A Plus or a Mess?

This poet was totally wrong
Expecting a ‘publican throng
At polls yesterday
But one can’t downplay
The message delivered was strong

The question we now must address
Is, is this a plus or a mess?
The early returns
Show few new concerns
And nothing approaching distress

The election results are very clear and now we move on to the more difficult stage, governing.  Certainly, this was a rejection of President Trump’s agenda, or at least some of his actions, with the Iran war resulting in much higher energy costs a significant issue for the electorate.  However, in many ways, this is the best possible outcome for markets as political gridlock has historically been a net positive for the economy.  If Congress cannot pass new laws, that is generally a good thing.  And this was made clear last night as you can see in the chart below of the S&P 500, which saw losses early in the evening and then a complete reversal to where futures are now higher by 1.1% as of 6:10 this morning.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

The other statistic I keep reading is that in the year following a midterm election, equities have been higher for the past 18 midterms.  Of course, the breakdown of which industries and market sectors improve is unclear, and the past is not prolog, but it has certainly been a highlight amongst the early commentators.

At any rate, as this is not a political discussion, let’s turn our focus to things economic and financial.  On the economy, the US data continues to be solid as per yesterday’s JOLTs data which showed more job openings, but perhaps just as importantly, more Quits, which implies that there is a greater willingness for people to leave their job as they believe their prospects of finding a new, better one are improving.  That has historically been a sign of a strong labor market.  If we look at the below chart from FRED of the Quits data this century, it is not hard to make the case that we have bottomed after the Covid induced market disruptions and beginning to trend back higher.  Given the slowing population growth and the ongoing illegal immigration crackdown, it is easy to believe that job prospects are improving for those in the workforce.

This morning we get the ADP Employment number (exp 69K) and, of course, Friday brings the latest NFP data.  Again, the US data continues to demonstrate an economy that is growing in many areas.  When I compare this with the economic data elsewhere in the world, I continue to have difficulty seeing the appeal elsewhere.  With that in mind, though, it will be interesting to see just how much of the inward investment promised over the past two years will pan out given the changes in Washington.

So, let’s see how the rest of the world responded to the US elections, assuming that was the driver.  In equity markets, Europe is virtually giddy over the outcome with all the major bourses much higher led by Spain (+2.8%) but with large gains across the board (France +1.5%, Germany +1.5%, UK +1.25%).  And US futures, as mentioned above are stronger with both the NASDAQ (+0.9%) and DJIA (+1.5%) also doing well.  Asia, though, saw things a little less positively.  Japan (-1.4%) slipped along with Taiwan (-0.8%) and Australia (-0.6%) although there were positives as well.  For instance, the Chinese plunge protection team was active last night increasing both loans and direct support as the CSI 300 rose 2.3% dragging the Hang Seng (+1.7%) along for the ride.  Too, Korea (+0.6%) benefitted from yesterday’s relief in the tech space.  But overall, equity markets are nonplussed this morning, if not genuinely happy.

In the bond market, yields are lower this morning and I must admit, I don’t understand the logic.  Now, if you look at the chart below of the past 24 hours, you can see that this has not been a straight-line process, but here we are with 10-year yields lower by -3bps as I write.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

I read one blurb explaining the market was anticipating lower deficits going forward but I fail to understand how that will work.  There is zero evidence that a Democrat led congress will pass an austerity budget, and I expect that President Trump would veto any bills that raise taxes, so I am at a loss as to the source of that deficit reduction, at least on the surface.  Perhaps the ongoing crackdown on fraud will be sufficient to reduce the deficit, but that seems a stretch.  And if everything becomes a continuing resolution, that is not going to reduce expenditures.  However, yields around the world are largely lower with Europe benefitting from the Treasury market’s lead as the weaker European credits (France, Italy, Spain, UK, Greece) all enjoy bond rallies with yields slipping -4bps or so across the board.  As it happens, German bund yields are unchanged this morning.

In the commodity space, oil (-1.0%) continues to slide although I have seen nothing indicating that a deal to end the war in Iran was imminent.  In fact, the WSJ this morning had an article about how Iran was desperately trying to stop the flow of oil and using guerilla tactics but having limited success doing so.  Iran’s bigger problem is now that the election is past, President Trump has a pretty free hand in doing what he wants there, and the evidence continues to show that the blockade is really hurting the Iranians.  As I said yesterday, my sense is this is going to end before long.

With oil continuing its recent decline, and yields lower, it should be no surprise that metals markets have benefitted, but the magnitude is surprising.  Gold (+2.8%) and silver (+4.4%) have recouped all of their declines of the past week, as per the below chart.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Will this rally hold going forward?  Much depends on the dollar’s performance, which today is much lower, and how the interest rate structure evolves.  If lower yields are on the horizon, perhaps this is just the beginning.

And yet, if we look at the CME Fed funds futures market, the probability of a hike in December rose in the wake of the election, which seems at odds with that narrative.

So, let’s look at the dollar this morning.  It is lower across the board, and by a decent amount virtually everywhere.  if you look at the table below from tradingeconomics.com, you can see that the only exceptions are RUB, which isn’t really a tradable currency, CNY, which didn’t move and BRL, which despite the dollar weakness can find no strength as investors continue to exit the economy there.  Otherwise, it’s pretty unanimous, nobody wants dollars today.

Will this continue?  Positioning in the dollar heading into the election was net long, so I expect much of this movement is simply the beginnings of unwinding those positions.  But as I frequently highlight, the dollar is merely in the middle of its long-term range, neither especially rich nor cheap here, so its future will depend on the fundamentals.  Perhaps today’s Eurozone inflation data, which printed at 4.0%, has traders looking for a more hawkish ECB but there is no evidence of that based on implied probabilities from futures and swaps markets as you can see below in the chart from rateprobability.com.

While the BOE is set to hike rates tomorrow, other than the RBA, which looks like it is done, the trajectory of future rate hikes appears pretty similar across the board.

I see no reason for the dollar to collapse, although it is possible that inward investment will diminish, which will slow any significant rise in the greenback.

On the data front, along with ADP Employment mentioned above, we see the Trade Balance (exp -$108B) and ISM Services (54.8) as well as the EIA oil inventories with a small build expected.  I expect that we are setting up for more range trading in the dollar with the chance of a strong trend in either direction vanishingly small right now.

Good luck

Adf

Still Burning

On Friday, it certainly seemed,
As equity markets got creamed,
The end of the world
Had slowly unfurled
Just like the bears worldwide had dreamed

This morning, though, screens are all green
‘Cept crude whose price has lost its sheen
But Europe’s still burning
And that’s quite concerning
So, what, from this mess, can we glean?

I am going to stop listening to podcasts on my weekend morning walks with Marvel as they have become increasingly apocalyptic and, frankly, if the world is going to end, perhaps it’s better not to know ahead of time, it will save so much angst!  One of the podcasts that I periodically listen to is Palisades Radio, which this week had an interview with Simon Hunt, a pretty well-known macroeconomist and analyst.  I have the link above, but I can only recommend listening if you are seeking a reason to commit suicide as he basically explained that the world we know is over, specifically that the House of Saud was going to collapse, the US was going to lose in Iran and with that China and Russia would become the new global hegemons.  Now, maybe that is exactly what is going to happen, I certainly don’t know.  But that feels like an outlier position to me.  Of course, Simon sounds so intellectual with his gravelly British accent, that it gets a great deal of respect.

However, I constantly go back to the idea that predictions are hard, especially about the future.  The other thing about pronouncements like this are they are impossible to verify given his timeline is measured in years, so in 2032 or 2034, if what he forecasts doesn’t pan out, nobody will remember, but if it does, he will be screaming it from the hills.  Of course, if it does pan out, no matter how loud he screams, nobody will be listening as the new global hegemons will not be interested in economic analysis.

My weekend perambulations aside, Friday certainly had an apocalyptic tone to it as earnings releases during the week mostly failed to meet expectations and equity markets fell sharply.  Meanwhile, the number of articles discussing the increasing likelihood that the US was going to resume its military campaign in Iran when the election was over, egged on by President Trump himself, grew and there was an overall negative vibe.  This was clearly expressed in the equity markets as you can see in the below chart with Friday’s large red candle portending doom and gloom.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Of course, there is another potential explanation for Friday’s price action, it was month end, and there could well have been rebalancing flows driving the trade.  And this morning, the entire vibe in the US, at least, has changed.  It starts with oil, as most markets do these days, and as you can see in the below chart, WTI has fallen sharply today, down -4.5% on news that a diplomatic solution to Iran may be coming together.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Now, I have no idea if that is true or not, and I suspect neither does anybody else, but it does appear that there has been an increase in diplomatic efforts by the Qataris, Turks and Omanis as the election comes near.  And despite Iran’s claims they are prepared for anything and will inflict significant damage if they are attacked, I imagine they really don’t want to sustain another intense wave of bombing.

But it’s not just the Iran situation that is on the markets’ collective mind, but US elections.  Now, I am on record as forecasting the Republicans maintain both houses of Congress, but I am in the minority.  However, the surprise endorsement of Republican Mike Rogers by Democrat Haley Stevens, the woman who lost the Democratic primary to Abdul El-Sayed, has certainly gotten tongues wagging and it appears there is a growing sentiment that some of the Senate Races that the MSM had confidently called for Democratic victories may not be so sure after all, notably Texas and Michigan.  If I am correct in my political prognostications, I believe much equity market angst will dissipate quickly.

Turning to Europe, there was a coup in Poland, or not, I am not sure what is going on, and based on the articles I have read, I don’t think anybody is sure.  Perhaps the most surprising thing I saw was that there are riots in Zurich and Basel.  Of all the places on the planet, perhaps only Antarctica would be a less likely spot for a riot than Zurich.  But one must question what would cause the people of Zurich to riot.  The idea that Europe is burning spontaneously is suspect.

If we sum it all up, what do we know?  The universal truth in media is, if it bleeds, it leads.  Given that as well as the fact that media has evolved into a 24/7/365 festival (nightmare?) on social media, perhaps we should not be surprised that every terrible event is highlighted and anything positive is dismissed because it doesn’t get enough engagement.  My experience over time, though, is that rarely do we see either the best or worst cases come about, but some middle ground instead.  I expect that is what we are going to see ahead as well.  Companies are still doing business and earning profits, people are still going to work, earning and spending money and living their lives, and that is the majority of activity.  We need to be careful as to how much of the news we consume as gospel given the potential for excessive pessimism, mostly, to become entrenched.

Enough life lessons.  Let’s review markets.  As I said, equities are having a better day than Friday with more strength (China +0.8%, HK +0.4%, Korea +2.2%, India +1.7%) than weakness (Tokyo -0.3%, Australia -0.6%, Taiwan -0.6%) in Asia as word from China was that they would be increasing their support for stock markets there as per this X summary.  As to Europe, while Spain (+0.9%) is having a solid session, the rest of the major bourses are +/-0.2% or less after PMI Manufacturing data was pretty decent (weak in France and Italy, not surprisingly) but Retail sales data was soft in both Germany and Switzerland. (I guess if the rioters are going to steal stuff, they won’t be buying much.) US futures, though, are firmer at this hour (7:30), up by 0.5% or so across the board.

In the bond market, Treasury yields (-2bps) continue to slide and are dragging European sovereign yields down as well.  I think it is worth remembering that less than a month ago, 10-year yields were 45bps higher than today and the consensus view was that owning bonds was a disastrous idea as the government would never close the deficit and other central banks would stop buying Treasuries.  But markets are funny like that, and the chart below shows just how big this reversal has been.  Are yields low?  Absolutely not, but for now, at least, fears of the bond market collapsing have gone away.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

This week also brings the Treasury refunding announcement for next quarter and there is some intrigue over how Secretary Bessent is going to present things and his strategy to reduce yields.  Of course, you remember when he talked about repurchasing off-the-run bonds at a discount it was all poo-poohed as a waste of time with no impact, and yet here we are 45bps lower.  Maybe he really is ‘The House’!

We cannot be surprised that metals markets have rebounded with the sharp decline in oil, so gold (+0.6%), silver (+2.3%) and copper (+0.4%) are all higher on the day.  However, that said, Friday’s declines were sharp enough to take gold below $4000/oz and silver below $50/oz, levels that had been seen as key supports for the long-term bulls.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Finally, the dollar is softer this morning, notably against the euro (+0.5%) and Swiss franc (+0.7%) although given the ongoing rioting in both places I am a bit confused by the price action.  Too, the economic data was not encouraging, but the best I can distill is traders are forecasting a Democratic sweep in tomorrow’s elections.  The yen (-0.2%) is not partaking, neither is Aussie (-0.3%) although we have seen real strength in CZK (+1.0%) and HUF (+1.0).  Weirdly, PLN (+0.1%) is not doing very much despite both the wide range of today’s trading and the news about the coup/not coup.

As this is the first week of the month, there is a lot to see.

TodayISM Manufacturing54.6
 ISM Prices Paid77.0
 RBA Interest Rate Decision4.85% (+25bps)
TuesdayJOLTs Job Openings7.13M
 Factory Orders1.2%
WednesdayADP Employment65K
 Trade Balance-$108.0B
 ISM Services54.8
ThursdayBOE Interest Rate Decision4.0% (+25bps)
 Initial Claims195K
 Continuing Claims1710K
 Unit Labor Costs0.6%
FridayNonfarm Payrolls65K
 Private Payrolls58K
 Manufacturing Payrolls4K
 Unemployment Rate4.2%
 Average Hourly Earnings0.3% (2.9% Y/Y)
 Average Weekly Hours34.4
 Participation Rate61.9%
 Michigan Sentiment48.2
 Consumer Credit$11.8B

Source: tradingeconomics.com

So, plenty to digest along with the election results.  Certainly, too much to describe at once.  As I have been saying, I think the elections are the fulcrum and once we see how they play out, we will have a better chance to make sense of other things as depending on who wins, different things may be important.  In the meantime, close to the vest and hedged remains the best thing you can be.

Good luck

Adf

In a Trance

The BOJ held
As widely expected, but
December looks live


“Medium- to long-term inflation expectations are at around 2 percent. Regarding the
outlook, inflation expectations are likely to remain broadly around their current level, as
firms' active wage- and price-setting behavior is expected to be maintained on the back of
factors such as the tightening of labor market conditions.”

The above is the key phrase from the BOJ last night after they left the base rate unchanged at 1.25%.  The key is that they now acknowledge that their 13-year quest to overcome deflation, as part of their deal with the government at the beginning of Abenomics, has been achieved.  Hooray! Prices are rising and I’m sure all the good folks in Japan are excited about that.  After all, I know all my readers are always heartened when they see prices rising 🙃.

At any rate, that is seen as the signal that the BOJ will be raising rates in December and as you can see in the below chart from rateprobability.com, further hikes are expected consistently in the future as the BOJ attempts to normalize their interest rate structure, or at least have it more closely resemble the rest of the G10 world.

One of the things I have noticed lately, although I think it has been this way for a little while, is that the major central banks all meet on roughly the same schedule, with eight meetings per year, so roughly every 6 weeks.  The BOE and BOJ both used to meet monthly but adjusted their schedules to align more closely with the Fed, while the ECB has always maintained that timing.

But now, the Fed is changing things by removing one rate setting meeting in 2027 and two in 2028.  So, to me the question going forward is, will the other major central banks adjust their schedules as well?  I have long been a proponent of less is more when it comes to central bankers speaking and meeting, but there was a great deal of demand for more ‘transparency’ after Paul Volcker basically ignored Congress completely.  Alan Greenspan went out of his way to obfuscate everything he said with this quote perhaps his most famous line, “I know you believe you understand what you think I said, but I am not sure you realize that what you heard is not what I meant.”

Of course, it was Ben Bernanke who really opened the kimono by having press conferences after initiating QE and changing the Fed’s process from one of scarce reserves to abundant reserves, and that is where all the problems accelerated.  But I digress.

One other thing that I continue to see highlighted by many pundits as a negative, which I personally believe is a positive, is that Chairman Warsh’s attempts to end forward guidance has already, and will going forward, result in more market volatility across all markets.

To me, and I imagine Chairman Warsh, that is a feature, not a bug of this process.  The great economist Hyman Minsky is the one who observed that stability leads to instability, i.e. when things are quiet for a long time, market volatility declines and position sizes increase, generally with leverage.  Then, when something changes, those much larger positions must be unwound quickly and significant market downturns can, and do, occur.  One need only remember back to Covid and the market volatility there as the most recent major occurrence.  When central banks offer guidance like rates are likely to stay low for a long time into the future, traders assume that they can lever up positions and generate significant profits easily.  Ask Silicon Valley Bank how that worked out.

When viewing the US and France
I don’t think it’s really by chance
The US is growing
While France keeps on slowing
As though business there’s in a trance

This takes us to the other story of note, the dramatic difference between US and European economic activity.  I’m picking on France because they reported this morning, and as the second largest economy in the Eurozone are, I believe, representative of the situation there.  If you look at the table below from tradingeconomics.com of relative GDP growth rates, you can see the dramatic difference between the US and Europe these days.

While on any given day, markets will behave as they do based on both recent news and positioning and rumor, the longer-term trends tend to hold up with bigger picture items, and this is a bigger picture item.  Economic activity in the US has been significantly greater than anywhere in Europe, and most of the world, as the US policy of ‘run it hot’ continues to show what it can do.  Investment into the US continues apace and as someone noted regarding the recent trade data, only 17% of the deficit was due to consumer goods, the rest was capital goods being imported to help expand production in the US.  That speaks well of future economic activity here.

Also, quickly touching on yesterday’s US GDP number, which was a better than expected 3.4%, the corresponding PCE data from that report was just 2.1%, meaning nominal GDP was 5.5% with the exact split that the administration would like to see.  Here is further proof that strong growth does not necessarily lead to inflation.

Ok, let’s turn to markets now.  It wasn’t very pretty in the US yesterday, especially the tech sector and US futures are continuing down that path (NASDAQ -2.4%, SPX -1.1%) at this hour (7:00) after more earnings misses last night from Amazon and Intel as the AI boom / semiconductor boom / tech bubble narrative has run into a few bumps.  So, Tokyo (-2.1%), China (-1.4%), Korea (-3.5%) and Taiwan (-2.5%) were all under great pressure to end the week.  Weirdly, HK (+1.5%) went the other way although that was by overcoming tech concerns.  Elsewhere in Asia, there were more laggards than winners, which given the overall sentiment is not that surprising.

European shares are mixed today with Spain (-0.6%) and Germany (-0.6%) both under pressure while France (+0.1%) and the UK (+0.2%) are both edging higher.  Given France’s disappointing GDP results, this is a bit surprising, but remember, Europe’s almost complete lack of tech companies means when tech crashes, Europe is fine.

In the bond markets, yesterday saw US yields fall sharply, ~10bps in the 10-year and similar elsewhere, and they are continuing to slide this morning, down another -2bps.  As you can see from the chart below, we are back to levels not seen since mid-September.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

I suppose part of this is a haven trade as equity markets have been under pressure around the world, and I find that quite interesting.  For instance, I have been assured by the Twitterati that US bond yields are going to 6% or higher as the dollar loses its reserve status because of the US spending problems.  And yet, many still see Treasuries as a haven.  Go figure.  I must admit that if I look into my personal crystal ball, which is both cracked and cloudy, I anticipate that both growth and inflation in the US are going to be around 3% going forward, but that implies real yields would slip to 1.9%, not terribly high and probably in line with the long-term average.  In that situation, I expect bonds will find plenty of investors.

European sovereign yields slipped yesterday as well, although not like Treasuries and they, too, are lower by between -1bp and -2bps this morning.

In the commodity markets, oil (+2.1%) is rallying again and at $104/bbl, is back to levels last seen in mid-September.  Concerns over a resumption of US military activity in Iran after the election next week are the proximate cause but I must admit, I don’t really understand all the talk and threats by the president on this subject.  It is here I would take the Teddy Roosevelt thesis of speak softly and carry a big stick to extremes.  But the negative correlation between oil and metals is back this morning with a real attack on silver (-3.3%) while both gold and copper are lower by -1.25% or so.

Finally, the dollar is a touch softer this morning, not behaving in a haven manner, although that may be a result of the sharp decline in yields yesterday.  But through all this, for those who look at the DXY, it is slightly softer today (-0.35%) but still sitting right at its breakout level from the beginning of the month.  Since February, as you can see in the chart below, it has been broadly trending higher, but the overall movement this year, about 6%, is hardly dramatic.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

As I have written lately, I think the FX markets are decoupling from the broader macro theses for the time being.

The only data point today is the Employment Cost index (exp +0.8%) and we hear from three Fed speakers, Daly, Barkin and Musalem, a dove, a moderate and a hawk respectively.  The market is pricing only a 70% probability of a hike in December, and now only one more hike after that sometime next year.  That’s a pretty big change from views just a few weeks ago when multiple hikes in 2027 were assumed.

Source: cmegroup.com

In fact, unless we see dramatically strong inflation data ahead of the next meeting, one more PCE and two CPI reports, I would not be surprised for the Fed to stay on hold then as well.

Heading into the weekend, while tech is under pressure, the election continues to hang over the market and will do so until we find out next Tuesday night how things go.  Again, close to the vest and hedged are my preferred positions.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

The What’s What

The Chairman’s idea is to shrink
Two things, but one’s not what you think
The balance sheet? Sure
But here’s the allure
A calendar showing less ink

So next year they’re planning to cut
One meeting, as eight is a glut
The following year
The Chairman made clear
Six meetings will be the what’s what

To absolutely nobody’s surprise, the Fed left policy on hold today, with the only possible wrinkle that the vote was 10-2 with Governor Cook and Cleveland President Hammack voting for a hike.  Now, Hammack has been a vocal hawk for a while, so no real surprise there but Cook?  Below is an interesting graphic from centralbank.watch which shows their estimate of the relative hawkishness or dovishness of the different FOMC members.  Up at the (hawkish) top you see Ms. Hammack.  But Governor Cook, who was put on the FOMC as a reliable dove and to the extent she has ever had serious thoughts about monetary policy has always been dovish is suddenly a hawk.  My best estimate is that given the ongoing legal issues she is having with the administration as they continue to try to get her removed for mortgage fraud, this was a purely political vote with the idea that since President Trump wants rates to fall, she wants them to go higher to hurt him.  I’m open to other explanations, but if Neel Kashkari, who dissented in August didn’t want a hike, explain the Cook vote otherwise.

But that’s not the interesting thing about this meeting.  Rather, Chairman Warsh has indicated that they will be reducing the number of rate decision meetings to seven next year and then down to six in 2028, with no statements released and the committee simply getting together to discuss the economy and the situation.  You will not be surprised that I believe this is a step in the right direction as the Chairman continues to try to wean markets from focusing on the Fed and forcing them to focus on the economy.  But it is a process.  He also indicated that he expected the task force reports to be submitted by year end, mostly, but then there would be time taken to discuss the results and see how they proceed going forward.

I continue to have great respect for him and his ability to navigate a clearly hostile environment as he is attacking the workings of an institution that has become hidebound and needing to get the agreement of the institution itself to change things.

As to the market response to the Statement and press conference…stocks did nothing, the yield curve steepened a bit with 2yr yields falling while 10yr yields edged higher as you can see below

source: tradingeconomics.com

And the dollar fell slightly as per the DXY chart below:

Source: tradingeconomics.com

These were my first thoughts on the FOMC and frankly, nothing has changed in my view this morning.  However, I am always amused at the definitive tone taken by some regarding events like the Fed press conference and what was intended beyond what was said.  This was my favorite this morning.  I don’t know James Thorne, and he is probably an excellent analyst in a position of importance, but to put his opinion out there like a fact, as though Warsh confided in him, is remarkable!

Perhaps he is correct, but my take is between now and the December meeting, there is an awful lot more information coming our way, starting with today’s PCE and GDP data.  Remember, too, Chairman Warsh was explicit in his view that stronger economic growth does not necessarily lead to inflation, it is only when there is an imbalance between the supply and demand sides when inflation arises.

Ok, let’s turn to market behavior in the wake of the FOMC as well as the two big earnings reports last night where Alphabet missed estimates and called into question the AI trade while Microsoft beat estimates demonstrating the AI trade is alive and well.

The Asian equity markets were mixed overall.  China (-1.0%), HK (-0.6%), Korea (-1.2%) and Taiwan (-1.4%) all followed Google, sinking amid concerns that the AI trade was hurting.  Tokyo (+0.15%) and India (+1.2%) saw no such problems nor did Australia (+0.5%) or the Philippines (+0.9%).  The Australian outcome was interesting as there has been further very hawkish talk from the RBA after inflation Down Under refuses to fall.  And our favorite whipping boy, Indonesia (-3.5%) continues to see significant outflows as international investors flee the market while losing hope the securities regulators can address the MSCI concerns about liquidity and market transparency.

In Europe, it is a mixed picture with Germany (+0.8%) and France (+0.9%) both having solid sessions while Spain (-0.9%) suffers again.  My initial thought on Spain was a response to the tragic train crash yesterday, but I think it is more a reflection of the weak Retail Sales data released this morning.  if you look at the recent trend in Retail Sales there, as per the below chart, the trend is not very positive!

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Meanwhile, US futures at this hour (7:00) are generally pointing lower led by the NASDAQ (-0.9%) with the Alphabet news obviously more important than the Microsoft news.  However, the other two indices are little changed.

The Madame is leaving her Chair
Next year, now those nations prepare
To choose someone new
Ere LePen can screw
Their choice with her typical flair

In the bond market, Treasury yields (-2bps) have edged lower this morning and continue to trade right at the 5.0% level.  European sovereign yields, which had been lower earlier in the day, have backed up to unchanged, perhaps on the news that Madame Lagarde has announced she will step down from the role of ECB president as of February 7 next year.  This is not that surprising to me, although I admit I thought she would be leaving for a different reason.  My take, now, is that she wants to step aside to allow Macron to be part of the decision process since it appears that Marine LePen is going to be the next French president and her views do not align with Lagarde’s at all.  My previous thought was she was going to step down early to run for French president, but that seems to be off the table for now, although I do not rule it out!

Turning to the commodity markets, oil prices (-1.5%) are falling this morning as there are sporadic stories about talks starting up again between the US and Iran, but weirdly, metals are also under pressure this morning (Au -0.7%, Ag -1.6%, Cu -1.1%), a break with the more recent negative correlatoin of oil up, metals down and vice versa.

Finally, the dollar is ever so slightly higher on the day as the euro (-0.1%) slips toward its lowest level in nearly 18 months as per the below chart.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

You may remember the beginning of last year when the dollar slid about 10% over the course of 6 months and the punditry was breathlessly explaining the end was nigh as this was an unprecedented move.  Of course that was all BS, it was merely a quirk of the calendar, but those were the headlines.  At any rate, the euro is back to levels not seen since the end of that run. Here’s the thing, there are so many problems extant in the Eurozone, it is hard to make a positive case for the single currency, at least for me to do so.  There is a distinct lack of leadership, a growing energy crisis and ongoing rioting as at least some folks there are displaying their anger more aggressively.  More worryingly, there is nothing obvious that is going to change these issues, and if they follow through and cut off LNG imports from Russia at the end of this year, I fear the entire experiment can disintegrate.

Elsewhere, remember when there was all that angst about the yen, and whether it was going to collapse, or whether the interventions would be effective?  Me neither!  Basically, as you can see in the below chart, we remain exactly where we were the day after the intervention.  There has been no massive repatriation of yen by Japanese investors and for now, it is hard to get excited in either direction.  So far, Secretary Bessent’s actions in both the FX and bond markets are holding up despite initial criticism.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Otherwise, FX remains dull with nothing to discuss.

On the data front, we do get a bunch of stuff this morning as follows:

Initial Claims199K
Continuing Claims1720K
Q3 GDP (1st look)3.2%
Personal Income0.3%
Personal Spending0.6%
PCE0.5% (3.6% Y/Y)
Core PCE0.35 (3.1% Y/Y)

Source: tradingeconmics.com

We also hear from the ECB at 9:15 this morning but no change is expected.  I imagine all the excitement from the ECB is already out there with Lagarde’s announcement.

Did the Fed change anything?  I don’t think so, and as I have maintained for a while, I think we need to get through the election before we can make a definitive move in any of these markets.

Good luck

Adf

His Quixotic Quest

While passing time ere comes the Fed
And after predictions misled
Most traders are waiting
For Warsh advocating
Some view as they all look ahead

But that seems unlikely, at best
As Kevin, each time he’s been pressed
Refuses to say,
Lest his words might sway,
His views in his Quixotic quest

With the midterm elections now less than a week away, and after the bruising that many traders and investors absorbed from the Brazilian election results, it is not surprising that markets are fairly quiet.  After all, it is very hard to explain to your manager why you not only got crushed once, but twice, on unexpected election results.

As such, I feel like most markets have put broad themes on hold and are, instead, looking at more specific potential catalysts for movement.  Of course, the FOMC meeting falls into that category, as does every central bank meeting along with corporate earnings. So, let’s turn out attention to the central banks.  As an example of how things can behave, last night, the RBNZ left rates on hold at 2.75%, surprising the market which was nearly fully priced for a 25bp rate hike. You can see the market response in the chart below.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Now, according to the BIS data, average daily volume in NZD is about $118 billion, of which $43 billion is in the spot market.  While that may sound like a lot, keep in mind the total FX market trades something on the order of $9.5 trillion per day, of which ~$3 trillion is spot, so NZD represents a bit over 1.2% of the market, hardly a harbinger of the future.  However, it is instructive as to what can happen when outcomes surprise markets.  We just saw what happened in Brazil, which was arguably a much larger surprise than a potential 25bp rate hike.  (This goes back to why I have protection for my portfolio expiring after the election next week.)

But let’s focus on today’s meetings where first, the BOC is forecast to hike their base rate by 25bps, to 2.50%.  Now, if we look at the history of USDCAD over the past year and add interest rate decisions and GDP reports, there is no obvious relationship between those data points and the currency’s movement as per the below.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

First off, their base rate has been on hold for quite a while.  Secondly, GDP has generally risen over the period, although the currency has weakened as well.  In fact, it is hard to discern any strong pattern.  Now, if the BOC stands pat, I suspect that the Loonie will fall initially, but I don’t believe it would head back to its lows (USD highs) more than 2% away. There is just not enough interest to drive that in my view.  And, with the Fed still on deck at that time, with the futures market pricing just a 10% probability of a hike, and Kalshi a 5% probability, a surprise there would be of much greater magnitude.

So, is there a possibility that the Fed hikes?  Of course, there is always a possibility but based on the last comments from other Fed speakers and the fact that the data since they have been in their quiet period has not shown dramatic changes from when they were still speaking, I agree with the odds.  The combination of the political questions of the Fed acting immediately ahead of an election, and the lack of compelling data that things have changed argues for no movement.  (The fact that raising interest rates is not obviously going to do anything about inflation anyway is not even part of their discussion, although is something we should all understand.  As The Inflation Guy highlighted yesterday, Keynesians see higher rates as impacting the demand side of the economy, which they clearly do, but never discuss the supply side of the economy, which is also directly impacted.  Which one matters more is the question.)

What I will say is, if they do hike, it will have a dramatic impact on all markets with equities likely to suffer significantly, the dollar likely to rally and long-dated bonds likely to rally (yields decline) as investors would take that as a sign that the Fed is more serious about inflation.  But I just don’t see it.  In the meantime, let’s look at how other markets are behaving.

Yesterday’s tech led US rally in stocks was followed by a more mixed session in Asia, with the obvious winners (Korea +6.6% after SK Hynix earnings were phenomenal and Taiwan +2.0%) along with Tokyo (+1.1%) and China (+0.9%) as official support showed up again.  But elsewhere in the region, things were far less interesting except that in New Zealand, despite the surprise rate move, equities could not rally.  In Europe, red is today’s tale with Spain (-1.3%) the laggard after Santander’s earnings, though strong, disappointed and its stock dragged the whole index lower.  As to the rest of the continent and the UK, indices are softer by between -0.1% and -0.3%, representing indifference ahead of the Fed.  And US futures?  At this hour (7:30) they are mixed, with DJIA a touch lower while both the S&P and NASDAQ are higher by a bit.

In the bond markets, yields are largely unchanged this morning across Treasuries and most European sovereigns with only Italian BTPs (+4bps) showing any movement of note.  While two smaller agencies reaffirmed Italy’s BBB+ rating, the broad trend in rates and concerns over the Meloni government’s ability to rein in spending have some investors nervous.  As well, the ECB meets tomorrow, and while no change is expected, everything I have heard from ECB speakers has leaned toward hawkishness, so while markets are pricing just a 3% probability of a hike, I guess we cannot rule it out. (see Brazil elections!)

In the commodity markets, oil (+1.7%) is bouncing again although as you can see in the below chart, has remained in a $98/$104 range for the past several weeks.  Now, while that is pretty wide, given oil’s volatility this year, I might argue it’s actually pretty narrow.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Here, too, the election is everything as more and more analysts and commentators are expecting an increase in hostilities when the election is past, something I discussed several weeks ago.  But we cannot ignore that there are ongoing efforts to negotiate a settlement between the US and Iran, although I have a hard time seeing that outcome in the near term.

Meanwhile, the metals markets have largely maintained their negative correlation with oil and both gold (-0.3%) and silver (-1.0%) are softer this morning.  However, it is worthwhile noting that the barbarous relic continues to find support at the $4000/oz level and has since it first broke through there last November.  Remember, central banks around the world continue to buy gold, although it has lost its speculative shine.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Finally, the dollar is little changed today but is consolidating its recent marginal strength.  The DXY is back above 102, although has not yet reached its spike high from two weeks ago near 103 as you can see below.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

One thing I would highlight is that yesterday’s Consumer Confidence number was MUCH stronger than forecast, printing at 91.7 more than 10 points above expectations.  However, the long-term downtrend there remains intact.  I imagine this cannot have hurt the dollar.  The one true outlier this morning is CLP (+0.8%) which seems to be benefitting from the central bank’s recent affirmation that inflation risks remain too high and future hikes are still on the table.

And that’s really it.  The only other news today is EIA oil inventory data with no net change expected and then the FOMC.  Microsoft reports earnings after the bell, but the world can be a very different place by then depending on what Chairman Warsh does, or doesn’t, say at the press conference.

Close to the vest with protection seems the best way to be positioned right now.

Good luck

Adf

Lie and Cheat

Said Lula, it might be confusing
But there is no way that I’m losing
So, I’ll lie and cheat
In order to beat
The other guy you could be choosing

Meanwhile it’s a central bank week
With Warsh, come this Wednesday, to speak
So, what will he say?
Are hikes still in play?
Or have Fed funds climbed to their peak?

In the biggest surprise of the weekend, Lula da Silva won the Brazilian presidential election.  It seems that right as the polls were due to close, a single member of the Brazilian Supreme Court, Christiano Zanin (who happened to be Lula’s personal attorney before being put on the Court) extended voting by 2 hours despite the rest of the court voting against that action.  I do not know if that changed the outcome, nor do I imagine we will ever really get the story, but the result stands for now.  I suspect the Senor Bolsonaro will sue for a recount or something, but the market has spoken, at least the equity market has as you can see from the following quote for the Brazil stock ETF, EWZ, before the market opens this morning.  That’s a 26% decline!

You may remember after the first round of the election three weeks ago, the market rallied sharply on the idea that Bolsonaro would be unwinding many of Lula’s policies as per the below chart.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But perhaps the most interesting thing is the fact that the prediction markets, the new “fount of truth” was also completely wrong on this outcome.  Going into the weekend, there was a more than 80% probability of a Bolsonaro victory.  It just goes to show that there are no guarantees when it comes to events.

It is still too early to tell what will happen in the FX markets as BRL is a restricted currency and won’t start trading until Brazilian markets open in a few hours, but I suspect that the real will fall pretty sharply as well.  After all, it mirrored the stock market rally on the first-round news.

Away from that story, and the ongoing riots in France, which seem to have been absorbed by markets now as there has not been much movement overall, at least not in government bond markets, focus is turning to the FOMC meeting that begins tomorrow with the statement and press conference on Wednesday afternoon.  As of this morning, futures markets are pricing less than a 10% probability of a hike, which as you can see is a substantial change from a month ago when there was nearly a 2/3 probability priced in.

Source: cmegroup.com

This is an important lesson, I believe, regarding markets.  I always refer to market pricing as the best descriptor of current information.  However, information changes, situations change and so prices do change.  Just because a future event seems to be priced in at some point in time doesn’t offer certainty, it is simply a reflection of the sum of knowledge at that time.  In this case, in the weeks since that pricing existed, a number of Fed speakers explained they were in no hurry to raise rates again and given the timing of the Fed meeting relative to the mid-term elections, the market has discounted the idea of a Fed move as it could be seen as political.  (LOL, as though all their moves aren’t political!). Nonetheless, at the moment, all the fears of Treasury yields exploding higher to 6% and beyond and the Fed turning more hawkish have faded away.  In fact, I suspect that this meeting will pass uneventfully.  The one thing of which I am confident is that at the press conference, Chairman Warsh will not offer any guidance but will instead reiterate that they will achieve their inflation goals, dammit!

And that’s how things are shaping up this morning, so let’s see how other markets look.  Friday’s weakness in US equity markets has not been the norm either overnight or in Europe this morning.  While Tokyo (-0.8%), Korea (-1.5%) and Taiwan (-1.8%) all fell on the same tech sell-off story, India (+0.7%), HK (+0.5%) and Thailand (+1.1%) all rallied while China’s Plunge Protection team was able to stabilize markets there with a basically unchanged session.  There is much discussion about how neocloud firms are going to run out of funding and how this is the beginning of the end of the AI trade which is clearly weighing on certain companies and markets, but as we saw this weekend, surprises are quite possible.

In Europe, only Spain (-0.2%) is lagging, and it is only slightly lower.  Otherwise, the major nations are all seeing gains (UK +0.5%, Germany +0.9%, France +0.75%, Italy +0.6%) with the only news of note the German Ifo reports which showed current conditions sagging but hope for the future as the Expectations reading was 91.6, higher than expected, but as you can see from the chart below, still well below the pre-Covid readings and the long-term average of 95.1.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

But it’s better than nothing!  As to US futures, they are little changed to slightly higher this morning.

In the bond market, Treasury yields are little changed from Friday’s close at 4.99%.  The real movement today has been in the Bund-OAT spread, which you may recall blew out above 175bps last week, but has now fallen back to 160bps with German yields edging higher by 3bps while French yields have slipped -4bps.  The thing about this movement is there is nothing I can see to drive a change in the concern over France’s fiscal future.  Riots continue there and are spreading to Barcelona and Italy in Milan I understand, and the Macron government can do nothing to change the fiscal accounting as it does not have the strength to pass legislation to address the issues.  This seems much more like a trading move with some profit taking than anything fundamental.

In the commodity markets, oil (-2.1%) is slipping as reports are coming through that more oil is transiting the Strait of Hormuz than before the Iran war began!  I cannot confirm that, but it is a widely read story this morning.  Remaining in the energy sphere, the dichotomy between US NatGas and TTF is extraordinary with the divergence accelerating as per the below chart from tradingeconomics.com.

At its current level, TTF is priced at ~$31/MMBtu, more than 12X US Henry Hub gas, and apparently, Asia is outbidding Europe for US LNG cargoes even though European storage is far below targeted levels.  If it is a cold winter in Europe, it could be quite problematic as their energy policy insufficiencies will make themselves very clear.    As to the metals markets, gold (+0.5%) is bouncing a bit as it trades either side of $4000/oz and silver and copper are little changed this morning.  There has been a story going round that gold has been successfully synthesized which is a reason that it cannot go higher, however, asking Grok, it is estimated to cost $1,000,000,000,000,000/oz to make it this way, so perhaps it is not an immediate threat.

Finally, the dollar is modestly higher this morning with the most exciting prospects remaining in Brazil when that opens in a bit.  The BOVESPA stock market doesn’t open until 9:00 EDT but I think the FX markets there will open an hour earlier than that, so pretty soon.  I suspect the BRL will weaken on the opening.

On the data front, there is plenty to digest this week as follows:

TodayChicago Fed National Activity-0.1
TuesdayDurable Goods1.5%
 -ex Transport0.6%
 Case Shiller Home Prices2.5%
 Consumer Confidence81.0
 New Home Sales650K
WednesdayGoods Trade Balance-$130B
 FOMC Rate Decision4.0% (unchanged)
ThursdayQ3 GDP3.2%
 Personal Income0.3%
 Personal Spending0.5%
 Initial Claims200K
 Continuing Claims1730K
 PCE0.5% (3.6% Y/Y)
 Core PCE0.3% (3.1% Y/Y)
FridayBOJ Rate Decision1.25% (Unchanged)
 Employment Cost Index0.8%
 Chicago PMI55.5

Source: tradingeconomics.com

So, while two major central banks meet, no action is anticipated.  I have maintained that things would remain range bound ahead of the elections here next week and nothing has changed that view.  I also believe that if the Democrats sweep both House and Senate, equities will suffer greatly, although I don’t believe that is going to be the outcome.  However, as we just learned yesterday, we won’t know until the votes are counted.  In the end, nothing has changed to make the dollar the least worst alternative, that’s for sure.

Good luck

Adf

Feeling the Heat

Risk assets are feeling the heat
As equity markets retreat
And gold is a mess
While most bonds feel stress
And crude hurts the man on the street

It seems that the drumbeats of war
Are louder than they’d been before
Now rumors abound
The US will pound
Iran with munitions galore

Risk is under pressure this morning as equity markets worldwide retreat, gold is falling and the only asset rising are US Treasuries.  Well, that and oil prices which seem to be the proximate cause of the whole story.

I guess we should start with oil (+2.0%) which is rebounding from yesterday’s decline as the story gaining traction is the US and Israel are going to resume military action in Iran shortly.  In fact, President Trump commented in questions yesterday that something would happen “pretty soon”.  This is of a piece with my expectation that in the wake of the mid-terms in two weeks, Trump would feel he had a free hand to go after Iran again, and I have seen this story from several generally reliable sources on X this morning.  I also read that another aircraft carrier group was heading to the Persian Gulf area, further supporting the idea.

This story coincides with the WSJ headline, “Iran’s Fleet of Shadow Tankers Has Run Out of Oil After Monthslong US Blockade” which is a serious problem for the mullahs as, according to the article, some 40% of Iranian government revenue comes from oil sales (I wonder where the rest comes from, pistachios?) and so renewed US/Israeli attacks will be far harder to absorb.  With this driving the narrative, it is not surprising that oil prices are higher and uncertainty has risen.

This has manifest itself in the following ways.  In equity markets, the below tradingeconomics.com screenshot at 7:08 this morning shows pretty clear evidence of what the mood is today and how things felt overnight (notice Shanghai, Hong Kong and Australia).

Investors are clearly getting a bit nervous everywhere around the world right now.  We can see that in bond markets as well where those nations who are still perceived as safe havens, US, Canada, Germany, Netherlands, Japan) have seen that flight to safety.  Even UK gilts have managed to rally, but the story on the continent is a far more concerning one.  Looking at the below Bloomberg.com screenshot, you can see that the problems in France are really starting to hurt.

It’s funny, I saw an argument(?), maybe a discussion, on X this morning where one person said traders are treating the situation in France as though the ECB is not going to step in and save the day by bailing out the French, and the response was that the only way for the ECB to do that was if the market behaved in just that manner.  The ECB will only jump if the situation looks untenable, at which point they will create yet another program with another acronym, something like European Activity Security Event (EASE) which will instruct central banks to purchase OATs, and possibly BTPs.  Now that the Bund-OAT spread is >175bps, it is a virtual guarantee that this will happen.

The other odd thing is that US Treasuries appear to be in demand.  It was not that long ago that the bond market narrative was that with US debt climbing above $40 trillion and showing no signs of slowing down, it would soon be worthless.  Foreign nations were selling their holdings and the end was nigh.  And yet, according to TIC data, the August records (latest available) show that foreign ownership of Treasuries rose ~$83.3 billion.  In fact, here is a table to consider.

It is true that both the UK and Belgium are clearinghouses, so it is not certain who is the ultimate owner of those bonds, but Canada is far more interesting, and I have read, although it is unsubstantiated, that China has been holding Treasuries there.  It is certainly believable that is the case given their ongoing trade surpluses and the need to put the dollars somewhere.   In the end, I wouldn’t write off the bond quite yet!

As to other markets, the rout in metals continues, which given the decline in most yields seems odd to me especially as the rationale had been given that higher yields were driving a replacement of gold with bonds.  Given its long history as a haven, I have trouble understanding the rationale to sell gold, and my sense is this could be short selling in an environment where risk assets are declining.  But I have written before that this is a very new paradigm through which we are living, and it appears this is a new response.  My personal view is that this is a short-term phenomenon and the precious metals will regain their luster again, but it may be a while yet.  So, gold (-1.9%), silver (-3.8%) and copper (-2.5%) are all on the schneid this morning.

I think it is also worth discussing natural gas, which has been falling sharply over the past several weeks, at least in the US.  In fact, the below chart shows a comparison of US and European natural gas prices.  If you were wondering what kind of problems Europe is in for this winter, as I have written elsewhere, I hope they have lots of warm sweaters!

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Finally, the dollar, which spent much of the evening doing nothing, has rallied as NY walks in the door, a reasonable response to a haven driven market.  But that rise is far more evident vs. EMG currencies than G10 as the DXY futures are essentially unchanged on the day, caught between modest EUR weakness (-0.3%) and more impressive JPY strength (+0.7%).  But, in the emerging markets, ZAR (-1.1%), MXN (-0.8%), INR -0.8%), CLP (-1.0%) and PLN (-0.6%) are all under more severe pressure, as overall risk concerns along with declining commodities prices are the drivers.

As it is Thursday, this morning we see Initial (exp 200K) and Continuing (1720K) Claims along with Leading Indicators (-0.1%).  And that’s really it.

Under the heading, I’d rather be lucky than good, yesterday afternoon I bought some SPY puts set to expire after the election as a portfolio hedge.  My concern is that while I believe the Republicans will do far better than currently forecast, I could easily be wrong and based on the stated policy objectives of the Democratic party, equity markets seem likely to fall if they are elected.  I truly hope my puts expire worthless, but for today, they are doing their job. (THIS IS NOT INVESTMENT ADVICE!)

It is certainly reasonable to expect the dollar to test its recent highs, but there doesn’t appear to be enough momentum to break those in any meaningful way, at least absent a major equity market dislocation.

Good luck

Adf

Not Paying Heed

Seems markets are not paying heed
To France where the riots proceed
Instead, it’s AI
And bonds gone awry
Where fears are replacing past greed

So, is this the end of the run
Which two decades past had begun?
Or is this a blip
Which soon will round-trip
As recent downdrafts are undone?

While there are always a group of voices singing a song of doom right around the corner, Keynes’ saying that markets can remain ‘wrong’ longer than you can remain solvent continues to be the reality.  One need only look at the barchart.com 20-year chart of the NASDAQ below to realize that since the GFC, while there have been two pretty sharp blips along the way, Covid and the Liberation Day, with the latter really short-lived, this is a chart that has been largely unidirectional.  Everyone who has explained that valuations are too high, and that earnings are shaky and that rising interest rates will undermine the structure of the market has basically been wrong for nearly 20 years.  I understand that there were calls for another Black Monday today, as this is the 39th anniversary of that remarkable day, but is this time different?

Those four words are the most dangerous in markets, there is no question about that.  You can make the case that AI has changed everything about the economy and that the old rules are no longer valid, but whatever AI’s capabilities may turn out to be over time, it’s still people who control the money, and the one thing of which I am certain is that people haven’t changed in the past 20 years.

Now, last week was a tough one for the Pollyannas who have been cheerleading the rally, and you can see that in the history of the CNN Fear & Greed Index below.  It has fallen quite sharply, from 46 to 18 in just a week.

Arguably, part of that has been the movement in the price of oil (-0.6%), which while modestly lower this morning, has rallied >14% during the past two weeks as Iran has increased its attacks on ships in the Strait of Hormuz while the Houthis have increased their attacks on Saudi Arabia.  It appears they are trying to goad President Trump to respond in an effort to help the Democrats take control of the House and the Senate, but so far, Trump has let things play out.  I suspect that no matter who wins the election, come November 4th, things in the Persian Gulf are going to intensify.  In fact, it would not surprise me if the Democrats win that the military campaign will be that much more intense.

Adding to the pressure of higher oil prices were hotter than expected inflation data last week with both CPI and PPI printing at higher-than-expected numbers.  But a funny thing happened, bond yields stopped climbing, at least for the moment, as it seems investors are both far more comfortable with the current yield structure as real yields reach multi-year highs, and the riots in France, that seem to be spreading elsewhere in Europe, have investors turning away from European sovereigns as an alternative.  After all, 10-year Treasury yields are down by 30bps from the highs reached just two weeks ago.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

This is not to imply that things are great, clearly multiple problems and concerns remain, but I still cannot see the end of days.  So, let’s turn to the market behavior from last night and this morning as we open.

Friday’s weakness in the US raised concerns that we were on the cusp of the end of the bull market run.  But as we have consistently seen over the past many years, those fears have abated just as quickly as they arrived.  Overnight, equity markets were mixed in Asia as while the Nikkei (-0.6%) slid a bit and that weighed on India (-1.2%), Taiwan (-0.6%) and several other smaller regional markets, China (+0.5%), Korea (+1.7%) and Australia (+0.4%) all managed gains.  As an aside, recall I mentioned the Jakarta Index last week?  Well, as you can see below, investors are still fleeing the country with the index now down -15% in the past three sessions.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

However, there is a region that is feeling the heat from the rioting in France, and that is Europe.  The below screenshot is eloquent in its depiction of today’s trading on the continent.

Apparently, there are several concerns, notably the fact that growth continues to be anemic while fiscal spending grows uncontrollably, but then the rioting in France, which seems to be spreading is adding pressure to governments across the continent.  As to the US, both SPX (+0.6%) and NASDAQ (+1.1%) futures are higher as I type (6:45am), hardly the stuff of Black Monday.

Perhaps the bond market is making a better case for apocalypse today.  Alas for those seeking such an outcome, other than French OATs (+8bps and now the widest spread vs. Germany since the Eurozone crisis in 2012, see below) which have dragged Italian BTPs (+4bps) higher as well, the rest of the continent has seen only a marginal movement today, +1bp or 2bps.

Turning to the commodity sector, while oil, as mentioned above, is pretty benign this morning, a note about Natural Gas, (+1.0%) which is seeing increased demand as the weather cools off.  Now, even though we have seen prices here increase nearly 20% since early August, that is a seasonal outcome entirely expected.  And let’s face it, $3.15/MMBtu is still an order of magnitude lower than European prices of nearly $30/MMBtu.  If you wonder why European growth is stagnating, look no further than this.  As to the metals sector, modest gains this morning are the order of the day, (Au +0.1%, Ag +1.2%, Cu +0.3%).  Nothing has changed my longer-term view that the supply-demand imbalance in metals markets remains firmly in the lack of supply situation.  Ironically, in oil, it is just the opposite, with ample oil around, it is simply the politics of war that is creating this price event.

Finally, the dollar is mixed this morning, with commodity currencies like AUD (+0.6%), CAD (+0.4%), NOK (+0.25%) and ZAR (+0.25%) all gaining while the euro (-0.15%) and yen (-0.1%) slip a bit.  It doesn’t feel to me like FX is the focus right now.  Rather bond markets and the question of the next Black Monday have a lot more press.  I imagine the euro will be an interesting case study going forward depending on how the ECB responds to the ongoing unrest in Europe.  Can more fiscal spending supported by more ECB bond buying be far away?  I have a feeling the euro may be setting up for another leg lower.

On the data front, it is an extremely quiet week:

TuesdayHousing Starts1.31M
 Building Permits1.40M
ThursdayInitial Claims200K
 Continuing Claims1712K
 Leading Indicators-0.2%
FridayFlash Manufacturing PMI55.5
 Flash Services PMI57.9
 Michigan Confidence46.3

Source: tradingeconomics.com

With the FOMC meeting a week from Wednesday, there are no Fed speakers this week.  Interestingly, despite the higher-than-expected inflation readings last week, the market is pricing only a 15% probability of a hike although there is virtual certainty that there will be a hike in December.  One other data issue to note was last night’s Chinese data as follows:

The situation there remains one of weak domestic activity alongside excess manufacturing capacity with China’s growing Trade Surplus becoming an issue in more and more nations around the world.  Alas for President Xi, the two choices to achieve his GDP goals are the current mercantilist process or a true effort to focus resources on the Chinese people.  I don’t see any changes coming despite some lip service to the contrary.  Even the WSJ wrote about it this morning.

My view remains that while there are many problems extant around the world, both economically and politically, we will get through this period just like we have made it through tough times in the past.  And undoubtedly, the US remains extremely well positioned to continue its economic strength given the willingness to utilize its natural resources.  While there are political divisions here, they don’t rise to the level of what we are currently witnessing in Europe.  Overall, it is hard not to like the dollar as the cleanest dirty shirt in the laundry for a while yet.

Good luck

Adf

Screed After Screed

Seems I just can’t leave you alone
Lest havoc and fear you’ll have sown
So, now that I’m back
Let’s try to change tack
And work on a positive tone

But seriously, what I read
Is doomsters in screed after screed
All preening and bragging
That all their chin-wagging
Was right while the markets recede

All I can say is, it’s so good to be home.  While the past three weeks have been enjoyable and traveling across half the country by car offers a great perspective on just how amazing this nation really is, I’m sure all of you will agree that there is nothing more comfortable than sleeping in your own bed.  And this is just as true for Marvel, as it is for the rest of us.

But seriously, I appreciate your patience as it is tough to keep up while driving 10 hours a day.  But now that I’m back, I think it is worthwhile to take a look at how things have moved since I first left back in late September.  Between closing on Friday, September 25 and last night at 9:00pm, these are the moves across major markets that I discuss.

Frankly, it is hard to look at this and conclude that the world is ending.  In fact, despite constant discussion about how the AI (or is it SI?) trade is imploding, the NASDAQ has fallen just -2.5% over the past three weeks and is less than 5% from its all-time highs.  I don’t see the reason for all the excitement.  In fact, the biggest mover, by far, has been silver, which is the least liquid and least important of all these markets.  Despite the end of days discussion about Treasuries, yields have slipped, as have JGB and Bund yields.  One other thing to note is the decline in gasoline prices given the political implications.  I’m confident the White House would like to see them fall further, but there is no indication there is a supply issue there.

I’m just trying to level set here.  I’m sorry if I’m not breathlessly describing the apocalypse, but I just don’t see it. Perhaps I’m simply blind.  But the data continues to lean toward economic growth, not weakness, at least based on the Retail Sales and Initial Claims data we saw yesterday, as well as the ISM and other numbers.  And inflation, to the extent that growth is a driver of that, remains well above the Fed’s 2% target, although based on its causes (read the Inflation Guy’s blog to really understand it), hiking rates is not going to be the solution to inflation, although it certainly has the opportunity to impede growth.

Anyway…

The rules of the road used to be
That nothing defied gravity
But Elon replied
We oughtn’t be tied
To earth, and his car, he set free!

I am sure there is a parable in the contrast between the doom and gloom that consistently dominates the discussion, the vibe as it were, and the fact that the richest man in the world continues to build extraordinary things.  I’m sure you have all seen the video clip of the new Tesla roadster that actually flies, but if not, it’s right there.  No matter your view of the man, you cannot dismiss his extraordinary genius when it comes to building things.  I guess the question is, will the flying car be a metaphor for the economy?  The markets? Or will it crash a burn?

So, now let’s turn to the markets, and I feel like bonds are the right place to start.  The below chart of the 10-year over the past week is remarkable given the CPI, PPI and Retail Sales data released.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

The huge gap was the immediate response to Wednesday’s CPI release which came in a tick hotter than forecast.  Yet much higher-than-expected PPI and Retail Sales data saw yields decline sharply.  Ostensibly, I continue to read about a flight to safety trade, but that seems at odds with the idea that Treasury debt is going to implode because there is so much of it.  I wish the punditry would get their stories straight.  No matter the cause, yesterday saw a complete reversal of the yield rally from Wednesday.  Maybe, and I’m just spit balling here, the punditry doesn’t have any idea about the way things work but simply try to drive a preferred narrative.  And given the underlying visceral hatred of the US administration, specifically President Trump, are very keen to do all in their power to make things worse for him.

Regardless, it appears that despite the higher-than-expected inflation data, yields at current levels represent an attractive opportunity to some investors.  While this morning, 10-year yields have bounced 4bps from yesterday’s closing levels, as I showed above, they are still lower on the month.  And it is no surprise that European sovereign yields have also rebounded this morning, although more on the order of 2bps across the board.  Frankly, it seems to me there is far more risk in owning Bunds or OATs or BTPs than in owning Treasuries.  At least the US is growing pretty well compared to the utter lack of growth in Europe.  Exactly how are the French going to repay their debt, or maybe more importantly service their debt, if growth remains <1%?

As to equities, they, too, have stopped tumbling for now with markets higher yesterday in the US and almost the entirety of Asia and Europe this morning with the one glaring exception of Indonesia (-10.8%) which suffered from MSCI explaining they could downgrade the country to standalone market status (a decisive negative outcome regarding the lack of transparency and liquidity) offering the potential for significant capital outflows.  I understand that there are AI names that have had problems and the banking sector, despite mostly strong earnings, has underperformed, but the end has not shown itself yet.

Gold (+0.2%) is another market that seems confused, or at least the trading of it seems so, as its relationship with oil (+0.1%), which had a very clear negative correlation for quite a while, arguably since the beginning of the Iran war, (although according to Grok, the numbers show that correlation to be -0.1% to -0.15% over the past year, hardly a strong relationship), are both higher this morning.  But looking at the chart below, the direction of travail since the summer has been largely opposite directions.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

Obviously, oil is a far more important commodity than gold, which can be seen as a sentiment indicator more than anything else.  But despite the recent rebound in oil prices, economies around the world seem to be figuring out how to cope.  Now, the recent uptick in Iranian and Houthi attacks on ships in Hormuz and Saudi infrastructure are having a clear impact and given the fact that the IRGC literally wrote an open letter to the US to elect Democrats to try to impede President Trump’s ongoing campaign, I have to believe things are getting a lot tougher over there.  It is not impossible to believe that after the election, especially if the Republicans hold both Houses of Congress, that the Iran conflict may end soon.  It does seem that the blockade has starved Iran of the one thing they need, capital, and that is running out quickly.

As to the FX market, I find it interesting that even though yields are rising around the world, the dollar has been the main beneficiary here.  In the wake of the CPI and PPI data, the probability of a rate hike at the end of the month has jumped to 85%, as per the below cmegroup.com table.

At the same time, Chairman Warsh spoke last night at the IMF meeting in Bangkok but once again, refused to discuss potential Fed moves going forward. “I don’t prejudge meetings. I don’t believe in saying now what I might do at the meetings we have in the balance of this year. It’s a new chapter at the Fed, and we’re not in that business anymore.” While virtually every other member of the FOMC likes the fame/notoriety they get by speaking, Warsh has remained true to his initial comments.  I guess the question is, has the data been sufficient to drive another hike?  It all depends on the membership’s view of economic activity.  If they see strength, I imagine that is what we will get despite the fact it is unlikely to do anything positive for the economy.

Back to the dollar, while it has backed off a bit this morning, with the DXY (-0.85%) the leading decliner despite the fact its components haven’t moved nearly that much (EUR -0.35, JPY unchanged), I guess broadly it is following the 10-year yield.  It is worth noting that while most currencies have not done very much in my absence, (MXN +0.1% today, -5.6% since Sept 25) has suffered on expectations that Banxico is going to cut rates further, thus reducing one of its key supports, the carry trade.

On the data front, this morning we see IP (exp 0.4%) and Capacity Utilization (76.5%).  Those tend not to be market movers so as is frequently the case, the FX market will take its cues from equities and bonds.  Right now, equity futures are essentially unchanged, so if the positivity we saw yesterday fades, perhaps the dollar will rally back some on that flight to safety trade.

Good luck and good weekend

Adf

Growth Outlives Politics

As much as the pundits keep trying
To tell us that nobody’s buying
The Dow hasn’t crumbled
And though bonds have stumbled
There’s no sign that they’re really dying

But negative stories get clicks
And that’s how the punditry ticks
Though there are concerns
‘Bout short-term returns
O’er time growth outlives politics

Over the past several sessions, basically until yesterday afternoon, the vibe was distinctly negative.  Oil prices had rebounded, bond yields continued to rise and there was red all over the equity market screens.  It’s funny, the dollar was rallying and one explanation was investors were fleeing to the dollar for safety, but if they were, it wasn’t clear what they were buying with those dollars.  It wasn’t stocks, bonds or gold, so I guess they were holding cash.  That seems odd in this day and age, but maybe.

The punditry was in its glory, though, explaining how everything that every government was doing, especially the Trump administration, was destined to fail and that we all must be very afraid.  And then it stopped.  Certainly, a key catalyst to this reversal of fortune was President Trump’s tweet late yesterday morning as per the below:

However, while there was an initial spike on the news, risk sold off further for the next hour, as you can see in the below chart, until the Iranians confirmed discussions were ongoing.  It seems that while neither Trump nor Iran is believed by themselves, markets are willing to take a flyer on the two of them saying the same thing.

Source: tradingeconomics.com

And that’s basically where we are this morning.  All the doom and gloom has been put on hold for the moment because, once again, hopes have been raised that there will be a conclusive outcome to the ongoing conflict in Iran and energy markets will be able to get back to a more normal functioning process.  Of course, the Russia/Ukraine war continues and that is also having a significant impact, maybe more than Iran, as Ukraine continues to destroy Russian refining capacity. But the punditry will wait until Iran is settled before they refocus there for their next negative stories.

But as I type this morning, that’s really all there is.  The election remains background noise so far, at least from a market perspective, and likely won’t have a direct market impact until the results are in on November 4th.  The dearth of data this week meant there were no economic fundamentals on which to define a view, so the old trend, which had turned negative, was the default position.  Now, if things really do settle down in Iran, I suspect that will drive renewed interest in both stocks and bonds while the dollar drifts lower.  But we shall see.

In the meantime, let’s tour how markets have responded to the change in tone.  Equity markets are looking much better this morning as per the below screenshot from tradingeconomics.com.  Other than the Nikkei, which was basically unchanged, green is this morning’s color.  And while the Nikkei slipped ever so slightly, every other index in Japan rose.

Maybe we are not all doomed after all.  In the bond markets, yesterday afternoon in the US saw yields back off sharply from their recent highs, falling -7bps on the day although they are unchanged this morning.  But that price action has been the driver around the world as you can see in the below Bloomberg screenshot.

This is not to imply that everything is better around the world, clearly there are still manifest fiscal and monetary issues as well as little things like riots on the streets of France, Belgium and Spain, but those are not yet impacting markets, I believe.  (Of course, if I were Emmanuel Macron, I would be making sure I have an escape route given the outcome of the leadership during the last French Revolution!)  But it seems that at current levels, investors are getting comfortable with the idea of owning bonds.  And the other positive for the bond market is The Economist’s cover this week, a near perfect negative indicator, looks like this:

In the commodity markets, oil (-0.9%) is continuing yesterday afternoon’s slide and sitting right on $90/bbl.  Not surprisingly, between the slide in oil and the fall in interest rates, precious metals markets have rebounded nicely (Au +1.25%, Ag +2.25%, Cu +2.0%).  Certainly, this price action is consistent with what we have seen of late.

Finally, turning to the dollar, it is the one thing breaking the trend as it is marginally higher this morning vs. most of its G10 counterparts.  Recent price action would have you think it should sell off with oil falling and gold rallying, but maybe the stories about fleeing to dollars is correct.  The two outliers here are BRL (+0.5%) and ZAR (+0.5%) with the former seemingly anticipating a Bolsonaro electoral victory and a move toward more conservative fiscal policies while the latter is simply responding to both oil’s decline and gold’s rise.  I continue to have a hard time getting excited about a significant move in the dollar for now although also believe that modest strength over time is the way forward.

On the data front, yesterday’s Initial Claims came in low, just 197K, which continues to point to a labor market that is not under huge stress.  I wonder, too, how quickly the impact of the administration’s crackdown on H1-B visas is going to be seen in the data as the numbers I read this morning, 700K US workers were laid off in the tech space and the same number of H1_B visa’ed immigrants were hired in their place could portend another step lower in this series.  As to this morning, Michigan Sentiment (exp 47.6) is the only thing on the docket.  However, I wonder how much of that particular indicator is a political statement vs. how much as an economic outlook.

The weekend is upon us, and I see no reason for this morning’s positive vibe to dissipate.  I know all the arguments about the lack of breadth in the market and the massive dichotomy between the tech space and the rest of the economy, but following the numbers, there is no indication to me that the end is nigh.  While I disagree with much of Keynesian monetary philosophies, (I lean Austrian there) he was certainly correct when he told us that ‘markets can remain irrational longer than you can remain solvent.’  I’m not betting against a continuation of the equity rally, and am long bonds as a trade, thinking yields have peaked, at least for a while.

Good luck and good weekend

adf