Tag Archives: #oil

Some Shocks

Posted on by

While many still seek goldilocks
The problem is we’ve seen some shocks
Inflation won’t fall
And oil’s in thrall
To US and UK war hawks
 
But if we adhere to the data
It’s really not looking that great-a
For those who think Jay
Will soon lead the way
By cutting the Fed’s funding rate-a

We are back to being inundated with new information from both economic data and global events, both of which are driving markets for now.  Interestingly, depending on the asset class, it seems that some are studiously ignoring what this new information means, at least what it has historically meant.

Let’s start with yesterday’s CPI data, which printed higher than forecast on both the headline (3.4%) and core (3.9%) measures.  One needn’t be a market technician to look at the chart below of annualized CPI over the past five years and consider the possibility that the downtrend has ended, and we are reversing higher.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

To the extent that financial data has trends, and I think that is a very realistic estimate of how things work, the Fed may have a much tougher time squeezing the last 1.0% – 1.5% out of the inflationary process than many seem to believe.  At least many in the bond market seem to believe that as despite the hotter than expected CPI data, bond yields actually declined yesterday.  As well, there is no indication from the Fed funds futures market that they have changed their view on the number of rate cuts coming in 2024 with an even higher probability of a March cut, > 70% this morning, and still 6 cuts priced in for the entire year.  

Regarding this seeming dichotomy, it is almost as if the market is trying to force the Fed’s hand.  Historically, the Fed has tried not to ‘surprise’ markets when it comes to decisions, keeping a close eye on market pricing on the day of each meeting.  As such, if the market is pricing in a cut or a hike, the Fed has been highly likely to follow through in the past.  When there have been disagreements, the Fed will typically roll out lots of speakers to get their view across before the meeting in order to prevent that surprise on meeting day.  As well, it is very clear that there is virtually no expectation of a rate adjustment at the FOMC meeting on January 31st, so perhaps the Fed doesn’t feel it is warranted to be that concerned yet.  And of course, the data may turn in the direction of much softer inflation and even modestly worse employment so a cut will become the de facto norm.  But my point is, the March 20th meeting is just 67 days away.  For an economy whose trends move very slowly, it seems like the market may be a bit ahead of itself in this case.

We did hear from three Fed speakers yesterday, Mester, Barkin and Goolsbee, all of whom indicated that while the broad direction of things seemed pretty good, a rate cut in March is very premature.  In fact, that has been the consistent theme from every Fed speaker and the market just doesn’t seem to care.  We will see two PCE reports, two more CPI reports and two more NFP reports before the March FOMC meeting.  And they will all be part of Q1 data, not Q4 data, so will at least have more relevance to the current situation.  Maybe the market is correct, and inflation is going to turn back lower, and the first signs of economic weakness will convince Powell and friends it’s time to preemptively cut rates.  However, even if that turns out to be the case, it is hard for me to see that as a > 70% probable outcome.  Of course, I am just an FX poet, so maybe I just don’t get it.

The other topic that is making an impact is the Middle East.  You may recall that oil prices had been on the soft side as the market saw weakening demand due to an impending recession with massive supply gains coming from better and better producer efficiency.  In fact, I wrote about the latter this past Sunday in Oil’s Price is not Rising.  However, all that efficiency is unimportant when compared to the escalation that we saw last evening in the Middle East, where US and UK forces attacked Houthi positions in Yemen in retaliation for the Houthi attacks on shipping in the Red Sea.  This morning, oil is higher by 3.5% and since Monday, the rise has been 6.6%.  

This poses several problems overall.  First, of course, is the widening of the Middle East conflict being a problem in and of itself.  The US military is already straining with its mission given the number of different places US troops are in harm’s way throughout the Middle East and Asia.  The one thing we have learned throughout history is that war is inflationary.  So, escalations in fighting will ultimately lead to escalations in prices of many things.  Oil is merely the first casualty.  

If you are Jay Powell whose current mission is to reduce inflationary pressures, a widening military conflict is not going to help the situation.  In fact, it is likely that he will be called upon to support the military by ensuring the Treasury can issue as much debt as necessary at reasonable prices.  This means the end of QT and a restarting of QE.  If that were to be the case, and that is a big if, inflation would start another strong leg higher, and markets will be greatly impacted.  Commodity prices will rise, the dollar will likely weaken, a bear steepening for bond yields would be in the cards and equity markets would rally, at least initially.  But it would throw out any ideas of low inflation.  I am not saying this is the current expectation, just that it is something that needs to be considered as events unfold going forward.

A quick look at the impact on markets today shows that equity markets are non-plussed by the escalation as yesterday’s benign US performance was followed by another rally in Japan although Chinese shares continue to lag after a big data dump showed economic activity there remains export oriented into a slowing global growth situation.  Inflation remains moribund there, the Trade Surplus grew, and domestic funding continues to grow at a slower and slower pace.    In Europe, though, there does not seem to be much concern as equity indices are all higher by about 0.5% although US futures are suffering a bit, -0.35%, at this hour (7:45).

In the bond market, Treasury yields are 3bps higher this morning than yesterday’s close, although they remain right at 4.00%, so are not really moving very much right now.  Meanwhile, European sovereign yields, which closed before the US yields declined late, are all down about 3bps this morning, helped by confirmation that final inflation readings in Europe remained at recent lows.  In the UK, the net data dump showed slightly weaker than forecast IP and GDP data which has helped drive the bid in Gilts. A quick JGB look, where yields fell 2bps, revolves around a story that the BOJ is going to reduce its end of year inflation forecast thus reducing the probability of any policy change anytime soon.  This is one of the things helping the Nikkei and also a key driver of USDJPY higher.

Aside from oil prices rising, we are seeing gold (+1.0%) on the move today on the back of the Middle East escalation although the base metals are mixed.  One other commodity note is uranium, a market which has been getting a lot more love lately given the recent acceptance by a portion of the eco community that its ability to generate electricity without producing CO2 is a net benefit.  40 nations have promised to increase their nuclear power use and demand for uranium has been rising amid a market where there is very limited supply and annual production does not meet current annual demand, let alone projected future demand.  I simply wanted to highlight that there are price movements all over the place and while uranium may not be a major contribution to inflation, the fact that its price is rising so rapidly (100% in the past year) is not going to push inflation lower.

Finally, the dollar is firming up this morning as risk assets come under pressure.  This is a typical war footing, where investors flee to the dollar in times of stress, just like they flee to gold.  While the movement thus far has not been substantial, just 0.3% on average, it definitely has room to move further if things deteriorate in the Red Sea.

On the data front, we see PPI this morning, expected 0.9% headline, 2.0% ex food & energy, although given CPI was released yesterday, I doubt it will matter very much.  As well, we hear from Minneapolis Fed president Kashkari, so it will be interesting to see if he has a different take than March is too soon, but things seem to be going well.

As we head into the weekend, the Middle East is the wild card.  If things heat up, look for oil prices to continue to rise and risk to be discarded.  That will probably help the bond market for now, and the dollar, but stocks will suffer.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Oil’s Price is not Rising

Posted on by

Recession has yet to appear
And Janet has signaled, ‘all clear’
But many still worry
She’s in quite a hurry
To help Biden’s prospects this year
 
One key to this outcome, surprising
Has been oil’s price is not rising
Now, why would that be
If strong ESG
Intentions force drilling downsizing?

This note is a departure from my daily missive as I wanted to address a bigger picture concern regarding the evolution of the US, and global, economy.  I would contend that one of the underlying theses that has been part of the market narrative for quite a while is that there is a finite supply of oil and hydrocarbons available beneath the surface and that since all the easy stuff has already been found, the cost of extraction is going to rise and push the oil price higher along with those costs.  I’m confident that if you have paid any attention to the discussion, you will have heard about peak oil being forecast (the IEA just claimed it will occur in 2030, although that was pushed back from 2028 in last year’s report) and a theory known as Hubbard’s peak theory, which explains that once an oil field has produced half its reserves, its ability to continue to produce at previous levels is dramatically reduced, thus reducing output.

In fact, this was a cornerstone of my mental model regarding inflation and the economy for the past several years.  Forgetting for a moment that oil prices are quite volatile as can be seen in the below long-term chart from tradingeconomics.com, one can argue that the broader trend has been for higher oil prices.

As such, if oil prices, and the concurrent price for all types of energy, was going to continue to rise, it seems difficult to believe that inflation would stabilize.  After all, energy is an input into virtually every part of the economy and if oil was rising, stable inflation would require deflation in other areas.  Now, during the past twenty odd years, with China’s entry into the WTO and the broader global economy, their rapid expansion clearly weighed on the price of manufactured goods.  But I believe it is a fair assessment to say that factor is currently dissipating and will continue to do so going forward as evidenced by the significant rise in populist politics around the world.  After all, a key part of populism is the inward-looking aspect, supporting domestic activity and shunning imports in an effort to keep jobs in the home country.

With this as a baseline thesis, the question at hand is what can change this view?  Well, I recently read a terrific article and listened to a very interesting podcast with an analyst who goes by the name of Doomberg.  Doomberg made some really great points about some little-known features of the oil and gas markets which tend to be ignored or glossed over, but which are ultimately very important.  Arguably, the most important was to recall that technology improvements are not simply made by Apple and Microsoft, but by energy firms as well, and they have been improving their efficiency in extracting oil and oil products dramatically.  Perhaps the number that will really blow your mind is that the US, by itself, is currently producing ~20 million barrels/day of oil and oil-type products (usually described as Natural Gas liquids or NGLs) which makes the US by far the largest producer of energy on the planet, dwarfing Saudi Arabia and Russia.  And despite all the efforts by those who are desperate to end oil production completely, these numbers are almost certainly going to continue to grow as cheap energy is the most critical feature to develop a growing economy and improve living standards.

The fact that the US economy continues to plug along and avoid recession, and the fact that despite very real concerns over an escalation of the fighting in the middle east and what that might do to the short-term supply of oil, the price of oil is trading far closer to recent lows than highs, indicates to me that there is a great deal of truth in this view.  In fact, I have become persuaded that I need to adjust my world view accordingly.  You know what they say about new information and changing your mind.

So, I am going to rough out a new mental model with this new information on the key input to economic activity, the price of energy, and see how I think things may evolve over time.

The first thing to note is that global growth, writ large, is likely to outperform current estimates going forward.  After all, if cheap energy becomes more widely available, then the billions of people who live in Africa, Asia and Latin America who subsist on minuscule amounts of energy each day are going to see substantial improvements in their lives.  (Of course, I cannot account for the political machinations which may prevent this, but I believe that no matter how inept or corrupt these governments are, some portion will get through to the population.)  The upshot of this is emerging market economies are likely to grow at a more rapid clip which will require more resources and feed through to more economic activity around the world.  While there will be constraints on this growth eventually, for the next several years at least, and probably for a decade or more, I expect that the story will be a large net positive.

But perhaps more importantly for a more current economic outlook, the availability of relatively cheap energy is going to be a huge boon for the developed world.  For instance, the below graph explains a great deal about the current situation in Germany with respect to the fact that it is experiencing a recession and the fact that the populist, right-wing AfD political party is making huge gains in the polls.

Energy intensive industry that had been built on the back of cheap natural gas imported from Russia has been fleeing the country with major companies building facilities in the US to take advantage of the fact that natural gas prices in the US are <$3.00/mmBTU while in Europe they remain above $9.00/mmBTU although they have fallen from their highest levels last year.  Consider, though, what will happen if the abundance of cheap energy about which I am hypothesizing becomes reality.  Suddenly, many more countries, even those without their own natural supplies of energy, will be able to take advantage of the benefit of cheap energy.  If we know one thing it is that all the energy produced will be consumed in some manner, and the cheaper the cost of production, the more widely spread will be its availability.

I highlight Germany as an illustration of what will almost certainly occur worldwide.  In other words, reducing the cost of the key input into virtually all economic activity, namely energy, is going to support a very real increase in that activity.

As to the inflation story, here too, much of the blame falls on political efforts to control certain sectors of an economy or to show favor to others, which impedes appropriate price discovery.  And that will never change, I fear.  However, it becomes much easier to believe that if we eliminate a key plank of the long-term inflation narrative, namely resource constraints driving prices higher, that general price inflation will have far less staying power.  

Putting this together leads to a very different, and much more positive, outcome than I had envisioned previously, and than I believe, many had envisioned.  For a given level of nominal GDP growth, more will be real growth and less will be price adjustments, a truly beneficial outcome.  

The next question then is how might this impact financial markets going forward?  This is always a treacherous question given nobody really knows.  But, looking at the four main market segments; interest rates, equities, commodities and FX, here are my first thoughts.

Interest Rates – The first thing to consider is that there is an enormous amount of debt currently outstanding around the world, something on the order of $300 trillion to $350 trillion.  The two macroeconomic ways to pay back debt are to inflate it away or to generate sufficient economic activity to outstrip the accumulation of that debt.  As my contention is inflation will be lower alongside higher productivity, this is a sea change in thinking.  While I had always expected inflation to be the likely course, this opens the possibility for growth to do the work.  While debtors typically like inflation, especially governments, this new paradigm is likely to be even more effective.  Net, I expect that the general level of interest rates will decline somewhat everywhere as higher productivity should help creditworthiness as well as governments.  Faster real economic activity should generate more tax revenues and reduce issuance from that perspective thus easing the oversupply problem.

Equity markets – This outcome should be a net long-term benefit for equity markets as the underlying aspect is that economic growth should accelerate.  However, while companies may perform well at the bottom line, equity markets are a function of the underlying company and the value multiple that investors place on those companies.  Right now, valuations remain far higher than long term historical values.  For instance, the current Shiller Cyclically Adjusted PE Ratio (CAPE) is at 31.78.  This compares to a mean of 17.07 and median of 15.96 over the past 150 years.  While improved productivity on the back of cheaper energy is likely to raise the appropriate level for this statistic, it still appears quite richly valued.  For instance, if 20.00 is a more appropriate price multiple in this new world, which would be a 25% increase on the median, the market is still massively overvalued.  As such, equity prices might still decline despite this good economic outcome.  However, I would say that given emerging market, and even European market pricing is much less robust, cheaper and more abundant energy should help those markets dramatically.

Commodities – Here, the tale will be told by the political machinations going forward.  By rights, commodity prices everywhere should decline, at least initially, if energy prices decline, if for no other reason than the cost of producing them will decline.  However, the ESG mindset remains widespread and there remain a disturbingly large number of people who want to stop all commodity production activity, oil & gas, metals, and even foodstuffs.  If this group is able to maintain political power, they can prevent all the possible benefits.  But even if we assume they lose power as people decide that improved living standards are more valuable to them than concerns over global warming, the fact that there may be an extraordinary amount of cheaply available energy does not mean there is an extraordinary amount of copper, nickel or aluminum available.  At some point, we could see physical constraints manifest themselves, but at least initially, I expect that other commodity prices will follow energy prices lower.

FX – Since FX is a relative game, this outcome is all about the relative adoption of this new paradigm.  The first nations to embrace this view and see improved economic activity are likely to see their currencies strengthen as investment flows in.  The fact that they will be able to keep interest rates lower will not necessarily hurt these currencies’ value as investors will be flocking to their equity markets and real investments, not looking for currency arbitrage.  Of course, at this time, there is no way to know who will embrace this idea and lead the pack, but the US certainly has a head start given it is the source of much of the cheap energy and the concomitant technology driving it.  But you can bet that China will get on this bus quickly, once they recognize its existence, and after that, widespread adoption will drive things.  In fact, my biggest concern is that the politics will hold back Europe as they remain enthralled by their climate virtue signaling and it may take far longer to change that view.  Either that, or a really cold winter with people running out of energy.  So initially, I think this is quite dollar supportive, but over time, we will need to see the evolution of the process.

This is the essence of my evolving view, better real economic activity and increased productivity alongside lower inflation on the back of abundant, and therefore, relatively cheap energy is a growing probability in my mind. If this scenario plays out, it will have very real impacts on financial markets, but more importantly on our everyday lives, and for the latter, I expect quite positive impacts.  However, given the current state of politics, this transition will likely take much longer in some parts of the world than others.  Keep that in mind as you consider these issues.  And remember, these are my first takes.  I could well be wrong about the market impacts and welcome comments offering different views.

I apologize for the length of this note, but that is why I put it out on a Sunday rather than a weekday!

Good luck

Adf

Dim-Witted

Posted on by 
Said Jay, though we’re strongly committed
To make sure no ‘flation’s permitted
Quite frankly we’re lost
And ‘fraid of the cost
If we screw up cause we’re dim-witted

So, we’ll watch the data releases
And act if inflation increases
But if it should fall
Then it will forestall
More hiking lest we step in feces

As expected, the Powell comments were yesterday’s highlights as he once again explained that the goal of 2% inflation remains their primary effort.  Not surprisingly, given what we have heard from the onslaught of Fed speakers over the past two weeks, he made clear that there will be no rate hike at the November meeting, but December is still in play.  When asked about the rise in long-term yields, he did indicate it could be doing some of the Fed’s work for them, just like we heard earlier this week from Lorrie Logan and others.  Somewhat surprisingly, he mentioned the rising budget deficits, describing them as on an “unsustainable” path.  Now, we all know this is true, but Powell has been extremely careful not to discuss government funding throughout his tenure as Chair.  I suspect his next testimony to Congress could be a little spicier!

Of course, the other six speakers added exactly nothing to the conversation as they merely reiterated in their own words the same message.  Perhaps of more interest was that despite effective confirmation that there was no hike upcoming and that the bar for a December rate hike was quite high, bonds continued to sell off with the 10yr yield closing at 5.0% while stocks took it on the chin again.  Methinks there is more than a little concern starting to grow amongst asset managers that the concept of the Fed put may finally be gone.  

The other really interesting outcome yesterday was the fact that gold rallied another 1.3% despite the ongoing rise in interest rates.  As there was no new news out of the Middle East of any real note, one possible explanation is that investors are simply getting quite scared overall.  

One thing is quite certain and that is if the situation changes such that Powell and company become concerned that the economy is reversing course and they have, in fact, overtightened monetary policy, any reversal of the current message is likely to lead to some very big moves.  In that case I would expect a much weaker dollar, a huge rally in gold and other commodities, an initial rally in equities and, remarkably, not much movement in bonds.  I remain of the strong belief that the supply issue is the key bond market driver, so that will only increase in the event of an economic slowdown and that cannot help the bond market, even if the Fed starts to buy them again.  But that is all hypothetical.

Turning to the overnight session, while risk continues to be shed in Asia and Europe, we did see Japanese inflation data where the headline rate declined to 3.0% and the core to 2.8% although their super core reading is still at 4.2%.  Certainly, Ueda-san must be pleased that the numbers are beginning to edge a bit lower although they remain far above the 2% target.  Of course, the very fact that they are edging lower implies that any end to QQE is even further in the future.  Recall, Ueda-san has been clear that he does not believe 2% inflation is yet sustainable in the economy and is concerned it is going to slip back below that level in the medium term.  With that attitude, he has exactly zero incentive to end YCC or QQE and seems far more likely to continue with them.  

The implication of this outcome is that the yen seems likely to weaken further.  Currently, USDJPY is trading at 149.95 and although it hasn’t touched the 150 level since that first brush on October 3rd, it has been grinding ever so slowly back there again.  This price action has all the earmarks of stealth intervention, something that may be carried out by the three Japanese mega banks at the BOJ’s behest.  However, given the ongoing trajectory in US interest rates, it seems only a matter of time before we once again breech 150.  It will be quite interesting to see the MOF/BOJ reaction at that time, although I suspect they will, at the very least, “check rates.”  For hedgers, be careful here.

And really, that’s all we’ve got to talk about today.  As mentioned above, equity markets fell in Asia overnight, with losses on the order of -0.5% or so and European bourses are all down about -1.0% this morning heading into the US open.  As to US futures, at this hour (7:00) they are off about -0.4% as we head into an option expiration session.  Thus far, earnings season has not been sufficient to excite investors and fear seems to be the driver of note.

Turning to the bond market, while we have backed off from yesterday’s closing highs of 5.0% by 5bps, we remain at multi-year highs and there is no reason to believe that we have seen the top in yields.  In fact, this move appears to be driven by rising real yields, not inflation concerns.  While real yields have already risen substantially over the past 6 months, rising from ~1.0% to the current 2.45%, history has shown that real yields can easily rise to 4% or more in the right circumstances, and these may just be those circumstance.  Again, there is no evidence that Treasury yields have topped.  As to European sovereigns this morning, they are edging lower by about -1bp after a large rally yesterday as well.  US Treasury price action continues to be the global driver for now.

Oil prices (+1.5%) continue to trade higher as concerns over a widening of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict keep traders on edge.  Combine this with the weaker production numbers from the US and the drawdown in inventories and you have the ingredients for a further price rally.  News that a US Missile Cruiser in the Red Sea shot down several drones and missiles launched from Yemen cannot have helped sentiment.  Meanwhile, gold (+0.4%, +2.6% this week) continues to play the role of safe haven.  Either that or there is a lot of short-covering ongoing.  The price is approaching $2000/oz, one of those big round numbers on which markets tend to focus so I would look for a test there if nothing else.  However, base metals are softer this morning as the price action today is not economically related.

Finally, the dollar continues to tread water this morning with most of the major currencies within +/- 0.2% of yesterday’s closing levels while EMG currencies seem to be edging a bit lower, down on the order of -0.3%.  The renminbi is little changed this morning despite (because of?) the PBOC injecting CNY733 billions of fresh liquidity into the market/economy there overnight.  Again, just like the yen, the diametrically opposed monetary policy of China and the US should lead to further currency weakness here over time.  Now, the PBOC doesn’t like to see sharp movement and will continue to prevent a blowout move, but the spot rate is currently trading right at its 2% band vs. the CFETS fixing, so something has got to give soon.  In the end, the dollar trend remains intact, but I must admit I am surprised it is not a bit stronger given the underlying fear in the market.

On the data front, there are no statistics released and we hear from two more Fed speakers, Harker and Mester, to finish things off before the quiet period begins.  It seems hard to believe that anything they say will be seen as more important than Powell’s comments yesterday.  As such, looking at today’s market activity, while there will be tape-watching regarding the Middle East and any escalation in hostilities, I suspect the equity market will have the most influence on things.  At this point, further weakness seems the most likely outcome, especially as traders will be reluctant to be overly long risk heading into the weekend.  

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Growth Dynamo

Posted on by 
The data continues to show
Economies still want to grow
Here in the US
The Retail success
Came ere China's growth dynamo

The upshot is all of the talk
That bonds are where people should flock
Turns out to be wrong
Then those who went long
Are likely to soon be in shock

Wow!  That’s all you can say about the data from yesterday where Retail Sales were hot and beat on every measure (headline 0.7%, ex-autos 0.6%, control group 0.6%) while IP (0.3%) and Capacity Utilization (79.7%) also indicated that economic activity remains quite robust in the US.  On the data front, this was followed by last night’s Chinese data dump where every one of their monthly indicators; GDP (4.9%), IP (4.5%), Retail Sales (5.5%), Fixed Asset Investment (3.1%), Capacity Utilization (75.6%) and Unemployment (5.0%), was better than expected.

Perhaps the idea that a recession is right around the corner needs to be reconsidered.  And remember, I have been in that camp as well, but the data is the data and needs to inform our opinions.  The immediate reaction to yesterday’s US data was a sharp decline in both stocks and bonds, while oil rallied, gold edged higher and the dollar tread water.  Of this movement, I was most surprised at the dollar’s lack of dynamism given the rate situation.  Unremarkably, given the ongoing belief in the Fed pivot, by the end of the day, US equities were tantamount to unchanged.  But the bond market remains under severe pressure with yields having risen another 12bps in the 10-year and having now reversed the entire safe haven move on the back of the Israeli-Hamas war situation.  

I continue to believe that yields have much further to rise and stronger data will only add to the case.  My view had been based on the combination of stickier inflation than the punditry describes along with massive amounts of new issuance requiring a lower price (higher yield) to clear markets.  But if we are going to continue to see strong economic growth, then there is an added catalyst for yields to rise.

One of the problems about which we hear constantly these days is the fact that there are no more natural buyers of US Treasury debt, at least not at current yield levels.  Many point to the decline in ownership by both Japan and China, the two largest foreign holders of Treasuries, and claim they are both selling their holdings.  However, I have a quibble with that thesis and would contend that perhaps, they are merely suffering the same mark-to-market losses that the banks are.  For instance, according to the US Treasury Department, holdings by these two nations from July 2022 through July 2023 declined by -9.6% (Japan) and -12.5% (China) respectively as can be seen in the chart below.  (data source US Treasury)

But ask yourself what has happened to interest rates over the past year?  They have risen dramatically (10yr yields +85bps) and that means the price of bonds has declined.  As a proxy, in the past 12 months, TLT (the long bond ETF) has declined by more than 13% in price.  So, if you have the exact same amount of bonds and their prices declined by 13%, it is not hard to understand how when you measure the value of your portfolio it has shrunk by upwards of 13%.  I have no idea what the maturity ladders for Japan and China look like, and it is likely they own a mix of short and long-dated bonds, but it is not at all clear to me they have actually been selling Treasuries.  Likely, they are simply holding tight, and I would not be surprised, given the dramatic rise in yields here, if they roll maturities into new bonds.  All I’m saying here is that the narrative about everybody fleeing bonds may not be correct.  In fact, regarding the TLT, which is a pretty good proxy for bond demand of the retail investor, there is a case to be made that demand is quite high.  My understanding is that calls on the TLT are amongst the most active contracts in the options market, and people don’t buy calls if they are bearish!

With that in mind, though, the underlying point is US yields continue to rise and that is going to be the driver for all markets.  In global bond markets, the US unambiguously leads the way and we have seen European sovereigns show similar movement to the US with large moves higher in yields yesterday, on the order of 10bps – 15bps depending on the nation, and consolidation today with virtually no movement, the same as Treasuries.  Last night, JGB yields managed to rally 3bps as well, another indication that as goes the US, so goes the world.

But the more interesting thing to me is the ability of the equity market to hold onto its gains.  The fact that US markets rallied back nearly one full percent from the immediate post-data lows was quite impressive.  Consider that the leadership of the US stock market has been the so-called magnificent 7 tech stocks (Apple, Microsoft, Google, Amazon, Nvidia, Meta (nee Facebook), and Tesla) most of which are essentially long duration assets with their extreme values based on a belief that they will continue to grow at incredible rates.  But with yields rising, the present value of those anticipated earnings continues to decline which should generally be a negative for their price.  So far, they have held up reasonably well, but cracks are definitely starting to show.  I suspect that at some point in the not-too-distant future if yields continue on their current trajectory, that equity market comeuppance will arrive and these stocks will feel the brunt of it.  But not yet apparently.  Interestingly, despite the positive Chinese data, equities in Hong Kong and the mainland both declined about -0.5%.  And looking at Europe, weakness is the theme with all the major bourses lower by -0.5%.  As to US futures, -0.25% covers the situation at this hour (8:00).

Meanwhile, the escalation in Israel and concerns about a wider Mideast war have joined with the stronger economic data, especially from China, to push oil prices higher again this morning, up 1.8%.  And that war theme has gold rocking as well, up 1.3% to new highs for the move with both copper and aluminum rising on the better economic data.  High nominal growth and high inflation (so low real growth) is going to be a powerful support for commodity prices.

Finally, turning to the dollar, this is where I lose my train of thought.  Given the higher yields and seeming increased worries about a wider Mideast war, I would have expected the dollar to continue to rally.  But that has not been the case.  Instead, it has been stable, stuck in a tight range against most of its major and emerging market counterparts.  Perhaps this market is waiting to hear from Chairman Powell tomorrow before traders take a view, but I need to keep looking for a reason to sell the dollar as the evidence to buy it seems strong, higher yields and safety.

Today’s data brings Housing Starts (exp 1.38M) and Building Permits (1.45M) as well as the EIA oil inventory data.  We also hear from a bunch more Fed speakers; Waller, Williams, Bowman Harker and Cook, so it will be interesting to see if there are more definitive views on a pause, especially after the recent hot data.  I have not changed my view that the dollar has further to rise, but its recent relative weakness is a potential warning that something else is driving things.  I will continue to investigate, but for now, higher still seems the better bet.

Good luck

Adf

Not Quite Yet Dead

Posted on by 
Inflation is not quite yet dead
And that has some thinking the Fed
May now have concern
That there’ll be no turn
And possibly more hikes instead

Last week, though, more Fedspeak, we heard
And three speakers’ comments sent word
That higher long rates
Have altered the fates
Now they think hikes could be deferred

Before I touch on the markets, I must acknowledge the heinous acts that occurred last weekend in Israel.  It is abundantly clear that this will not be ending soon, and it seems likely that it may ultimately have an impact on financial markets.  However, this commentary revolves around how global markets move, what new catalysts are driving things and how we might consider all the information when trying to determine the best way to hedge outstanding FX exposures.

So, before we talk about the overnight session, let’s quickly recap my week away.  Inflation, in both the guise of PPI and CPI, was a bit hotter than expected which has put a crimp in the Paul Krugman ‘inflation battle is won’ narrative.  I am constantly amazed at the disingenuity of analysts explaining that if you ignore food, energy, rent, used cars and any other thing that rose, then inflation is back at the Fed’s target.  It is not clear to me if they don’t eat, use energy, or pay for living expenses, but that is simply ridiculous.  The consumer confidence data makes clear that folks are extremely unhappy with the current economic situation and too high inflation remains the primary cause.  Regardless of the data points, people are feeling it when they buy gas and groceries, or if they go out for dinner, let alone buying other stuff.  

I have maintained this is not going to end soon and that 3.5% – 4.0% is going to be the new normal inflation rate.  While Daly, Logan and Jefferson all explained that the steepening of the yield curve with long end rates rising more rapidly than short end rates was helping the Fed’s cause, not one of them indicated they were even thinking about thinking about cutting rates.  In fact, my money is on at least one more hike, probably in December at this point, and I cannot rule out further hikes in 2024.  And folks, higher rates are going to wind up breaking more things.  Do not believe the soft-landing narrative, things are going to get worse, almost certainly.  Arguably, that sums up last week.

Turning to the overnight session, there was limited new news in the way of data or commentary.  Market participants continue to focus on central banks and any potential adjustments in their policies, economic data and clues as to whether the long-anticipated recession is finally coming, and the trajectory of inflation and whether the price of oil is going to have a longer-term impact on that trajectory.

Regarding the first of these issues, in addition to the above-mentioned Fedspeak, the market is anxiously awaiting Chairman Powell’s comments to be made Thursday afternoon just before the Fed’s quiet period begins.  While we will hear from ten other Fed speakers over sixteen different venues (!), the reality is that Powell’s words are the most important.  However, given the seeming unanimity in the new message about the long end of the curve helping the Fed, I suspect that Powell will touch on that subject as well.  To my mind, this is not an indication they are unhappy with the bond market selloff, rather that they are quite comfortable and will not do anything to stop it.  That could well give the bond market vigilantes a signal to sell even more aggressively so be prepared.

Last night we did hear from Kanda-san of the MOF who explained that rate hikes are one option when excessive forex moves are seen.  Now, that seems a bit of a surprise in that the BOJ is ostensibly the one controlling interest rates, but this shows that the concept of central bank independence is quite tenuous in Japan, and probably in most places.  You may recall a few weeks ago when USDJPY touched 150 and immediately reversed and fell 2% in mysterious fashion as no intervention was confirmed.  Do not be surprised if we see similar price action at various levels higher in the dollar, although helpfully, there was a comment that the fundamentals (meaning interest rate differentials) were responsible for much of the movement in FX.  Nothing has changed my view that USDJPY has higher to go.

On the economic data front, obviously last week’s inflation data had an impact with Treasury yields shaking off their safe-haven bid due to the Israeli-Palastinian conflict and rising again this morning.  While they are not yet back at the highest levels seen two weeks ago, I expect we will get back there and move higher still going forward.  This week’s Retail Sales data (exp 0.3%, 0.2% ex autos) is the big print and recall, it has been running hotter than expected for a while now.  Understand that Retail Sales counts the dollars spent, not the items bought, so rising inflation will drive this number higher even if things aren’t improving.  But for now, there is scant evidence that the economy is slowing rapidly, at least based on the headline data we have been seeing for the past months.

Finally, the inflation story is part and parcel of all the discussions.  Oil’s rise on the back of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict has been pronounced and this morning it remains some 7% higher than before things started there.  There is a growing concern that if the conflict widens, OPEC could consider an embargo of some sort, just like in 1973 in the wake of the Yom Kippur War, which would likely drive oil prices much higher, at least to $150/bbl.  Obviously, that would have a dramatic impact on financial markets as well as on our everyday lives.  It would also have a dramatic impact on inflationary readings.  But the other concern is that despite some of the more Pollyanna-ish narratives about the Fed has already achieved its goals, the reality appears to be that core inflation is simply not falling any further and ultimately, this is going to weigh on equity multiples and earnings as well as further on bond prices.  I would contend that inflation remains the primary issue for the foreseeable future.

With all this in mind, a quick look at the overnight session shows that after a mixed session in the US on Friday, Asian equity markets were all lower by at least -1.0%.  European bourses, however, have managed to eke out very modest gains, on the order of 0.2% and US futures are currently (7:30) higher by about 0.25%.

Meanwhile, Treasury yields are higher by 9bps this morning and we are seeing yields on European sovereigns all higher by between 4bps and 5bps.  Clearly inflation concerns are rampant, as are concerns over continuing increases in supply as every major nation runs a growing budget deficit.  Of course, the exception to this rule is Japan, where yields are unchanged on the day and currently sitting at 0.75%, their high point for the past decade, although still well below the current YCC cap of 1.00%.

Turning to commodities, with oil quiet this morning focus is turning to the metals markets where gold (-0.8%) is retracing some of last week’s 5.0% rally as the combination of rising inflation and fear seems to have underpinned the barbarous relic.  As to base metals, they are mixed this morning with copper a touch higher and aluminum a touch lower, a perfect metaphor for the confusion on the economic situation.

Finally, the dollar is clearly not dead yet.  While this morning it is consolidating last week’s gains and has edged lower about 0.15%, last week saw gains in excess of 1% vs. most major counterparts.  The dollar, despite all the problems in the US, continues to be the haven of choice for most investors.

On the data front, aside from Retail Sales and the remarkable amount of Fedspeak, we see the following:

TodayEmpire Manufacturing-7
TuesdayRetail Sales0.3%
 -ex autos0.2%
 IP0.0%
 Capacity Utilization79.6%
WednesdayHousing Starts1.38M
 Building Permits1.455M
ThursdayInitial Claims213K
 Continuing Claims1707K
 Philly Fed11.1
 Existing Home Sales3.89M

Source: TradingEconomics.com

For my money, barring something surprising from the Middle East, like an OPEC move, I expect that the market will be entirely focused on Powell’s speech Thursday at noon.  We are also at the beginning of earnings season, so we could get some surprises there.  However, the big picture remains sticky inflation, massive new supply of Treasuries and higher yields along with a higher dollar overall.

Good luck

Adf

Two-Faced

Posted on by 
On Tuesday the market was JOLTed
And buyers of assets revolted
But then ADP
Said, no, look at me
And bulls, toward risk assets, all bolted

Now those numbers offer a foretaste
Of how market prices are two-faced
But really the key
Is Sep’s NFP
Ahead of which, traders will stay chaste

Remember all the carnage on Tuesday?  Never mind!  In truth, it is remarkable that the market response to the Tuesday JOLTS data was so strong, given the number has historically not been a key market driver. At the same time, yesterday’s weaker than expected ADP Employment data, just 89K new jobs, had the exact opposite impact on the market.  So, bonds rallied, and yields declined sharply, with 10-yr Treasury yields lower by 14bps from the highs seen yesterday pre-data, while stocks rallied nicely, led by the NASDAQ’s 1.4% gains although the other two indices lagged that badly.

My first thought was to determine what type of relationship both numbers have with the NFP data which is set for release tomorrow morning.  I ran some simple regressions for the past year and as it happens, the R2 between NFP and ADP is 0.5 while between NFP and JOLTS it is 0.65.  I do find it interesting that the JOLTS data, which has a bigger lag built in, has the stronger relationship, but I also remember that ADP changed its model and formulation and since they have done that, the fit to NFP is far less impressive.

It is anyone’s guess as to what tomorrow’s data is actually going to be like, but it is clearly instructive that the market was so keen to react to both of these data points so dramatically ahead of the release.  Ostensibly, the market has come around to my view that NFP is the data point on which the Fed is relying to continue their higher for longer mantra.  As such, a weak number (something like 100K or lower) seems very likely to soften the tone of Fedspeak and result in an immediate rip-roaring rally in the stock market.  Correspondingly, a strong number (200K or higher) seems more likely to bring out the hawkishness that remains widely evident on the FOMC.  The consensus view appears to be 160K, but then consensus for ADP was 150K and that missed badly.

The point is, for now, the market is hyper focused on the NFP number, and I suspect that between now and then, we are unlikely to see too much movement.  As an aside, one of the best indicators of the employment situation is Initial Claims, which is more frequent and thus timelier, and that number, which is expected at 210K this morning, has clearly been trending lower, a sign of a strong jobs market.  I believe we will need to see a lot of convincing evidence for the Fed to alter their current stance, but tomorrow’s NFP will certainly be important.

Away from that, right now other fundamentals just don’t seem to matter very much.  The dysfunction in Washington is a big issue in Washington, but not in financial markets, at least not yet.  I guess if we wind up in a situation where there is a government shutdown it may wind up mattering, but we know there is six weeks before that will come up again.  Next week is the Treasury refunding auction with $102 billion of notes and bonds coming to market.  I believe a key part of the bond market’s recent downward trend is the concern over the massive supply that is coming to market.  Next week’s realization, plus the fact that there is no end in sight should continue to weigh on bond prices and support yields.  And as long as US yields are forced higher, so too will be European sovereign, and truthfully, global yields.

On the oil front, the OPEC+ meeting came and went without incident as the production cuts that the Saudis initiated back in June are to remain in place through December, at least, with the group set to revisit the issue later in the year.  While oil (-2.0%) has been slumping badly during the past week, falling $10/bbl in that short time frame, I would contend the trend remains higher.  Remember, oil is a highly volatile commodity, both in reality and from a market price perspective.  We have heard nothing to alter my long-term conclusion that oil demand is going to continue to grow and oil supply remains constricted.  In truth, if I were a hedger, I would be looking to take advantage of the current price action, especially since the market is in backwardation (future prices are lower than current spot prices) so hedging is quite cost effective.  It’s kind of like earning the points in FX.

At the same time, metals prices remain under pressure with gold suffering from the combination of still high US yields and a strong dollar, while industrial metals like copper and aluminum are both pointing to weaker economic activity.  I continue to believe this is a short-term fluctuation in a broader long-term move higher in commodities in general, but again, if I were a hedger, current prices would be interesting.

A look at equity markets overnight showed that the Nikkei (+1.8%) approved of the US price action and that dragged much of the rest of Asia along for the ride although, recall, mainland China remains closed for their Golden Week holidays.  In Europe, today has been far less impressive with very modest gains across the continent averaging about 0.2% while US futures are little changed at this hour (7:30).  As I said before, I anticipate a slow day ahead of tomorrow’s NFP report.

Turning to the dollar, it, too, is little changed this morning after a bit of a sell-off yesterday.  For instance, the euro, which has rebounded from its recent lows, is still just barely above 1.05 and higher by just 0.1% this morning.  And those gains are similar across all the major currencies.  Now, if we look at the EMG bloc, despite the dollar’s pullback against some G10 counterparts, we see MXN (-1.0%) and ZAR (-1.25%) leading the way lower as both of those nations have large commodity sectors and the decline in prices there is more than sufficient to offset any benefit of a little bit of dollar weakness broadly.  Here, too, I see no reason to change my view on the dollar following yields higher, and the fact that yields have backed off for a day does not change the underlying reality.

In addition to the Initial Claims data, we see the Trade data (exp -$62.3B) and we hear from three more Fed speakers, Mester, Daly and Barr.  ADP did not change the world.  We will need to see more data demonstrating that growth, at least as defined by the Fed, is slowing before they are going to change their tune.  Today is shaping up as quite dull, but tomorrow, at least immediately after the 8:30 data print, could be interesting.  Remember, too, that Monday is Columbus Day, so markets will have less liquidity and be susceptible to larger movements.

Good luck

Adf

Much More Afraid

Posted on by 
Watanabe-san,
A previous Mr Yen,
“No intervention”

As USD/JPY approaches the psychological level of 150.00, there is a growing belief in the market that the BOJ is soon going to intervene.  Recall, last week we heard about the urgency with which the MOF is watching the exchange rate.  Historically, the next step would be for the BOJ to ‘check rates’.  This is when they call around to the big Tokyo bank FX trading desks and ask for levels.  The implication is they are ready to sell dollars and defend the yen.

However, unlike the previous decline in the yen almost exactly a year ago, the recent movement has been somewhat more gradual as can be seen in the chart below (source tradingeconomics.com)

This was highlighted last night by Hiroshi Watanabe, the deputy FinMin in charge of currency policy from 2004 through 2007.  He explained that after seeing the dollar remain in a 145-150 range for much of the past year, “I don’t think authorities are worried about the outlook as much as they were last year.  There’s no sense of imminence because the dollar/yen level hasn’t changed much from a year ago, and it doesn’t seem like the yen will start to plunge even if it breaches the 150 mark.”

As is often the case when it comes to concerns about a currency’s value, the pace of its decline is far more important than the actual level.  Most countries, or at least most finance ministries, feel they can handle slow and steady.  It is the abrupt collapses that scare them.  This move has been quite steady, and as long as both the Fed and BOJ maintain their current monetary policies, a continuation seems likely.  Hedgers, keep that in mind.

Now, turning to yesterday’s trade
A message was clearly conveyed
As interest rates rise
Risk appetite dies
And people are much more afraid

The most pressing story in markets continues to be the US Treasury market where sellers outnumber buyers on a daily basis.  Yields on the 10-year rose 10bps yesterday, touching 4.70% and are continuing higher by another 2bps so far this morning.  The bear steepener continues to be the story with the 2yr-10yr spread falling to -40bps and looking for all the world like it is going to go positive before the end of the year, if not the end of the month.  And it makes sense.  There is still substantial demand for short-term paper yielding more than 5% (yesterday’s 3mo T-Bill auction cleared at 5.35%).  Meanwhile, we are seeing money flee those assets with long duration over fears that inflation has not yet been quelled and that the structural issues (ongoing massive supply meeting limited demand) has investors pulling back quickly.  Not only are Treasury bonds being sold aggressively driving yields higher, but yesterday saw utility stocks, often seen as a duration proxy given the high amount of debt on their balance sheets, fall nearly 5%.  

This activity is having the knock-on effects that one would expect as well.  Yields around the world continue to get dragged higher by Treasuries, the dollar continues to benefit, and commodity prices are suffering.  In fact, yesterday saw a sharp decline in the price of oil and it has now retraced more than 6% from the peak last week.  I had written about the simultaneous rise in yields, the dollar and oil as being a HUGE problem for global markets.  Well, it seems that oil is starting to feel the pain of higher yields and a stronger dollar.  As well, tomorrow OPEC meets in Vienna and there is some talk that the Saudis may increase their production, unwinding those unilateral cuts made back in June and continued since then.   

But make no mistake, ongoing rises in Treasury yields will continue to underpin the dollar and that will be enough of a problem for economies elsewhere even if oil prices slide some more.  And right now, there is no indication things are going to change.  Yesterday we heard from two Fed speakers, Governor Bowman and Cleveland Fed President Mester with both maintaining the hawkish views.  In fact, Bowman expressed the need for several more rate hikes in order to get inflation under control and both were clear that higher for longer was crucial.  As long as that remains the Fed attitude, until we see a substantial change in the data stream, yields are going to continue to rise.

Now, this week brings the all-important NFP report on Friday, which has been a key driver of Fed policy.  With inflation readings continuing far above the Fed’s target, as long as NFP remains positive and the Unemployment Rate remains either side of 4%, the Fed will have no reason to reconsider the current policy mix.  In their minds, they have not yet broken anything, at least not so badly that it couldn’t be fixed.  I’m sure they are straining their arms as they pat themselves on the back for the effectiveness of the Bank Term Funding Program (BTFP) which was created after the bank failures in March.  In fairness, it seems to be working for now.  However, I will warn that cans can only be kicked down the road for so long, and I fear the end of that road is nearing.

As to the rest of the session today, risk is decidedly on the back foot.  Those equity markets in Asia that were open all fell pretty sharply with the Nikkei (-1.6%) and Hang Seng (-2.7%) leading the way lower.  The story is similar in Europe with the major indices all lower by about -0.75% or so as they respond to the ongoing increase in interest rates around the world.  Finally, US futures are lower by -0.45% at this hour (7:30) with concerns growing that yields will not stop rising.

Looking at European sovereign bonds, yields there are rising alongside Treasury yields with most of them higher by 3bps-4bps and Italy higher by 9bps.  That Bund-BTP spread, currently at 193bps, is something we need to watch as 200bps is likely to be the first place the ECB really shows concern and if it heads higher than that, expect more direct actions.  As to JGB yields, they remain static at 0.76%.

We already discussed oil prices and we are seeing serious weakness across the entire metals complex lately, although today’s declines are relatively muted, on the order of -0.2%, as the moves have already been pretty large.  The lesson from the recent price activity is that yields continue to drive the market.

Finally, the dollar remains king with the euro below 1.05, USDJPY just below 150 and the pound making a run at 1.20.  Last night, the RBA met and left rates on hold, as widely expected, but the tone of new governor Michele Bullock’s first meeting was seen as somewhat dovish leading to a nearly 1% decline in the Aussie.  At the same time, the EMG bloc of currencies is also coming under pressure with declines today on the order of -0.5% across all three regions.  There is a term, the dollar wrecking ball, which is quite apt.  As it continues to rise it puts intense pressure on countries around the world as they scramble to get dollars to service the trillions upon trillions of dollars of debt outstanding.  Nothing has changed my view that this has further to run.

On the data front today, the only release is JOLTS Job Openings (exp 8.8M) a number that remains significantly larger than the number of unemployed.  We also hear from Atlanta Fed president Bostic this morning so it will be interesting if he is willing to push back against the ongoing hawkishness.

I see no catalysts to change the current trend in the dollar, so for all you receivables hedgers out there, keep that in mind.

Good luck

Adf

Three Extra Trill

Posted on by 
Said Goolsbee, I’m, processing, still
Why bond yields keep moving uphill
Perhaps he should look
At Yellen’s full book
Of issuance, three extra trill

So, with the third quarter now ending
And core PCE, today, pending
The hope and the dream
Is next quarter’s theme
Will be ‘bout risk assets ascending

In a speech yesterday at the Peterson Institute for International Economics, Chicago Fed President Austan Goolsbee laid out his current views on the US economic situation, which he thought was generally in good shape, and warned about overtightening.  He also noted the Fed has a rare opportunity to achieve a soft landing.  All that is ordinary enough.  The odd comment came when he mentioned that he was “still processing’ why bond yields were rising so much recently.  It is always disconcerting to me when the so-called best and brightest who lead our key institutions expose themselves as being clueless in their main role.  

As I have discussed in the past, it is not very difficult to determine why long-term yields are rising in the US, it is a combination of two absolutes and one likelihood.  The absolutes are the amount of supply hitting the market and the reduced demand.  Treasury Secretary Yellen has indicated in Q4 there will be new issuance of ~$852 billion on top of current refinancing of >$1.3 trillion, hitting the market.  At the same time, the Fed continues its QT program reducing demand by $180 billion in Q4 and both China and Japan, the two largest holders of Treasuries have been slowly reducing their positions.  The point is excess supply and reduced demand will drive prices lower.  The likelihood is that the private sector that will be required to purchase these bonds is wary of inflation rebounding on the back of higher energy prices and increasing wage costs (between the UAW strike and the latest law in California that mandates a $20/hour minimum wage for fast food workers, wages seem set to rise further still), and so are demanding to be paid more to buy the paper.  It is not really that complex.

Yesterday, after printing at 4.68%, a new high for the move, the 10-year yield fell back a bit, which is much more about market technicals and an oversold condition rather than a change in the underlying issues discussed above.  This morning, that yield is lower still, but just by 2bps and currently trading at 4.55%.  Of equal interest is the fact that the yield curve continues to bear steepen with the 2yr-10yr curve inversion now down to -50bps.  While we are likely to see a little trading bounce, this trend remains clear, and the fundamentals support higher yields.  I expect the 10-year yield to reach 5% by the end of 2023 and somewhere between 5.5% and 6.0% by the election next year.

If we look elsewhere in the world, we are seeing yields rise right alongside Treasury yields.  Perhaps the only place that is lagging is Japan, where the BOJ executed an unscheduled JGB buying operation last night of¥300 billion to help moderate recent movement.  This was interesting given the data out of Japan last night, notably weaker Retail Sales and a lower-than-expected Tokyo CPI at 2.8% (2.5% core) implies that the BOJ is not likely to feel much pressure to tighten.  With the Fed still all-in on higher for longer and the BOJ able to point to softening inflation as a reason to continue QE and loose policy, USDJPY will continue to be the outlet valve in the economy, and it should rise (yen weaken) still further.

Meanwhile, the most important spread in Europe, the bund-BTP spread in the 10-year space is back to 200bps.  This is the level at which the ECB has demonstrated concern in the past and I am confident that there is much discussion ongoing today.  We did hear from one of the ECB hawks overnight, Nagel, who was clear that another rate hike might be appropriate, but I assure you, if that spread widens much further, rate hikes are not going to be the ECB’s approach.  All in all, we are likely to see much future stress in bond markets.  And to think, none of this even touches on the potential government shutdown tomorrow!

And yet, equity markets bounced yesterday into month/quarter end and European bourses and US futures are all in the green today as the bulls are now telling us that things are oversold, and a rip-roaring rally is imminent.  Clearly, we have seen some pretty weak behavior in the risk asset space lately and a technical bounce is not surprising.  However, it remains very difficult for me to see the upside for stocks as long as bond yields are rising along with oil and inflation remains sticky.  Too, the dollar, while it also reversed course yesterday after a remarkable run higher over the past two plus months, is still quite firm overall, and as long as US yields rise, I look for the dollar to follow.

On the lighter side, the best non-sequitur correlation I have seen is that Top Gun was released in May 1986 and Black Monday, which saw the largest equity market selloff in history occurred in October 1987.  Well, Top Gun II was released in May 2022.  Should we be looking for a massive market decline in the next two weeks?  The starting conditions are not actually that different with an overvalued stock market, rising rates, rising oil prices and a rising dollar.  Just sayin!

As we look to the calendar today, the Core PCE data is set to be released at 8:30 and expected at 0.2% M/M, 3.9% Y/Y.  Many analysts continue to use the concept of annualizing last month’s data and pointing to the Fed achieving its target, or excluding the rise in prices of certain segments beyond food and energy and claiming not only is inflation falling, but deflation is coming.  Clearly, if you exclude the prices that are rising in the index, then the index will demonstrate falling prices, however it is not clear to me what that tells us.  We also get the Goods Trade Balance (exp -$95.0B), that excludes services, and we see Chicago PMI (47.6) and Michigan Sentiment (67.7).  Yesterday’s GDP data was a touch softer than expected at 2.1% with the most concerning part that Real Consumer Spending rose only 0.8% Q/Q, half the level of forecasts and down from 3.8% in Q1. On the flipside, Initial Claims fell to 204K, back to levels seen in January, and certainly no indication of economic weakness.

And that’s how we are heading into the weekend.  While yesterday saw trading reversals of the recent trends, there is no indication that those trends have ended.  The reversal and consolidation may last through today’s quarter end trading and into early next week but look for the longer term trends of a higher dollar, higher bond yields, higher oil prices and lower risk asset prices to resume before too long.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

What He’s Sought

Posted on by 
On Monday, the market did naught
As traders were giving much thought
To how Jay explains
The work that remains
For him to achieve what he’s sought

And so, while no change is expected
In rates, look at what is projected
The June dot plot showed
The Fed’s preferred road
Was four cuts will soon be effected

Once again, the overnight activity remains fairly dull as traders and investors around the world await the results of tomorrow’s FOMC meeting.  At this point, it seems quite clear the Fed will remain on hold tomorrow leaving Fed funds in a 5.25%-5.50% range while continuing their QT program.  With this in mind, all the excitement will come from the new Summary of Economic Projections (SEP) which includes the dot plot.  The dot plot is the graphical representation of the FOMC members’ expectations for the path of Fed funds going forward.  Below is the most recent release from the June meeting (chart from Bloomberg).

The chart shows each of the FOMC members’ forecasts for where Fed funds will be at the end of 2023, 2024, 2025 and over the long term.  The green line shows the median forecast which in June indicated a belief there will be one more rate hike in 2023 and then four rate cuts in 2024 with another five cuts in 2025 before eventually seeing Fed funds move back to the perceived ‘neutral’ rate of 2.5%.

However, let us consider how some alternative scenarios might evolve.  For instance, I continue to wonder why the Fed will be cutting rates by 100bps in 2024 if they no longer forecast a recession in the US.  After all, if the economy continues to chug along with rates at 5.5%, what purpose would be served by cutting rates?  And if the economy does enter a recession next year, something which seems realistic, then the Fed will be cutting far more than 100bps.  It’s funny, if you look at the dispersion of expectations for 2024, there is one member who feels certain a recession is coming, with an expected rate of 3.625%, and another one who sees higher for longer as lasting the entire year.  At least those two members are making some sense.  However, the idea that the Fed will cut just because, without a more severe economic shock, seems quite unlikely.  After all, Chairman Powell has invoked the ghost of Paul Volcker numerous times and explained they will not be fooled by a temporary decline in inflation.  Rather, they are in this for the long haul and will win the battle.

There are those who would argue that the Fed will cut rates, regardless of the economic situation, because the US cannot afford to continue to pay interest at the current level on their >$32 trillion in debt.  As such, Powell will feel enormous pressure from the administration to reduce rates to help the government.  Now, that is the exact opposite of central bank independence, but certainly not an impossible outcome.  But absent that type of situation, it strikes me that we remain a very long way from the Fed achieving their target inflation rate of 2.0%.  At this point, the one thing Powell has made abundantly clear is that he will not stop until they achieve that goal.  

Another fly in the rate cutting ointment is the price of oil.  Again, this morning it is higher, +0.8%, and now above $92/bbl and seemingly approaching the magical $100/bbl level.  In the wake of the Russian invasion of Ukraine, the Biden administration released some 300 million barrels from the US’s Strategic Petroleum Reserve (SPR) which helped moderate price increases at the time.  However, the ability to repeat that exercise does not exist as currently, the SPR only holds about 350 million barrels and there are actual physical constraints regarding the integrity of the salt domes in which the SPR is kept.  If too much is released, the domes could cave in.  When considering this alongside the ongoing production cuts from OPEC+ as well as the administration’s effective war on domestic oil production, it is reasonable to conclude that oil prices have higher to climb.  Working our way back to the Fed, the problem is that high energy prices ultimately become embedded in all prices, as even services require energy to be accomplished.  This underlying cost pressure is going to prevent any significant decline in the rate of inflation and, in turn, support the Fed’s higher for longer narrative for even longer.

Wrapping up the discussion, I would contend that absent a sharp recession, the Fed is not going to be pressured into cutting the Fed funds rate anytime soon.  Instead, I expect that we will continue to see longer end rates rise slowly as the combination of massive new issuance of Treasury debt and lingering inflation will require higher yields to find buyers.  Currently, the two largest non-Fed holders of Treasury securities are China and Japan, and both of them have been slowly liquidating their portfolios as they need dollars to sell in the FX markets in order to support their own currencies.  When push comes to shove, I expect that we will see US rates retain their advantage over other G10 currencies and that it will continue for a while to come.  As such, I continue to expect the dollar to outperform, at least until something really breaks.  However, what that something is remains open to debate.

Turning to the overnight session, which was quite uninteresting as mentioned above, we saw mixed to weaker performance in Asian equities, with only the Hang Seng managing to eke out any gains at all, while European bourses are mixed with the major exchanges all within 0.2% of yesterday’s closing levels.  Yesterday’s US performance was as close to unchanged as it could get while being open, and this morning’s futures market is showing tiny gains (<0.1%) at this hour (8:00).

Bond markets are somewhat mixed on the day, with Treasury yields backing up 2bps, while UK gilt yields are lower by 4bps and everything else is in between.  Eurozone final CPI for August was released with the headline ticking down 0.1% to 5.2%, but core unchanged at 5.3%, with both, obviously, still well above the ECB target.  Madame Lagarde must be praying quite hard for inflation to fall further as she made it clear she does not want to raise rates again.  In the end, the Eurozone has myriad problems with sticky high prices and slowing growth, an unenviable position.

Aside from oil’s gains, gold has been performing relatively well lately, which given the dollar’s resilience and higher interest rates seems somewhat odd.  One possible explanation is that there continues to be significant demand in Asia, where, for example, the Shanghai Gold exchange price is currently some $30/oz higher than on the COMEX, and this spread has been growing.  We have heard much about the record amount of gold buying by central banks this year, and this seems of a piece with that outcome.  However, looking at industrial metals, both copper and aluminum are softer this morning as the prospects for Chinese growth diminish and with them so do prospects for demand for those metals.

Finally, the dollar is a bit softer this morning vs. most of its G10 counterparts with NOK (+0.75%) leading the way higher on the back of oil’s continuing rally.  In fact, the entire commodity bloc is at the top of the charts today.  However, in the EMG bloc, we are seeing more of a mixed picture with an equal number of gainers and laggards and none showing exuberance in either direction.

On the data front today, we see Housing Starts (exp 1439K) and Building Permits (1440K) as well as Canadian CPI (3.8% headline, 3.7% core), with both measures rising and keeping pressure on the BOC.  There are still no speakers, so my take is that things will be dull until tomorrow’s FOMC announcement at 2:00pm.

Good luck

Adf

Some Dismay

Posted on by 
While everyone’s certain that Jay
Will leave rates alone come Wednesday
The curve’s longer end
Is starting to trend
Toward rates that might cause some dismay

The problem remains his frustration
That he can do naught ‘bout inflation
As oil keeps rising
It’s demoralizing
For Jay and his rate formulation

The overnight session was quite dull overall with virtually no new data or information on the macroeconomic front and a limited amount of commentary from the central banking and financial poohbahs of the world.  Friday’s desultory US equity market performance was followed by a mixed session in Asia while European bourses are all in the red after the Bundesbank indicated that Germany would have negative growth in Q3.  As well, after last week’s ECB rate hike, we did hear from one of the more hawkish members that further hikes are possible, although listening to Madame Lagarde’s comments, that seems quite a high bar at this time.

So, given the limited amount of new information, it seems that it is time for central bank prognostications.  The first thing to note is that while the Fed is certainly the main act this week, there are no less than a dozen other major interest rate decisions due this week including the BOE, BOJ, PBOC, Swedish Riksbank, Norgesbank, SNB and Banco Central do Brazil.  

While much has been written about the FOMC on Wednesday, with the current market pricing just less than a 1% probability of a hike, the European banks that are meeting are all expected to follow the ECB and hike by 25bps.  Meanwhile, the PBOC remains caught between a rock (slowing economic growth) and a hard place (a weakening currency) and seems highly likely to follow the Fed’s lead and leave rates on hold.  

The BOJ is also very likely to leave their rate structure on hold, but questions keep arising regarding any other potential tweaks to the YCC framework.  However, given the relatively strong denials of anything like that from Ueda-san at the end of last week, I am inclined to believe they are comfortable where they are.  

Finally, a look down south shows that Brazil is forecast to cut the SELIC rate (their Fed funds equivalent) by 50bps to 12.75% with a handful of analysts calling for a 75bp cut.  Of course, inflation in Brazil has fallen from effectively 12% last summer to 4.65% now, so real rates are still remarkably high there which is the key reason the real has been such a great performer over the past twelve months, having risen ~8%.

The only market that is really showing much movement is oil, which is higher yet again this morning, by another 0.5% and now above $91/bbl.  It is becoming very clear that the OPEC+ production cuts are having the impact that MBS desired, with tightening supply meeting ongoing demand growth, despite slowing economic activity.  The one thing that should remain abundantly clear to all is that no amount of effort by Western governments to reduce demand for fossil fuels is going to have the desired impact as developing nations will not be denied their opportunities to improve their own economic situation and that generally takes access to energy.  To date, fossil fuels continue to prove to be the most cost-effective and efficient sources, so that demand will just not abate.  Oil prices are going to continue to head higher, mark my words.

And truthfully, on this rainy Monday morning in NY, that is pretty much all the excitement that we have ongoing.  The data this week is focused on Housing and expectations are as follows:

TuesdayHousing Starts1437K
 Building Permits1440K
WednesdayFOMC Rate Decision5.50% (current 5.50%)
ThursdayInitial Claims225K
 Continuing Claims1695K
 Philly Fed-1.0
 Existing Home Sales4.10M
 Leading Indicators-0.5%
FridayFlash PMI Manufacturing48.2
 Flash PMI Services50.6

Source: Bloomberg

A side note regarding the data is that the Leading Indicators Index is forecast to decline again, which will be the 17th consecutive decline, a very strong indication that future economic activity seems likely to suffer.  Of course, this is just one of the numerous signals of an impending recession (inverted yield curve, ISM/PMI sub 50.0, etc.) that have yet to play out as they have done historically.  Perhaps the UAW strikes will be enough to tip things over, especially if they widen in scope, but that seems premature. 

In addition, we are beginning to hear more about a potential government shutdown as the House has not yet completed its funding bills but my take here is that while the rhetoric may heat up, the reality is that a continuing resolution will be passed and that this is just another tempest in a teapot in Washington, SOP really.

When looking a little further ahead, I continue to see a far better chance that the Fed remains the most hawkish of the major central banks, and that higher for longer really means just that.  Economic activity elsewhere, notably in Europe and China, is suffering far more acutely than in the US, at least statistically, and that implies that this week’s rate hikes across the UK and the continent are very likely the end of the cycle.  I am not convinced that the Fed is done.  That combination leads me to continue to look for relative dollar strength over time.  For asset/receivables hedgers, keep that in mind.

Good luck

Adf