all referring to the concept of R-star, the mythical rate at which policy is neither restrictive nor accommodative.  In fact, R-star has become the Fed’s north star, with the key difference being, we can actually see the north star while R-star, even they will admit, is unobservable.  Of course, that hasn’t stopped them from basing policy decisions on the variable.

I highlight this because the tone of virtually every one of these speeches has been one of caution, with the implication being they are very close to their nirvana so the last steps will be small.  However, we cannot forget that though the last steps may be small, there is still confidence amongst the entire body that the direction of travel is toward lower rates. certainly, as you can see from the aggregated meeting probabilities from the Fed funds futures market below, there is zero expectation that rates will rise anytime during the next two years and a decent chance of another 100bps of cuts over that time.

Source: cmegroup.com

I might contend that is a pretty negative outlook on the US economy by the Fed.  Given the Fed’s models assume that a key to lower inflation is slowing economic growth, the idea that rates are going to fall implies slower growth to help them achieve the inflation portion of their mandate.  But that seems out of step with both the Atlanta Fed’s GDPNow forecast shown below and currently sitting at 4.1% annualized for Q3 and with earnings forecasts in the equity markets.

Asking Grok, the average current earnings growth forecasts for 2026 for the S&P 500 is somewhere in the 13% – 14% range with revenue growth running at ~6.9%, which is typically in line with nominal GDP growth.  (I understand that current forward PE ratios are extremely high at 23x, so be careful that companies hit their targets while their share prices fall anyway.)  But if nominal GDP is going to run at nearly 7%, and let’s assume inflation is at 3.5%, which I think is a reasonable possibility, then the math tells us that GDP is growing at 3.5% on a real basis.  With Fed funds currently at 4.0%, why would they need to decline further?

Looking back at the Fed’s September Summary of Economic Projections, it appears that the Fed sees a very different economy than the markets see.  In fact, you can see that they believe nominal GDP in the long run is going to average <4.0% (sum of longer run GDP and PCE in the table below).  

That is a really big difference, one that is the type that can lead to massive policy errors.  Now, if those 17 people cloistered in the Marriner Eccles building have a better handle on the economy than everybody else, I can understand why they believe rates need to fall further.  But is that the case?  

Here’s something else to ponder, I asked Grok about the relationship between nominal GDP and Fed funds and the below table is what it produced:

It is patently obvious how the Fed has developed its models and because of that, why they have been so wrong.  In fact, look at the SEP above and compare it to the period from 2001 – 2019, they are essentially identical.  But I would argue, and I’m not alone, that the economy from the dot.com crash up to the pandemic is no longer the reality on the ground.  The Fed’s backward-looking models seem set to make yet more errors going forward.

And with those cheery thoughts, let’s look at what happened overnight.  Yesterday’s continuation of the US stock decline seems to be finding a bottom, at least temporarily as Asian markets were mixed (Nikkei -0.3%, Hang Seng -0.4%, CSI 300 +0.4%) with the rest of the region showing a similar mixture of gainers (India, Malaysia, Indonesia, Philippines) and losers (Korea, Taiwan, Australia) as it appears the entire world is awaiting Nvidia’s earnings after the US close today.

Similarly, European bourses are edging higher this morning with the rout seemingly over for now.  This morning Spain (+0.5%) is leading the way higher followed by Germany (+0.3%) with the rest of the markets little changed overall, although leaning higher.  As to US futures, at this hour (7:30) they are pushing higher by about 0.4%.

In the bond market, Treasury yields are unchanged this morning, still sitting right around that 4.10% level while European sovereigns have seen demand with yields slipping -2bps to -3bps across the continent.  The UK is the outlier here, with yields unchanged after releasing inflation data that was bang on expectations, and below last month’s readings, though remains well above their 2.0% target.  I guess if I look at the chart below, I might be able to make the case that core UK CPI is trending lower, but similarly to the Fed, the last time they were at their target was July 2021.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

I would be remiss if I didn’t mention that JGB yields have moved higher by 3bps, pushing their decade long highs further along as concerns grow over the Japanese fiscal situation.

Oil prices (-2.4%) are falling this morning, slipping to the low side of $60/bbl after API inventories showed a surprise build of 4.4 million barrels.  However, I would contend that there is very little new here.  Perhaps the dinner last night where President Trump hosted Saudi Prince MbS has some thinking OPEC will increase production more aggressively going forward.  In the metals markets, they are all shining this morning led by silver (+3.1%) and platinum (+3.0%) with gold (+1.3%) and copper (+1.3%) lagging, although remember the latter two are much larger markets so need more interest to rise as quickly.

Finally, the dollar continues to find support, despite the precious metals gains, and this morning we see the DXY (+0.15%) pushing back toward that psychological 100.00 level.  JPY (-0.5%) has traded through 156 and certainly seems like it wants to push back to its YTYD highs of 158.80.  Interestingly, there was no Japanese commentary of note last night, but I presume if this continues, the MOF will be out warning of potential future action.  Another interesting fact is that while the dollar is firmer against virtually all G10 currencies, the EMG bloc is holding its own this morning led by HUF (+0.6%), PLN (+0.25%) and ZAR (+0.15%) with the rand obviously benefitting from gold’s rally.  The forint has benefitted from the central bank maintaining policy on hold at 6.5%, one of the highest available rates in Europe and that has helped drag the zloty along for the ride.

On the data front, this morning we see the August Trade Balance (exp -$61.0B) and then the EIA oil inventories where a small draw is expected.  We also get the FOMC Minutes at 2:00pm and hear from NY Fed president Williams this afternoon.

I cannot help but look at the difference between the Fed’s very clear view and the markets expectations and feel like the Fed is on the wrong side of the trade.  It is for this reason I fear higher inflation and ultimately, a much lower likelihood of further rate cuts.  If that is the case, the dollar will find even more support.  Interesting times.

Good luck

Adf

Left For Dead

Posted on by

Takaichi’s learned
Her chalice contained poison
Thus, her yen weakens

 

If one needed proof that interest rates are not the only determining factor in FX markets, look no further than Japan these days where JGB yields across the board, from 2yr to 40yr are trading at decade plus highs while the yen continues to decline on a regular basis.  This morning, the yen has traded through 155.00 vs. the dollar, and through 180.00 vs. the euro with the latter being a record low for the yen vs. the single currency since the euro was formed in 1999.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Meanwhile, JGB yields continue to rise unabated on the back of growing concerns that Takaichi-san’s government is going to be issuing still more unfunded debt to pay for a massive new supplementary fiscal package rumored to be ¥17 trillion (~$109 billion).  While we may have many fiscal problems in the US, it is clear Japan should not be our fiscal role model.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

This market movement has led to the second step of the seven-step program of verbal intervention by Japanese FinMins and their subordinates.  Last night, FinMin Satsuki Katayama explained [emphasis added], “I’m seeing extremely one-sided and rapid movements in the currency market. I’m deeply concerned about the situation.”  Rapid and one-sided are the key words to note here.  History has shown the Japanese are not yet ready to intervene, but they are warming to the task.  My sense is we will need to see 160 trade again before they enter the market.  However, while that will have a short-term impact, it will not change the relative fiscal realities between the US and Japan, so any retreat is likely to be a dollar (or euro) buying opportunity.

As to the BOJ, after a highly anticipated meeting between Takaichi-san and Ueda-san, the BOJ Governor told a press conference, “The mechanism for inflation and wages to grow together is recovering. Given this, I told the prime minister that we are in the process of making gradual adjustments to the degree of monetary easing.”   Alas for the yen, I don’t think it will be enough to halt the slide.  That is a fiscal issue, and one not likely to be addressed anytime soon.

The screens everywhere have turned red
As folks have lost faith that the Fed,
Next month, will cut rates
Thus, leave to the fates
A stock market now left for dead

Yesterday, I showed the Fear & Greed Index and marveled at how it was pointing to so much fear despite equity markets trading within a few percentage points of all time highs.  Well, today it’s even worse!  This morning the index has fallen from 22 to 13 and is now pushing toward the lows seen last April when it reached 4 just ahead of Liberation Day.

In fact, it is worthwhile looking at a history of this index over the past year and remembering what happened in the wake of that all-time low reading.

Source: cnn.com

Now look at the S&P500 over the same timeline and see if you notice any similarities.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

It is certainly not a perfect match, but the dramatic rise in both indices from the bottom and through June is no coincidence.  The other interesting thing is that the fear index managed to decline so sharply despite the current pretty modest equity market decline.  After all, from the top, even after yesterday’s decline, we are less than 4% from record highs in the S&P 500.

Analysts discuss the ‘wall of worry’ when equity markets rise despite negative narratives.  Too, historically, when the fear index falls to current levels, it tends to presage a rally.  Yet, if we have only fallen 4% from the peak, it would appear that positions remain relatively robust in sizing.  In fact, BoA indicated that cash positions by investors have fallen to just 3.7%, the lowest level in the past 15 years.  So, everyone is fully invested, yet everyone is terrified.  Something’s gotta give!  In this poet’s eyes, the likely direction of travel in the short run is lower for equities, and a correction of 10% or so in total makes sense.  But at that point, especially if bonds are under pressure as well, I would look for the Fed to step in and not only cut rates but start expanding its balance sheet once again.  QT was nice while it lasted, but its time has passed.  One poet’s view.

Ok, following the sharp decline in US equity markets yesterday on weak tech shares, the bottom really fell out in Asia and Europe.  Japan (-3.2%) got crushed between worries about fiscal profligacy discussed above and the tech selloff.  China (-0.65%) and HK (-1.7%) followed suit as did every market in Asia (Korea -3.3%, Taiwan -2.5%, India -0.3%, Australia -1.9%).  You get the idea.  In Europe, the picture is no brighter, although the damage is less dramatic given the complete lack of tech companies based on the continent.  But Germany (-1.2%), France (-1.3%), Spain (-1.6%), Italy (-1.7%) and the UK (-1.3%) have led the way lower where all indices are in the red.  US futures, at this hour (7:15) are also pointing lower, although on the order of -0.5% right now.

In the bond market, Treasury yields, after edging higher yesterday are lower by -4bps this morning, and back at 4.10%, their ‘home’ for the past two months as per the below chart from tradingeconomics.com.

As to European sovereigns, they are not getting quite as much love with some yields unchanged (UK, Italy) and some slipping slightly, down -2bps (Germany, Netherlands), and that covers the entire movement today.  We’ve already discussed JGBs above.

In the commodity space, oil (-0.2%) continues to trade either side of $60/bbl and it remains unclear what type of catalyst is required to move us away from this level.  Interestingly, precious metals have lost a bit of their luster despite the fear with gold (-0.25%), silver (-0.2%) and platinum (-0.2%) all treading water rather than being the recipient of flows based on fear.  Granted, compared to the crypto realm, where BTC (-1.0%, -16% in the past month) has suffered far more dramatically, this isn’t too bad.  But you have to ask, if investors are bailing on risk assets like equities, and bonds are not rallying sharply, while gold is slipping a bit, where is the money going?

Perhaps a look at the currency market will help us answer that question.  Alas, I don’t think that is the case as while the dollar had a good day yesterday, and is holding those gains this morning, if investors around the world are buying dollars, where are they putting them?  I suppose money market funds are going to be the main recipient of the funds taken out of longer-term investments.  One thing we have learned, though, is that the yen appears to have lost its haven status given its continued weakening (-3.0% in the past month) despite growing fears around the world.  

On the data front, yesterday saw Empire State Manufacturing print a very solid 18.7 and, weirdly, this morning at 5am the BLS released the Initial Claims data from October 18th at 232K, although there is not much context for that given the absence of other weeks’ data around it.  Later this morning we are due the ADP Weekly number, Factory Orders (exp 1.4%) and another Fed speaker, Governor Barr.  Yesterday’s Fed speakers left us with several calling for a cut in December, and several calling for no move with the former (Waller, Bowman and Miran) focused on the tenuous employment situation while the latter (Williams, Jeffereson, Kashkari and Logan) worried about inflation.  Personally, I’m with the latter group as the correct policy, but futures are still a coin toss and there is too much time before the next meeting to take a strong stand in either direction.

The world appears more confusing than usual right now, perhaps why that Fear index is so low.  With that in mind, regarding the dollar, despite all the troubles extant in the US, it is hard to look around and find someplace else with better prospects right now.  I still like it in the medium and long term.

Good luck

Adf

A Day to Give Thanks

Posted on by

Today is a day to give thanks
To those who flew planes and drove tanks
In multiple wars
And too many tours
No matter which service or ranks
 
Now, turning to markets at hand
The bulls, yesterday, had command
So, risk assets rose
While pundits compose
A narrative, things are just grand

 

It was certainly a positive day in markets yesterday, with equities and commodities rising sharply while bonds sat in the corner with the dollar, neither one trying to rain on the parade.  The imminent end of the government shutdown had everyone feeling euphoric.  But that is so yesterday. It appears that reopening the US government is not enough to keep global markets rallying.

And the thing is, there is just not that much new of note to discuss this morning.  As it is Veteran’s Day here in the US, banks and the bond market are closed, although equities and commodities markets are open.  But the news cycle overnight was led by the fact that Softbank sold their NVDA stake for a $5.8 billion profit.  And that’s pretty thin gruel for someone who writes about market activities.  Everything else is about who won/lost regarding the shutdown and frankly, that is something markets tend to ignore.

With that in mind, and given the absence of any substantive data, let’s go right into market activity overnight.  Asian equity markets were mixed although I would say there was more red (Japan, China, Taiwan, Australia, Indonesia, Thailand, Philippines) than green (HK, Singapore, Malaysia, Korea, India) but it appears most of the activity had limited volumes and there are few stories of note as drivers.  

In Europe, though, things are looking better with all the major bourses higher this morning, led by the UK (+0.8%) where bad news was good for stocks as the Unemployment Rate ticked higher, to 5.0%, which has markets now pricing an 80% probability of a rate cut by the BOE next month.  This has been enough to help most European markets higher (CAC +0.65%, IBEX +0.5%) except for the DAX (0.0%) which is lagging after the ZEW Sentiment Index was released at a weaker than forecast 38.5, which was also down from last month’s reading.  

I think it might be worthwhile, though, to take a longer-term perspective on this sentiment survey.  As you can see from the chart below (data from ZEW.de), the current level is very middle of the pack.  In fact, the long-term average reading is 21.3, but of course, that includes numerous negative readings during recessions.  I might argue that things in Germany are not collapsing, but nowhere near robust.  My concern, if I were a German policymaker, is that it appears the survey has peaked at a much lower level than history, an indication that the best they can hope for is still mediocre.

Finally, US futures are pointing slightly lower, -0.2% or so, at this hour (7:50), arguably a little hangover from yesterday.

In the bond market, of course, Treasury yields aren’t trading, but European sovereigns are essentially unchanged as well, except for UK Gilts, which have seen yields slip -7bps on that higher Unemployment data driving rate cut expectations.  Given the ongoing fiscal issues in the UK, where they cannot seem to come up with a budget and all signs point to a worsening debt position, I’m not sure why yields there would decline, but that’s what’s happening.

Turning to the commodity markets, oil (+0.5%) continues to trade either side of $60/bbl, making no headway in either direction.  I listened to an excellent podcast yesterday with Doomberg, who once again highlighted his view that the long-term direction of the price of oil is lower.  The case he makes is that on an energy basis, NatGas, even though it is up 48% in the past year, remains significantly cheaper than oil, one-quarter the price, and that the arbitrage will close driving the price of oil lower and the price of NatGas higher.  Remember, politics is far more impactful on oil drilling than geology.  Ask yourself what will happen to the price of oil if Venezuela’s government falls and is replaced by a pro-US government allowing the oil majors in to help tap the largest oil reserves on the planet.  I assure you that is not bullish for the price of oil.

As to the metals markets, after yesterday’s very impressive moves, they are continuing higher this morning, at least the precious metals are with gold (+0.5%), silver (+0.8% and now over $50/oz) and platinum (+0.75%) all extending their gains.  These are the same charts in the metals, and my take is we had a blowoff run which has now corrected, and we could easily see another leg higher of serious magnitude.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Finally, the dollar is mostly drifting lower this morning, although not universally so.  While the euro (+0.15%), CHF (+0.6%) and Scandies (NOK +0.6%, SEK +0.4%) are all firmer, the pound (-0.2%) and Aussie (-0.2%) are suffering a bit.  Yen is unchanged along with CAD.  In the EMG bloc, it is also a mixed bag with INR (+0.25%) and PLN (+0.25%) having solid sessions although KRW (-0.6%) is going the other way and the rest of the bloc is +/- 0.1% or so different.  Again, the dollar is just not that exciting in its own right.

There is a new data point coming out, ADP Weekly Employment change, seemingly in an effort to fill in gaps until the BLS gets back to work.  However, given its newness, it is not clear what value it will have to markets.  There is also a speech by Governor Barr but tomorrow is when the Fedspeak really hits.

It is shaping up to be a quiet day, and I suspect absent a major equity move, or some White House bingo, FX markets are going to drift nowhere of note.

Good luck

adf

Like a Fable

Posted on by

It seems there’s a deal on the table
To end the shut down and enable
The chattering classes
To force feed the masses
A story that’s quite like a fable
 
Both sides will claim they have achieved
Their goals, though they were ill-conceived
But markets will love
The outcome above
All else, and we’ll all be relieved

 

While the shutdown is not technically over as the House of Representatives need to reconvene (they have been out of session since September 19th when they passed the continuing resolution) and adjust the bill so that it matches the one the Senate agreed last night and can be voted on in the House, it certainly appears that the momentum, plus President Trump’s imprimatur, is going to get it completed sometime this week. 

The nature of the deal is unimportant for our purposes here and both sides will continue to claim that they were in the right side of history, but the essence is that there appeared to be some movement on health care funding so, hurray!

As you can see in the chart below, while the story broke late yesterday afternoon and futures responded on the open in the evening session, the reality is the market sniffed out something was coming around noon on Friday.  In fact, the S&P 500 has rallied 2.4% since noon Friday.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

So, everything is now right with the world, right?  After all, this has been the major topic of conversation, not just by the talking heads on TV, but also in markets as analysts were trying to determine how much damage the shutdown was doing to the economy.  While I have no doubt that there were many people who felt the impact, my take is there were many, many more who felt nothing.  After all, the two main features were air travel and then SNAP benefits.  Let’s face it, on average (according to Grok) about 2.9 million people board airplanes in the US, well less than 1% of the population, although SNAP benefits, remarkably, go to 42 million people.  However, those have only been impacted for the past week, not the entire shutdown.

I’m not trying to make light of the inconveniences that occurred, just point out that from a macroeconomic perspective, despite the fact that the shutdown lasted 6 weeks, it probably didn’t have much of an impact on the statistics as all the money that wasn’t spent last month will be spent next month.  Different analyst estimates claim it will reduce Q4 GDP by between 0.2% and 0.5% with a concurrent impact on the annual result.  I am willing to wager it is much less.  However, it appears it will have ended by the end of the week and so markets are back to focusing on other things like AI, unemployment and QE.

Now, those three things are clearly important to markets, but I don’t think there is anything new to discuss there today.  Rather, I would like to focus on two other issues, one more immediate and one down the road, which may impact the way things evolve going forward.

In the near term, as winter approaches, meteorologists are forecasting a much colder winter in the Northern Hemisphere across both North America and Europe, something that is going to have a direct impact on NatGas.  Bloomberg had a long article on the topic this morning with the upshot being that the Polar Vortex may break further south early this year and bring a lot of cold weather along for the ride.  This is clearly not new news to the NatGas market, as evidenced by the fact that its price has exploded (no pun intended) higher by 43% in the past month!

Source: tradingeconomics.com

While oil prices have remained stuck in a narrow range, trading either side of $60/bbl for the past 6 weeks amid a longer-term drift lower as you can see in the below chart, oil is only utilized by ~4% of homeowners for heating with 46% using NatGas.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Ultimately, I suspect that we are going to see this feed through to inflation as not only are there the direct costs of heating homes, but NatGas is also the major source of generating electricity, with 43% of the nation’s electricity using that as its source.  We have already seen electricity prices rise pretty sharply over the past months (I’m sure you have all felt that pain) and if NatGas prices continue to climb, that will continue.  Remember, the current price ~$4.45/MMBtu is nowhere near significant highs like those seen just 3 years ago when it traded as high as $10/MMBtu.  With all this price pressure, will the Fed continue down their path of rate cuts?  Alas, I believe they will, but that doesn’t make our lives any better.

Which takes me to the second, longer term issue I wanted to mention, European legislation that is seeking to effectively outlaw the utilization of cash euros.  This substack article regarding recent Eurozone legislation is eye-opening as the ECB and Europe try to combat the coming irrelevance of the euro.  For everyone who either lives in Europe or does business there, I cannot recommend reading this highly enough.  There are many changes occurring in financial architecture, and by extension financial markets.  Keep informed!

Ok, enough of that, let’s see how markets have responded to the Senate deal.  Apparently, US politics matters to the entire global equity market.  Green is today’s color with Japan (+1.25%), HK (+1.55%) and China (+0.35%) all performing well, although not as well as Korea (+3.0%) which really had a good session.  Pretty much all the other regional markets were also higher.  In Europe, the deal has everyone excited as well with gains across the board (Germany +1.8%, France +1.4%, Spain +1.4%, UK +1.0%).  As to US futures, at this hour (7:45) they are higher by about 1% across the board.

I guess with that much excitement about more government spending, we cannot be surprised the yields have edged higher.  This morning Treasury yields are up by 3bps, which is what we saw from JGB markets last night as well, although European sovereign yields are little changed on the day.  I suspect, though, if equities continue to rally, we will see yields there edge higher.

In the commodity space, oil (+0.5%) continues to trade in its recent range.  The most interesting thing I saw here was that the IEA is set to come out with their latest annual assessment of the oil market and for the first time in more than a decade they are not going to claim that peak fossil fuel demand is here or coming soon.  The climate grift is truly breaking down.  But the commodity story of the day is precious metals which are massively higher (Au +2.5%, Ag +3.3%, Pt +2.6%) with copper (+1.6%) coming along for the ride.  The narrative here is that with the government shutdown due to end soon, President Trump talking about $2000 tariff rebate checks and the Fed likely to cut rates in December (65% probability), debasement is with us and metals is the place to be!

Interestingly, the dollar is not suffering much at all despite the precious metals story.  While AUD (+0.6%), ZAR (+0.6%) and NOK (+0.6%) are all stronger on the commodity story, the euro is unchanged, JPY (-0.4%) continues to decline and the rest of the G10 is not doing enough to matter.  In truth, if I look across the board, there are more currencies strengthening than weakening vs. the greenback, but overall, at least per the DXY, the dollar is little changed.

There is still no data at this point, although it will start up again when the government gets back to work.  Actually, there has been much talk of the weakness in Consumer sentiment based on Friday’s Michigan Index which fell to 50.3, the second lowest in the history of the series with several subindices weakening substantially.  However, that was before the news about the end of the shutdown, so my take is people will regain confidence soon.  As well, we hear from 9 Fed speakers this week, with 5 of them on Wednesday!  Both dissenters from the October meeting will speak, so perhaps things have changed in their eyes, but I doubt it.

At this point, all is right with the world as investors anticipate the US government getting back to work while the Fed will continue to support markets by easing policy further.  In truth, the dollar should not benefit here, but I have a feeling that any weakness will be short-lived at best.  Longer term, I continue to believe the dollar is the place to be.

Good luck

Adf

Woes and Scraps

Posted on by

The PMI data is in
And so far, it’s not really been
A sign of great strength
When viewed from arm’s length
No matter the punditry’s spin
 
That said, we are not near collapse
Despite many trade woes and scraps
And stocks keep on rising
So, t’will be surprising
For all when we see downside gaps

 

It was a quieter weekend than we have seen recently in the global arena with no new wars, no mega protests and no progress made on any of the major issues outstanding around the world.  Thus, the US government remains shut down, the war in Ukraine remains apace and the AI buzz continues to suck up most of the oxygen when discussing markets.

With this as background, arguably the most interesting market related news has been the manufacturing PMI data released last night and this morning.  starting in Asia, the story was some weakness as Chinese, Korean and Australian data all fell compared to last month, although India and Indonesia continued along well.  Meanwhile, in Europe, the data improved compared to last month, but the problem is it remains at or below 50 virtually across the board, so hardly indicative of strong economic activity.

                                                                                                      Current         Previous               Forecast

Source: tradingeconomics.com

I don’t know about you, but when I look at the releases this morning, I don’t see a European revival quite yet, not even if I squint.

I guess the other thing that has tongues wagging is Election Day tomorrow with three races garnering the focus, gubernatorial contests in New Jersey and Virginia and the mayoral race in New York City.  The first two are often described as harbingers of a president’s first year in office and I think this time will be no different.  But will they impact market behavior?  This I doubt.

So, let’s get right into markets this morning.  Friday’s further new record highs in the US were followed by strength through much of Asia (Tokyo was closed for Culture Day) with China (+0.3%), HK (+1.0%), Korea (+2.8%) and Taiwan (+0.4%) leading the way with only the Philippines (-1.7%) bucking the regional trend as earnings growth in the country continues to disappoint relative to its peers around the region.  Europe, too, has seen broad based gains with the DAX (+1.2%) leading the way higher and gains in the IBEX (+0.45%) and CAC (+0.3%) as well.  I guess the PMI data was sufficient to excite folks and despite Europe’s status as a global afterthought, at least in terms of geopolitical issues, their equity markets have been rising alongside the rest of the world’s all year.  And you needn’t worry, US futures are all higher at this hour (6:50), with the NASDAQ (+0.7%) leading the way.

Perhaps more interesting than equities though is the fact that government bond markets are doing so little.  Treasury yields jumped ~10bps in the wake of the FOMC meeting and, more accurately, Chairman Powell’s ostensible hawkishness.  However, as you can see in the below tradingeconomics.com chart, since then, nothing has happened. 

Recall, the probability of a December rate cut by the FOMC also fell from virtual certainty to 69% now.  In fact, if you think about it, that 30% probability decline translates into about 7.5bps, approximately the same amount as 10-year yield’s rose.  It appears that the market is consistent in its pricing at this point, and when (if?) data starts coming back into the picture, we will see both these interest rates rise and fall in sync.  As to European sovereigns, they continue to track the movement in the US and this morning, this morning, the entire bloc has seen yields edge higher by 1bp, exactly like the US.

Commodities remain the most interesting place, although the dollar is starting to perk up a bit.  Oil (-0.3%) slipped overnight after OPEC+ indicated they were increasing production by another 137K bbl/day, although there would be no more increases for at least three months given the seasonality of reduced oil demand at this point on the calendar.  Something I have not touched on lately is NatGas, which traded through $4.00/MMBtu late last Thursday, and is now up to $4.25.  in fact, in the past month it has risen nearly 27%, which given it is massively underpriced compared to oil (on a per unit of energy basis) should not be that surprising.  Nonetheless, sharp movements are always noteworthy, and this is no different.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Certainly, part of this is the fact that winter is coming and seasonal demand is rising in the US. 

Combine that with the European needs for LNG, of which the US is the largest provider, and you have the makings of a rally.  (I wonder though, did the fact that Bill Gates changed his tune on global warming no longer being an existential threat signal it is now OK to burn more fossil fuels?)

Turning to the metals markets, the ongoing fight between the gold bugs and the powers that be continues as early in the overnight session, gold was lower by nearly -1% but as I type, just past 7:00am, it is slightly higher (+0.1%) compared to Friday’s closing levels.  Silver (+0.1%) has seen similar price action although copper (-0.5%) appears more focused on the economic story than the inflation story.  

Which takes us to the dollar and its continued rally. Using the DXY (+0.1%) as our proxy, it is higher again this morning and pushing back to the psychological 100.00 level.  Now, I have made the case several times that the dollar has done essentially nothing for the past six months, and the chart below, I believe, bears that out.  We have basically traded between 96.5 and 100 since May.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

You will also recall that there is a narrative around about the end of the dollar’s hegemony and how nations around the world are trying to exit the USD financial system that has been in place since Bretton Woods, or at least since the fiat currency world took off when President Nixon closed the gold window.  And there is no doubt that China is seeking to become the global hegemon and thus wants a renminbi-based system to use to their advantage.  However, let’s run a little thought experiment. 

The Trump administration has embraced the cryptocurrency space, and especially the use of stablecoins.  Legislation has been passed (GENIUS Act) to help clarify the legal framework and the SEC has been solicitous in its willingness to ensure that these creations are not securities, thus placing them outside the SEC’s oversight.  When looking at the world of stablecoins, their current total value is approximately $311 billion (according to Grok) of which only ~$1.2 billion are non-USD.  

Now, if stablecoins represent the payment rails of the future, an idea that is readily believable, and the stablecoin market is virtually entirely USD, with massive first mover advantage, is it not possible that economies around the world are going to find it much easier to dollarize than to maintain their own native currency?  While there are calls for Argentina to dollarize, what would the world look like if the EU fell apart (an entirely possible outcome given the inconsistencies in their current energy and immigration policies and the stress within the bloc) and the euro with it?  Would smaller nations opt for their own currency, or would they see the value of having a dollarized economy given the many efficiencies it would present, especially for their export industries?

While I have no doubt that China will never accept that outcome for themselves, is the future a world where there are two currency blocs, USD and CNY, and everything else simply disappears?  Remember, we are merely spit balling here, but if that is the outcome, demand for dollars will continue to rise, and the value of other currencies will continue to decline until such time as they succumb.

Again, this is a thought experiment, but one that offers intriguing possibilities for the future.  And one where the foreign exchange market may ultimately meet its demise.  After all, if there are only two currencies, that doesn’t make much of a market.

One other thing I must note, in the stablecoin realm, there is a remarkable product, USDi (usdicoin.com), which tracks US CPI exactly, yet can fit within those same payment rails.  If you are looking into this space, USDI is worth a peek.

Ok, back to the markets, looking across the FX space, +/-0.2% is today’s theme virtually across the board, with the more important currencies slipping against the dollar (EUR, GBP, JPY, CHF, CAD) than rising vs the greenback (MXN, CLP, NOK, CZK), although the magnitudes are similar.

With the government still closed, there is no official data, but we do get ISM Manufacturing (exp 49.5) with the Prices Paid subindex (61.7) released at the same time.  There are two Fed speakers today, Daly and Cook, and then 9 more speeches throughout the week.  We also get the ADP Employment data on Wednesday (exp 24K), but I imagine that will get more press after the election results are learned Tuesday evening.

It is hard to get excited about things today, but nothing points to a weaker dollar right now.

Good luck

Adf

A Strong Sense of Urgency

Posted on by

Katayama said
“A strong sense of urgency”
Informs our views now

 

The wonderful thing about Japanese translations into English is that they can be both consistent and nonsensical at the same time.  The term, “a strong sense of urgency” has been used by virtually every Japanese FinMin for the past 40 years, and probably longer, when they discuss the yen after a sharp move.  But ask yourself, is that how you would express this sentiment?  While I have no doubt that the MOF (and the BOJ) are closely watching the movements in the FX market as the yen continues to weaken, if it was urgent, they would have done something.  And they are not going to do anything, I think, until 160 is seen again.  As it happens, the yen is at its weakest point since mid-February and it is hard to make the case that it is going to reverse course soon.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But this is the first step in their typical seven step plan before intervention.  And I get it, the combination of Chairman Powell suddenly sounding hawkish on Wednesday afternoon, telling us a December rate cut was not a foregone conclusion and the BOJ continuing to sit on its hands despite inflation running at 2.9%, the 42nd consecutive month (see below) that it has been above their 2.0% target (sound familiar?), indicates that the current policy stances will likely lead to further dollar strength vs. the yen.  

Source: tradingeconomics.com

There is something of an irony in the current situation in Japan.  Recall that for years, the Japanese economy was in a major funk, with deflation the norm, not inflation, as government after government issued massive amounts of debt to try to spend their way to growth.  In fact, Shinzo Abe was elected in 2012, his second stint as PM, based on his three arrows plan to reinflate the economy because things were perceived so poorly.  If you look at the chart below, which takes a longer-term view of Japanese inflation, prior to 2022, the two positive spikes between 1992 and 2022 were the result of a hike in the Japanese VAT (they call it the Goods and Services Tax) which raised prices.  In fact, during that 30-year period, the average annual CPI was 0.25%.  And the Japanese government was desperate to raise that inflation rate.  Of course, we know what HL Mencken warned us; be careful what you wish for, you just may get it…good and hard.  I have a sense the Japanese government understands that warning now.

Data source: worldbank.org

Net, it is hard to make a case that the yen is going to reverse course soon.  For receivables/asset hedgers, keep that in mind.  At least the points are in your favor!

So, now that a trade deal’s agreed
Can China reverse from stall speed?
The data last night
Sure gave Xi a fright
More stimulus is what they need!

The other noteworthy macro story was Chinese PMI data coming in weaker than expected with the Manufacturing number falling to 49.0, vs 49.8 last month, with all the subcategories (foreign sales, new orders, employment and selling prices) contracting as well.  The Chinese mercantilist model continues to struggle amid widespread efforts by most developed nations to prevent the Chinese from dumping goods into their own economies via tariffs and restrictions.  The result is that Chinese companies are fighting on price, hence the deflationary situation there as too many goods are chasing not enough demand (money).  

There have been many stories lately about how the Chinese have the upper hand in their negotiations with the US, and several news outlets had stories this morning about how the US got the worst of the deal just agreed between Trump and Xi.  As well, this poet has not been to China for a very long time, so my observations are from afar.  However, things in China do not appear to be going swimmingly.  While there continues to be talk, and hope, that the government there is going to stimulate domestic consumer spending, that has been the story for the past 3 or 4 years and it has yet to occur in any effective manner.  The structural imbalances in China remain problematic as so many people relied upon their real estate investments as their nest egg and the real estate bubble continues to deflate 3 years after the initial shock.  Chinese debt remains extremely high and is growing, and while they certainly produce a lot of stuff, if other nations are reluctant to buy that stuff, that production is not very efficient for economic growth.

Many analysts continue to describe the US-China situation as China is playing chess while the US is playing checkers, implying the Chinese are thinking years ahead.  If that is so, please explain the one-child policy and the decimation of their demographics.  Just sayin.

Ok, let’s look at markets overnight.  While yesterday’s US markets were blah, at best, strong earnings from Amazon and Apple has futures rocking this morning with NASDAQ higher by 1.3% at this hour (7:40).  Those earnings, plus the euphoria over the Trade deal with the US sent Japanese shares (+2.1%) to another new all-time high which dragged along Korea (+0.5%) and New Zealand (+0.6%) but that was all.  The rest of Asia was under pressure as the weak Chinese PMI data weighed on both HK (-1.4%) and mainland (-1.5%) indices and that bled to virtually every other market. Meanwhile, European bourses are all somewhat lower as well, albeit not dramatically so, as the tech euphoria doesn’t really apply here.  So, declines between -0.1% (Spain) and -0.4% (UK) are the order of the day.

In the bond markets, yields have essentially been unchanged since the FOMC response with treasury yields edging 1bp higher this morning, now at 4.10%, while European sovereign yields are either unchanged or 1bp higher.  The ECB was a nothingburger, as expected, and going forward, all eyes will be on the data to see if any stances need change.

The commodity markets continue to be the place of most excitement with choppiness the rule.  Oil (-0.25%) is a touch softer this morning but continues to hover around the $60/bbl level.  I’m not sure what will get it moving, but right now, neither war nor peace seems to matter.  Regime change in Venezuela maybe?

Source: tradingeconomics.com

In the metals markets, volatility is still the norm with gold (-0.45%) lower this morning after a nice rebound yesterday and currently trading just above $4000/oz.  Silver and copper are unchanged this morning with platinum (-0.9%) following gold.  However, regardless of the recent market chop, the charts for all these metals remain distinctly bullish and the theme of debased fiat currencies is still alive.  Run it hot is still the US playbook, and that is going to support all commodity prices.

Finally, the dollar, after another step higher yesterday, is little changed this morning.  Both the euro and yen are unchanged and the rest of the G10 has slipped by between -0.1% and -0.2%.  In truth, today’s outlier is ZAR (-0.4%).  Now, let’s look at two ZAR charts, the past year and the long term, which tell very different stories.  In fact, it is important to remember that this is often the case, not merely a rand situation.  First, the past year shows the rand with a strengthening trend as per the below from tradingeconomics.com.  That spike was the response to Liberation Day.

But now, let’s look at a longer-term chart of the rand, showing the past 21 years.

Source: finance.yahoo.com

Like most emerging market currencies, the rand has been steadily depreciating vs. the dollar for decades.  It’s not that we haven’t seen a few periods of modest strength, but always remember that in the big picture, most EMG currency’s slide over time.  This is merely one example, and it is a BRICS currency.  The demise of the dollar remains a long way into the future.

On the data front, Chicago PMI (exp 42.3) is the only release, and we hear from three more Fed speakers.  It appears every FOMC member wants to get their view into the press as quickly as possible since there seem to be so many differing views.  In the end, I continue to think the Fed cuts in December, and nothing has changed.  But for now, there is less certainty as this morning, the probability of a cut is down to 66%.  I guess we’ll see.  But regardless, I still like the dollar for now.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

What Havoc it Wreaks

Posted on by

Today, for the first time in weeks
Comes news that will thrill data geeks
It’s CPI Day
So, what will it say?
We’ll soon see what havoc it wreaks
 
The forecast is zero point three
Too high, almost all would agree
But Jay and the Fed
When looking ahead
Will cut rates despite what they see

 

Spare a thought for the ‘essential’ BLS employees who were called back to the office during the shutdown so that they could prepare this month’s CPI report.  The importance of this particular report is it helps define the COLA adjustments to Social Security for 2026, so they wanted a real number, not merely the interpolation that would have otherwise been used.  Expectations for the outcome are Headline (0.4% M/M, 3.1% Y/Y) and Core (0.3% M/M, 3.1% Y/Y) with both still well above the Fed’s 2% target.  As an aside, we are also due Michigan Sentiment (55.0), but I suspect that will have far less impact on markets.

If we consider the Fed and its stable prices mandate, one could fairly make the case that they have not done a very good job, on their own terms, when looking at the chart below which shows that the last time Core CPI was at or below their self-defined target of 2.0% was four and one-half years ago in March 2021.  And it’s not happening this month either.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Now, when we consider the Fed and its toolkit, the primary monetary policy tool it uses is the adjustment of short-term interest rates.  The FOMC meets next Tuesday and Wednesday and will release its latest statement Wednesday afternoon followed by Chairman Powell’s press conference.  A quick look at the Fed funds futures market pricing shows us that despite the Fed’s singular inability to push inflation back toward its own target using its favorite tool, it is going to continue to cut interest rates and by the end of this year, Fed funds seem highly likely to be 50bps lower than their current level.

Source: cmegroup.com

The other tool that the Fed utilizes to address its monetary policy goals is the size of its balance sheet, as ever since the GFC and the first wave of ‘emergency’ QE, buying (policy ease) and selling (policy tightening) bonds has been a key part of their activities.  As you can see from the chart below, despite the 125bps of interest rate cuts since September of 2024 designed to ease policy, they continue to shrink the balance sheet (tighten policy) which may be why they have had net only a modest impact on things in the economy.  Driving with one foot on the gas and one on the brake tends to impede progress.

But now, the word is the Fed will completely stop balance sheet shrinkage by the end of the year, something we are likely to hear next Wednesday, as there has been much discussion amongst the pointy-head set about whether the Fed’s balance sheet now contains merely “ample” reserves rather than the previous description of “abundant” reserves.  And this is where it is important to understand Fedspeak, because on the surface, those two words seem awfully similar.  As I sought an official definition of each, I couldn’t help but notice that they both are synonyms of plentiful.

These are the sorts of things that, I believe, reduces the Fed’s credibility.  They sound far more like Humpty Dumpty (“When I use a word, it means just what I choose it to mean – neither more nor less.”) than like a group that analyses data to help in decision making.  

At any rate, no matter today’s result, it is pretty clear that Fed funds rates are going lower.  The thing is, the market has already priced for that outcome, so we will need to see some significant data surprises, either much weaker or stronger, to change views in interest rate sensitive markets like bonds and FX.

As to the shutdown, there is no indication that it is going to end anytime soon.  The irony is that the continuing resolution passed by the House was due to expire on November 21st.  it strikes me that even if they come back on Monday, they won’t have time to do the things that the CR was supposed to allow.  

Ok, let’s look at what happened overnight.  Yesterday’s rally in the US was followed by strength in Japan (+1.35%) after PM Takaichi indicated that they would spend more money but didn’t need to borrow any more (not sure how that works) while both China (+1.2%) and HK (+0.7%) also rallied on the confirmation that Presidents Trump and Xi will be meeting next week.  Elsewhere, Korea and Thailand had strong sessions while India, Taiwan and Australia all closed in the red.  And red is the color in Europe this morning with the CAC (-0.6%) the main laggard after weaker than forecast PMI data, while the rest of Europe and the UK all suffer very modest losses, around -0.1%.  US futures, though, are higher by 0.35% at this hour (7:20).

In the bond market, Treasury yields edged higher again overnight, up 1bp while European sovereigns have had a rougher go of things with yields climbing between 3bps and 4bps across the board.  While the French PMI data was weak, Germany and the rest of the continent showed resilience which, while it hasn’t seemed to help equities, has hurt bonds a bit.  Interestingly, despite the Takaichi comments about more spending, JGB yields slipped -1bp.

In the commodity space, oil (+0.7%) continues its rebound from the lows at the beginning of the week as the sanctions against the Russian oil majors clearly have the market nervous.  Of course, despite the sharp rally this week, oil remains in the middle of its trading range, and at about $62/bbl, cannot be considered rich.  Meanwhile, metals markets continue their recent extraordinary volatility, with pretty sharp declines (Au -1.7%, Ag -0.9%, Pt -2.1%) after sharp rallies yesterday.  There seems to be quite the battle ongoing here with positions being flushed out and delivery questions being raised for both futures and ETFs.  Nothing has changed my long-term view that fiat currencies will suffer vs. precious metals, but the trip can be quite volatile in the short run.

Finally, the dollar continues to creep higher vs. its fiat compatriots, with JPY (-.25%) pushing back toward recent lows (dollar highs) after the Takaichi spending plan announcements.  But, again, while the broad trend is clear, the largest movement is in PLN (-0.4%) hardly the sign of a major move.

And that’s all there is today.  We await the data and then go from there.  Even if the numbers are right at expectations, 0.3% annualizes to about 3.6%, far above the Fed’s target and much higher than we had all become accustomed to in the period between the GFC and Covid.  But remember, central bankers, almost to a wo(man) tend toward the dovish side, so I think we all need to be prepared for higher prices and weaker fiat currencies, although still, the dollar feels like the best of a bad lot.

There will be no poetry Monday as I will be heading to the AFP conference in Boston to present about a systematic way to more effectively utilize FX collars as a hedging tool.  But things will resume on Tuesday.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Has, Now, the Bell Tolled?

Posted on by

The pundits are still talking gold
But what is the reason it sold?
Liquidity drying
Means selling, not buying
Of havens. Has, now, the bell tolled?

 

One of the great things about FinX (FKA FinTwit) is that there are still a remarkable number of very smart folks who post things that help us better understand market gyrations.  The recent parabolic rise and this week’s reversal in the price of the barbarous relic seem unrelated to any concept of fundamentals one might have.  After all, perhaps the only fundamental that impacts gold is the rate of inflation, and since we haven’t seen a reading there in a month, it seems unlikely that had anything to do with this price action.  However, there is a far more likely explanation for the move lower, which has been very impressive in any context.  First, look at the chart below from tradingeconomics.com which shows the daily bars for the past 6 months.  The rise since early September has been nothing short of remarkable.

This begs two questions; first, why did it rise so far so fast, and second, what the heck happened on Friday to turn it around so dramatically?

The first question has several pieces to its answer including ongoing concerns over fiat currencies in general (the debasement trade that became popular), increased central bank buying and a recent change in financial advisors’ collective thought process about the merits of holding gold in an investment portfolio.  In fact, I think it was Bank of America (but I could be wrong) that recently suggested that the 60:40 portfolio should really be 60:20:20 with the final 20% being gold!  Given the human condition of jumping on bandwagons, it is no surprise that this type of ‘analysis’ has become more popular lately.  Whatever the driver, or combination of drivers, the price action was remarkable and clearly overdone.  After all, compare the current price, even after the recent sharp decline, to the 50-day moving average (the blue line on the chart) as an indicator of the extreme aspect of the price action.

But let’s focus on the last few days and the sharp reversal, which takes me back to X.  There is an account there (@_The_Prophet_) who put out an excellent step by step rationale of what led up to yesterday’s dramatic decline and why it is important.  I cannot recommend it highly enough as a short read.

In sum, his point is, and I fully subscribe to this idea, that when things get tough, investors/traders/speculators sell what they can sell, not what they want to sell.  If liquidity is drying up for the funding of speculative assets that are highly leveraged, then when margin and collateral calls come, and they always do, those owners sell whatever they have that they can liquidate.  In this case, given the massive run up in the price of gold, there was a significant amount of value to be drawn down and utilized to satisfy those margin calls.  

History has shown this to be the case time and again.  I would point to the Long-Term Capital Management fiasco back in 1998 where the Nobel Prize winning fund managers quickly found out that liquidity was much more important than ideas and they were forced to sell out their Treasury holdings rather than their leveraged positions because the former had prices and the latter didn’t.  This ultimately led to the liquidation of their fund along with some $5 billion in capital.

There has been much discussion as to the nature of the recent rise in asset prices with many pundits calling it the everything bubble.  Bubbles are created when central banks pump significant liquidity into the system and this is no different.  We know the Fed has allegedly (look at the graph of M2 below to see how much they have been increasing money supply during their tightening) been trying to reduce its balance sheet (i.e. liquidity) but this could well be a sign that phase is over.  Typically, the next step is QE in some form, so beware.  And when that comes, you can be sure that gold will rally sharply once again!

Of course, while the gold move has been the most spectacular, we have seen a lot more market volatility in the past several sessions, so let’s look at how things behaved overnight.  Yesterday’s mixed US session was followed by more laggards than leaders in Asia with Japan essentially unchanged, while HK (-0.9%) and China (-0.3%) both slid a bit.  Recent comments by President Trump that he may not sit down with President Xi next week have investors and traders there nervous.  Elsewhere, Korea (+1.5%) and Thailand (+1.1%) had solid sessions while the rest of the region (Indonesia -1.0%, Malaysia -0.9%, Australia -0.7%) all lagged.

In Europe, the UK (+0.9%) is benefitting this morning from softer than expected inflation readings (3.8% vs 4.0% expected) which has tongues wagging that the BOE will now be cutting rates.  The market priced probability has risen to 60% for a cut this year, up from 40% yesterday, before this morning’s data release.  However, on the continent, only Spain (+0.6%) is showing any life on local earnings performance while the rest of the markets are all lower by varying degrees between -0.1% and -0.5%.  As to US futures, at this hour (7:20) they are unchanged.

Bond markets continue to see yields slide lower with Treasuries (-1bp) now nicely below 4.00% and trading at their lowest level in more than a year (see below)

Source: tradingeconomics.com

European sovereign yields have seen similar movement, edging lower by -1bp except for UK gilts, which have fallen -10bps this morning after that inflation report.  Perhaps more interesting is the fact that despite Takaichi-san becoming PM, with her platform of increased fiscal spending, JGB yields are 2bps lower this morning.

Turning to the rest of the commodity space, oil (+2.1%) is rising on the news that the US has started to refill the SPR.  While the initial bid is only for 1 million barrels, this is seen as the beginning of the process with the administration taking advantage of the recent low prices.  Arguably, given they want to see more drilling as well, it is very possible that $55/bbl is as low as they really want it to go.  As to the metals beyond gold (-2.4% this morning), silver (-1.6%) is still getting dragged along but copper (+0.6%) and platinum (+0.9%) seem to be consolidating after sharp declines in both.  My sense is gold remains the liquidity asset of choice given its far larger market value.  (One other thing to note is that there was much discussion how gold has replaced Treasuries as the most widely held central bank reserve asset.  That was entirely a valuation story, not a purchase story.  In other words, the dramatic rise in the price of gold increased the value of its holdings relative to other assets on central bank balance sheets.)  

Finally, the dollar is doing just fine.  It continues within its recent trading range and basically hasn’t gone anywhere in the past six months.  In fact, of you look at the DXY chart below from Yahoo Finance, it is arguably in the upper quintiles of its long-term price action.  It is very difficult for me to listen to all the reasons that the dollar is going to be replaced by some other reserve currency and take it very seriously.

As to specific currency moves today, the pound (-0.3%) is slipping on the increased belief in a rate cut coming soon and ZAR (-0.5%) is suffering on the ongoing gold price decline but away from those two, +/-0.1% is the story of the day.

EIA Crude Oil inventories are the only data of the day with a modest build expected.  Yesterday, Governor Waller discussed payment systems and cryptocurrencies never straying into monetary policy so we will need to wait for CPI on Friday, the FOMC next Wednesday and whenever the government reopens, which I sense is coming sooner rather than later as the Democrats have been completely unsuccessful in making the case this is President Trump’s fault.  

It appears the cracks in the leverage that has accompanied the recent rally in asset prices are beginning to appear.  If things get worse, and they probably will, look for the Fed to respond and haven assets to be in demand.  Amongst those will be the dollar.

Good luck

Adf